Publication Ethics
Resonance: Journal of Global Music Studies is committed to the integrity, transparency, fairness, accountability, and independence of scholarly publishing. Its ethical framework is informed by the principles and guidance of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and relevant academic publishing standards. Authors, reviewers, editors, guest editors, and the publisher share responsibility for trustworthy scholarship, responsible artistic publication, and the treatment of people, communities, and cultural materials represented in the journal.
These standards apply to original research, critical reviews, interviews, translations, annotated sources, sound archives, performance documentation, scores, creative works, and scholarly exchanges. The evaluation procedure depends on the contribution's content and claims, but obligations concerning accuracy, originality, attribution, permissions, confidentiality, disclosure, and editorial integrity apply to all publication types.
Reference to COPE guidance describes the principles used to inform journal policy; it does not imply COPE membership, certification, accreditation, or endorsement.
Core Principles of Publication Ethics
The journal's ethical expectations are organized around the following principles:
- Research and Scholarly Integrity: Published contributions must represent sources, methods, findings, interpretations, and creative processes accurately and without fabrication, falsification, or deliberate misrepresentation.
- Originality and Attribution: Authors must acknowledge relevant scholarship, intellectual contributions, artistic materials, and prior publications. Plagiarism, deceptive duplication, and substantial unattributed reuse are prohibited.
- Authorship and Accountability: Authorship must reflect substantive contributions and responsibility for the submitted work. All named authors must approve the manuscript and its submission.
- Independent Editorial Evaluation: Manuscripts must be evaluated according to appropriate scholarly, artistic, documentary, or editorial standards without improper influence from personal relationships, financial interests, institutional position, or publication charges.
- Confidentiality and Procedural Fairness: Unpublished manuscripts, research materials, reviewer reports, complaints, and integrity investigations must be handled responsibly and with appropriate confidentiality.
- Protection of Participants and Communities: Research must respect informed consent, privacy, cultural protocols, participant safety, and restrictions governing sensitive or community-specific knowledge.
- Transparency and Disclosure: Relevant conflicts of interest, funding, permissions, research ethics approvals, prior dissemination, and substantive AI-assisted activities must be disclosed.
- Integrity of the Published Record: Significant errors and ethical concerns must be assessed appropriately, with corrections, expressions of concern, retractions, or other measures taken when warranted.
Responsibilities of Authors
Authors bear primary responsibility for the originality, reliability, accuracy, lawful publication, and ethical integrity of their submissions.
Originality, Plagiarism & Prior Publication
- Original Work: Manuscripts must contain original scholarly, artistic, critical, documentary, or interpretive contributions appropriate to the selected publication category.
- Exclusive Consideration: A manuscript must not be under simultaneous consideration by another journal unless an exceptional arrangement has been explicitly authorized by the relevant editors.
- Plagiarism: Authors must not reproduce another person's text, arguments, data, musical materials, images, recordings, translations, or intellectual contributions without appropriate attribution and necessary permissions.
- Self-Plagiarism and Text Recycling: Substantial reuse of an author's previously published material must be disclosed, properly cited, and justified. Authors must not misrepresent previously disseminated work as entirely new.
- Preprints and Related Works: Authors must disclose relevant preprints, working papers, conference versions, theses, repository deposits, or related publications where these affect originality or the assessment of overlap.
- Translations and Source Editions: Original source materials, earlier translations, editions, archival reproductions, and relevant rights holders must be acknowledged accurately.
- Accurate Citation: Citations and references must identify authentic, relevant, and appropriately consulted sources. Invented references or misleading attribution are prohibited.
The journal may use similarity screening together with editorial examination of sources and citation practices. A similarity score is not a finding of plagiarism: editors must consider the nature and extent of overlap, attribution, disciplinary conventions, relevant quotations, and any prior dissemination. Where concerns remain, authors may be asked to explain or correct the material under the journal's Plagiarism Policy.
Authors should consult the journal's Plagiarism Policy.
Authorship, Contributorship & Approval
- Substantive Contribution: Named authors must have contributed meaningfully to the conception, design, research, analysis, interpretation, translation, artistic creation, or preparation of the work, as appropriate to the publication type.
- Manuscript Approval: All named authors must review and approve the submitted version and accept appropriate responsibility for their contributions and the integrity of the publication.
- Contribution Transparency: Authors should identify relevant individual roles where necessary, including research, artistic collaboration, data analysis, translation, editing, documentation, and manuscript preparation.
- Prohibited Authorship Practices: Ghost authorship, gift authorship, honorary authorship, unauthorized attribution, and deliberate omission of qualifying contributors are not permitted.
