Review Criteria
Resonance: Journal of Global Music Studies uses these criteria to guide independent, evidence-based assessments of manuscripts and other proposed contributions. Reviewers and editors should establish what a submission sets out to accomplish, assess the adequacy of its sources, reasoning, methods, and presentation, and explain how its scholarly, artistic, cultural, or documentary value meets the expectations of its intended publication type. A useful report distinguishes matters affecting the reliability or significance of a contribution from matters of editorial preference.
These criteria accommodate musicology, ethnomusicology, sound studies, performance studies, music history, musical aesthetics, artistic research, and interdisciplinary work. The appropriate evidentiary and methodological standards depend on the manuscript's objectives and disciplinary context; no single research design, theoretical tradition, linguistic preference, or geographic orientation is presumed to be superior.
Review classification matters. Original research manuscripts proceeding to external assessment undergo double-blind review by at least two independent qualified specialists. Reviews, interviews, translations, scores, artistic reflections, and other non-research content normally receive editorial assessment, with additional specialist advice when necessary. The detailed procedures are governed by the journal's Peer Review Process and Special Issues & Non-Research Content Review Policy; the present page explains how to evaluate the material.
General Principles of Evaluation
Reviewers should apply the following principles consistently while remaining attentive to the submission's disciplinary and publication context:
- Scholarly Independence: Judgments must be based on the manuscript's substance rather than an author's perceived identity, academic seniority, institutional affiliation, nationality, or professional reputation.
- Methodological Appropriateness: Evaluate the methods and interpretive approaches appropriate to the research problem, rather than imposing a single disciplinary model on all submissions.
- Evidence-Based Judgment: Support substantive criticism with specific reasoning and identifiable examples.
- Intellectual Fairness: Represent the manuscript's arguments accurately and acknowledge reasonable differences in theoretical or methodological perspectives.
- Constructive Feedback: Identify essential revisions clearly and distinguish them from optional improvements.
- Cultural and Linguistic Awareness: Respect diverse musical traditions, historical contexts, research languages, and culturally specific forms of musical knowledge.
- Confidentiality and Integrity: Follow the journal's peer-review, conflict-of-interest, research ethics, and AI-use policies.
1. Originality & Scholarly Contribution
Reviewers should consider whether the manuscript offers a meaningful contribution to existing knowledge, interpretation, documentation, methodology, theory, or artistic understanding.
- Does the manuscript present a clearly identifiable original contribution?
- Does it introduce new evidence, interpretations, arguments, approaches, or relevant scholarly insights?
- Does it explain how its contribution relates to previous scholarship or existing artistic and documentary practices?
- Are claims of novelty or significance appropriately supported?
- Does the manuscript clarify its significance without overstating its findings or implications?
Originality need not depend on new empirical data or technological novelty. A well-supported reinterpretation of archival evidence, a substantial conceptual synthesis, a carefully documented musical practice, or a new understanding of a familiar repertoire can advance scholarship. Reviewers should identify the particular contribution and assess its significance relative to existing work.
Popularity, institutional visibility, and the perceived novelty of a subject are not reliable substitutes for an assessment of the argument, evidence, or intellectual contribution.
2. Relevance to the Journal's Scope
The manuscript should contribute meaningfully to the understanding of music, sound, musical cultures, or related scholarly and artistic practices.
- Is the manuscript relevant to the aims and scope of Resonance?
- Does it engage with questions of interest to musicology, ethnomusicology, sound studies, performance studies, or related disciplines?
- Is its musical, cultural, historical, theoretical, or methodological context sufficiently established?
- Does it explain why the topic or issue matters to its intended scholarly audience?
- Where comparative or interdisciplinary claims are made, are the relevant relationships justified and adequately examined?
International relevance does not require cross-cultural comparison. A closely argued investigation of one region, repertoire, community, artist, archive, language, or historical setting can meet the journal's scope. Reviewers should request comparison or interdisciplinarity only when it would help test or clarify the manuscript's own claims.
3. Theoretical, Conceptual & Methodological Rigor
Reviewers should assess whether the intellectual approach and methods are appropriate to the manuscript's objectives and whether the evidence and analysis adequately support its conclusions.
