Book & Media Reviews is a dedicated section of Resonance: Journal of Global Music Studies for independent, critically informed evaluations of scholarly publications, sound recordings, films, digital platforms, artistic projects, and other media relevant to music and sound studies. The section encourages reviews that move beyond descriptive summaries to examine the intellectual, methodological, aesthetic, cultural, and technological significance of the works under consideration.

The section contributes to scholarly exchange through the examination of new and significant works, the identification of developing debates, and attention to languages, traditions, and regions underrepresented in international scholarship. Review authors are expected to assess material they have actually examined, represent its aims accurately, and offer independent, evidence-based critical judgment rather than promotional coverage.

What We Review

The section welcomes reviews of publications and media that make substantive contributions to the understanding, documentation, interpretation, creation, or circulation of music and sound. Relevant materials include, but are not limited to:

  • Scholarly Books: Academic monographs, edited collections, reference works, critical editions, and significant publications in musicology, ethnomusicology, sound studies, performance studies, and related disciplines.
  • Sound Recordings and Albums: Commercial, independent, experimental, archival, and community-based recordings, including albums, field-recording collections, historical reissues, and other significant recorded sound projects.
  • Films and Audiovisual Works: Documentary films, fiction films, concert films, audiovisual essays, and other productions in which music, musical culture, performance, or sound forms a central subject or analytical concern.
  • Digital Platforms and Research Tools: Online music archives, digital databases, streaming platforms, computational tools, scholarly applications, digital exhibitions, and interactive resources relevant to music research or musical practice.
  • Sound Art and Multimedia Projects: Sound installations, interactive artworks, immersive environments, digital performances, experimental sonic projects, and interdisciplinary artistic productions.
  • Music Editions and Documentary Resources: Published musical scores, critical editions, facsimiles, archival catalogues, transcription collections, and other materials contributing to musical scholarship and documentation.
  • Public-Facing and Interdisciplinary Works: Significant publications and media addressing music education, cultural policy, creative industries, musical heritage, technology, cultural identity, and the social or political dimensions of sound.

Global Scope: Reviews of works published or produced in languages other than English are particularly encouraged. The section welcomes contributions concerning diverse musical cultures, geographic regions, intellectual traditions, and forms of artistic expression.

Recent works are generally prioritized. However, older publications, recordings, films, or digital resources may be considered when a new edition, reissue, restoration, rediscovery, or significant scholarly development provides a compelling reason for renewed critical evaluation.

Works should be considered according to their intellectual, artistic, documentary, or cultural significance rather than their commercial visibility or the reputation of their creators.

Review Formats & Length

The section accepts two principal formats:

Single Review

Length: 1,000–1,500 words.

A Single Review offers a focused critical evaluation of one principal publication, recording, film, digital resource, or artistic project. It should identify the work accurately, explain its relevant context, assess its principal contributions and limitations, and consider its significance for music and sound studies.

Brief comparisons with related works may be included where they strengthen the evaluation, but the discussion should remain centered on the selected work.

Review Essay

Length: Up to 3,000 words.

A Review Essay examines two or more related works through a coherent critical question, theme, methodological concern, intellectual debate, or development within music and sound studies.

Review Essays should develop an integrated argument rather than present several independent reviews in sequence. Authors are encouraged to consider relationships among the selected works, including their differing methods, perspectives, evidence, aesthetic choices, cultural contexts, and contributions to wider disciplinary discussion.

Particularly valuable review essays may identify emerging scholarly directions, contested interpretations, neglected repertoires, new research resources, or significant developments across fields and geographic regions.

