Resonance: Journal of Global Music Studies is committed to ethical, respectful, transparent, and culturally responsible research involving fieldwork, interviews, oral histories, participant observation, sound recordings, musical performances, photographs, audiovisual documentation, archival sources, and digital environments. The journal recognizes that music and sound research often involves relationships of trust among researchers, performers, listeners, communities, and institutions. Authors must protect the rights, dignity, safety, agency, and legitimate interests of those whose experiences, voices, performances, or cultural knowledge inform published scholarship.

This policy applies to original research, ethnographic studies, historical investigations, interviews, translations, sound archives, performance studies, creative scholarship, and other contributions that involve human participants, identifiable individuals, cultural communities, or potentially sensitive research materials.

Authors are responsible for complying with applicable institutional ethics requirements, laws, informed-consent agreements, copyright and performers’ rights, archival access conditions, and relevant cultural protocols. Ethical responsibility begins with the design of the research and continues through documentation, analysis, publication, archiving, and lawful subsequent reuse. A formal approval or legal permission does not, by itself, resolve every question of respectful or culturally appropriate use.

1. General Ethical Principles

Research involving people, communities, performances, or culturally meaningful materials should follow these principles:

  • Respect and Dignity: Treat participants and communities fairly, respectfully, and without coercion, discrimination, or misleading representation.
  • Informed Participation: Obtain appropriate consent or establish another valid ethical and legal basis for relevant research activities.
  • Minimization of Harm: Consider and reduce foreseeable risks to individuals, groups, performers, and communities.
  • Accuracy and Context: Represent statements, performances, traditions, recordings, translations, and source materials faithfully and with sufficient contextual information.
  • Privacy and Confidentiality: Protect personal information, confidential communications, restricted research records, and sensitive material.
  • Cultural Responsibility: Respect relevant cultural norms, community protocols, traditional knowledge, and legitimate restrictions on access and dissemination.
  • Transparency: Explain relevant research procedures, participant relationships, permissions, ethical approvals, and limitations.
  • Accountability: Authors remain responsible for the ethical collection, interpretation, storage, and publication of their research materials.

Public availability, technological accessibility, or institutional possession of material does not automatically establish that its collection, quotation, reproduction, analysis, translation, publication, or redistribution is ethically appropriate. In assessing a disputed use, authors and editors should distinguish legal authorization, research-ethics approval, participant expectations, copyright and related rights, and cultural obligations rather than treating any one of these as a substitute for the others.

2. Research Involving Human Participants

Research involving human participants may include interviews, oral histories, questionnaires, ethnographic observation, workshops, rehearsals, musical performances, lessons, community events, digital interactions, and correspondence with musicians, composers, performers, teachers, students, listeners, curators, archivists, cultural workers, and other individuals.

Authors should ensure that:

  • Participants receive an understandable explanation of the research purpose and the nature of their involvement.
  • Participation is voluntary, and individuals are not subjected to improper pressure, deception, or exploitation.
  • Relevant risks, benefits, and foreseeable uses of the collected material are explained appropriately.
  • Participants understand whether their identities, voices, images, performances, or statements may be recognizable.
  • Researchers disclose relevant institutional affiliations, research roles, and relationships that could affect participation.
  • Restrictions or conditions agreed with participants are respected throughout the research and publication process.
  • Researchers take appropriate steps to protect individuals who may be affected by the publication even when they did not directly participate in the research.

Researchers should consider power differences arising from age, employment, education, institutional position, social status, cultural identity, economic circumstances, or dependence on the researcher or research institution.

Where a researcher is also a teacher, employer, curator, performer, community insider, or organizer, the research relationship may involve overlapping professional or personal roles. Authors should explain material role conflicts, ensure that declining to participate does not improperly affect a person's existing opportunities or relationships, and avoid relying on apparent consent obtained under pressure.

Participation in a public performance, attendance at a community event, or appearance in a publicly accessible recording does not necessarily imply agreement to participate in a separate research project or to have identifiable material republished without restriction.

3. Informed Consent and Publication Authorization

Authors must obtain appropriate informed consent for participant-based research activities when required by applicable ethical standards or law. Interviews, identifiable recordings, photographs, performance documentation, and the public release of personal or restricted materials may require specific authorization.