Research Focus and Conceptual Framework
- Are the principal research questions, aims, or analytical problems clearly articulated?
- Are the central concepts accurately defined and used consistently?
- Are the selected theories or interpretive frameworks appropriate to the inquiry?
- Does the manuscript explain relevant assumptions, analytical boundaries, and limitations?
Research Methods and Analytical Procedures
- Are the research design, source selection, methods, and analytical procedures suitable for the stated objectives?
- Are the procedures described with sufficient transparency for readers to evaluate the findings or interpretations?
- Are relevant methodological limitations, uncertainties, and alternative explanations considered?
- Are the conclusions proportionate to the available evidence?
Discipline-Specific Evaluation
Reviewers should apply standards appropriate to the manuscript's research tradition:
- Historical and Archival Research: Evaluate source provenance, contextual accuracy, chronology, interpretation, and the handling of conflicting or incomplete records.
- Ethnomusicological and Qualitative Research: Evaluate fieldwork design, participant selection, contextual interpretation, research relationships, reflexivity, and relevant ethical safeguards.
- Quantitative and Computational Research: Evaluate data quality, operationalization, sampling, analytical procedures, assumptions, reproducibility where feasible, and interpretation of results.
- Theoretical and Philosophical Research: Evaluate conceptual clarity, logical coherence, scholarly interpretation, engagement with relevant arguments, and the strength of the reasoning.
- Musical and Performance Analysis: Evaluate the relationship between analytical claims and musical evidence, performance context, interpretive decisions, and relevant disciplinary methods.
- Practice-Based Research: Evaluate how artistic practice functions within the research process, how evidence is documented and interpreted, and whether the stated knowledge contribution is substantiated.
Reviewers must not demand hypotheses, statistical tests, quantitative samples, fieldwork, or formal theoretical frameworks when these are not warranted by the research question. Instead, they should evaluate whether the chosen approach is credible, sufficiently explained, and capable of supporting the conclusions presented.
4. Structure, Argumentation & Clarity
Reviewers should consider whether the manuscript communicates its objectives, evidence, analysis, and conclusions coherently and effectively.
- Is the manuscript logically organized and easy to follow?
- Does each section contribute meaningfully to the central argument or purpose?
- Are important claims supported by relevant examples, sources, data, or analysis?
- Are the introduction and conclusion consistent with the material actually presented?
- Is the language sufficiently clear and precise for scholarly communication?
- Are figures, tables, musical examples, and supplementary materials incorporated meaningfully?
Reviewers should identify passages where terminology, organization, or language obstructs a substantive argument, while distinguishing such problems from minor stylistic preferences. Consistent regional varieties of an accepted submission language should not be treated as scholarly deficiencies.
5. Engagement with Relevant Scholarship
The manuscript should demonstrate adequate familiarity with the scholarship, primary sources, artistic practices, or theoretical debates necessary to support its contribution.
- Does the manuscript engage with relevant existing research and primary sources?
- Does it accurately represent the principal arguments and findings of cited scholarship?
- Does it explain its relationship to existing debates, interpretations, methods, or evidence?
- Are important alternative perspectives considered where they materially affect the argument?
- Are references selected for relevance and scholarly significance rather than prestige or citation volume?
Relevant scholarship should be judged by its contribution to the manuscript's question, including work in languages other than English and research outside widely indexed journals. Reviewers should identify material omissions with sufficient specificity to help authors determine what must be addressed.
Requests to add citations must be substantively justified. Coercive citation requests designed to increase citations to a reviewer's own work, a particular journal, or unrelated publications are incompatible with independent peer review.
6. Use of Sources, Musical Evidence & Media
Music and sound scholarship may rely on textual documents, musical scores, recordings, interviews, audiovisual materials, fieldnotes, archives, datasets, digital resources, and performance documentation. Reviewers should evaluate whether these materials are appropriately selected, represented, interpreted, and cited.
- Source Identification: Are the origin, authorship, date, edition, recording, archive, or other relevant characteristics of the materials adequately documented?
- Evidence and Interpretation: Does the evidence genuinely support the manuscript's principal analytical or historical claims?
