Resonance: Journal of Global Music Studies welcomes original scholarly, critical, documentary, and creative contributions that advance understanding of music and sound across cultures, historical periods, and disciplinary boundaries. The journal supports rigorous research, informed interpretation, interdisciplinary exchange, and responsible engagement with musical and artistic practices. Authors should prepare manuscripts in accordance with the requirements of their intended publication section and the journal's standards of originality, scholarly integrity, ethical responsibility, and editorial presentation.

These guidelines explain the journal's submission languages, publication sections, manuscript preparation requirements, author information, supporting materials, ethical declarations, review procedures, and online submission process.

Submissions must not be under simultaneous consideration by another journal. Authors must disclose relevant preprints, earlier manuscript versions, conference publications, related works, translations, and other previous dissemination that may affect the originality or publication status of their contribution.

The journal recognizes that publication requirements differ among original research articles, artistic works, musical scores, documentary materials, interviews, and other forms of contribution. Where a section-specific requirement differs from a general manuscript requirement, the relevant section-specific instruction takes precedence.

1. Eligibility & Originality of Submissions

Resonance welcomes contributions from established scholars, early-career researchers, postgraduate students, independent scholars, music practitioners, composers, performers, translators, and other contributors whose work meets the standards of the intended publication category.

Authors are expected to ensure that:

  • Originality: The submission makes an identifiable original scholarly, critical, documentary, artistic, or interpretive contribution appropriate to its genre.
  • Exclusive Consideration: The manuscript is not simultaneously under consideration for publication by another journal.
  • Prior Dissemination: Relevant preprints, theses, conference presentations, proceedings, translations, and related publications are disclosed accurately.
  • Authorship: All listed authors have made appropriate contributions, approved the submission, and accepted responsibility for its contents.
  • Scholarly Attribution: Borrowed text, concepts, sources, recordings, musical examples, and other intellectual or artistic contributions are appropriately acknowledged.
  • Accuracy: Research evidence, quotations, references, translations, fieldwork records, analytical outputs, and other materials are represented faithfully.
  • Ethical and Legal Compliance: The submission satisfies relevant consent, institutional review, confidentiality, copyright, and cultural responsibility requirements.

Previously deposited preprints and appropriately disclosed earlier versions are not automatically treated as duplicate publication. However, authors must identify relevant prior dissemination and ensure that the submitted work meets the journal's originality and publication requirements.

Translations, annotated source texts, and other forms of republication may be considered where the relevant section permits them and necessary attribution, publication history, and rights requirements are satisfied.

2. Submission Languages

English is the primary language of publication. In support of multilingual scholarly exchange, the journal accepts submissions in the following five languages:

  • English
  • Chinese
  • German
  • Italian
  • Russian

English Title: All submissions must include an accurate English title. Authors may additionally provide the title in the original language of the manuscript.

English Abstract: An English abstract must be provided where required by the intended publication section. Abstract requirements vary among standard research submissions, forum contributions, short-form essays, and creative formats.

Authors are responsible for the accuracy, clarity, terminology, citation consistency, and appropriate academic or artistic presentation of their submissions. Non-English manuscripts should use consistent transliteration and identify significant original-language terminology where necessary for interpretation.

The Editorial Office may request language revisions or clarification when a manuscript's presentation materially affects readability, scholarly assessment, or the accuracy of publication metadata.

3. Abstracts, Keywords & English Metadata

Abstract requirements are determined by the selected publication section. Authors should not assume that one universal abstract length applies to every contribution.

English abstract requirements by contribution category
Contribution Category Abstract Requirement
Standard Scholarly Submissions An English abstract of up to 300 words, unless the section establishes a more specific requirement.
Forum: Author Replies and Scholarly Exchange An English abstract of up to 150 words.
Everyday Resonances An English abstract of 150–200 words, as required by the section's specific submission instructions.
Resonant Verses: Poetry and Music An English title and abstract are required. Authors must follow the section's requirements concerning translation and contextual documentation.
Other Creative and Special Formats Follow the abstract, contextual commentary, translation, and documentation requirements of the selected section.

Research Abstracts: Standard research abstracts should identify the research problem, principal objective, scholarly approach, major findings or argument, and contribution to the field. Claims in the abstract must be supported by the submitted manuscript.