Consent must be sought before the relevant activity where required and documented in a way suited to the research context. Written, recorded, or appropriately documented oral consent may be acceptable according to applicable law, institutional requirements, participant preference, and the circumstances of the fieldwork. Information should be communicated in a language and format the participant can understand; the use of an interpreter or culturally appropriate explanation should be considered where necessary. Obtaining a signature is not, on its own, evidence that the person understood the proposed uses.

Elements of Informed Consent

Where relevant, the consent process should explain:

  • The purpose, scope, and expected activities of the research project.
  • Whether interviews, performances, images, audio, video, fieldnotes, or other materials will be collected.
  • Whether material may be quoted, translated, edited, transcribed, analyzed, reproduced, or used in public presentations.
  • Whether the participant will be named, identified by professional role, represented through a pseudonym, or anonymized.
  • Whether relevant materials may appear in open-access publications, online supplements, repositories, archives, or other publicly accessible resources.
  • The foreseeable limitations on confidentiality, online dissemination, and subsequent reuse.
  • Any applicable procedures for participant review, correction, restriction, or withdrawal.
  • Any relevant cultural, institutional, archival, legal, or community restrictions.

Separate Uses and Permissions

Consent to participate in an interview does not automatically authorize the publication of a full recording, identifiable photograph, video, transcript, or musical performance.

Likewise, permission to use a short quotation in an article does not necessarily authorize unrestricted public distribution of the underlying source recording or its deposit in an open repository.

Where relevant, authors should distinguish among permission to participate, permission to record, permission to quote or reproduce, permission to identify the participant, and permission to archive or make material publicly accessible.

Particular care is needed when a recording includes several performers, speakers, a venue operator, or a musical work owned by someone other than the interviewee. Permission from one participant cannot automatically authorize all relevant copyrights, performers’ rights, privacy interests, or publication restrictions. Authors should identify which rights and consents are needed for the specific material that will actually appear in the article or its supplements.

Ongoing Consent and Withdrawal

Consent may require continuing communication when a project's purpose, audience, publication format, or intended use of participant material changes materially.

Participants should be informed of any applicable legal right or agreed opportunity to discontinue participation, withdraw unprocessed material, correct an attribution, or restrict a specified recording or interview. Researchers should distinguish withdrawal from an ongoing research activity from subsequent requests to alter a manuscript, an archived source, or a formally published article. The relevant procedure and practical limits should be explained before public release wherever possible.

After formal open-access publication, complete removal of material from all third-party repositories, downloads, indexing systems, and archival copies may be technically or legally impossible. Authors must not promise unrestricted post-publication withdrawal where it cannot be guaranteed.

Where a legitimate privacy, consent, safety, or rights concern arises after publication, the journal will consider an appropriate correction, restriction, replacement, or other action under its published post-publication policies.

4. Consent Documentation and Record Protection

Authors should retain appropriate evidence of consent and relevant permissions in accordance with institutional requirements, applicable laws, agreed research arrangements, and responsible data management practices.

Documentation may include:

  • Signed consent or release forms.
  • Recorded or otherwise documented oral consent.
  • Appropriate electronic correspondence confirming agreed uses.
  • Institutional ethics approval or exemption determinations where applicable.
  • Archive agreements, performance releases, copyright permissions, or community-specific authorizations.
  • Records of subsequent changes to consent or access restrictions.

The Editorial Office may request confirmation of appropriate consent or documentation of relevant approvals. Authors should not routinely upload identifiable consent forms, confidential recordings, participant contact details, or other sensitive records into ordinary submission files.

When confidential supporting documentation is necessary for editorial assessment, a suitably restricted and authorized method of communication should be used. Access should be limited to those with a legitimate need to examine the material.

Where an editor needs to verify consent, authors can initially provide a non-identifying explanation of the consent process or a suitably redacted document, provided this is sufficient for the issue under review. Original consent records and access-restricted research materials should remain under appropriate control; their routine transfer to external similarity-checking or AI services is not justified by the submission process.

The journal does not establish a universal retention period for all research records. Retention, deletion, and transfer arrangements must follow applicable institutional, legal, contractual, and ethical requirements.