- Musical Examples: Are scores, transcriptions, audio excerpts, figures, and other examples accurate, legible, relevant, and sufficiently explained?
- Audio and Audiovisual Integrity: Are recordings represented accurately, with relevant editing, reconstruction, processing, or production details disclosed where necessary?
- Translation and Transcription: Are significant translation choices, transcription conventions, editorial changes, and interpretive uncertainties appropriately identified?
- Digital Resources: Are software, databases, tools, datasets, and relevant versions described sufficiently for the reader to understand the analytical process?
- Data and Material Availability: Are availability statements, access conditions, and justified restrictions consistent with the manuscript's claims and ethical responsibilities?
- Permissions and Attribution: Have relevant copyright, performer, archival, cultural, and third-party rights requirements been addressed?
Supporting media should be evaluated for their relationship to the submitted argument rather than for their mere presence. Reviewers should not demand audiovisual materials or unrestricted access to sources when unnecessary or incompatible with consent, confidentiality, cultural protocols, copyright, or legitimate technical restrictions. Where access is restricted, assess whether the author explains the evidentiary limitations adequately.
7. Ethical Considerations & Research Integrity
Reviewers should consider whether the manuscript complies with relevant standards of research ethics, authorship, attribution, consent, confidentiality, intellectual property, and scholarly integrity.
- Research Ethics: Have appropriate ethical approvals, consent arrangements, or equivalent safeguards been described where applicable?
- Participant Protection: Are interviewees, performers, research participants, and identifiable individuals represented responsibly?
- Cultural Responsibility: Does the work respect relevant community protocols, restricted knowledge, and culturally sensitive musical materials?
- Research Honesty: Are the data, citations, sources, musical examples, and conclusions presented without apparent fabrication or material misrepresentation?
- Authorship and Disclosure: Are relevant author contributions, funding, competing interests, and prior dissemination appropriately addressed?
- AI-Assisted Activities: Are substantive AI uses disclosed where required, and are synthetic or materially altered materials clearly distinguished from authentic evidence?
- Rights and Permissions: Are relevant permissions and licensing conditions adequately identified for protected compositions, recordings, images, translations, and other materials?
Where a credible concern arises about plagiarism, inappropriate duplication, possible fabrication, manipulated media, consent, misuse of protected knowledge, or other integrity matters, reviewers should report the concern confidentially to the handling editor, identifying the relevant passages or evidence. The editorial process—not the individual reviewer—determines what further inquiry is warranted.
Reviewers must not contact authors, research participants, institutions, or third parties to investigate a confidential submission without editorial authorization. Suspicions, similarity scores, and automated AI-detection results are not findings of misconduct; concerns require contextual, evidence-based assessment.
Evaluation of Different Contribution Types
Each contribution should be assessed according to its declared aims and the publication category in which it would appear. The criteria below identify the principal issues rather than imposing research-article standards on creative or documentary formats:
- Original Research Articles: Evaluate the research question, originality, relevant scholarship, methodological quality, evidence, interpretation, limitations, and contribution to knowledge. These manuscripts undergo the journal's double-blind peer review process.
- Book and Media Reviews: Evaluate the accuracy of the work's description, fairness of judgment, critical depth, contextual relevance, and independence from promotional interests.
- Translations and Source Texts: Evaluate source provenance, translation accuracy, editorial interventions, scholarly commentary, rights, and historical or cultural significance.
- Dialogues and Interviews: Evaluate participant consent, transcript accuracy, attribution, editorial transparency, contextualization, and scholarly relevance.
- Performance Notes and Practice-Based Contributions: Evaluate artistic context, critical reflection, documentation, originality, and the relationship between performance practice and the contribution's stated purpose.
- The Score Page: Evaluate the originality and presentation of musical notation, the relevance of accompanying commentary, technical clarity, and appropriate intellectual property documentation.
- Forum and Scholarly Exchange: Evaluate the clarity of the position, accuracy of references, fairness toward opposing arguments, and contribution to constructive scholarly discussion.
- Creative, Reflective, and Documentary Works: Evaluate the intellectual, artistic, cultural, or documentary value in relation to the specific section's purpose, rather than requiring conventional empirical research methods.