Keywords: Standard scholarly submissions require four to six English keywords or keyword phrases, unless a section-specific rule provides otherwise. Keywords should represent the principal subject, musical tradition, research approach, geographic or historical context, or other important characteristics of the work.

Metadata Consistency: The title, abstract, keywords, authorship information, and other metadata entered into the online submission system must accurately correspond to the manuscript and be updated when necessary during revision and production.

Authors should consult the requirements of their intended section before submission. Where the section-specific abstract rule differs from the general Style Guide, the section-specific rule takes precedence.

4. Journal Sections & Contribution Types

Resonance publishes scholarly and creative contributions across twelve sections. Authors should select the category that best represents the purpose, content, and scholarly or artistic character of their submission.

  1. Research Articles

    Original research contributions addressing music and sound through historical, theoretical, analytical, empirical, or interdisciplinary approaches. The standard manuscript length is 6,000–10,000 words. Research articles undergo double-blind peer review by at least two independent qualified reviewers.

  2. Timeless Resonance: East–West Music Review

    Critical interpretation and scholarly discussion of musical works, traditions, histories, and cultural encounters, including the relationships and exchanges between different musical contexts.

  3. Sound Archives: Fieldwork and Memory

    Documentary, archival, ethnographic, and reflective work concerning musical memory, field recordings, historical sources, cultural heritage, and the preservation of sonic knowledge.

  4. Voices Now: Contemporary Soundscapes

    Contributions examining contemporary musical practices, sound environments, digital media, technological change, and the cultural life of music and sound in the present.

  5. The Score Page

    Original musical scores and related artistic or scholarly commentary. The section requires a readable musical score in PDF format accompanied by contextual or critical commentary, normally 1,000–3,000 words.

  6. Dialogues & Interviews

    Scholarly conversations, interviews, and documented exchanges involving musicians, researchers, performers, composers, cultural practitioners, and other relevant contributors.

  7. Performance Notes

    Critical and reflective writing about musical performance, interpretation, rehearsal, improvisation, composition, and artistic practice.

  8. Book & Media Reviews

    Analytical reviews of scholarly books, recordings, audiovisual media, performances, exhibitions, and other significant works relevant to music and sound studies.

  9. Translations & Source Texts

    Translated, annotated, or critically presented source materials. An English translation and appropriate introductory essay or critical commentary must be supplied according to the section's requirements, together with necessary source information and permissions.

  10. Forum: Author Replies and Scholarly Exchange

    Focused, constructive responses and exchanges concerning published research, musical interpretation, scholarly debate, and related issues. An English abstract of up to 150 words is required.

  11. Resonant Verses: Poetry and Music

    Original poetry, lyrics, sound poetry, translations, and experimental writing engaging with music and sound. An English title and abstract are required, and non-English creative texts must include an English translation.

  12. Everyday Resonances

    Concise, accessible, analytically grounded essays exploring music in everyday cultural life. The recommended length is 2,500–4,000 words, with a 150–200-word English abstract under the section's specific instructions.

Each section may establish additional requirements regarding length, manuscript organization, abstract, translation, musical examples, commentary, documentation, media, or ethical declarations.

The Editorial Office may recommend a different section where the selected category does not accurately reflect the manuscript's principal purpose or review requirements.

Manuscripts that substantially function as original research articles must undergo the applicable research peer-review procedure, regardless of the section initially selected by the author.

5. Manuscript Preparation & General Formatting

Standard scholarly manuscripts must comply with the journal's general formatting requirements. Creative, musical, documentary, and experimental formats may follow additional or alternative presentation requirements established by their respective sections.

  • File Format: Microsoft Word (.docx) is required for standard text-based manuscripts. PDF, musical notation, audio, video, image, and other supporting files may be submitted separately where applicable.
  • Font: Times New Roman is the standard font for English and other Latin-script manuscripts. Authors writing in Chinese or another non-Latin script should use an appropriate, legible Unicode-compatible font.
  • Font Size: Standard manuscript text should be 12 pt, with appropriate adjustments where different scripts or specialized musical notation require them.
  • Line Spacing: Double spacing is required for standard prose manuscripts. Poetry, musical scores, transcripts, and other specialized formats may follow section-specific requirements.
  • Page Layout: Use standard page margins, consecutive page numbering, clear paragraphs, and a consistent hierarchy of headings and subheadings.
  • Document Preparation: Avoid unnecessary decorative formatting, inconsistent styles, or complex layouts that obstruct editing and production.
  • Tables and Figures: Number tables, figures, illustrations, and musical examples consistently, with descriptive captions and appropriate source information.
  • Supplementary Materials: Identify relevant audio, video, musical notation, research data, transcripts, appendices, and other accompanying files clearly in the manuscript.
  • Accessibility: Provide appropriate descriptions, captions, transcripts, or equivalent supporting information where practicable to facilitate scholarly access.
  • Language and Terminology: Apply consistent spelling, transliteration, capitalization, musical terminology, and translation conventions throughout the manuscript.