- Acknowledgments: Individuals whose assistance does not justify authorship should be acknowledged appropriately, subject to relevant consent and confidentiality considerations.
- Changes to Authorship: Requests to add, remove, or reorder authors after submission require an explanation and the agreement of relevant contributors. The Editorial Office may request supporting documentation or refer unresolved disputes to appropriate institutions.
- Corresponding Author: The corresponding author is responsible for maintaining communication with the journal and ensuring that required author approvals, declarations, and revisions are coordinated.
Authorship must be determined according to the nature of the contribution, not merely by a person's presence in the source material. An interview participant is not automatically a manuscript co-author, and a performer whose work is documented may require artistic credit without necessarily meeting the manuscript's authorship criteria. Authorship, consent to publish, acknowledgments, and applicable performance or recording rights must be addressed separately. The corresponding author coordinates communication and the author group's required approvals and declarations.
Data, Evidence & Research Reliability
- Accurate Reporting: Research data, historical evidence, interview statements, musical examples, recordings, images, statistical results, and scholarly findings must be presented accurately.
- No Fabrication or Falsification: Authors must not invent, manipulate, selectively alter, or suppress evidence in ways that materially misrepresent a research process or its findings.
- Methodological Transparency: Research manuscripts should describe methods, sources, analytical procedures, and relevant limitations sufficiently to support critical evaluation.
- Source Verification: Authors should retain appropriate documentation of research materials and be prepared to respond to reasonable editorial requests for verification.
- Data Availability: Authors should explain the availability of supporting research data where relevant. Sharing may be limited by participant consent, confidentiality, contractual restrictions, copyright, cultural protocols, or other legitimate obligations.
- Research Limitations: Authors must disclose material limitations and avoid conclusions that exceed the evidence presented.
Requests for supporting data or records must be proportionate and consistent with consent, privacy, lawful access, archive agreements, and cultural restrictions. The journal does not require unrestricted public disclosure of identifiable participant information, private interviews, confidential fieldwork, or protected community knowledge. Appropriate restricted verification and transparent descriptions of access limitations may be considered where evidence cannot be made publicly available.
Funding, Conflicts of Interest & Disclosures
Authors must disclose financial and non-financial relationships that could reasonably influence, or appear to influence, the conduct, interpretation, presentation, or publication of their work.
- Identify relevant research funding, grants, sponsorship, institutional assistance, and material support.
- Disclose relationships with organizations, publishers, performers, cultural institutions, or commercial entities directly connected to the work.
- Declare relevant professional, personal, institutional, or financial interests affecting scholarly independence.
- Explain the role of funders or sponsors in the research, analysis, manuscript preparation, publication decision, or dissemination, where applicable.
- Submit an appropriate declaration when no relevant competing interests exist.
The existence of a competing interest does not automatically disqualify a manuscript. The purpose of disclosure is to enable editors and readers to assess the potential influence of relevant relationships.
Research Participants, Fieldwork & Cultural Ethics
Research and creative documentation in music and sound studies may involve performers, interviewees, oral histories, recordings, archives, cultural communities, and forms of knowledge subject to particular access conditions. Researchers must respect participants' dignity, privacy, autonomy, safety, and relevant cultural protocols, including when material is already publicly accessible.
- Ethics Approval: Obtain institutional ethics approval or another applicable form of review where required. If formal approval was not required, authors may be asked to explain the ethical safeguards used.
- Informed Consent: Obtain appropriate consent for participation, recording, quotation, identification, translation, publication, and relevant reuse of participant materials.
- Privacy and Confidentiality: Protect personal information and respect agreed restrictions on attribution, recording, archiving, and publication.
- Participant Safety: Consider foreseeable risks to participants' reputation, employment, safety, legal status, family relationships, and community standing.
- Culturally Sensitive Materials: Respect relevant community protocols and restrictions involving ceremonial music, sacred sound, traditional knowledge, community archives, and culturally restricted performances.
- Audio-Visual Research: Obtain appropriate permissions for publication of voices, recordings, photographs, performances, musical examples, and other identifiable material.
- Archival and Digital Sources: Consider source provenance, access conditions, rights, privacy, and cultural sensitivity. Public availability of material does not automatically eliminate ethical obligations.
- Translation and Representation: Translate, transcribe, and contextualize participants' words and musical practices accurately, without material distortion or misleading editorial intervention.
Authors should accurately identify required ethics approval, applicable consent arrangements, and material restrictions on access or publication. Where formal institutional review is not required, they may explain the safeguards actually used; they should not claim approval that was never obtained. Private consent records, identifiable participant data, and restricted materials must not be made public merely to satisfy editorial verification.
