Special Issues & Content Review
Resonance: Journal of Global Music Studies publishes original research alongside critical, documentary, creative, reflective, and practice-based contributions. This policy establishes how the journal develops and oversees special issues, appoints and supervises guest editors, handles invited submissions, and evaluates non-research content. Its purpose is to protect scholarly and artistic quality while maintaining editorial independence, conflict-of-interest safeguards, accurate review classifications, and standards suited to different forms of music and sound scholarship.
The journal welcomes research articles, thematic collections, reviews, interviews, translations, source texts, archival reflections, performance notes, musical scores, poetry, scholarly exchanges, and interdisciplinary essays. Each contribution is assessed in relation to its actual content, evidentiary claims, and intended publication category. A special issue is a form of editorial organization, not a separate route that exempts manuscripts from the journal's normal requirements.
Original research articles, including those submitted to special issues, undergo double-blind peer review by at least two independent qualified reviewers. Non-research contributions normally receive editorial assessment, supplemented by independent subject, language, technical, or ethics expertise where necessary. A specialist consultation does not, on its own, convert an editorially reviewed contribution into a double-blind peer-reviewed research article.
1. General Editorial Principles
All contributions are evaluated according to standards appropriate to their content, purpose, and publication category.
- Scholarly and Artistic Quality: Contributions must demonstrate appropriate originality, accuracy, clarity, relevance, and intellectual, cultural, documentary, or artistic value.
- Equal Research Standards: Research articles in regular and special issues are subject to the same standards of independent peer review and scholarly assessment.
- Appropriate Review Methods: The review process must correspond to the nature of the contribution rather than apply a single research article model to every genre.
- Editorial Independence: Decisions must be based on relevant editorial considerations and must not be improperly influenced by personal relationships, institutional status, sponsorship, guest editorship, or payment arrangements.
- Conflict-of-Interest Management: Relevant relationships among authors, reviewers, editors, and guest editors must be disclosed and managed appropriately.
- Transparency: The journal must distinguish research peer review from editorial review and describe a contribution's publication status accurately.
- Ethical Compliance: Every contribution must comply with applicable requirements concerning originality, consent, copyright, confidentiality, attribution, disclosure, and responsible AI use.
- Human Editorial Accountability: Final editorial authority remains with appropriately authorized human editors.
The journal recognizes methodological and disciplinary diversity. Historical, philosophical, ethnographic, analytical, computational, documentary, and artistic contributions should be assessed using criteria appropriate to their respective aims and forms of evidence.
A contribution is not required to include cross-cultural comparison, quantitative analysis, formal theoretical modeling, or conventional empirical methods unless such approaches are necessary for its stated research questions or claims.
2. Special Issues: Purpose and Scope
Special issues are thematically organized collections designed to advance focused scholarly discussion within musicology, ethnomusicology, sound studies, performance studies, cultural history, and related disciplines.
A special issue may address a particular theoretical debate, musical repertoire, region, historical period, research method, archive, performance practice, technological development, or emerging interdisciplinary question.
Special issues may be proposed by scholars, editorial board members, research groups, guest editors, conference organizers, professional networks, or other qualified contributors.
Proposals should demonstrate:
- A coherent and clearly defined scholarly theme.
- Relevance to the journal's aims and scope.
- A meaningful contribution to existing debates or emerging areas of inquiry.
- Appropriate disciplinary or interdisciplinary expertise.
- A feasible editorial and publication plan.
- An appropriate approach to contributor diversity, editorial independence, and potential conflicts of interest.
A special issue may include both research articles and clearly identified non-research contributions. The presence of different genres within one collection does not alter the review requirements applicable to each contribution.
A collection's coherence is assessed separately from the publication merits of each manuscript. Editorial or guest-editor introductions may explain relationships among contributions, but neither their inclusion nor a planned thematic sequence can substitute for the individual evaluation, documentation, and approval required by each submission.
3. Special Issue Proposals and Approval
Prospective guest editors should submit a sufficiently detailed proposal for consideration by the Editorial Office.