5. Interviews and Oral Histories

Interviews and oral histories frequently involve collaborative processes through which participants share memories, musical knowledge, professional experiences, personal interpretations, and culturally meaningful narratives.

Authors must represent interviewees accurately and avoid misleading quotation, selective editing, mistranslation, false attribution, or distortion of the original context.

Interview-based submissions should address, where applicable:

  • Purpose and Recording: Explain the interview's purpose and whether it will be audio-recorded, video-recorded, transcribed, or otherwise documented.
  • Identity and Attribution: Confirm how the participant wishes to be identified and whether their name, professional role, or community affiliation may be disclosed.
  • Transcript Accuracy: Ensure that edited quotations and transcripts preserve the substance and intended meaning of the original statements.
  • Translation: Identify material translation choices and acknowledge translators where relevant.
  • Publication Scope: Clarify whether the journal may publish selected quotations, a complete interview, a recording, a translation, or supplementary documentation.
  • Access and Preservation: Explain any intended archival deposit, public access conditions, embargo, or restriction on future use.
  • Participant Review: Where appropriate and feasible, provide an opportunity to review relevant quotations, transcripts, or recordings before public release.

For oral-history projects, the journal encourages practices consistent with the Oral History Association’s guidance, including informed consent, clear agreements about recording and future use, responsible stewardship, and an opportunity for the narrator to review the interview or relevant publication material before public release where feasible and appropriate. Researchers should make the agreed review, approval, restriction, or access arrangements clear at the outset and respect them as the project develops.

Participant or narrator review should be arranged with a clear understanding of its scope—for example, confirming factual accuracy, correcting transcription errors, or deciding whether a complete interview may be released. Approval of the public release of an oral-history recording is distinct from the author's independent scholarly interpretation of that source. A participant does not automatically acquire editorial control over an unrelated research argument, but any agreed approval or use restrictions must be honored.

Where the publication format involves an edited or translated interview, authors should identify significant editorial interventions that affect the structure or interpretation of the conversation.

6. Fieldwork, Participant Observation and Public Events

Musical fieldwork may take place in homes, schools, studios, rehearsal rooms, concert venues, religious settings, festivals, public spaces, online environments, or other settings with differing expectations of privacy and participation.

Researchers should consider whether their activities involve ordinary observation, active participation, interviews, recording, or the collection of identifiable personal information. Ethical obligations differ according to the activity, context, and foreseeable risk.

  • Public Observation: Observation of a genuinely public musical event may not always require individual consent from every person present. Authors must still consider applicable law, research ethics requirements, and potential risks associated with identifiable publication.
  • Private and Restricted Settings: Rehearsals, private lessons, closed ceremonies, invitation-only gatherings, and restricted community spaces may require permission from appropriate individuals or organizers.
  • Participant Observation: Researchers should describe relevant roles, relationships, participation arrangements, and the circumstances under which research material was obtained.
  • Recording Activities: Audio or video capture may create additional consent, privacy, copyright, and performer-rights obligations beyond those associated with observing an event.
  • Researcher Position: Authors should reflect on material power relationships and their own position where these affect access, interpretation, or participant vulnerability.
  • Representation: A limited observation should not be presented as representative of an entire musical community or population without sufficient evidence.

Researchers should avoid collecting more identifiable information than is reasonably needed for the scholarly purpose, particularly in settings where individuals may not expect their behavior to become the subject of a permanently accessible academic publication.

Where observation becomes a recorded interview, identifiable case study, publication of a participant’s image, or an open online dataset, the ethical implications should be reassessed rather than assuming that the conditions for initial observation authorize all later uses. The researcher should also consider whether public identification could affect other members of a small ensemble, workplace, family, or musical community.

7. Sound Recordings, Images, Video and Performance Rights

Research involving recordings, images, musical performances, or audiovisual documentation may require separate consideration of participant consent, copyright, performers' rights, rights in recordings, privacy, and applicable cultural restrictions.