Detailed preparation requirements are provided in the Journal Style Guide and the Article Templates.

6. Citation Style, References & Source Documentation

Resonance follows The Chicago Manual of Style, 17th edition. Authors may use either the Notes and Bibliography system or the Author-Date system, provided that the selected approach is applied consistently.

Notes and Bibliography

Authors using this system should provide appropriately numbered footnotes or endnotes, accurate citations, and a bibliography formatted according to Chicago conventions.

Author-Date

Authors using this system should provide consistent in-text author-date citations and a complete corresponding reference list.

Special Source Types

Music and sound scholarship may require citation of materials not adequately identified through conventional book or journal references. Authors should provide sufficient information to locate and evaluate relevant sources, including:

  • Musical compositions, scores, arrangements, editions, and manuscripts.
  • Sound recordings, performers, recording dates, producers, and catalog information.
  • Performances, concerts, exhibitions, broadcasts, and audiovisual works.
  • Archival collections, repository names, collection numbers, and relevant access conditions.
  • Interviews, oral histories, field recordings, and unpublished documentary materials.
  • Digital platforms, web materials, electronic databases, and other online sources.
  • Original-language sources, translations, and annotated editions.

All bibliographic references must be authentic, accurate, and verifiable. Include DOIs, stable URLs, archival identifiers, and other persistent references where available and appropriate.

Authors must not include invented references, misleading quotations, fabricated archives, or other unsupported source information. Citations suggested by AI-assisted tools must be checked against reliable original sources.

7. Required Submission Components

Authors should prepare the applicable submission materials before beginning the online process. Requirements may vary according to the contribution category.

A. Cover Letter

The cover letter should briefly:

  • Identify the manuscript title and intended journal section.
  • Explain the principal contribution and its relevance to the journal.
  • Confirm that the manuscript is not under simultaneous consideration by another journal.
  • Disclose relevant preprints, related works, previous presentations, or overlapping publications.
  • Identify any significant ethical, permissions, authorship, or editorial matters requiring attention.
  • Indicate relevant special circumstances, such as a proposed special issue or an unusual publication format, where applicable.

B. Main Manuscript

Submit the complete manuscript in the required editable format. Standard original research manuscripts must be prepared for double-blind peer review, with author-identifying information removed from the review file.

For non-research contributions, the appropriate level of anonymity may differ where the artistic, documentary, or editorial nature of the submission makes full anonymization unnecessary or impracticable.

C. Author Information and Title Details

Provide complete and accurate author information through the journal's online submission system. Relevant details include names, institutional affiliations, email addresses, and ORCID identifiers where available.

A separate title page or author-information file may be used where required to protect anonymity during research peer review.

Authors must confirm that contributor identities, authorship order, and institutional information are accurate and approved by the relevant contributors.

D. Abstract and Keywords

Provide the required English title, abstract, and keywords according to the selected section. Authors should ensure consistency between the manuscript and the metadata entered into OJS.

E. Biographical Note

Provide an author biography of approximately 100–150 words in the third person. The biographical note should be kept separate from the anonymized manuscript during double-blind review.

F. Declarations and Supporting Documents

Where relevant, provide or disclose:

  • Funding sources and financial support.
  • Competing interests and relevant professional relationships.
  • Ethics approval, exemption, and participant consent information.
  • Permissions and copyright documentation.
  • Substantive AI-use statements.
  • Relevant data-availability or access-restriction statements.
  • Musical scores, transcripts, audiovisual files, and other appropriate supplements.
  • Translation and source-text documentation where required.

Sensitive consent forms, identifying participant records, confidential recordings, or restricted research documents should not be uploaded indiscriminately as ordinary review files. The Editorial Office may arrange an appropriately restricted method of providing sensitive documentation where necessary.