A proposal should normally include:
- The proposed special issue title and thematic description.
- The scholarly rationale, significance, and expected contribution.
- The disciplinary, geographic, historical, or methodological scope.
- The names, affiliations, qualifications, and brief biographies of proposed guest editors.
- A preliminary list of proposed topics, invited contributors, or possible manuscripts, where available.
- An indication of the anticipated balance between research and non-research contributions.
- The proposed submission, assessment, revision, and publication schedule.
- Relevant conference, workshop, research project, or institutional connections.
- Any financial sponsorship, organizational support, or other material interests.
- Potential conflicts of interest and proposed arrangements for independent manuscript handling.
The Editorial Office may request clarification, amendments to the proposed scope, changes to guest editor arrangements, or additional information before determining whether the collection is suitable for development.
Proposal assessment should also consider whether the proposed guest editors can exercise independent judgment, whether their specialist expertise adequately covers the planned subject matter, and whether the collection can be supervised within the journal's established editorial workflow. The journal should not approve a project merely because it comes from a prominent institution, conference, sponsor, or contributor network.
Approval of a special issue proposal authorizes the development of the collection under journal oversight. It does not guarantee acceptance of individual manuscripts, a fixed number of articles, or publication on a particular date.
The journal may reconsider or discontinue a special issue arrangement where significant problems concerning editorial quality, feasibility, conflicts of interest, research integrity, or compliance arise.
4. Guest Editor Eligibility and Appointment
Guest editors are selected for relevant scholarly or artistic expertise, professional suitability, capacity to coordinate the thematic collection, and willingness to comply with the journal's editorial and publication ethics requirements. The Editorial Office should take reasonable steps to verify their identities, affiliations, credentials, and relevant editorial experience rather than relying solely on unsolicited nominations or unverified online profiles.
Before confirming an appointment, the Editorial Office may examine:
- The proposed guest editor's scholarly or professional qualifications.
- Relevant research, publication, editorial, or creative experience.
- Knowledge of the proposed subject area and appropriate research methods.
- Ability to identify independent, suitably qualified reviewers.
- Relevant professional affiliations and disclosed interests.
- Ability to communicate with contributors and meet agreed editorial responsibilities.
- Any credible concerns that materially affect professional or editorial suitability.
Appointment as a guest editor does not confer unrestricted authority over the journal's submission system, confidential records, reviewer assignments, financial arrangements, or publication decisions.
The Editorial Office determines the responsibilities and access privileges appropriate to the appointment. Guest editors may be replaced or have their responsibilities modified if they cannot fulfill the journal's requirements.
An appointment should distinguish thematic curation, contributor communication, reviewer recommendations, specialist assessment, and access to confidential records from the authority to issue formal editorial decisions. Any participation in the review workflow must be supervised by the journal and restricted to functions actually assigned. The guest editor's scholarly prominence does not override these limits.
5. Calls for Papers, Invitations and Publication Arrangements
Calls for papers and invitations associated with a special issue must describe the collection accurately and must not mislead prospective contributors concerning editorial authority, peer review, acceptance, publication schedules, or applicable fees.
An approved call for papers should ordinarily identify:
- The journal title and special issue theme.
- The responsible guest editor or editorial team, where applicable.
- The scholarly scope and eligible submission categories.
- The official manuscript submission procedure.
- The applicable research peer-review or editorial assessment arrangements.
- Submission dates and indicative publication planning, where established.
- Any relevant author-side publication charges and applicable waiver arrangements.
- The fact that invitation or thematic suitability does not guarantee publication.
Guest editors must not promise manuscript acceptance, guaranteed publication, exemption from peer review, or preferential editorial treatment.
Submission invitations should not be used to disguise paid publication guarantees, exchange favors for authorship or publication, or pressure potential contributors to cite particular works unnecessarily.
Any Article Processing Charges, discounts, or waivers must follow the journal's officially published arrangements. Payment or sponsorship must not determine the scholarly outcome of manuscript assessment.
