Resonance: Journal of Global Music Studies is committed to maintaining the accuracy, reliability, transparency, and integrity of its published scholarly and creative record. Errors, significant omissions, ethical concerns, or questions about the reliability of published material may occasionally arise after publication. The journal addresses such matters through proportionate, evidence-based editorial procedures, including corrections, expressions of concern, retractions, and exceptional content removal when warranted.

This policy applies to all published contributions, including original research articles, scholarly reviews, translations, source texts, musical scores, performance notes, interviews, poetry, creative works, and other editorial content. The appropriate response depends on the nature of the publication, the seriousness of the problem, and its implications for the scholarly or artistic record.

The journal draws upon internationally recognized publication ethics principles, including guidance from the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), while applying its own published policies and the circumstances of each case. This reference to COPE guidance does not imply COPE membership, certification, or endorsement. Editorial decisions remain with authorized human editors, supported by independent specialist, institutional, or legal consultation when necessary.

1. General Principles

Post-publication actions are guided by the following principles:

  • Integrity of the Published Record: Errors and serious integrity concerns must be addressed in ways that allow readers to understand the current status of a publication.
  • Evidence-Based Decisions: Editorial actions must be based on available evidence, the nature of the concern, and its implications for the reliability or integrity of the contribution.
  • Proportionality: The appropriate action should reflect the seriousness and scope of the problem. Minor errors, correctable deficiencies, and fundamentally unreliable publications require different responses.
  • Transparency: Substantive post-publication actions should be documented through clear, accessible, and appropriately linked notices.
  • Procedural Fairness: Affected authors and other relevant parties should normally have an opportunity to respond before a final editorial determination.
  • Editorial Independence: Individuals with material conflicts of interest must not control the assessment or final decision.
  • Preservation: Corrections and retractions should preserve an identifiable publication history rather than silently erase the record.
  • Timely Action: The journal should assess credible concerns without unnecessary delay while allowing sufficient time for complex investigations.

A retraction identifies a published contribution whose findings, evidence, attribution, or publication integrity can no longer be relied upon in the manner originally presented. Its primary purpose is to protect the scholarly record and inform readers, not to punish authors. A retraction does not, by itself, establish that deliberate misconduct occurred.

The journal may take appropriate action whether a problem results from an honest mistake, a technical failure, an ethical breach, or deliberate misconduct. Determining whether misconduct occurred is distinct from determining whether the published work remains reliable.

2. Types of Post-Publication Action

The journal distinguishes among corrections, expressions of concern, retractions, and exceptional removal. These actions serve different editorial purposes.

Summary of publication record actions
Action Appropriate Circumstances
Correction A material error or omission requires amendment, but the publication's central contribution remains sufficiently reliable.
Expression of Concern Serious, credible concerns remain unresolved, and readers should be alerted while an investigation proceeds or evidence remains inconclusive.
Retraction Substantial unreliability, serious integrity deficiencies, or other sufficiently established problems invalidate the publication or fundamentally compromise its integrity.
Exceptional Removal Continued public access creates a compelling legal, privacy, safety, or comparable risk that cannot adequately be addressed through an ordinary editorial notice.

These are distinct editorial responses, not successive levels of punishment. A journal may also use an addendum, clarification, or another clearly labeled notice where that format accurately explains an update. Labels such as erratum or corrigendum, where used, should identify the underlying correction without obscuring its effect on the publication.

3. Corrections

A correction may be issued when a published contribution contains an error or omission affecting accuracy, interpretation, attribution, presentation, or bibliographic information, but the problem can be remedied without fundamentally invalidating the publication.

Corrections may address:

  • Author names, affiliations, ORCID iDs, acknowledgments, funding information, or competing-interest disclosures.
  • References, quotations, translations, source attributions, archival citations, and bibliographic details.
  • Errors in figures, tables, musical scores, transcriptions, notated examples, captions, or analytical descriptions.
  • Mistakes in audio or audiovisual documentation, recording credits, performance information, or supplementary materials.
  • Errors in data presentation, calculations, terminology, or interpretation that can be corrected without undermining the essential conclusions.
  • Missing permissions, attribution statements, editorial disclosures, or other information that can appropriately be supplied after publication.
  • Production errors introduced during copyediting, typesetting, file conversion, or online publication.