Detailed requirements are available in the journal's Fieldwork & Interview Ethics Policy.
Intellectual Property, Permissions & Licensing
Authors are responsible for ensuring that submitted materials may lawfully and ethically be reproduced, distributed, translated, displayed, performed, or otherwise used in the proposed publication.
- Identify copyright holders and other relevant rights holders for third-party materials.
- Obtain necessary permissions for protected musical works, recordings, images, scores, translations, archival reproductions, and audiovisual content.
- Respect performers' rights, recording rights, publication agreements, contractual restrictions, and applicable rights of identifiable participants.
- Distinguish the copyright status of an original historical text from that of a later translation, critical edition, photograph, or other separately protected contribution.
- Identify third-party materials excluded from the article's Creative Commons license and describe applicable rights or restrictions clearly.
- Ensure that the author's own contribution and any material represented as CC BY 4.0 licensed may lawfully be distributed under those terms.
The journal's open-access publication model does not automatically confer unrestricted reuse rights over third-party compositions, recordings, photographs, archival materials, or translated works. Consent to participate in a performance or interview is also distinct from permission to redistribute the resulting material under an open license.
Authors should consult the Open Access Policy.
Responsibilities of Reviewers
Reviewers contribute independent scholarly expertise to the assessment of manuscripts and are expected to maintain confidentiality, objectivity, integrity, and professional responsibility.
- Confidentiality: Treat manuscripts, unpublished evidence, reviewer correspondence, and editorial information as confidential materials.
- Independence: Assess originality, significance, methods, evidence, analysis, and scholarly contribution without inappropriate personal or institutional bias.
- Competence: Accept review assignments only when adequately qualified to provide a useful evaluation, and notify the editor when specialist expertise is insufficient.
- Conflicts of Interest: Disclose relevant personal, professional, financial, institutional, supervisory, or collaborative relationships and decline assignments where impartiality cannot be maintained.
- Constructive Assessment: Provide clear, evidence-based, proportionate, and professionally expressed recommendations that identify substantive strengths and weaknesses.
- Timeliness: Inform the editor promptly if unable to complete a review or meet the agreed deadline.
- Source Attribution: Identify significant missing references or possible unattributed material where relevant. Citation requests must have scholarly justification and must not be used for inappropriate citation manipulation.
- Unpublished Materials: Do not use confidential manuscripts, unpublished ideas, data, musical examples, recordings, or artistic works for personal research or professional advantage without authorization.
- Responsible AI Use: Do not upload confidential manuscripts, reviewer reports, participant materials, or unpublished works to unauthorized AI systems. Review judgments must remain the responsibility of the assigned human reviewer.
- Integrity Concerns: Report suspected plagiarism, fabricated evidence, manipulated images or recordings, ethical violations, or other substantive concerns confidentially to the handling editor.
Reviewers must not contact authors directly concerning a confidential review unless the Editorial Office has authorized the communication. They must not delegate the review to another individual without editorial permission.
Reviewer recommendations are advisory. The journal's editors retain responsibility for final editorial decisions.
Responsibilities of Editors
Editors are responsible for maintaining the quality, independence, fairness, confidentiality, and ethical integrity of the journal's editorial and publication processes.
- Fair Evaluation: Evaluate submissions according to their academic, artistic, cultural, or documentary merits and the standards appropriate to their content type.
- Editorial Independence: Protect editorial decisions from inappropriate influence by authors, publishers, sponsors, advertisers, institutions, personal relationships, or publication payments.
- Appropriate Review: Ensure that original research articles undergo the applicable double-blind peer review process, while non-research contributions receive the editorial or specialist assessment required by their publication category.
- Reviewer Selection: Select appropriately qualified and independent reviewers, evaluate conflicts of interest, and manage significant disagreements among review reports.
- Confidentiality: Restrict access to confidential submission and review materials to individuals with legitimate editorial responsibilities.
- Conflicts of Interest: Disclose relevant competing interests and transfer affected manuscripts to an independent editor when necessary.
- Procedural Fairness: Give authors appropriate opportunities to respond to substantive concerns and consider evidence before reaching conclusions concerning research integrity.
- Editorial Accountability: Ensure that decisions are documented, justified by relevant academic or ethical considerations, and communicated through appropriate channels.
- Publication Accuracy: Maintain accurate article metadata, author information, dates, content classification, review-status descriptions, and publication notices.
- Post-Publication Responsibility: Assess credible concerns about published work and arrange appropriate corrections, expressions of concern, retractions, or other actions where warranted.
Editorial Board and Guest Editor Submissions
Manuscripts submitted by editors, Editorial Board members, guest editors, or individuals with relevant editorial responsibilities must be handled by an appropriately qualified independent editor.