Authors should submit invited and open-call manuscripts through the journal's online submission system, using the appropriate section and any special-issue identification supplied by the Editorial Office. Guest editors should not require authors to send confidential manuscripts to personal email accounts or unrelated services as a substitute for the authorized submission workflow. Current rates and eligibility conditions are governed by the Article Processing Charges (APC) Policy, not by informal statements in a call for papers.
6. Review of Special Issue Research Articles
Original research articles submitted to special issues must satisfy the same editorial and scholarly standards as research articles submitted to regular issues.
All special issue research articles are subject to double-blind peer review by at least two independent qualified reviewers. A thematic invitation, guest editor recommendation, prior conference presentation, or inclusion in an approved collection does not replace this requirement.
The procedure includes:
- Initial Editorial Screening: The Editorial Office or responsible editor assesses relevance, manuscript completeness, originality, ethical compliance, basic scholarly quality, and suitability for full research review.
- Independent Reviewer Selection: At least two qualified reviewers are selected according to subject expertise, independence, and the absence of relevant conflicts of interest.
- Double-Blind Evaluation: The journal seeks to protect both author and reviewer identities throughout the research review process, including appropriate manuscript anonymization.
- Scholarly Assessment: Reviewers evaluate originality, contribution, conceptual and methodological appropriateness, evidence, analysis, interpretation, relevant literature, presentation, and ethical integrity.
- Editorial Decision: The responsible editor considers reviewer reports and the journal's standards before determining an appropriate decision.
- Revision and Reassessment: Authors respond to reviewer comments and provide revised manuscripts where requested. Further external evaluation may be required.
- Final Journal Authorization: Acceptance or rejection is confirmed by an authorized editor acting under the journal's editorial responsibility.
Where reviewers offer substantially conflicting assessments or a manuscript requires additional specialist knowledge, the handling editor may invite further independent review.
Guest editors may explain the collection's thematic context, identify potential reviewers, and offer documented editorial advice within their assigned role. They must not circumvent the journal's independent research-review requirements, select conflicted reviewers, suppress material criticisms, or decide acceptance for manuscripts under their own influence. The responsible journal editor evaluates the reports and is accountable for the decision, including when reviewer recommendations differ.
Double-blind review may be more difficult where a submission derives from a publicly presented conference paper, preprint, performance, or readily identifiable research project. Reasonable anonymization measures should nevertheless be applied. The journal must not imply that identities were demonstrably concealed in circumstances where anonymity could not realistically be maintained.
Reviewer expertise and independence must remain verifiable even where the scholarly community is small or the work is identifiable. If a reviewer recognizes an author or discovers a relevant relationship during assessment, the reviewer should notify the handling editor; the editorial office will determine whether reassignment or another safeguard is necessary. A publicly accessible preprint does not itself eliminate the journal's obligation to manage reviewer conflicts.
Further details are provided in the Peer Review Process and Review Criteria.
7. Guest Editor Responsibilities and Editorial Oversight
Guest editors help develop the intellectual direction and coherence of a special issue while operating within the journal's established editorial and ethical framework.
Their responsibilities may include:
- Developing and refining the special issue's academic scope.
- Identifying potential contributors and encouraging suitable submissions.
- Providing relevant thematic and disciplinary expertise.
- Recommending independent reviewers with appropriate qualifications.
- Assessing thematic coherence and relevant scholarly questions.
- Supporting communication about revisions and editorial deadlines where authorized.
- Disclosing conflicts of interest and recusing themselves when required.
- Protecting confidential manuscripts, reviewer information, and internal editorial records.
- Working with the Editorial Office on unresolved ethical, authorship, or permissions concerns.
Guest editors must not use privileged access to unpublished manuscripts for personal advantage, disclose reviewer identities without authorization, or exercise editorial powers beyond those assigned by the journal.
The Editor-in-Chief or another authorized, independent journal editor retains overall oversight of the special issue, including appropriate manuscript handling and final acceptance decisions.