Minor Technical Corrections

Minor typographical, spacing, formatting, or accessibility errors may be corrected directly where they do not affect meaning, interpretation, authorship, attribution, citation, indexing, or the substantive publication record.

Such changes should be limited to genuinely non-substantive matters. The Editorial Office should retain an appropriate internal record of changes when necessary for production accountability.

Substantive Corrections

Errors that materially affect scholarly interpretation, attribution, methodological description, source identification, or publication metadata should normally be addressed through a formal correction notice.

The notice should identify the affected publication, explain the error and correction, state whether the principal findings or contribution remain reliable, and be linked to the relevant article.

Where a corrected article file is supplied for reader convenience, the journal should identify the update and maintain a clear relationship with the formal notice. Substantive corrections must not be concealed through silent replacement of the original published file.

Corrections concerning authorship, contributor credit, or sensitive declarations may require additional confirmation from the affected authors or relevant parties before publication.

4. Retractions

A retraction may be issued when reliable evidence establishes that a published work contains serious problems that invalidate its central findings, interpretations, scholarly contribution, or publication integrity.

Retraction may be necessary whether the underlying problem arose from an honest error or from deliberate misconduct. The purpose is to communicate that the affected work should no longer be relied upon in the manner originally presented.

Grounds for retraction may include:

  • Unreliable Findings: Serious methodological, analytical, computational, or interpretive errors that invalidate important findings or conclusions.
  • Fabrication or Falsification: Invented or materially manipulated data, sources, interviews, fieldnotes, performances, recordings, images, or research findings.
  • Serious Plagiarism: Substantial unattributed copying, misappropriation of intellectual or creative contributions, or other plagiarism that fundamentally compromises the publication.
  • Redundant Publication: Substantial undisclosed duplication that misrepresents the originality of the published contribution.
  • Research Ethics Violations: Serious violations involving consent, participant protection, confidentiality, or restricted research materials.
  • Publication Process Manipulation: Fabricated reviewer identities, compromised peer review, fraudulent authorship, or comparable manipulation affecting the legitimacy of the publication.
  • Unresolvable Rights or Attribution Problems: Serious copyright, permissions, or intellectual property concerns that fundamentally affect the integrity or lawful publication of the work and cannot be adequately corrected by narrower measures.
  • Other Serious Integrity Failures: Material problems that make the contribution unreliable or substantially undermine confidence in its scholarly or creative record.

A formal retraction should not be issued merely because an author disagrees with a reviewer, an interpretation is controversial, or a subsequent study reaches different conclusions.

When only a discrete figure, audio file, translation, musical example, or supplementary component is affected, the editor should assess whether a targeted correction, replacement, or access restriction adequately protects the record. Retraction is appropriate when a narrower action cannot resolve a problem that fundamentally compromises the work or its publication integrity.

A correctable citation error, limited text recycling, ordinary authorship dispute, or isolated permissions issue does not automatically justify retraction. The editor must assess whether a correction or other proportionate measure would adequately address the concern.

Retraction Notices

Retraction notices must be clearly identified, openly accessible, and linked to the affected publication. They should describe the reasons for the retraction using factual, neutral language and distinguish established findings from unresolved allegations.

The notice should identify the editorial or other responsible issuing party and explain the relevant circumstances to the extent compatible with confidentiality, applicable law, and procedural fairness.

The original article will normally remain accessible with a prominent retraction statement or watermark and a direct link to the notice. The publication's status must also be clearly visible on its landing page.

Retraction does not erase the fact that a publication occurred, and it does not automatically cancel rights previously granted under an applicable open-access license. Appropriate restrictions may still be required for particular content under law or ethical obligations.

5. Expressions of Concern

An expression of concern may be issued when credible and serious questions arise about a published contribution, but the evidence is not yet sufficient to determine whether correction or retraction is necessary.

Circumstances may include:

  • An ongoing investigation into potentially unreliable data, sources, findings, or publication processes.
  • Credible allegations of fabrication, plagiarism, unauthorized source use, or research ethics violations that remain unresolved.
  • Serious uncertainty about authorship, consent, permissions, or the authenticity of important research materials.
  • An institutional investigation whose findings are not yet available.
  • Insufficient cooperation or unavailable evidence preventing a timely and conclusive determination.