Authors must verify the relevant authorization and rights associated with:

  • Musical compositions, arrangements, scores, and notated excerpts.
  • Live performances, rehearsals, improvisations, and recorded interpretations.
  • Sound recordings, audiovisual productions, and their relevant producers or rights holders.
  • Images, photographs, portraits, screenshots, and identifiable likenesses.
  • Interview recordings, oral testimony, and translations or edited transcripts.
  • Archival reproductions, historical recordings, and restricted collections.

A performer’s consent to be interviewed, observed, or recorded does not necessarily establish that the researcher owns copyright in the underlying composition, arrangement, sound recording, or audiovisual production. These interests may belong to different persons or organizations. Equally, permission to reproduce a short musical example within an article does not necessarily cover unrestricted distribution of an entire performance or recording as supplementary media.

All media must be accurately captioned and credited. Relevant production dates, sources, performers, composers, translators, and rights holders should be identified where appropriate.

Editing, restoration, noise reduction, source separation, synthetic reconstruction, or other transformations must not misleadingly alter the meaning or evidentiary status of a recording.

If an audiovisual resource cannot lawfully or ethically be published, authors may describe it in the article without publicly distributing the underlying material, provided the description itself does not reveal protected or restricted information.

When a publicly accessible example includes a participant’s recognizable voice or likeness, authors should consider how attribution, consent, and third-party licensing interact. A caption can describe an authorized rights exclusion from the article’s CC BY 4.0 license, but a caption alone cannot cure an absence of permission or an underlying privacy or consent violation.

8. Cultural Responsibility and Community-Restricted Knowledge

Research involving Indigenous peoples, minority communities, religious groups, ritual music, sacred sound, endangered traditions, traditional cultural expressions, or community-restricted knowledge requires careful attention to collective interests, cultural protocols, and the conditions under which information is shared.

A source may be accessible to a researcher without being intended for unrestricted publication, translation, recording, digitization, or commercial reuse.

Authors should, where relevant:

  • Respect legitimate community procedures governing access to specific musical, ceremonial, archival, or oral materials.
  • Seek appropriate engagement with community representatives or knowledge holders where such engagement is necessary and feasible.
  • Distinguish consent given by an individual from authorization required under relevant community arrangements.
  • Avoid presenting communities as culturally static, exotic, anonymous, or lacking agency.
  • Recognize relevant local concepts of authorship, custodianship, ownership, attribution, and responsibility.
  • Consider whether publication may disclose restricted repertoires, ritual practices, locations, identities, or other sensitive information.
  • Describe significant collaborative research arrangements, community review processes, or benefit-sharing commitments where applicable.

For research involving Indigenous data and knowledge, the CARE Principles for Indigenous Data Governance provide a relevant, non-binding framework: Collective Benefit, Authority to Control, Responsibility, and Ethics. They emphasize the rights and interests of Indigenous peoples in the governance and reuse of data and cultural knowledge, complementing technical principles of data findability and sharing. Authors should explain relevant community agreements and custodial responsibilities where these are material to the research, without presenting CARE as a substitute for applicable law or specific community protocols.

Community-level permission does not automatically replace individual informed consent where individual rights are involved. Conversely, individual consent does not always resolve collective cultural restrictions.

The journal does not presume that a single person or organization represents an entire community in every matter. Authors should explain how relevant authority, consent, and representation were established.

Collaborative research may involve agreed procedures for review, acknowledgment, access, return of copies, or sharing of research benefits. Where such commitments have been made, authors should describe and honor them. This does not establish a universal requirement that every community-based study obtain a single form of collective authorization; the necessary approach depends on the people, materials, relationships, and applicable governance arrangements.

9. Vulnerable Participants and Risk of Harm

Additional safeguards may be required when research involves minors, students, individuals in dependent relationships, refugees, displaced persons, survivors of trauma, persons with limited capacity to consent, politically exposed individuals, or participants who may face significant personal, professional, legal, or community risks.

Authors should assess foreseeable risks involving:

  • Identification or re-identification of individuals who expected confidentiality.
  • Exposure of sensitive political, religious, medical, legal, personal, or employment-related information.
  • Retaliation, discrimination, reputational harm, or damage to family and community relationships.
  • Misuse of identifiable voices, images, performances, recordings, and cultural materials.
  • Disclosure of restricted locations, social networks, ceremonies, archives, or cultural practices.