The journal may review guest editor performance and intervene when necessary to protect editorial integrity, independence, or publication quality.
Oversight includes attention to the quality and independence of proposed reviewer pools, the consistency of editorial recommendations, and any unusual patterns across a collection. A guest editor's involvement in an allegation concerning reviewer identity, coercive citations, undisclosed competing interests, or coordinated submissions should be referred to an authorized journal editor without the relevant conflict of interest.
8. Conflicts of Interest and Independent Manuscript Handling
Special issues often arise from professional networks, scholarly collaborations, research conferences, and disciplinary communities. Such connections do not automatically disqualify contributors or guest editors, but relevant conflicts must be disclosed and appropriately managed.
Potential conflicts include:
- Recent co-authorship, research collaboration, or joint publication activity.
- Current or recent supervisory, student, mentoring, or employment relationships.
- Institutional affiliations or professional dependencies relevant to the manuscript.
- Close personal or familial relationships.
- Financial interests, funded collaborations, or sponsorship arrangements.
- Direct participation in the research, artistic production, translation, or project under evaluation.
- Personal or professional interests that could materially affect impartial judgment.
Manuscripts Submitted by Guest Editors
A guest editor may submit scholarly work to a special issue only where the journal can arrange genuinely independent manuscript handling.
The guest editor must not select reviewers, access confidential reviewer identities or reports beyond the author's ordinary access, direct revisions, influence the handling editor, or participate in the acceptance decision for their own manuscript.
The manuscript must be assigned to an independent editor without a relevant conflict of interest and must undergo the review process appropriate to its content category.
Other Editorial Conflicts
Submissions by Editorial Board members, journal editors, or other individuals with privileged editorial access must likewise be handled independently. An involved editor must not control the review or decision-making process for their own work.
Where an appropriate independent editorial arrangement cannot be established, the journal may decline or defer consideration of the submission.
For a guest editor's own submission, independence concerns not only who communicates the final decision but also who selects reviewers, accesses confidential assessments, evaluates revisions, and maintains the decision record. The journal should also monitor how many contributions are authored by guest editors or closely connected editorial participants, since excessive concentration may undermine confidence in the collection even when individual manuscripts have received independent assessment.
9. Reviewer Independence and Peer-Review Integrity
Reviewer selection must be based on genuine expertise, independence, professional suitability, and the capacity to provide constructive assessment.
The Editorial Office should take reasonable steps to:
- Confirm that proposed reviewers are identifiable and appropriately qualified.
- Examine relevant conflicts of interest before assigning manuscripts.
- Avoid excessive reliance on a narrow group of closely connected reviewers.
- Protect reviewer confidentiality and the integrity of the double-blind process.
- Monitor irregular patterns of reviewer recommendations, unusually coordinated reports, or suspicious reviewer identities.
- Prevent review manipulation, coercive citation requests, reciprocal publication arrangements, or improper influence by guest editors or contributors.
- Maintain sufficient records to establish that the required review procedure was completed.
Manuscripts under review are confidential. Reviewers, guest editors, and other editorial participants must not distribute unpublished content or upload it to unauthorized AI systems or third-party services.
Serious concerns involving compromised reviewers, manipulated reports, identity fraud, or other integrity failures may justify suspension of review, reassignment to independent reviewers, investigation, or other appropriate editorial action.
10. Non-Research Content: Scope and Categories
The journal publishes non-research contributions that advance scholarly exchange, critical discussion, cultural documentation, artistic reflection, and public engagement with music and sound.
The term non-research describes a contribution's principal publishing function, not a judgment that it lacks scholarly merit, specialist expertise, or originality. A translated source, substantive interview, annotated score, or critical review may make an important contribution without claiming to report a newly conducted research study. The journal applies the review standard appropriate to the actual claims and the nature of the evidence.