Submission Requirements

  • Submission Languages: English, Chinese, German, Italian, and Russian.
  • English Title: Required for all submissions. Authors may additionally provide the title in the original language.
  • English Abstract: Provide an abstract of up to 300 words identifying the reviewed work or works, their scholarly or cultural relevance, and the central critical assessment. Its scope should be proportionate to the review's length.
  • Keywords: Four to six English keywords or keyword phrases.
  • Manuscript Format: Microsoft Word (.docx).
  • Typography: Double-spaced text using 12-point Times New Roman for standard English-language prose. Appropriate Unicode-compatible fonts may be used for Chinese and other writing systems.
  • Citation Style: Follow The Chicago Manual of Style, 18th edition, using either Notes and Bibliography or Author-Date consistently when references are included. Detailed source and citation conventions are provided in the journal's Style Guide.
  • Author Biography: A 100–150-word third-person biographical note, submitted separately from the review manuscript where requested.
  • Work Identification: Provide accurate bibliographic, publication, production, or technical information for each work under review.
  • Originality: Submitted reviews must represent original critical work and must not be simultaneously under consideration by another journal.
  • Disclosure: Authors must declare relevant relationships, financial interests, complimentary review copies, sponsorship, or other circumstances that could reasonably affect the independence of their evaluation.

All submission metadata must accurately correspond to the manuscript. Authors should verify the spelling of titles, names, publication dates, identifiers, and other relevant details before submission.

Identification of Works Under Review

Each review must provide sufficient information to enable readers to identify and locate the work being discussed. The following information should be included where applicable and available.

  • Books: Author or editor, full title and subtitle, publisher, publication year, edition, ISBN or DOI where available, and page count or other descriptive details when relevant to identifying the edition reviewed.
  • Sound Recordings: Album or recording title, principal artists, composers or performers as appropriate, record label or publisher, release year, relevant catalog number or identifier, recording format, and other information necessary for accurate identification.
  • Films and Audiovisual Works: Full title, director, production or distribution information, release year, duration, and relevant language or edition details where applicable.
  • Digital Platforms and Resources: Resource title, creator or responsible organization, provider, relevant version or release information, stable URL or persistent identifier, and access date where appropriate for changing online content.
  • Sound Art and Multimedia Projects: Work title, creator or collective, date, medium, exhibition or presentation context, relevant venue or platform, and available documentation.
  • Music Editions and Scores: Composer, editor or arranger as applicable, title, edition, publisher, publication year, and relevant catalog or publication identifiers.

The review should make clear which edition, recording, restoration, version, performance, or platform release was examined. Authors must not claim to have reviewed materials that they have not adequately accessed or evaluated.

For digital services and changing online resources, authors should describe the principal functions or materials actually examined and, where relevant, note the date and conditions of access. Claims concerning features, availability, or functionality should reflect the version evaluated rather than unsupported assumptions about the platform as a whole.

Standards of Critical Evaluation

Reviews should demonstrate sustained critical engagement with the work under consideration. Evaluation should be proportionate to the work's aims, medium, genre, intended audience, and relevant scholarly or artistic context.

  • Accurate Representation: Describe the principal aims, arguments, artistic intentions, content, methods, or functions of the work fairly and accurately.
  • Contextual Understanding: Situate the work within relevant scholarly debates, musical traditions, historical developments, artistic practices, technological settings, or cultural circumstances.
  • Analytical Depth: Evaluate the quality of arguments, evidence, methods, musical interpretation, artistic design, documentation, or technical execution as appropriate to the medium.
  • Original Contribution: Explain what the work adds to existing knowledge, artistic practice, cultural documentation, public understanding, or relevant disciplinary discussion.
  • Limitations and Critical Questions: Identify substantive weaknesses, omissions, methodological limitations, interpretive difficulties, or unresolved issues using clear reasoning and supporting evidence.
  • Cultural and Linguistic Sensitivity: Evaluate works with appropriate attention to their original languages, cultural settings, musical conventions, translation practices, and intended audiences.
  • Scholarly and Public Relevance: Consider the contribution's potential significance for researchers, educators, artists, students, cultural institutions, or other relevant readers.
  • Evidence-Based Judgment: Support evaluative claims with identifiable passages, arguments, musical examples, documented features, or other appropriate evidence rather than unsupported praise or criticism.

Critical independence does not require a negative assessment. Positive reviews are welcome when praise is specific, proportionate, and supported by evidence. Likewise, substantial criticism is appropriate when expressed fairly, accurately, and without personal attacks.

Reviews should assess the work itself rather than relying on the reputation, nationality, institutional status, commercial success, or personal characteristics of its creator.