An expression of concern serves to inform readers of a significant unresolved issue. It must not present unproven allegations as established misconduct.

The notice should explain the nature of the concern, the uncertainty involved, and any relevant limitations on the available evidence. It should be clearly linked to the article and remain discoverable.

When the matter is resolved, the journal may issue a correction or retraction, update the concern notice, publish a statement indicating that the concern was resolved, or take another proportionate action.

An expression of concern may remain part of the publication history where the underlying investigation cannot be completed or uncertainty cannot reasonably be resolved.

An expression of concern is not a substitute for investigating a credible allegation or for issuing a correction or retraction when the evidence already warrants one. Editorial follow-up should distinguish a genuinely unresolved issue from a case that can be concluded on the available evidence.

6. Manuscript Withdrawal Before Publication

Manuscript withdrawal refers to the discontinuation of editorial consideration before the journal formally publishes the contribution.

Authors may request withdrawal during editorial screening, peer review, revision, or accepted-manuscript production by contacting the Editorial Office and explaining the circumstances.

The Editorial Office will review the request, verify the relevant submission status, and communicate the appropriate administrative steps. Withdrawal requests involving multiple authors, unresolved ethical concerns, or publication agreements may require additional clarification.

The corresponding author should coordinate a withdrawal request with co-authors where applicable. Authors should not assume that a manuscript has been withdrawn merely because a request has been sent; its status should be confirmed through the journal’s authorized editorial correspondence or online submission system. A withdrawal request does not, by itself, resolve an existing research-integrity concern.

Online First and Formal Publication

An article that has been formally released through the journal's Online First publication workflow is considered published even if it has not yet been assigned to a scheduled issue.

Formal publication status is determined by the journal's public release of the contribution as a published work. It does not depend solely on the assignment of a volume, issue, page range, or DOI.

Once formally published, the contribution will normally be managed under the journal's post-publication procedures rather than treated as an unpublished manuscript eligible for ordinary withdrawal.

An article's later assignment from Online First to a June or December issue is a bibliographic publication update and does not normally constitute a new submission or a basis for withdrawal.

7. Version of Record & Publication Updates

The Version of Record is the authoritative published form of a contribution. Its identity and publication history must remain traceable after formal release.

Substantive alterations to the Version of Record must be documented appropriately. The journal will not silently change material that affects conclusions, evidence, authorship, attribution, substantial interpretation, or other matters relevant to scholarly citation.

The journal distinguishes among:

  • Minor Production Adjustments: Non-substantive corrections that do not alter the meaning or bibliographic identity of the publication.
  • Bibliographic Updates: Addition or correction of volume, issue, publication identifiers, or other metadata without changing the scholarly content.
  • Formal Corrections: Documented changes that materially affect the published record while leaving the principal contribution sufficiently reliable.
  • Retractions and Expressions of Concern: Formal notices addressing significant reliability or integrity concerns.
  • Exceptional Restrictions: Removal or limitation of public access to specific content where necessary for compelling legal, safety, privacy, or ethical reasons.

Where a revised file is issued, the journal should identify its relationship to the original publication and retain sufficient documentation to distinguish the change from an undisclosed replacement.

Authors who maintain repository deposits are encouraged to update those records with links to relevant correction, concern, or retraction notices.

8. Requirements for Formal Editorial Notices

Formal notices should be independently identifiable, freely accessible, and directly connected to the affected publication.

Where applicable, a notice should include:

  1. A clear heading identifying the notice type, such as Correction, Expression of Concern, or Retraction.
  2. The full title and relevant bibliographic details of the affected publication.
  3. The original article's DOI or persistent URL.
  4. The date of the notice and its own persistent identifier where assigned.
  5. A factual explanation of the issue and the reason for the editorial action.
  6. A description of the affected material or relevant changes.
  7. A statement explaining the effect of the issue on the publication's reliability, interpretation, or status, where relevant.
  8. Identification of the issuing party and other relevant contributors to the notice, where appropriate.
  9. A direct link between the notice and the affected article.

Notices should communicate verified information using clear, neutral, and non-inflammatory language. Personal allegations, unnecessary confidential information, and unsupported conclusions should not be included.

An editorial notice may be issued by the journal even when one or more authors disagree with the proposed action, provided the decision is sufficiently supported and appropriate procedural steps have been followed.