Research involving children or participants unable to provide legally sufficient consent must follow applicable requirements concerning parental or guardian permission, participant assent, independent safeguards, and institutional review.

Where appropriate, authors should use pseudonyms, remove identifying details, generalize locations, obscure recognizable characteristics, restrict recordings, or omit sensitive material.

Anonymization must be meaningful rather than merely cosmetic. A distinctive voice, musical style, instrument, occupation, venue, geographic location, or combination of contextual details may permit identification even when a participant’s name has been removed. When an audio excerpt cannot be made genuinely non-identifying without compromising its evidentiary value, authors should seek appropriate publication authorization or restrict the excerpt rather than incorrectly labeling it anonymous.

Protective editing must not fabricate evidence or distort the essential scholarly meaning of the research. Where anonymization affects interpretation, authors should explain the limitation without revealing protected information.

10. Archival, Digital and Online Research Materials

Archival and digital research may involve historical documents, recordings, digitized manuscripts, personal correspondence, public social media, private online communities, streaming platforms, discussion forums, and other electronic sources.

Authors must distinguish technical accessibility from ethical permission. A public webpage, searchable archive, or freely viewable recording may remain subject to copyright, privacy, consent, contractual restrictions, or cultural expectations.

Authors should consider:

  • Archive Provenance: The origin, rights status, collection history, cataloguing practices, and relevant access conditions of archival materials.
  • Contextual Privacy: Whether individuals reasonably expected an online communication or performance to remain within a limited audience.
  • Private Platforms: Whether a closed group, restricted discussion, or invitation-only community requires permission for research participation or publication.
  • Identifiability: Whether direct quotations, usernames, timestamps, screenshots, or other information enable readers to locate or identify individuals.
  • Reproduction Rights: Whether downloading, embedding, publishing, translating, or reproducing material is authorized.
  • Ethical Alternatives: Whether paraphrasing, anonymization, limited quotation, aggregate reporting, or description can support the research while reducing risk.
  • Preservation and Access: Whether materials may be deposited in open repositories or must remain subject to restricted access.

Public online observation does not always require individual consent. The appropriate approach depends on relevant legal and institutional requirements, the setting, participants' reasonable expectations, the sensitivity of the information, and the potential consequences of publication.

Researchers should avoid treating publicly searchable personal statements as unrestricted research resources when disclosure or recontextualization could create significant and foreseeable harm.

For research involving social-media performances, online concerts, livestreams, private group discussions, or comment threads, authors should consider whether direct quotation or screenshots could enable reverse searching of an otherwise pseudonymous participant. The conditions of the platform, the expectations of the participants, and the permanence of a journal publication are relevant to a proportionate ethical assessment.

11. Translation, Transcription and Cultural Representation

Translation and transcription are interpretive processes. They may affect the representation of musical practices, participants' voices, cultural identities, emotional expression, oral traditions, and historical sources.

Authors should document material decisions concerning:

  • The identity or role of the translator, transcriber, interpreter, or relevant language collaborator.
  • The source language, dialect, script, performance context, or relevant musical notation system.
  • Significant differences between the source material and the translated or edited version.
  • The handling of culturally specific terminology, song lyrics, poetic forms, metaphors, and performance-related expressions.
  • Whether the translation or transcript was checked by the participant, a collaborator, or another appropriately qualified person.
  • Whether musical notation or transcription conventions substantially simplify or reinterpret the original performance.

An edited interview or translated passage must not be presented as a verbatim transcript or literal translation when substantive changes have occurred.

Researchers should preserve meaningful linguistic and musical distinctions where possible and explain important limitations arising from translation, transcription, or editorial normalization.

Automated transcription or translation may be used subject to the journal's AI Use Policy. Authors remain responsible for verifying the accuracy of the resulting text and ensuring that restricted materials have not been disclosed to unauthorized services.

12. Data Protection, Storage and AI-Assisted Processing

Research materials involving participants, performers, confidential communications, or culturally sensitive information must be stored and processed with safeguards appropriate to the sensitivity and foreseeable risks of the material.