Reviews should also consider relevant linguistic and geographic scholarship and explain their evaluative criteria when examining works produced within unfamiliar traditions or disciplinary settings. Where the work's primary value is documentary, pedagogical, artistic, or technical, it should be assessed on standards appropriate to that purpose rather than against expectations designed for unrelated genres.

Recommended Review Structure

Authors may adapt their structure according to the medium and purpose of the review. A strong contribution will ordinarily include the following elements:

  1. Identification and Introduction: Identify the work, explain its principal subject or purpose, and establish why it merits critical attention.
  2. Contextualization: Position the work within relevant scholarship, artistic traditions, cultural contexts, technological developments, or existing publications.
  3. Concise Description: Present the principal argument, organization, content, artistic approach, or technical features without excessive summary.
  4. Critical Analysis: Evaluate significant strengths, limitations, methodological decisions, interpretations, design choices, or contributions using appropriate supporting evidence.
  5. Comparative Perspective: Where useful, discuss related works, alternative approaches, established debates, or developments in the relevant field.
  6. Concluding Assessment: Provide a balanced judgment concerning the work's significance, limitations, potential audience, and contribution to music and sound studies.

Review Essays should organize the discussion around a shared analytical problem or theme. Comparisons must be substantively developed, with attention to differences among the works rather than simple descriptive juxtaposition.

The recommended structure is flexible. Authors may adopt alternative approaches where they produce a more effective critical argument and remain consistent with the journal's standards.

Editorial Independence & Section Boundaries

Book & Media Reviews publishes independent critical assessments. It is distinct from promotional writing, commercial advertising, ordinary publicity materials, and original research articles.

  • Independent Reviews: The principal purpose must be critical evaluation. Promotional descriptions, publisher announcements, press releases, and uncritical endorsements are unsuitable for publication as scholarly reviews.
  • Research Articles: A manuscript principally presenting original empirical, theoretical, historical, or methodological findings may belong in Research Articles and must follow the research-review requirements applicable to that classification.
  • Performance Notes: A text principally examining the author's own performance experience, rehearsal practice, or artistic process may be more appropriate for Performance Notes.
  • Digital Resource Assessment: Critical evaluations of digital archives, databases, research tools, or music platforms are welcome when they assess scholarly relevance, accessibility, evidence, documentation, functionality, or other meaningful criteria.
  • Editorial Selection: The Editorial Office may commission reviews, accept unsolicited proposals, recommend alternative works, or decline submissions that do not meet the section's standards.

The acceptance of a review proposal, invitation to contribute, or provision of complimentary review material does not guarantee publication or a favorable assessment.

Editors and contributors must preserve the independence of the review process. Publishers, creators, sponsors, and other interested parties must not be given control over the review's conclusions or the journal's final editorial decision.

Conflicts of Interest & Review Integrity

Authors of book and media reviews must disclose relationships or interests that could reasonably influence, or appear to influence, their assessment. This includes involvement in the reviewed work, close personal or professional connections with its creators, financial relationships, or access supplied for review. The Editorial Office may seek clarification, reassign the work, or decline publication when editorial independence cannot be adequately maintained.

Relationships Requiring Disclosure

  • Professional Relationships: Recent collaboration, co-authorship, joint artistic production, supervision, employment, or institutional relationships involving the work's creators.
  • Personal Relationships: Close personal relationships or other circumstances that could compromise the independence or perceived fairness of the review.
  • Financial Interests: Payments, sponsorship, royalties, consultancy arrangements, commercial relationships, or other material financial interests connected to the work.
  • Complimentary Materials: Complimentary books, advance screening access, promotional recordings, software licenses, or other access provided specifically for review purposes.
  • Direct Creative Involvement: Authorship, editing, performance, production, development, distribution, or other substantial involvement in the work under consideration.

Authors should not ordinarily review their own publications, recordings, artistic projects, or works in which they have had a substantial creative or commercial role. Such contributions may be considered under a different, clearly identified format where editorially appropriate.

A complimentary review copy, screening access, or temporary software license does not automatically disqualify an author, but the arrangement must be disclosed. Such access must not be conditional on a positive judgment, and a publisher, creator, or sponsor cannot control the review's conclusions or the journal's publication decision.