All formal notices must remain freely accessible to readers and should not require a subscription or payment.

A formal notice should be clearly labeled on the journal website and linked in both directions with the affected publication where the platform permits. Readers accessing the article landing page, official full-text files, or relevant publication metadata should be able to identify its updated status. The notice and the article must not communicate conflicting information about whether the work has been corrected, retracted, or placed under concern.

9. DOI Management, Metadata & Record Linking

The journal seeks to maintain accurate and persistent bibliographic records for published contributions and formal post-publication notices.

An existing article DOI should ordinarily remain associated with the original publication. Correction or retraction does not justify deleting the DOI or assigning a replacement DOI merely to conceal the publication's earlier status.

Where the journal's DOI registration arrangements support the relevant functions, post-publication record management should include:

  • Independent Notice Records: Register a separate DOI for a substantive correction, retraction, expression of concern, or comparable notice where appropriate and supported.
  • Metadata Relationships: Record the relationship between the notice and the affected article using the relevant registration service's supported metadata structure.
  • Article Status: Update the original article's landing page, publication display, and available metadata to communicate the current status.
  • Persistent Resolution: Maintain functioning DOI links and appropriate destination URLs.
  • Cross-Platform Communication: Communicate important updates to relevant indexing services, repositories, and preservation systems where feasible.
  • Record Consistency: Ensure that the notice, article page, PDF labeling, and relevant bibliographic information do not present conflicting publication statuses.

When identifiers are registered through Crossref, the responsible publisher should use the available update and relationship metadata to connect a substantive notice with the affected article. Crossref’s versioning guidance recommends a separate, identifiable record for an editorially significant update, with its own DOI where the necessary registration functions are available. Registering such an update does not, by itself, establish that the journal operates the full Crossmark status-display service; those arrangements must be described accurately.

Where identifiers are registered through another service, the journal should follow that service's supported procedures for linking and documenting publication updates.

The journal should avoid overwriting complete DOI metadata records with incomplete updates that unintentionally remove earlier bibliographic information.

For a retraction, article-facing status labels and available DOI metadata should identify the work as retracted rather than leaving it indexed as an unqualified current publication. Where the registration service supports status relationships or notices, the publisher should preserve the original article’s persistent identifier while making the update discoverable. Subsequent issue assignment of an Online First article, by contrast, is a bibliographic update and does not by itself require a replacement article DOI.

Further technical guidance is available from Crossref: Version Control, Corrections and Retractions.

10. Editorial Investigation & Decision Procedure

Concerns may be submitted by authors, readers, reviewers, editors, research participants, institutions, rights holders, or other parties with relevant information.

The Editorial Office assesses concerns through a documented procedure proportionate to their nature and seriousness.

  1. Receipt and Registration: Record the concern, identify the affected publication, and acknowledge receipt where appropriate.
  2. Preliminary Assessment: Determine the apparent nature of the problem, whether supporting evidence is available, and whether immediate protective measures are necessary.
  3. Conflict-of-Interest Review: Ensure that the matter is handled by an editor or other authorized person who can act independently.
  4. Evidence Examination: Review relevant manuscripts, published files, source materials, permissions, correspondence, data, recordings, or other available information.
  5. Author Response: Invite the corresponding author and other affected contributors to provide appropriate explanations or documentation, subject to necessary confidentiality and protective measures.
  6. Specialist Consultation: Seek qualified advice from reviewers, subject specialists, institutions, ethics advisers, or legal professionals where necessary.
  7. Editorial Determination: Decide whether no action, clarification, correction, expression of concern, retraction, restriction, or another response is justified.
  8. Notice and Record Update: Publish an appropriate notice and update the affected article page, files, identifiers, and relevant metadata.
  9. Follow-Up: Monitor outstanding investigations, communicate relevant outcomes, and address necessary further updates.

A journal editor may examine whether a publication remains reliable, while an institution or another competent body may have broader responsibility for investigating possible research misconduct.

The journal need not delay a necessary publication notice indefinitely while waiting for an external determination where sufficient evidence already supports an appropriate editorial action.

Conversely, where evidence remains incomplete, the journal should avoid presenting an allegation as established misconduct.

The journal does not impose a universal fixed deadline on investigations. Cases requiring legal advice, institutional findings, technical verification, translation assessment, or specialist musical analysis may require additional time.