Non-research materials normally receive editorial assessment and may be referred to relevant specialists. An additional expert opinion does not by itself establish double-blind research peer review, and the published content type must reflect the evaluation actually completed. Research articles submitted to special issues are subject to the same research-review standards as regular research articles.
Preparing a Constructive Review Report
A review report should explain the recommendation through specific, actionable analysis. It should identify what the manuscript does well, which weaknesses affect its contribution or reliability, what corrections are needed, and which suggestions are optional. The structure below helps authors and handling editors understand the reasoning without turning evaluation into an unprioritized list of demands.
A. Brief Summary and Overall Assessment
Briefly identify the manuscript's purpose, approach, principal argument or findings, and claimed contribution. Explain the most important strengths and the principal issues affecting its suitability for publication.
B. Major Comments
Major comments should address issues that materially affect the manuscript's scholarly contribution, research reliability, interpretation, coherence, or suitability for publication. These may include:
- Insufficient justification of the central research problem or contribution.
- Important methodological weaknesses or inadequate source documentation.
- Substantial gaps in evidence, reasoning, analysis, or interpretation.
- Failure to engage with essential relevant scholarship or source material.
- Conclusions that materially exceed the supporting evidence.
- Significant ethical, permissions, or research integrity questions requiring editorial attention.
For each major issue, reviewers should explain its scholarly consequences, point to relevant evidence or sections of the manuscript, and indicate what a satisfactory response should address. Requests for substantial new research must be proportionate to the manuscript's stated scope and aims.
C. Minor Comments
Minor comments should identify limited improvements that do not fundamentally alter the principal contribution, such as:
- Clarification of particular sentences, concepts, or definitions.
- Correction of minor bibliographic, typographical, or formatting errors.
- Improvement of figure labels, musical example captions, or cross-references.
- Limited additions or corrections to relevant citations.
- Refinement of organization, terminology, or presentation.
D. Confidential Comments to the Editor
Confidential comments may alert the editor to suspected ethics problems, relevant conflicts, limits of the reviewer's competence, or reasons to seek additional expertise. Concerns that the author could fairly address should also appear, in an appropriately phrased form, in the author-facing report unless disclosure would compromise a confidential integrity assessment.
Final Recommendation
Reviewers should select the recommendation that best reflects the issues described in their report. These four categories express the reviewer's professional assessment; they do not bind the handling editor or replace the journal's formal editorial decision.
| Recommendation | Evaluation Standard |
|---|---|
| Accept | The manuscript meets the journal's applicable scholarly and ethical standards and is suitable for publication without substantive revision. Routine copyediting or production corrections may still be necessary. |
| Minor Revisions | The principal contribution is sound, but limited clarification, correction, additional explanation, or presentation improvements are required. The core research design or argument does not require substantial reconstruction. |
| Major Revisions | The manuscript has publication potential but requires substantial improvements to its argument, evidence, methodology, interpretation, scholarly engagement, or organization before a new decision can be made. |
| Reject | The manuscript is unsuitable for publication because of a fundamental scope mismatch, insufficient contribution, serious or unresolvable weaknesses, inadequate reliability, or other substantial concerns that cannot reasonably be addressed through revision within the current submission. |
Recommendation Consistency: The selected recommendation should be consistent with the reviewer's written comments. A recommendation of Major Revisions should identify substantive problems and provide a reasonable explanation of what must change. A recommendation of Reject should explain the decisive grounds for unsuitability rather than relying on a general negative judgment.
A recommendation to revise is not a promise of publication. The editorial office may request a further report, reassess the revision, or reject the manuscript when substantive concerns remain.
Evaluating Revised Manuscripts
Following substantive revision, reviewers may be invited to determine whether the authors have adequately addressed the concerns that affected the original recommendation. The revised manuscript and the point-by-point response should be read together; changes must be judged by their scholarly adequacy rather than simple compliance with every suggested wording or method.
- Read the revised manuscript and the author's response to previous comments.
- Assess whether the principal methodological, analytical, conceptual, or evidentiary concerns have been resolved.
- Consider whether alternative solutions proposed by the author are reasonable and adequately supported.