The person submitting the work must not select its reviewers, access confidential editorial deliberations beyond the ordinary rights of an author, influence the evaluation, or participate in the final publication decision.
Invited submissions and special issue contributions remain subject to the applicable scholarly and ethical standards. Invitation, editorial position, or institutional affiliation does not guarantee acceptance.
Peer Review Integrity & Editorial Classification
Original research articles proceeding to external assessment undergo double-blind peer review by at least two independent qualified reviewers. Creative, documentary, interpretive, and other non-research content normally undergoes editorial assessment, supplemented by specialist evaluation when appropriate. Review status must reflect the procedure actually completed, and independent specialist advice alone does not establish research-article peer-review status.
Attempts to manipulate assessment are prohibited, including fictitious reviewer identities, deceptive reviewer nominations, undisclosed disqualifying conflicts, unauthorized access to confidential reports, coerced citations, and interference with recommendations or editorial decisions. Further details appear in the Peer Review Process and Special Issues & Non-Research Content Review Policy.
Artificial Intelligence & Research Integrity
AI-assisted technologies may support research, creative practice, translation, transcription, analysis, or manuscript preparation only in a manner consistent with the journal's AI Use Policy, intellectual property, participant protection, and confidentiality obligations. Human contributors must disclose substantive uses and remain accountable for the content submitted under their names.
- Human Accountability: Named human authors remain responsible for the accuracy, originality, interpretation, integrity, and ethical compliance of their submissions. AI systems must not be listed as authors.
- Disclosure: Substantive AI-assisted activities affecting research, writing, translation, transcription, analysis, musical generation, or preparation of evidence must be disclosed as required by journal policy.
- Verification: Authors must check AI-assisted quotations, references, summaries, translations, analyses, and other materials against reliable sources and relevant original records.
- Prohibited Fabrication: AI must not be used to fabricate data, references, interviews, archival sources, fieldnotes, musical examples, recordings, images, research findings, or participant statements.
- Authenticity of Media: Synthetic or materially altered audio, visual, and musical materials must not be misrepresented as authentic recordings, historical evidence, or unmodified documentation.
- Confidentiality: Authors, reviewers, and editors must not disclose confidential manuscripts, unpublished compositions, restricted cultural materials, or private participant information to unauthorized AI services.
- Peer Review Integrity: AI systems must not be used to impersonate authors, reviewers, editors, or participants; generate fictitious reviews; or manipulate editorial screening and assessment.
Automated AI-detection results are not definitive evidence of misconduct. Concerns involving AI use must be evaluated through appropriate editorial inquiry, contextual evidence, and the journal's applicable procedures.
Reporting and Assessing Ethical Concerns
Resonance considers credible concerns raised before or after publication by authors, readers, reviewers, participants, institutions, rights holders, or other parties. A concern should identify the affected manuscript or publication and explain the possible problem with available supporting information. Editorial examination is distinct from a formal institutional determination of research misconduct.
Reports should identify the manuscript or publication concerned, describe the suspected problem as precisely as possible, and provide relevant documentation or verifiable supporting information where available.
Editorial Assessment Procedure
- Receipt and Initial Assessment: The Editorial Office considers whether the concern falls within the journal's responsibilities and whether the information provided is sufficiently specific to justify further assessment.
- Preservation of Relevant Records: Where appropriate, editors preserve relevant manuscript versions, submission metadata, review correspondence, publication records, and supporting evidence while restricting unnecessary access.
- Clarification and Author Response: The Editorial Office may request explanations, source records, relevant declarations, or other information from the authors and affected parties. Individuals whose conduct is questioned should normally be given a reasonable opportunity to respond.
- Independent Evaluation: When necessary, editors may consult independent specialists, editorial advisers, ethics bodies, relevant institutions, or legal advisers. Conflicted individuals must not control the assessment.
- Proportionate Editorial Action: Decisions are based on the nature, reliability, seriousness, and impact of the evidence. Possible outcomes include clarification, revision, additional verification, rejection, correction, expression of concern, retraction, or no further action.
- Documentation and Communication: The Editorial Office records relevant decisions and communicates outcomes to appropriate parties, subject to confidentiality, privacy, legal restrictions, and the requirements of the published record.
Anonymous or confidential reports may be considered when sufficiently specific and supported by credible information. Editors should protect reporting persons and affected parties as far as practicable while preserving procedural fairness, relevant rights of reply, confidentiality, and applicable legal requirements.