A serious concern affecting privacy, participant safety, or access to restricted cultural material may require an immediate, proportionate protective response while the substantive inquiry continues. Any interim restriction should be distinguished from a final finding of misconduct or a decision to retract the work.

11. Music, Translation, Fieldwork & Creative Materials

The journal recognizes that post-publication issues in music and sound scholarship may involve complex relationships among written research, musical evidence, cultural interpretation, performer rights, recordings, and source materials.

Particular considerations may include:

  • Musical Scores and Notation: Errors in pitches, rhythms, notation, editions, composer attribution, or analytical examples should be assessed according to their effect on the scholarly or creative contribution.
  • Audio and Video: Incorrect recording identification, misleading editing, manipulated performances, or inaccurate source credits may require correction or more substantial action.
  • Translations: Significant mistranslations, omissions, false attribution, or misrepresentation of source texts should be evaluated for their effect on interpretation and reliability.
  • Fieldwork and Interviews: Concerns may involve participant consent, privacy, inaccurate transcription, misquotation, fabricated interviews, or the disclosure of restricted information.
  • Cultural and Community Materials: Editors should consider legitimate community restrictions, sacred or ceremonial knowledge, provenance, and relevant cultural protocols.
  • Creative Works: Substantial misattribution, unauthorized reproduction, or misleading claims of originality may require appropriate editorial action, even where the contribution is not an original research article.
  • AI-Assisted Materials: Synthetic audio, generated images, fabricated transcripts, undisclosed material transformations, or AI-assisted source manipulation must be assessed in light of the journal's AI policy and the actual claims made by the publication.

Where only a specific musical example, image, recording, translation, or supplementary file is affected, the Editorial Office should consider whether replacing or restricting that component, together with an appropriate notice, can resolve the issue without invalidating the entire publication.

Where the affected material is essential to the publication's conclusions or central artistic contribution, more substantial action may be warranted.

The journal may seek relevant specialist advice before deciding whether an issue concerns a correctable technical error, a contested artistic interpretation, a rights dispute, or a serious reliability problem.

When obtaining specialist advice on culturally restricted music, unpublished recordings, identifiable interview material, or archival sources, editors should limit disclosure to what is necessary and respect the consent, access, and confidentiality conditions attached to those materials.

12. Responsibilities of Authors, Editors & the Publisher

Authors

  • Notify the Editorial Office promptly when a significant error, omission, rights issue, or integrity concern is discovered.
  • Provide accurate explanations and relevant supporting documentation in response to editorial inquiries.
  • Cooperate with correction, investigation, or publication status procedures.
  • Inform relevant co-authors or collaborators of material issues affecting their contributions where appropriate.
  • Update personally maintained repository records to reflect important corrections or retractions.

Editors

  • Assess credible concerns impartially and with appropriate attention to evidence.
  • Manage conflicts of interest and obtain independent advice when needed.
  • Distinguish correctable errors from fundamentally unreliable publications.
  • Provide appropriate opportunities for explanation or response.
  • Prepare clear notices and maintain accurate publication records.

Publisher and Editorial Administration

  • Support appropriate record preservation, hosting, notices, and metadata maintenance.
  • Provide technical assistance when publication files, identifiers, or online records require correction.
  • Maintain appropriate confidentiality and access controls for investigation records.
  • Avoid inappropriate influence over scholarly determinations or the handling of ethics concerns.
  • Coordinate relevant updates with repositories, indexing services, or registration agencies where feasible.

The failure of an author to respond to reasonable inquiries does not automatically establish misconduct. However, the journal may proceed on the available evidence when appropriate efforts to obtain clarification have been unsuccessful.

13. Appeals, Disputes & Independent Review

Authors and other materially affected parties may request reconsideration of an editorial action by submitting a reasoned written appeal supported by relevant evidence.

Grounds for reconsideration may include:

  • A significant factual error in the original determination.
  • Relevant evidence that was not considered.
  • A material procedural irregularity or conflict of interest.
  • A substantial misunderstanding of the relevant research method, source material, translation, or musical evidence.
  • Other circumstances reasonably capable of affecting the decision.

Where appropriate, an appeal may be reviewed by an independent editor, Editorial Board member, or external adviser who was not directly responsible for the original decision.