- Identify remaining issues clearly, distinguishing substantial unresolved concerns from minor matters.
- Avoid introducing entirely new demands unrelated to earlier concerns unless they arise from significant new material or are necessary for reliability, ethics, or scholarly quality.
Authors may reasonably disagree with a recommendation and propose a documented alternative. Reviewers should judge the response on its merits; the handling editor determines whether remaining matters warrant further changes or assessment.
Reviewer Ethics, Confidentiality & Independence
Accepting an invitation carries obligations of subject expertise, confidentiality, timely communication, independent judgment, and disclosure of relevant conflicts. The practical duties below complement the journal's broader peer-review ethics policies.
- Expertise: Accept assignments only when the manuscript falls sufficiently within the reviewer's competence. Notify the editor where important specialist expertise is lacking.
- Conflicts of Interest: Declare relevant personal, professional, financial, institutional, supervisory, or collaborative relationships. Decline or seek editorial guidance when impartiality may be compromised.
- Confidentiality: Do not share, distribute, reproduce, or discuss unpublished manuscripts or review correspondence outside the authorized review process.
- No Unauthorized Delegation: Do not transfer a review assignment to students, colleagues, assistants, or third parties without editorial permission.
- No Misuse of Materials: Do not use unpublished ideas, data, methods, recordings, compositions, translations, or other materials for personal research or professional advantage.
- No Direct Contact: Do not contact the author about the confidential manuscript without authorization from the Editorial Office.
- Professional Conduct: Avoid personal attacks, discriminatory comments, dismissive language, and criticism unrelated to the manuscript's scholarly content.
- Timeliness: Complete the review within the agreed period or promptly request an extension where necessary.
- Citation Integrity: Recommend references on the basis of genuine scholarly relevance, never for coercive citation accumulation or personal advantage.
Use of Artificial Intelligence in Peer Review
Reviewers must not submit confidential manuscript text, tables, scores, recordings, images, reviewer correspondence, participant materials, or derived content to public or unauthorized AI services. Confidentiality obligations apply whether a tool is used for summarization, translation, language editing, or analysis.
Limited assistance with a reviewer's own original wording may be permissible under the AI Use Policy, provided that confidential information is protected and the human reviewer independently verifies the final report. AI cannot replace professional judgment or be used to invent sources, findings, or evaluations.
Broader obligations are set out in Publication Ethics.
Editorial Decision-Making
Review reports inform—but do not determine—the editorial decision. The handling editor assesses the quality of the reasoning, the seriousness of identified weaknesses, and the suitability of the contribution for its designated publication category. A simple count of positive and negative recommendations does not substitute for editorial judgment.
Where reports disagree, the editor may evaluate the contested arguments, seek clarification, commission additional qualified review, or reach a documented decision using the evidence available. Conflicts must be managed appropriately, and a decision must not be influenced by a contributor's status, institutional affiliation, relationship with the journal, or publication fees.
A research article must complete the applicable independent research review before it is identified as peer-reviewed original research. Editorially reviewed reviews, interviews, translations, musical scores, and creative contributions retain their appropriate content classification.
Final Checklist for Reviewers
Before submitting a review report, reviewers should confirm that:
- The complete manuscript and relevant supplementary materials have been evaluated to the extent required by the assignment.
- The assessment addresses originality, relevance, scholarly rigor, evidence, clarity, and ethics as applicable.
- The manuscript has been evaluated using methods and expectations appropriate to its discipline and research design.
- Major and minor comments are clearly distinguished and supported by reasons.
- Requests for additional evidence, analysis, or citations are necessary and proportionate.
- Confidential ethical or conflict-of-interest concerns have been communicated appropriately to the editor.
- No confidential manuscript information has been disclosed to unauthorized persons or AI systems.
- The written assessment is respectful, constructive, and free from personal attacks.
- The final recommendation is clearly stated and consistent with the review report.
For procedural instructions beyond these evaluation criteria, see How to Review, Peer Review Process, and Special Issues & Non-Research Content Review Policy.
Questions concerning reviewer invitations, evaluation standards, conflicts of interest, or review procedures may be directed to the Resonance Editorial Office: [email protected].