Relevant safeguards may include:

  • Limiting collection to information reasonably necessary for the research.
  • Controlling access to identifiable or restricted research files.
  • Using suitable secure storage, encrypted transfer, and appropriate backup measures where warranted.
  • Keeping identifying information separate from pseudonymized research records where practical.
  • Following relevant data-retention, deletion, archival, and access agreements.
  • Avoiding unnecessary transfer of sensitive material to external platforms.
  • Reviewing third-party services before processing restricted or identifiable research data.

AI-Assisted Transcription, Translation and Analysis

AI-assisted systems may be used for transcription, translation, sound classification, archival analysis, coding, or other research activities only where the proposed processing complies with relevant consent, confidentiality, legal, institutional, and rights requirements.

Authors must not upload confidential interviews, unpublished recordings, participant identities, restricted community materials, or protected archival files to an unauthorized AI service.

Researchers should examine the service's data retention, access controls, model-training practices, contractual protections, and other relevant technical conditions before using it for sensitive materials.

Machine-generated transcriptions, speaker labels, translations, or interpretations must be independently checked. Synthetic or altered recordings must not be presented as authentic fieldwork or historical evidence.

For recordings, a transcript should be assessed not only for word accuracy but also for speaker attribution, pauses, culturally significant expressions, and the limits of automated speech recognition. Where editing or translation changes the intended meaning, the published material should identify the intervention. AI-generated reconstructions must be labeled as reconstructions rather than passed off as an authentic recording of a past event.

Material AI assistance must be disclosed in accordance with the AI Use Policy.

13. Ethics Approval and Institutional Review

Authors must obtain approval from an appropriate ethics committee, institutional review board, or other competent body before commencing research whenever such approval is required by applicable law, institutional regulations, funding conditions, research-site requirements, or the relevant research framework.

The journal does not require every historical, documentary, artistic, archival, or observational contribution to possess a formal institutional ethics approval number. The need for such review depends on the nature of the activity and applicable requirements.

Authors may be asked to provide:

  • The name of the responsible ethics body or institution.
  • The approval or reference number and approval date, where available and appropriate.
  • Confirmation that the approved procedures covered the relevant research activities.
  • An applicable exemption or determination that formal review was not required.
  • A reasoned explanation of the ethical arrangements where no formal review mechanism applied.

Where prior approval was required, retrospective statements made during journal submission cannot replace approval that should have been obtained before the research began. Authors should not describe a personal assessment of low risk as an institutional ethics exemption unless the applicable rules permit that determination; where appropriate, they should identify the competent body or rule supporting the exemption.

The absence of a formal institutional review process does not eliminate responsibilities concerning informed consent, privacy, participant protection, source integrity, cultural responsibility, or copyright.

Research conducted across institutions or countries may be subject to more than one ethics, privacy, research-site, or community approval arrangement. Authors should explain material differences in the applicable requirements and should not assume that approval by one institution automatically authorizes collection or publication in every location or setting.

14. Open Access, Archiving and Participant Materials

Resonance publishes scholarly content under an open-access framework. Authors must account for the implications of online publication, persistent identifiers, downloading, repository deposits, archiving, and reuse by other parties.

The journal's CC BY 4.0 licensing framework applies to appropriately licensed published content. It does not automatically extend to third-party music, recordings, images, performances, private interviews, restricted archival materials, or other components identified as subject to separate rights.

Permission to publish a participant’s quotation, image, or recording in one article does not necessarily authorize every downstream reuse otherwise allowed under CC BY 4.0. Consent and licensing should be evaluated together before publication. When an identifiable recording, image, transcript, or other third-party component is not authorized for the journal’s standard open license, the publication must accurately identify the applicable rights exclusion, obtain appropriate authorization, or omit the material.

Authors must ensure that published rights notices distinguish appropriately licensed material from third-party or restricted components. Where the proposed licensing arrangement is incompatible with an applicable consent condition or rights restriction, the relevant material may need to be excluded, replaced, restricted, or otherwise handled through an authorized arrangement.

Sensitive research records should not be made openly available merely to satisfy general expectations of data sharing or reproducibility. Authors should explain legitimate access limitations where relevant without disclosing the protected information itself.