Relevant sections include:
- Timeless Resonance: East–West Music Review
- Sound Archives: Fieldwork and Memory
- Voices Now: Contemporary Soundscapes
- The Score Page
- Dialogues & Interviews
- Performance Notes
- Book & Media Reviews
- Translations & Source Texts
- Forum: Author Replies and Scholarly Exchange
- Resonant Verses: Poetry and Music
- Everyday Resonances
A contribution's title or section placement alone does not determine its review requirements. Editors should consider whether its central purpose is to present new original research findings, offer critical commentary, document cultural materials, communicate artistic practice, or contribute another form of scholarly exchange.
Where a submission substantially functions as an original research article, the Editorial Office may require transfer to the appropriate research section and completion of its double-blind peer-review process.
11. Editorial Review Procedures for Non-Research Content
Non-research contributions are normally assessed by the Editorial Office, responsible section editors, or suitably qualified editorial advisers.
Additional external specialist evaluation may be sought when the submission involves complex scholarly arguments, significant historical assertions, unpublished archival materials, substantial fieldwork evidence, specialized translation, contested cultural representation, or technical musical analysis.
Editorial review may involve:
- Section Suitability: Assess relevance to the journal and appropriateness for the proposed publication category.
- Originality and Contribution: Examine the distinct intellectual, cultural, documentary, critical, or creative value of the work.
- Accuracy and Context: Verify important claims, quotations, source identification, music-related information, and contextual descriptions where appropriate.
- Ethics and Rights: Assess originality, attribution, copyright permissions, participant consent, cultural restrictions, and relevant disclosures.
- Structure and Presentation: Consider clarity, coherence, language, accessibility, and suitable formatting.
- Additional Specialist Assessment: Obtain independent subject, language, musical, archival, or ethics advice where needed.
- Revision and Decision: Request appropriate changes or issue an editorial decision based on the completed assessment.
The extent of assessment should be proportionate to the contribution's content and potential risks. An original poem, a short book review, and an annotated translation of a historical source do not necessarily require the same review procedures.
External specialist assessment of non-research content does not automatically mean that the publication has undergone the journal's full double-blind research peer-review process. The review status must reflect the actual procedure completed.
Editorial records and, where relevant, article-level descriptions should distinguish internal editorial review, a commissioned specialist opinion, and the formal double-blind research peer-review process. When specialist review is required, editors should specify its scope—for example, translation fidelity, musical notation, source provenance, archival permission, or a contested factual claim—rather than assuming that every external opinion verifies every aspect of the work.
12. Book, Media and Critical Reviews
Book and media reviews are normally evaluated by the Editorial Office or responsible section editor for accuracy, fairness, critical substance, relevance, and clarity.
Editorial assessment should consider whether the review:
- Clearly identifies the reviewed publication, recording, performance, exhibition, media project, or other work.
- Accurately represents its central arguments, characteristics, or artistic contribution.
- Develops a reasoned and appropriately supported critical evaluation.
- Situates the work within relevant musical, cultural, disciplinary, or historical contexts.
- Avoids personal attacks, unsubstantiated allegations, promotional copy, and conflicts that compromise independence.
- Respects relevant quotation, reproduction, attribution, and copyright requirements.
Review authors must disclose relevant relationships with the author, performer, composer, publisher, institution, sponsor, or other party associated with the work under review.
Additional specialist assessment may be appropriate when a review makes substantial technical, historical, legal, or otherwise consequential claims.
A critical review is not an advertisement for a commercial release or a mechanism for settling a professional dispute. Editors should consider whether a reviewer or commissioned critic has a material relationship with the work or its producers and whether the article's evaluative claims are adequately supported without imposing an obligation to offer a favorable judgment.
13. Dialogues, Interviews, Forum Contributions and Scholarly Exchange
Dialogues, interviews, author replies, and forum contributions support scholarly discussion, cultural interpretation, and engagement among researchers, performers, artists, and other contributors.
These submissions are normally evaluated for:
- Relevance to the journal and the intended discussion.
- Accuracy of quotations, statements, and source descriptions.
- Appropriate consent, attribution, and participant identification.
- Transparency concerning editing, translation, and transcript preparation.
