Resonance: Journal of Global Music Studies applies a structured editorial process to original research and to the journal’s creative, critical, documentary, and reflective contributions. Research articles are subject to double-blind peer review by at least two independent qualified reviewers when they proceed to external review; non-research submissions follow the editorial and, where necessary, specialist assessment applicable to their content type. The review classification of each published contribution must accurately reflect the process completed.

Manuscript handling proceeds from submission and initial screening through the appropriate assessment route, editorial decisions, any necessary revisions, formal acceptance, production, and online publication. Accepted work may subsequently be assigned to a scheduled issue. At each stage, the journal seeks scholarly independence, transparent communication, confidentiality, and the integrity of the published record.

Indicative submission-to-publication target: approximately 20 weeks. For a research manuscript completing an ordinary review and revision cycle, this is an editorial planning target from initial submission to Online First publication, not a guaranteed maximum or a measured average. Reviewer availability, additional review rounds, substantive author revisions, ethical or rights questions, and production needs can lengthen the process.

Indicative Editorial Timeframes

The periods below are planning estimates, not enforceable deadlines or statistically verified averages. The actual timetable depends on manuscript complexity, the review route, the number and extent of revisions, specialist availability, and the work needed to prepare an accepted contribution for publication.

Indicative review and production periods
Stage Indicative Period
Initial Editorial Screening Typically 2–3 weeks
Double-Blind Peer Review Generally 6–12 weeks for research manuscripts
Author Revision Typically 2–4 weeks per revision round, where applicable
Copyediting and Typesetting Typically 2–3 weeks
Acceptance to Online Publication Approximately 3–5 weeks, including production
Overall Submission-to-Publication Target Generally within approximately 20 weeks under standard conditions; not a guaranteed maximum

Reading the timetable: Individual periods must not be added mechanically to promise a publication date. The estimated 3–5 weeks from acceptance to online publication already includes production; the 2–3-week copyediting and typesetting estimate is not a separate charge of time added after that period. Revision and additional review may occur more than once, and the total may exceed 20 weeks.

The previously cited 8–10-week review estimate sits within the broader 6–12-week indicative peer-review range. It should not be described as an empirically established average without journal-level performance data. Non-research contributions may follow different timetables; formal issue assignment is distinct from the Online First date.

Non-research contributions may follow shorter or different assessment routes and are not automatically subject to the research peer-review timetable. Formal issue assignment also follows the journal's publication schedule and is distinct from the date of Online First publication.

Review Routes & Content Classification

Resonance publishes original research as well as artistic, documentary, interpretive, critical, and public-facing scholarly material. The manuscript's substantive claims and intended publication category determine the assessment route; a section title, creative format, or reference to research does not by itself determine peer-review status.

Original Research Articles

Original research manuscripts proceeding to external review undergo double-blind assessment by at least two independent reviewers with expertise appropriate to the research question, method, and subject area. Evaluation addresses scholarly significance, engagement with relevant work, methodological rigor, evidence, interpretation, and the originality of the contribution.

This standard applies to original research in regular and special issues alike. An invitation, institutional relationship, or thematic fit does not replace independent research review.

Non-Research and Creative Contributions

Book and media reviews, interviews, source translations, performance notes, scores, forum contributions, creative works, and other non-research formats normally receive assessment by the Editorial Office or suitably qualified editors and advisers. Their evaluation is tailored to the work's scholarly, artistic, documentary, interpretive, or public-facing purpose.

Editorial assessment addresses relevance, contribution, factual and documentary accuracy, interpretive quality, clear presentation, consent, permissions, and publication ethics. Independent expertise may be sought where linguistic, historical, technical, musical, methodological, or cultural issues warrant closer consideration.

Accurate Review-Status Disclosure

Editorial assessment and formal research peer review are not interchangeable. A non-research work that receives specialist verification is not automatically a double-blind peer-reviewed research article. The journal's content labels, article metadata, and review-status statements should accurately describe the procedure used.