Allegations are not findings of misconduct. Scholarly disagreement, competing interpretations, and criticism of a method do not by themselves establish ethical wrongdoing. Where a concern exceeds the journal's investigatory authority or access to evidence, appropriate institutional or specialist assistance may be sought; the journal remains responsible for its own publication decisions and record.
Policy Violations & Editorial Actions
When evidence substantiates a material breach of publication requirements, the journal may take an action proportionate to the seriousness of the concern, the work's publication stage, its impact on reliability or rights, and applicable policy. The available responses are not automatic penalties: editorial judgment, adequate evidence, and the opportunity for relevant explanation remain important.
Before Publication
- Request clarification, missing declarations, permissions, research records, or other necessary documentation.
- Require correction or revision of problematic passages, data presentations, references, or supporting materials.
- Suspend editorial assessment while a substantial concern is examined.
- Reject a manuscript where serious ethical violations, unreliable research, or unresolved publication barriers make acceptance inappropriate.
- Seek appropriate institutional or specialist assistance where the available evidence warrants further investigation.
After Publication
- Correction: A correction may be issued where an error materially affects the published record but does not invalidate the overall scholarly contribution.
- Expression of Concern: An editorial notice may be issued where credible and serious concerns remain unresolved or an investigation is ongoing.
- Retraction: A retraction may be issued where findings, evidence, or the integrity of the publication are seriously compromised by misconduct, fundamental error, unethical research, or other substantial defects.
- Additional Measures: The journal may correct metadata, identify relevant rights restrictions, notify appropriate institutions or parties where warranted, or take other proportionate measures consistent with its policies and legal obligations.
Not every concern warrants retraction. An honest or limited error may be correctable, while serious unreliability can require a retraction even without proof of deliberate misconduct. Editorial notices should accurately distinguish proven facts from unresolved allegations, identify the affected publication, and preserve a traceable scholarly record.
Substantive changes after publication must not be concealed by silent replacement of the version of record. Retracted contributions normally remain accessible with prominent notices, except where a compelling legal, privacy, safety, or comparable reason justifies restriction or removal. Consult the Corrections and Retractions Policy.
Complaints, Appeals & Procedural Fairness
Authors and other affected parties may raise concerns about editorial decisions, the conduct of peer review, conflicts of interest, confidentiality, ethical investigations, or post-publication actions.
Complaints and appeals should identify the relevant manuscript or publication, explain the matter in question, and provide supporting information where appropriate.
- Appeals Against Decisions: Authors may request reconsideration where they identify a material factual error, procedural problem, overlooked evidence, or other substantive reason affecting the decision.
- Complaints About Editorial Conduct: Concerns involving reviewer behavior, conflicts of interest, confidentiality, discrimination, or procedural irregularities may be referred to an editor or adviser not implicated in the complaint.
- Independent Assessment: The Editorial Office may seek review by an independent Editorial Board member or external adviser where necessary to manage conflicts or ensure procedural fairness.
- Opportunity to Respond: Relevant parties should normally have an opportunity to provide explanations before adverse findings are finalized, consistent with confidentiality and the circumstances of the case.
- Proportionality: Editorial actions must be based on the evidence and seriousness of the concern. An appeal does not automatically require a new review or reversal of the original decision.
The journal aims to handle complaints and appeals impartially, with appropriate confidentiality and a reasonable opportunity for relevant parties to respond. Complex matters involving disputed evidence, outside institutions, or legal restrictions may require additional time. An appeal does not guarantee renewed review or reversal of the original decision.
Responsibilities of the Publisher
Panorama Scholarly Group, as publisher, supports the journal's editorial independence, publishing infrastructure, transparent public policies, responsible handling of submitted and published materials, and the accuracy of the publication record. Publisher support includes technical and administrative assistance with access, metadata, permissions-related processes, and post-publication notices.
The publisher must not use APC payments, sponsorship, institutional relationships, or commercial considerations to influence peer-review recommendations, manuscript acceptance, or an ethics determination. These responsibilities extend to regular and special issues and to guest editorial arrangements.
Reporting Ethical Concerns
Reports of suspected research integrity concerns, authorship disputes, inappropriate conduct, ethical complaints, or problems with published work should be addressed to the Resonance Editorial Office at [email protected]. Include the manuscript title and submission ID, DOI, or stable article URL where available, a clear description of the issue, and relevant supporting material.
Correspondents should distinguish verified facts from suspicions or interpretations. Requests for confidentiality will be considered in light of fairness, relevant legal requirements, and the need to examine the evidence without unnecessary disclosure.
Related policies and practical instructions: Submission Guidelines, Plagiarism Policy, Fieldwork & Interview Ethics Policy, AI Use Policy, and Corrections and Retractions Policy.