An access-restricted archive or secure research repository may sometimes preserve source material responsibly without making it available to every reader. Authors should distinguish the preservation of a confidential source from open publication and should not imply that a journal article’s open-access status overrides a participant’s informed preferences or an archive’s agreed access controls.

Further information is available in the Open Access & Self-Archiving Policy and Archiving & Preservation Policy.

15. Ethics Statements and Submission Documentation

Manuscripts involving human participants, fieldwork, interviews, oral histories, identifiable recordings, or culturally sensitive sources should include an appropriate ethics statement or provide equivalent information during submission.

The statement should accurately identify the ethical arrangements relevant to the research. Authors must not claim that approval or consent was obtained if it was not, or use a generic declaration that does not accurately reflect the actual research procedures.

Example A: Research with Institutional Ethics Approval

This study involved [description of participants and research activities]. Ethical approval was obtained from [name of institution or committee] under reference number [number], dated [date]. Participants provided informed consent in accordance with the approved procedures. Identifiable quotations, recordings, images, and other materials were used only within the relevant consent and publication conditions. Appropriate confidentiality and data-protection measures were implemented.

Example B: Research Without a Formal Ethics Approval Requirement

This study involved [description of fieldwork, interviews, or observations]. Formal institutional ethics review was not required under [applicable institutional or research context]. The author(s) followed appropriate ethical practices concerning voluntary participation, informed consent where applicable, confidentiality, participant protection, and responsible representation. Publication permissions and relevant restrictions were addressed before submission.

Example C: Archival or Documentary Research

This study is based on archival and documentary materials obtained from [source or collection]. The author(s) reviewed the relevant access conditions, attribution requirements, reproduction permissions, and potential privacy or cultural restrictions. No direct participant recruitment was undertaken [if applicable]. Materials were cited and reproduced in accordance with the relevant permissions and ethical requirements.

Additional Documentation

Depending on the contribution, the Editorial Office may request confirmation of:

  • Relevant ethics approval or exemption information.
  • Consent and authorization for identifiable quotations or media.
  • Copyright, performance, translation, or archival reproduction rights.
  • Anonymization and confidentiality arrangements.
  • Relevant community permissions or cultural access protocols.
  • AI-assisted transcription, translation, or processing disclosures.
  • Restrictions on supplementary-file publication or repository deposition.

Authors should omit identifying participant information from anonymized review manuscripts where disclosure is unnecessary. Sensitive documentation should be supplied separately through an appropriately restricted editorial channel when requested.

16. Editorial Assessment and Verification

The Editorial Office may assess compliance with this policy during initial screening, peer review, revision, production, or after publication.

Relevant concerns may include:

  • Missing, disputed, or inadequately documented participant consent.
  • Unclear ethics approval status where formal approval appears necessary.
  • Unauthorized disclosure of identifiable or confidential information.
  • Insufficient rights to reproduce or distribute musical, photographic, audiovisual, or archival materials.
  • Inadequate consideration of cultural or community restrictions.
  • Misleading transcription, translation, representation, or source attribution.
  • Fabricated interviews, manipulated recordings, or misrepresented research evidence.
  • Unauthorized AI processing of restricted or sensitive research materials.

The journal may request clarification, supporting information, revisions, rights confirmation, anonymization, or additional specialist assessment. Complex matters may require advice from qualified ethics specialists, relevant institutions, cultural advisers, or other competent parties.

Reviewers must not independently contact research participants or disclose confidential manuscripts to external parties without authorization. Ethical concerns identified during peer review should be communicated through the handling editor.

An allegation of unethical conduct is not automatically an established finding. The Editorial Office should assess the available evidence, distinguish an honest error from a serious or deliberate breach when supported by the facts, and ordinarily allow affected authors a reasonable opportunity to respond before reaching a final adverse determination. Confidentiality and protective measures may be necessary while the issue is examined.

Serious or unresolved matters may be referred to the appropriate institution, ethics body, or competent authority where additional investigation is required. Editorial decisions concerning the journal's publications remain the responsibility of authorized editors.

17. Non-Compliance and Post-Publication Action

Where ethical concerns are established or remain materially unresolved, the journal may take appropriate action according to their seriousness, the supporting evidence, and their effect on participant protection and publication integrity.