Further details are available in the Special Issues & Non-Research Content Review Policy.

Double-Blind Peer Review Standards

The journal applies double-blind peer review to original research manuscripts. Under this model, the identities of authors and reviewers are not disclosed to one another through the formal review process.

  • Independent Reviewers: At least two independent specialists with relevant subject knowledge are selected to assess each research manuscript proceeding to peer review.
  • Reviewer Selection: Editors consider methodological expertise, disciplinary relevance, scholarly experience, independence, and potential conflicts of interest.
  • Author Anonymization: Authors are expected to prepare an anonymized review manuscript and provide identifying information separately, according to the journal's submission instructions.
  • Reviewer Confidentiality: Reviewers must protect manuscript contents, unpublished findings, confidential data, and information acquired through the review process.
  • Conflicts of Interest: Editors and reviewers must declare relevant personal, professional, institutional, financial, or academic relationships. Individuals with disqualifying conflicts must not participate in the affected evaluation.
  • Additional Review: An additional reviewer may be appointed where reports diverge substantially, specialist expertise is missing, or further independent evaluation is necessary.
  • Fair Evaluation: Manuscripts must be assessed according to scholarly merit, methodological appropriateness, originality, evidence, and relevance rather than author identity, institutional prestige, nationality, or financial circumstances.
  • Editorial Responsibility: Reviewers provide expert recommendations, while acceptance and rejection decisions remain the responsibility of the journal's editors.

Double-blind review reduces the disclosure of identities but does not guarantee that every manuscript can be made completely unidentifiable. Prior public presentations, preprints, distinctive datasets, artistic works, or specialized research contexts may allow an informed reviewer to infer authorship. Editors should manage such limitations and associated conflicts of interest appropriately.

Publication Ethics & Editorial Independence

Manuscripts are subject to relevant originality, plagiarism, authorship, disclosure, research ethics, and publication integrity checks. The journal may request additional information where concerns arise concerning source reliability, consent, copyright, data integrity, artificial intelligence, or potential duplicate publication.

  • Originality and Plagiarism: Editors may use similarity screening and manual verification to assess inappropriate textual overlap, unattributed sources, and potential duplicate publication. Similarity results require contextual evaluation and do not independently establish misconduct.
  • Research Ethics: Studies involving human participants, recordings, interviews, fieldwork, or restricted cultural materials must meet relevant consent, confidentiality, institutional approval, and publication requirements.
  • Authorship and Contributions: Authors must accurately identify contributors and disclose relevant authorship changes, funding, acknowledgments, and conflicts of interest.
  • AI Use: Substantive use of AI-assisted technologies must be disclosed as required by the journal's AI Use Policy. AI-generated citations, evidence, recordings, findings, or other materials must not be misrepresented as authentic sources.
  • Confidentiality: Editors and reviewers must not disclose confidential manuscript materials or use unpublished content for unauthorized personal or professional purposes.
  • Independent Editorial Decisions: Editorial decisions must not be influenced by sponsorship, institutional relationships, commercial interests, author identity, or the ability to pay an Article Processing Charge.

Submissions from Editors and Editorial Board Members

Manuscripts submitted by editors, Editorial Board members, guest editors, or other individuals with editorial responsibilities must be handled by an appropriately qualified independent editor without a relevant conflict of interest.

An involved editor or board member must not select reviewers, access confidential review or decision materials beyond their role as an author, influence reviewer recommendations, or participate in the editorial decision on their own manuscript.

Editorial and reviewer conflicts must be managed consistently for both regular and special issue submissions. Invitation or editorial status does not guarantee acceptance.

Stages of the Publication Process

1. Submission & Initial Editorial Screening

Authors submit their manuscripts through the journal's online submission system. The Editorial Office checks the submission for completeness, section suitability, originality, formatting, required metadata, declarations, ethical compliance, and adherence to relevant submission policies.