8. Manuscript Anonymization for Double-Blind Review

Research manuscripts undergoing double-blind peer review must be prepared in a manner that protects author anonymity as far as reasonably practicable.

Authors should:

  1. Remove author names, affiliations, email addresses, ORCID identifiers, and direct identifying statements from the review manuscript.
  2. Keep acknowledgments, funding details, biographies, and identifying ethics declarations in separate submission materials where necessary.
  3. Review document properties, file names, comments, and tracked changes for identifying information.
  4. Cite previously published work accurately while avoiding unnecessary self-identifying language.
  5. Review supplementary files, transcripts, media credits, and embedded metadata for information that could compromise anonymity.
  6. Enter complete author information separately through the submission system.

The journal recognizes that complete anonymity may be difficult for work involving publicly available preprints, unique archives, published musical performances, publicly known artistic projects, or highly specialized research settings.

Authors should nevertheless make reasonable efforts to anonymize research manuscripts. The Editorial Office may provide instructions where full anonymization is impracticable.

Non-research works subject to editorial assessment may follow alternative identification requirements appropriate to their category.

9. Musical Examples, Audio, Video & Supplementary Files

The journal welcomes appropriate supporting materials that contribute to the scholarly, documentary, artistic, or interpretive value of a submission.

Supporting materials may include:

  • Musical Notation: Legible scores, transcriptions, excerpts, analytical reductions, and other notated examples.
  • Sound Recordings: Relevant performances, field recordings, archival audio, or other sonic evidence, subject to necessary permissions.
  • Audiovisual Materials: Video performances, interviews, demonstrations, or other multimedia documentation.
  • Images and Figures: Photographs, manuscript reproductions, analytical diagrams, and related visual materials.
  • Transcripts and Source Texts: Interview transcripts, oral histories, lyrics, translations, fieldnotes, and relevant documentary materials.
  • Research Documentation: Appendices, supplementary analyses, datasets, methods documentation, and other materials necessary to understand the contribution.

Files should have clear titles and identifying labels, with appropriate references in the manuscript. Captions and file descriptions should identify relevant sources, contributors, dates, recordings, rights holders, and restrictions where applicable.

Authors should use suitable file formats and provide timestamps, source descriptions, or explanatory notes where these are necessary for readers to locate the material discussed.

An external streaming link does not guarantee that the linked media will remain accessible indefinitely. Where supplementary materials are essential to evaluating an argument, authors should consider whether sufficiently documented, authorized copies can be provided to the journal.

The Editorial Office may request alternative formats, clearer documentation, replacement files, or additional permissions when necessary for evaluation, accessibility, or publication.

10. Copyright, Permissions & Publication Rights

Authors must ensure that submitted text, images, musical notation, lyrics, recordings, performances, translations, audiovisual materials, and other accompanying content can lawfully and ethically be published.

Music and sound publications may involve separate rights held by composers, lyricists, arrangers, performers, recording producers, publishers, photographers, translators, archival institutions, or other relevant parties.

Authors are responsible for:

  • Identifying materials created or owned by third parties.
  • Determining which reproduction, adaptation, translation, or publication permissions are required.
  • Obtaining appropriate authorization before publication where necessary.
  • Providing accurate attribution and rights information.
  • Disclosing materials that are excluded from the article's general open-access license.
  • Respecting relevant restrictions imposed by archives, communities, consent agreements, or applicable law.

Published scholarly content is subject to the journal's CC BY 4.0 open-access framework. However, third-party material expressly excluded from that license remains governed by its own copyright and rights conditions.

Permission to access or cite a work does not automatically confer permission to reproduce, translate, redistribute, or commercially reuse it.

Authors should consult the Open Access & Self-Archiving Policy for details of copyright ownership, publication rights, and licensing conditions.

11. Research Ethics & Author Declarations

Authors are responsible for the originality, integrity, accuracy, and ethical conduct of their work. The journal's ethical requirements apply to all submissions, including research, reviews, interviews, translations, musical compositions, poetry, and other creative contributions.

Research Involving Human Participants

Research involving interviews, fieldwork, identifiable participants, recordings, or sensitive personal information must comply with applicable consent, confidentiality, legal, and institutional ethics requirements.