- Scholarly or cultural significance and clarity of presentation.
- Respectful, evidence-based engagement with differing interpretations.
- Compliance with privacy, confidentiality, copyright, and AI-use requirements.
Interviewees should be informed of the proposed publication format and applicable use of their identifiable statements, images, voices, and recordings.
Where a forum contribution discusses disputed academic claims, sensitive historical questions, or potentially defamatory assertions, the Editorial Office may seek independent factual or specialist verification.
Forum publication does not confer an automatic entitlement to an unlimited series of responses. The Editorial Office may determine an appropriate scope and closing point for an exchange while applying its standards fairly.
When an exchange involves named scholars or contested claims, authors should distinguish verifiable facts from interpretation and criticism. The editor may seek clarification or, when appropriate, offer a proportionate opportunity to respond, but must avoid presenting a forum exchange as a substitute for the journal's formal complaint or correction procedures.
Relevant requirements are described in the Fieldwork & Interview Ethics Policy.
14. Translations, Archival Sources and Documentary Materials
Translations, source texts, archival reflections, fieldwork documentation, and other documentary contributions require assessment appropriate to the authenticity, provenance, language, cultural context, and intended use of the materials.
Editorial review should consider:
- Source Identification: Accurate identification of authors, creators, archives, editions, recordings, and relevant publication history.
- Authenticity and Provenance: Reasonable documentation of the origin and nature of the source material.
- Translation Accuracy: Faithfulness to source meaning, appropriate treatment of cultural terminology, and transparent explanation of material interpretive choices.
- Original Contribution: The value of the translation, introduction, annotation, interpretation, documentary presentation, or other editorial work.
- Rights and Permissions: Compliance with relevant copyright, reproduction, translation, archival, and publication conditions.
- Research and Cultural Ethics: Appropriate treatment of participants, communities, restricted records, and culturally sensitive knowledge.
Where the material requires specialist linguistic, philological, historical, or musical knowledge, the Editorial Office may request assessment by a qualified independent adviser.
A historical source's apparent public-domain status does not automatically establish that a modern translation, critical edition, archival reproduction, or recording may be published without additional permission.
When an annotated translation or source edition contains a substantial new argument, editors should assess the intellectual character of that argument as well as the accuracy of the reproduced text. A specialist translation check addresses fidelity and source handling; it does not, by itself, establish that a separate original research claim has met the journal's research peer-review requirements.
Submissions containing substantial new research claims or interpretations may require more extensive review than a primarily documentary or editorial contribution.
15. Creative, Reflective and Practice-Based Contributions
Creative and practice-based content contributes to the journal's mission by expanding the forms through which musical knowledge, performance, interpretation, and cultural experience may be communicated.
Sections such as The Score Page, Performance Notes, Resonant Verses: Poetry and Music, and Everyday Resonances may contain artistic, reflective, analytical, experimental, or documentary work.
Editorial assessment may consider:
- Originality: The distinctive artistic, interpretive, scholarly, or reflective contribution.
- Relationship to Music: The relevance of the work to musical practice, sound, performance, listening, or the journal's intellectual scope.
- Formal and Expressive Quality: The effectiveness of the chosen form, including relevant notation, language, rhythm, performance, structure, or multimedia.
- Contextual Adequacy: Whether sufficient explanation is provided for the reader to understand the work's purpose and significance.
- Attribution and Permissions: Appropriate credit, rights documentation, and authorization for relevant source materials.
- Ethical and Technical Integrity: Accurate representation of performances, recordings, interviews, cultural materials, and AI-assisted elements.
Creative contributors are not universally required to formulate a research hypothesis, present a formal methodology, perform statistical analysis, or write a conventional literature review.
Where a creative submission makes significant empirical, historical, or technical claims, the relevant evidence must still support those claims. Specialist assessment may be requested accordingly.
AI-generated or AI-assisted creative material may be considered under the journal's AI Use Policy, provided that its role is appropriately disclosed and relevant human contribution, rights, and authenticity requirements are satisfied.