Editors may return an incomplete submission for technical correction, reject a manuscript without external review when it is outside the journal's scope or fails essential standards, or assign it for further assessment. The timetable above indicates the approximate duration of this stage; a screening decision does not constitute peer review.

2. Reviewer Selection & Expert Evaluation

Research manuscripts selected for external review are sent to at least two independent qualified reviewers. The review may take longer than the indicative period when suitable expertise is difficult to secure, reports conflict, or additional assessment is required. Non-research submissions follow their applicable editorial route.

Reviewers assess the manuscript's scholarly quality and provide reasoned recommendations. Their reports should identify strengths, limitations, methodological or conceptual concerns, and revisions necessary to improve the work.

3. Initial Editorial Decision

After considering the review reports and the manuscript's overall merits, the responsible editor determines the appropriate next action.

Editorial decisions may include:

  • Accept: The manuscript satisfies publication requirements, subject to any remaining production checks.
  • Revisions Required: The author must address specified scholarly, analytical, ethical, structural, or editorial issues before a further decision.
  • Reject: The manuscript is unsuitable for publication or does not meet the necessary scholarly or editorial standards.
  • Further Review: An additional independent opinion or further evaluation is required before a decision can be reached.

Authors normally receive the decision and relevant anonymized reviewer comments through the submission system or official editorial correspondence. Reviewer recommendations inform but do not determine the final editorial decision.

4. Revision & Resubmission

Authors invited to revise should submit a revised manuscript together with a clear, point-by-point response explaining how the editorial and reviewer comments have been addressed.

The timetable gives a typical revision window of 2–4 weeks per round; the editor may agree to additional time where extensive changes, new analyses, source verification, or ethical documentation are necessary. A revision request is not a promise of acceptance.

Authors may explain a reasoned disagreement with a reviewer's recommendation, provided that the response is scholarly, specific, and supported by appropriate evidence. Compliance with every reviewer suggestion is not automatically required where an alternative approach is adequately justified and accepted by the editor.

Revised submissions may be examined by the handling editor, returned to reviewers, or referred to further specialists. The editorial decision depends on the adequacy of the revision and any remaining substantive concerns.

5. Final Editorial Evaluation & Acceptance

Following revision and any necessary further review, the responsible editor evaluates whether the manuscript satisfies the applicable academic, ethical, documentary, and publication standards.

Formal acceptance is issued only after the journal has determined that the manuscript is suitable for publication. The final decision is made by an authorized editor and must remain independent of the author's financial status or publication fee arrangements.

Any applicable Article Processing Charge is handled only after formal acceptance, subject to the journal's published fees, promotional arrangements, and waiver policy. No payment is required merely to submit a manuscript for consideration.

6. Copyediting, Typesetting & Author Proofs

Accepted manuscripts enter the production process, which may include language and copyediting checks, reference verification, formatting, preparation of figures and tables, supplementary media processing, and typesetting.

Authors may be asked to review proofs to identify errors introduced during production, verify bibliographic and author information, and confirm that figures, musical examples, translations, and relevant supplementary files are correctly represented.

The table gives an indicative 2–3 weeks for copyediting and typesetting and 3–5 weeks overall between acceptance and Online First release. These periods overlap; they are not sequential promises. Proof corrections, complex media, translation checks, or rights clearance may extend production.

Significant changes to research findings, authorship, conclusions, or the scholarly substance of a manuscript after acceptance require editorial approval and may necessitate additional review.

7. Online First Publication

Following completion of production and final publication checks, accepted contributions may be released individually through the journal's Online First publication model.

On publication, the article record should contain accurate authorship, title, content type, publication date, and citation details. A DOI is recorded in accordance with the journal's applicable DOI-registration practice, and the published version should be cited through its available persistent identifier and bibliographic metadata.

Online First publication makes the completed article available before its formal assignment to a scheduled issue. Authors should cite the published version using its DOI and available bibliographic information.

8. Formal Issue Assignment

Online First contributions are subsequently allocated to scheduled issues under the journal's stated semiannual publication model. The schedule and production arrangements determine when this occurs; issue allocation does not reset the earlier online publication date.