Reviews must not contain fabricated evaluations, invented quotations, false claims about the reviewed work, plagiarism, undisclosed paid promotion, or misleading representations of the reviewer's access to and assessment of the material.

AI Use & Critical Accountability

Reviews must represent the named human author's independent critical judgment. Artificial intelligence and AI-assisted technologies may be used only in accordance with the journal's AI Use Policy and must not substitute for genuine engagement with the work under review.

  • Substantive AI-assisted activities affecting the review's drafting, analysis, translation, organization, or presentation must be disclosed in accordance with journal policy.
  • Authors must personally verify all citations, quotations, bibliographic details, publication information, and factual claims.
  • AI-generated summaries, promotional descriptions, or automated evaluations must not be presented as evidence of direct examination of a work.
  • Authors must not fabricate reviewed passages, musical features, recordings, platform functions, sources, or critical observations.
  • Confidential manuscripts, unpublished materials, restricted recordings, and protected resources must not be uploaded to AI services without the necessary permissions and safeguards.
  • Named human authors remain responsible for the originality, accuracy, interpretation, fairness, and integrity of their reviews.

Basic language correction or formatting assistance may be used within the limits of the journal's policy. AI systems must not be credited as authors or relied upon as independent authorities for scholarly evaluation.

For detailed requirements, consult the AI Use Policy.

Quotations, Images & Supporting Media

Reviews may include short quotations, relevant images, musical examples, screenshots, or other supporting materials when these are necessary for critical analysis. Authors must comply with applicable copyright, licensing, attribution, and publication requirements.

  • Textual Quotations: Quote accurately, identify the source, and avoid reproducing excessive portions of the reviewed work. Permission may be necessary depending on the material, extent of reproduction, and applicable law.
  • Book Covers and Promotional Images: Provide appropriate source and rights information. Publication of a cover image or promotional photograph is subject to applicable permissions, licenses, or legal exceptions.
  • Musical Examples: Include musical notation or excerpts only where relevant to the analysis, with accurate identification and appropriate rights clearance.
  • Audio and Video: Supporting clips, recordings, and audiovisual materials must comply with applicable copyright, performers' rights, licensing conditions, and technical requirements.
  • Digital Screenshots: Screenshots of platforms, databases, and digital tools should be clearly identified, accurately represent the version reviewed, and comply with relevant rights and use conditions.
  • External Links: Authors may provide relevant stable links or persistent identifiers. External embedding or interactive presentation is subject to the journal's technical and editorial approval.

The journal's CC BY 4.0 licensing framework does not automatically place reproduced third-party works under the same license. Materials excluded from the article's Creative Commons license must be clearly identified, together with their applicable rights and restrictions.

Authors should consult the journal's Open Access Policy.

Editorial Assessment & Review

Submitted reviews undergo editorial assessment for relevance, factual accuracy, independence, critical substance, presentation, disclosure, and compliance with publication ethics and copyright requirements. The responsible editor may seek corrections, revised analysis, supporting references, or evidence of access to the work under review. Additional specialist advice may be sought when technical, musicological, historical, linguistic, or other complex questions require it.

Review Essays and Single Reviews are normally editorially assessed rather than processed as original research articles. Specialist consultation does not itself constitute double-blind research peer review; publication metadata and descriptions must accurately reflect the assessment actually completed. Final decisions—including acceptance, revision, rejection, further assessment, or appropriate section transfer—remain with authorized journal editors. Neither an invitation nor approval of a proposal guarantees publication.

For the treatment of non-research content and special collections, consult the Special Issues & Non-Research Content Review Policy.

How to Submit

Authors may submit a completed review or a suitable review proposal through the journal's online submission system, selecting Book & Media Reviews as the intended section. Identify whether the work is a Single Review or Review Essay, supply complete information about each work examined, and enter the required English metadata, contributor details, and applicable disclosures.

Before submitting, consult the Submission Guidelines and Style Guide. The Editorial Office may assess a proposal or redirect a manuscript to a more suitable section; submission or preliminary correspondence does not constitute acceptance.

Submit to Book & Media Reviews