For performances and recordings, the editor may consider the relationship between an artist's explanation and the submitted musical evidence, the quality of documentation, and whether any reconstruction or synthetic transformation is described accurately. Practice-based reflection should not be reduced to a conventional research-article checklist, but factual or historical claims still require adequate support.
16. Invited, Conference-Derived and Thematically Commissioned Contributions
The journal may invite scholars, artists, performers, translators, critics, or other qualified contributors to submit material for a regular section or special issue.
An invitation does not guarantee publication or exemption from the review process appropriate to the contribution.
Conference papers, workshop presentations, invited lectures, performances, and related project materials may be developed into journal submissions where the manuscript meets applicable originality, disclosure, rights, and publication standards.
Authors should disclose:
- Relevant earlier conference, workshop, or public presentation of the material.
- Existing proceedings publications, preprints, institutional repository deposits, or related articles.
- Significant overlap with previously disseminated work.
- Relevant copyright, contractual, or third-party restrictions.
- Any invitation-related relationship or material interest that may affect impartial editorial handling.
A previously presented work may be suitable for publication if its nature and previous dissemination are accurately disclosed and the manuscript satisfies the journal's requirements.
Research contributions derived from such activities must complete the required research peer-review procedure. Editorially reviewed contributions must be classified and described according to their actual publication category.
17. Editorial Decisions, Revisions and Section Transfers
Decisions for special issue and non-research submissions are determined by the responsible editor on the basis of the review record, applicable editorial standards, and the journal's publication requirements.
| Decision | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Accept | The contribution meets the applicable standards and may proceed to publication preparation, subject to ordinary production requirements. |
| Minor Revisions | Limited improvements are required in clarity, presentation, attribution, documentation, or another specific area. |
| Major Revisions | Substantial issues concerning structure, scholarly support, artistic development, interpretation, or ethical documentation require further work and reassessment. |
| Reject | The contribution does not meet the journal's requirements or cannot be made suitable through a reasonable revision process. |
| Section Transfer or Additional Assessment | A different publication category or additional specialist assessment is required before the appropriate editorial decision can be determined. |
Requests for revision should identify the principal matters requiring attention and provide sufficient guidance for a meaningful author response.
Authors may explain a reasoned disagreement with reviewer or editorial comments. They are not required to accept every suggested change when a defensible alternative is provided.
A request for revision does not guarantee subsequent acceptance. The responsible editor may seek further review or reject the submission if substantial concerns remain unresolved.
A proposed section transfer should be explained to the author, including any change to format-specific requirements or assessment procedure. It cannot be used to bypass the peer-review standards for original research or to relabel an inadequately reviewed research article as an editorial contribution solely to secure publication. The responsible editor must ensure that the final section and description reflect the process actually completed.
18. Publication Transparency, Labelling and Record Integrity
The journal aims to ensure that readers can distinguish among research articles, editorially reviewed essays, reviews, interviews, translations, original creative works, performance documentation, and other publication types.
Appropriate publication information may include:
- The publication section and contribution category.
- Whether the work underwent research peer review or editorial assessment.
- Relevant authorship, translation, editorial, or creative contributor credits.
- Applicable copyright and licensing information.
- Funding, competing interests, ethical approvals, and AI-use disclosures where required.
- Publication identifiers and accurate bibliographic metadata.
- Relevant correction, expression-of-concern, or retraction notices after publication.
A collection may contain research articles assessed through double-blind peer review alongside editorially reviewed interviews, reviews, translations, or creative works. The label applied to the collection as a whole must not misrepresent the individual review status of those contributions.
The journal should avoid describing a contribution as "double-blind peer reviewed" where the applicable process was only an internal editorial reading or an informal consultation.
Similarly, the presence of a DOI, a special issue designation, or an academic journal imprint does not independently establish that the work received a particular form of peer review.
Publication Scheduling and Incomplete Collections
Special issue publication schedules are subject to editorial progress, reviewer availability, revision requirements, production capacity, and manuscript quality.