Approval from an institutional review board or another competent ethics body must be obtained when required. The journal does not require all historical, archival, observational, or artistic contributions to possess a formal ethics approval number where such approval was not applicable.

Cultural and Community Responsibilities

Authors working with Indigenous, minority, sacred, ceremonial, traditional, or community-restricted musical materials must respect relevant cultural protocols, legitimate access restrictions, and appropriate attribution and consent requirements.

Plagiarism and Research Integrity

Plagiarism, substantial unattributed borrowing, fabricated evidence, manipulated research materials, and misleading prior-publication practices are incompatible with the journal's standards.

Authors should verify sources and review their manuscripts for originality before submission. Automated similarity reports may assist this process but do not independently establish plagiarism or originality.

Artificial Intelligence

Authors must disclose substantive AI-assisted activities in accordance with the journal's AI Use Policy. Relevant use may involve manuscript preparation, translation, transcription, data analysis, musical processing, sound generation, image production, or other significant scholarly and creative tasks.

AI systems cannot be named as authors. Human contributors remain responsible for the accuracy, originality, interpretation, ethics, and final content of submitted material.

Funding, Competing Interests and Other Declarations

Authors must disclose relevant research funding, financial or professional relationships, potential competing interests, and other circumstances that could materially affect the interpretation or editorial assessment of the work.

Authors should disclose significant prior publication, related manuscripts, preprints, and appropriate data or material access restrictions where applicable.

Further requirements are available in the Publication Ethics, Plagiarism Policy, AI Use Policy, and Fieldwork & Interview Ethics Policy.

12. Editorial Assessment & Peer Review

All submissions undergo an initial editorial assessment. The Editorial Office examines relevance, completeness, originality, scholarly or artistic quality, ethical compliance, and suitability for further evaluation.

Manuscripts may be returned for missing information, clarification, or technical correction. Submissions that do not satisfy the journal's minimum requirements may be declined during editorial screening without external review.

Original Research

Original research manuscripts proceeding beyond editorial screening undergo double-blind peer review by at least two independent qualified reviewers. This standard applies to research articles in regular and special issues.

Reviewers examine scholarly contribution, originality, conceptual and methodological appropriateness, relevant evidence, quality of analysis, clarity of presentation, and ethical compliance.

Non-Research and Creative Contributions

Book reviews, media reviews, interviews, poetry, musical scores, translations, performance reflections, scholarly exchanges, and other non-research contributions are normally assessed by the Editorial Office, section editors, or qualified editorial advisers.

Additional specialist assessment may be arranged when a submission contains complex music analysis, substantial scholarly claims, archival materials, translation questions, or significant ethical concerns.

Editorial review and independent research peer review are distinct procedures. A contribution evaluated solely through editorial assessment must not be described as a double-blind peer-reviewed original research article.

Editorial Decisions

The responsible editor may determine acceptance, minor revisions, major revisions, rejection, or further assessment as appropriate to the manuscript and completed review process.

Reviewers provide scholarly recommendations, while final acceptance and rejection decisions remain with authorized journal editors. An invitation to revise does not guarantee acceptance.

For further details, consult the Peer Review Process, Review Criteria, and Special Issues & Non-Research Content Review Policy.

13. Indicative Editorial & Publication Timeline

The journal seeks to provide timely editorial assessment, constructive feedback, responsible manuscript handling, and orderly publication preparation.

The following timeframes are indicative planning estimates rather than guaranteed deadlines or verified historical averages.

Indicative research manuscript processing periods
Stage Indicative Period
Initial Editorial Screening Typically 2–3 weeks
Double-Blind Peer Review Generally 6–12 weeks
Author Revision Typically 2–4 weeks per round, where applicable
Copyediting and Typesetting Typically 2–3 weeks
Overall Planning Target Approximately 20 weeks from submission to Online First publication under standard conditions

The estimated periods should not be added mechanically to establish a guaranteed publication date. The overall target includes applicable editorial and production activities, while additional revision or review rounds may extend the process.

Actual timing depends on reviewer availability, manuscript complexity, revision requirements, editorial workload, ethical verification, and production circumstances.

Non-research contributions may follow different review and production schedules. The assignment of an accepted article to a regular journal issue is distinct from its Online First publication date.