Reconsideration does not guarantee reversal of a correction, retraction, expression of concern, or other action. An appeal also does not automatically suspend a necessary measure to protect readers or the published record.

If new evidence materially changes the conclusion, the journal may revise its original determination and publish an appropriate explanatory notice. Previous notices should remain traceable rather than being silently removed.

14. Exceptional Content Removal & Access Restrictions

The journal normally preserves published articles and related notices as part of the scholarly record, including publications that have been retracted.

Complete removal of published content is an exceptional action and should be considered only when continued access presents substantial risks that cannot adequately be addressed through ordinary correction, retraction, or a limited modification.

Possible grounds may include:

  • A binding legal requirement or other sufficiently established legal necessity.
  • Serious threats to the privacy, safety, or welfare of identifiable individuals.
  • Disclosure of sensitive research materials that creates a substantial and continuing risk.
  • Protected cultural or community-restricted material for which public dissemination creates serious ethical or legal concerns.
  • Other exceptional circumstances in which retaining access would create compelling harm.

Where feasible, the journal should consider narrower measures, such as restricting a specific audio file, removing an identifiable image, redacting sensitive information, or replacing an unauthorized supplementary item, before removing an entire article.

When removal is necessary, the journal should ordinarily preserve the article's bibliographic record and an explanatory notice, subject to applicable law and safety requirements.

Removal of a publication from public access does not automatically erase its DOI, historical metadata, citation record, or previous appearance in external archives and repositories.

15. Preservation of the Scholarly Record

The journal seeks to maintain an accurate and traceable record of published contributions, post-publication actions, and associated metadata.

Corrections, expressions of concern, and retractions should remain associated with their original publications through clear links, persistent identifiers where available, and appropriate publication status information.

Relevant preservation arrangements should take account of the original publication, formal notices, corrected files where applicable, and necessary metadata relationships.

The journal does not guarantee that external repositories or archives will automatically synchronize every change. Authors, repositories, indexing services, and other third parties may need to update their own records following a formal notice.

Further information is available in the Archiving & Preservation Policy.

16. Reporting Errors & Publication Integrity Concerns

Authors, readers, institutions, research participants, librarians, reviewers, and other relevant parties may report suspected errors or integrity concerns to the Editorial Office.

A report should include, where available:

  1. The publication title, author names, DOI, or stable article URL.
  2. A clear description of the alleged error, omission, or integrity concern.
  3. Relevant page numbers, paragraphs, figures, musical examples, recordings, or timestamps.
  4. Relevant source documents, evidence, or verifiable supporting information.
  5. An explanation of any immediate privacy, safety, or confidentiality concerns.

Reports that do not identify a reporting person may be examined where sufficient specific and credible information is available. The journal will seek to protect confidential information appropriately but cannot guarantee absolute anonymity in all circumstances.

The Editorial Office may request further information before proceeding, especially where an allegation cannot be evaluated from the materials initially supplied.

A reporting person should not be required to establish misconduct conclusively before raising a specific, credible concern. The journal assesses the substance of the evidence and should distinguish reasonable good-faith reporting from knowingly false or malicious allegations without prejudging the matter.

Resonance Editorial Office: [email protected]

17. Policy Interpretation & Review

The Editorial Office interprets and applies this policy in conjunction with the journal's Publication Ethics, Plagiarism Policy, AI Use Policy, Open Access Policy, and other relevant editorial requirements.

The journal may periodically revise this policy to reflect developments in publication ethics, digital preservation, DOI registration, research integrity, intellectual property, privacy, and music-related scholarship.

Material amendments should be accompanied by an accurate update record or effective date following formal editorial approval. Earlier decisions should be evaluated with due regard to the applicable policies and circumstances at the relevant time.

Editorial Statement: Resonance: Journal of Global Music Studies regards the integrity of the published record as a continuing editorial responsibility. Errors should be corrected transparently; serious unresolved concerns should be communicated responsibly; and publications that cannot be relied upon should be appropriately retracted. These actions are intended to protect readers, support accountable scholarship, respect affected contributors, and preserve an accurate history of musical and scholarly knowledge.

Related policies include the Publication Ethics, Plagiarism Policy, AI Use Policy, Open Access Policy, and Archiving & Preservation Policy.

Original effective date: May 28, 2026. Last updated: October 28, 2026.