The journal may reschedule a collection, reduce its scope, publish suitable contributions through another authorized arrangement, or discontinue a collection when circumstances justify such action.
Where a collection changes substantially after approval, the Editorial Office should consider whether its call for papers, thematic description, invited-editor attribution, or publication planning requires clarification. Accepted and rejected manuscripts must be handled on their individual merits; a collection should never be completed by relaxing standards for its remaining submissions.
Individual manuscripts must not be accepted merely to achieve an originally proposed article count, complete a thematic volume, or satisfy an announced publication deadline.
Formally published Online First articles are part of the scholarly record. Any later assignment to a scheduled issue or thematic collection must preserve the appropriate publication identity and metadata.
19. Ethics Concerns, Complaints and Appeals
Authors and other relevant parties may raise concerns about the handling of special issue manuscripts, guest editor conduct, reviewer independence, conflicts of interest, review integrity, misrepresentation of editorial decisions, or the evaluation of non-research content.
A complaint or appeal should, where possible, include:
- The manuscript or publication concerned.
- The nature of the alleged problem or disputed decision.
- Relevant correspondence, documents, or verifiable supporting evidence.
- An explanation of any material procedural irregularity, conflict of interest, or factual misunderstanding.
- The specific action or clarification being requested.
The Editorial Office assesses credible complaints in light of the manuscript record, the nature of the alleged error, and the independence of the persons involved. An appeal concerning guest-editor conduct or an editor's conflict should not be reviewed solely by the person whose conduct is disputed. A qualified independent editor or adviser may be consulted where necessary; review of a complaint does not itself imply that the original decision was improper.
An author's disagreement with an unfavorable editorial assessment is not by itself evidence of improper conduct. Appeals should identify substantive concerns capable of affecting the fairness or validity of the decision.
Where a serious concern arises regarding peer-review manipulation, unauthorized disclosure, fabricated evidence, plagiarism, or other publication integrity matters, the journal may suspend further consideration while an appropriate assessment is undertaken.
The journal may request clarification, reassign editorial responsibilities, obtain independent review, reject a manuscript, or take other proportionate action. Where an issue is identified after publication, the relevant Corrections and Retractions Policy applies.
Confidential information should be handled responsibly, and affected parties should normally be given appropriate opportunities to respond to substantive allegations. Editorial action must not be based solely on unsupported accusations or automated detection scores.
20. Policy Interpretation and Review
The Editorial Office is responsible for interpreting and applying this policy in conjunction with the journal's peer-review, publication ethics, plagiarism, conflict-of-interest, AI-use, and other applicable requirements.
Where an issue is not expressly addressed by this policy, the journal will seek to apply its general principles of scholarly quality, fairness, independence, transparency, and proportionality.
This policy may be revised periodically in response to developments in scholarly publishing, guest-edited collections, publication ethics, research practices, intellectual property, editorial technology, and relevant disciplinary standards.
Material amendments should be documented with an accurate revision or effective date following formal editorial approval. Revisions must not be described as having taken effect before their adoption.
Editorial Statement: Resonance: Journal of Global Music Studies recognizes special issues and non-research contributions as important components of scholarly and cultural exchange. Their publication requires a balance between intellectual openness, disciplinary diversity, editorial independence, and appropriate quality assurance. Research articles must satisfy the journal's independent double-blind peer-review standards, while reviews, interviews, translations, artistic works, and other contributions are evaluated through procedures suited to their particular forms and purposes. The journal remains committed to accurate review classifications, responsible guest editorship, transparent editorial decisions, and the integrity of every published contribution.
Authors, reviewers, and guest editors should also consult the journal's Peer Review Process, Review Criteria, How to Review, Publication Ethics, AI Use Policy, and Fieldwork & Interview Ethics Policy.
Contact: Questions concerning special issue proposals, guest editorship, review classifications, or editorial procedures may be directed to the Resonance Editorial Office: [email protected].
Original effective date: May 28, 2026. Last updated: October 28, 2026.