Volume, issue, page, article number, or other bibliographic information may be added or confirmed as applicable. Such changes should be reflected consistently in the public article record and citation metadata.

Editorial Communication & Delays

The Editorial Office communicates decisions, requests for additional information, and revision instructions through the journal's online submission system or official correspondence. Corresponding authors should monitor the status of their manuscript and keep their contact information current.

Processing delays may arise from reviewer recruitment, unavailable specialist expertise, multiple rounds of revision, manuscript complexity, unresolved ethical or copyright issues, author response times, or technical production requirements.

Where a manuscript remains under consideration beyond the indicative timeframe, the corresponding author may contact the Editorial Office for an update. A processing estimate should not be interpreted as a guarantee of acceptance, rejection, review completion, or publication by a specific date.

Appeals, Complaints & Procedural Fairness

Authors may submit reasoned appeals or complaints to the Editorial Office in writing, identifying the manuscript, the decision or procedure involved, and the evidence supporting the concern. These requests are considered under the journal's applicable editorial and ethical procedures; the publication timetable does not override procedural fairness.

Appeals Against Editorial Decisions

An appeal should explain a material factual mistake, overlooked evidence, substantive misunderstanding, conflict of interest, procedural irregularity, or another issue capable of affecting the original decision. Disagreement with an adverse outcome alone is insufficient grounds for reversal.

Where appropriate, reconsideration may involve a qualified editor or adviser not previously responsible for the decision. An appeal does not automatically trigger another round of peer review or guarantee a different outcome.

Complaints About Editorial Procedures

Complaints may involve conflicts of interest, confidentiality, reviewer conduct, unexplained delay, unequal treatment, or procedural matters that could impair fair evaluation. The Editorial Office should consider relevant information, seek clarification when necessary, and handle sensitive details confidentially.

Post-Publication Corrections & Research Integrity

The journal's responsibility to maintain a reliable scholarly record extends beyond online publication. Authors, readers, reviewers, and other parties may report significant errors or integrity concerns to the Editorial Office for assessment under the relevant post-publication policies.

Depending on the nature and severity of the issue, the journal may assess the need for a correction, expression of concern, retraction, or other appropriate editorial action.

Material changes affecting evidence, conclusions, authorship, or the reliability of a published contribution must be documented through an appropriate public or editorial record rather than silently altering the version of record. See the Corrections and Retractions Policy for the relevant procedure.

Author Responsibilities Throughout the Workflow

Authors are expected to contribute to the efficiency, accuracy, and integrity of the editorial process by:

  • Submit original, appropriately prepared work with accurate author identities, affiliations, metadata, relevant citations, and complete funding, competing-interest, and AI-use disclosures.
  • Prepare anonymized review files when required, and protect the confidentiality of peer-review correspondence and restricted research materials.
  • Provide necessary permissions, consent and ethics information, and accurate reporting of prior dissemination, related publications, and contributors.
  • Respond to editorial decisions and reviewer recommendations constructively, explaining changes and any justified disagreements in revised submissions.
  • Review production proofs for author, bibliographic, language, musical, figure, and supplementary-material accuracy; report material post-publication errors promptly.

Editorial Inquiries

For manuscript-status inquiries, revision questions, production issues, appeals, or procedural concerns, contact the Resonance Editorial Office at [email protected]. For an active submission, include its title and submission identifier where available.

Editorial Statement: Resonance seeks consistent scholarly standards, appropriate assessment of each publication type, transparent handling of decisions, and responsible maintenance of the published record. The timeframes on this page support authors' planning; they do not guarantee the completion of review, acceptance, or publication within a specified period.

Authors should consult the Submission Guidelines, Peer Review Process, and Special Issues & Non-Research Content Review Policy for further policy details. When a query concerns a specific active manuscript, its corresponding author should communicate through the journal's online submission system or the official Editorial Office address above.