14. Open Access & Publication Charges

Resonance provides immediate open access to published articles without reader subscription fees or embargo periods. Authors retain copyright in their original contributions under the journal's applicable publication agreement and licensing arrangements.

The journal operates an Article Processing Charge (APC) framework. No submission fee is charged, and an APC is assessed only following formal manuscript acceptance.

Standard charges, reduced rates, promotional arrangements, and full waivers are governed by the journal's published APC policy. Applicable charges may depend on submission date, author eligibility, formally announced promotions, and approved waiver arrangements.

Editorial screening, peer review, revision, acceptance, and rejection decisions are independent of the author's ability to pay. A fee payment, discount, sponsorship, or waiver does not guarantee publication or preferential editorial treatment.

Authors should review the Article Processing Charges & Waiver Policy before submission and contact the Editorial Office where clarification is required.

15. Online Submission Procedure

Manuscripts should be submitted through the official Resonance online submission system. Authors may need to register or sign in before beginning the submission process.

A standard submission involves the following steps:

  1. 1. Account Access: Register for an author account or sign in through the official journal platform.
  2. 2. Select the Journal Section: Choose the publication category most appropriate to the manuscript.
  3. 3. Provide Submission Details: Enter the manuscript title, abstract, keywords, language, author information, and other required metadata.
  4. 4. Upload Manuscript Files: Upload the main manuscript and any required separate title page, author information, and supporting files.
  5. 5. Provide Declarations: Complete relevant originality, prior-publication, ethics, funding, copyright, conflict-of-interest, and AI-use information.
  6. 6. Review and Confirm: Verify the completeness of uploaded files and consistency of the manuscript and submission metadata before final submission.
  7. 7. Editorial Communication: Monitor the submission account and associated email address for requests for clarification, reviewer comments, editorial decisions, and production correspondence.

Incomplete submissions may be returned to the author for correction. The Editorial Office may request additional materials where necessary for the selected publication category or editorial assessment.

Go to the Submission Portal

This link opens the journal's submission process. Authors who are not signed in may first be directed to the login or account registration page.

16. Pre-Submission Checklist

Before completing a submission, authors should confirm that:

  1. The manuscript fits the journal's aims and scope and has been assigned to the appropriate publication section.
  2. All authors have approved the submission and the manuscript is not simultaneously under consideration elsewhere.
  3. Relevant earlier publications, preprints, translations, conference presentations, and overlapping works have been disclosed.
  4. The main manuscript follows the applicable length, format, language, and citation requirements.
  5. An accurate English title, the required abstract, and appropriate keywords have been provided.
  6. Complete author information and the required biographical note have been entered or supplied separately.
  7. Research manuscripts have been appropriately anonymized for double-blind review.
  8. All references, musical scores, figures, audiovisual materials, quotations, translations, and archival sources are accurately identified.
  9. Necessary copyright permissions, participant consent, research ethics documentation, and relevant cultural restrictions have been addressed.
  10. Applicable funding, competing interests, research data restrictions, and substantive AI-assisted activities have been disclosed.
  11. Supplementary files are clearly labeled and correspond to references in the manuscript.
  12. Online submission metadata is complete, accurate, and consistent with the uploaded materials.

17. Editorial Inquiries & Author Support

Authors may contact the Editorial Office with questions concerning manuscript preparation, appropriate publication sections, submission requirements, editorial procedures, special issue arrangements, permissions, or other matters relevant to their submission.

Inquiries concerning a manuscript already under editorial consideration should include the manuscript title and submission identification number where available.

Resonance Editorial Office
[email protected]

The Editorial Office may provide procedural clarification and direct authors to relevant policies. Such correspondence does not constitute advance acceptance or a guarantee of a favorable editorial decision.

Editorial Statement: Resonance: Journal of Global Music Studies seeks to provide a clear, fair, and responsible submission process for scholars and creative contributors working across the diverse fields of music and sound studies. Manuscripts are evaluated according to their intellectual or artistic contribution, appropriate evidence and methods, editorial quality, and compliance with publication ethics. The journal encourages originality, cultural sensitivity, methodological diversity, accurate attribution, and meaningful scholarly dialogue while maintaining transparent distinctions between research peer review and other forms of editorial assessment.

Authors should consult the journal's Style Guide, Article Templates, Peer Review Process, Publication Ethics, and Article Processing Charges & Waiver Policy before preparing their submissions.