Possible actions include:

  • Clarification: Request an explanation of research procedures, consent, approval, or relevant permissions.
  • Revision: Require correction, anonymization, removal, or replacement of material that cannot appropriately be published.
  • Suspension: Pause editorial consideration while a significant concern is examined.
  • Rejection: Decline publication where serious ethical deficiencies cannot be adequately resolved.
  • Institutional Consultation: Seek appropriate advice or refer serious matters to a relevant institution or competent body.
  • Correction: Amend a published record where a specific error or omission can be remedied without fundamentally undermining the contribution.
  • Expression of Concern: Alert readers to serious unresolved questions where available evidence is incomplete.
  • Retraction: Retract a contribution where serious ethical or integrity problems fundamentally compromise the publication.
  • Exceptional Access Restriction: Restrict or remove particular published materials where necessary to address compelling legal, privacy, safety, or comparable concerns.

Editorial responses should be proportionate. A correctable caption error or incomplete permission statement does not automatically require withdrawal or retraction of an entire article.

Where the affected material is central to the publication's evidence or conclusions, more substantial action may be necessary.

Post-publication actions must follow the journal's Corrections and Retractions Policy, including appropriate notice, record preservation, and procedural fairness.

18. Ethical Concerns, Complaints and Appeals

Authors, research participants, interviewees, performers, cultural communities, rights holders, reviewers, readers, and other relevant parties may report concerns about research ethics, consent, confidentiality, representation, or publication of restricted materials.

Reports should, where possible, identify:

  1. The manuscript or published contribution involved.
  2. The nature of the alleged ethical issue.
  3. Relevant passages, recordings, images, statements, or supporting materials.
  4. Any urgent privacy, confidentiality, cultural, or safety concerns.
  5. Relevant permissions, agreements, or other information supporting the report.

The journal will seek to handle complaints with appropriate confidentiality, sensitivity, evidence-based assessment, and procedural fairness. Absolute anonymity cannot be guaranteed where disclosure is legally required or necessary for an appropriate investigation.

Authors and other materially affected parties may request reconsideration of an editorial decision by presenting relevant factual information, new evidence, or a substantial procedural concern.

Where appropriate, an appeal may be considered by an independent editor or qualified adviser who was not directly involved in the original determination. An appeal does not automatically reverse or suspend a measure necessary to protect participants or the scholarly record.

A complaint involving immediate disclosure of a vulnerable participant’s identity, a restricted ceremonial recording, or another serious privacy or safety risk may require proportionate interim protection before a full review is complete. Such a precaution is not by itself a finding of misconduct. The journal should document and explain its ultimate decision as fully as confidentiality and law permit.

19. Policy Interpretation and Review

The Editorial Office is responsible for applying this policy in conjunction with the journal's Publication Ethics, AI Use Policy, Open Access Policy, and other relevant requirements.

Particular cases may require attention to differences among disciplinary conventions, national legal systems, institutional ethics arrangements, cultural practices, and specific research methods.

This policy may be reviewed periodically in response to developments in research ethics, music and sound scholarship, Indigenous data governance, data protection, copyright, digital archives, AI-assisted research, and audiovisual publishing.

Substantive amendments should be identified by their actual approval or effective dates. Policy revisions should not be represented as having been in force before formal adoption.

Editorial Statement: Resonance: Journal of Global Music Studies regards ethical fieldwork, responsible interviewing, respect for cultural knowledge, and the protection of participants as essential components of music and sound scholarship. The journal supports research that is transparent in its methods, accurate in its representation, attentive to relationships of trust, and responsible in its handling of personal, musical, and community materials. Scholarly access and cultural exchange must remain consistent with human dignity, meaningful participation, legitimate rights, and the integrity of the research record.

Authors and reviewers should also consult the journal's Publication Ethics, AI Use Policy, Open Access Policy, and Corrections and Retractions Policy.

Additional non-binding guidance may be found in the Oral History Association's Best Practices and the CARE Principles for Indigenous Data Governance.

Contact: Questions about this policy or concerns regarding research participants, interviews, recordings, cultural materials, or consent may be directed to the Resonance Editorial Office: [email protected].

Original effective date: May 28, 2026. Last updated: October 28, 2026.