Resonance: Journal of Global Music Studies maintains editorial, linguistic, citation, and presentation standards that support scholarly accuracy, accessibility, and consistency across its publications. This Style Guide provides a common framework for research manuscripts while accommodating the distinctive requirements of musical scores, interviews, translations, documentary materials, creative writing, audiovisual submissions, and practice-based scholarship.

Authors must follow the requirements appropriate to their chosen publication section. Where a section has distinct presentation requirements, those instructions take precedence over the general provisions below. The Submission Guidelines address the broader submission process and required materials.

1. Language & Academic Style

English is the primary language of publication. The journal welcomes manuscripts in the following five languages:

  • English
  • Chinese
  • German
  • Italian
  • Russian

All submissions must include an accurate English title. An English abstract is required in accordance with the selected section's instructions. Authors should use clear, appropriately structured language suited to the scholarly, critical, documentary, or artistic purpose of the contribution.

General language standards include:

  • Clarity: Express arguments and interpretations precisely. Define specialized terminology when its meaning is not likely to be familiar to the intended readership.
  • Consistency: Apply consistent spelling, capitalization, punctuation, terminology, transliteration, and reference conventions throughout the manuscript.
  • Academic Register: Use an appropriate scholarly style without unnecessary jargon, inflated claims, repetitive expressions, or excessive theoretical exposition.
  • Disciplinary Precision: Explain musical, historical, ethnographic, analytical, computational, and other technical concepts with sufficient accuracy for meaningful evaluation.
  • Non-English Terminology: Unfamiliar foreign-language terms may be italicized on first use where appropriate. Established loanwords, proper names, and expressions governed by disciplinary conventions should follow the relevant usage.
  • Names and Transliteration: Use a consistent, recognized system for rendering names, places, instruments, musical concepts, and other terms originally written in non-Latin scripts.
  • Original Scripts: Include original-language or original-script forms where necessary for accurate identification, interpretation, or source verification.
  • Translation Attribution: Identify translators and distinguish published translations from those prepared by the author.
  • Inclusive Scholarly Communication: Describe people, cultures, traditions, and communities accurately and respectfully, avoiding unsupported generalizations or stereotypes.

First-person writing is acceptable where appropriate to the research method, reflective genre, or creative purpose. Authors should nevertheless distinguish personal experience from independently established evidence and avoid presenting limited observations as broadly representative without adequate support.

2. Manuscript File Format & Page Layout

Standard scholarly manuscripts should be submitted in an editable format suitable for editorial assessment, copyediting, and publication production.

  • Primary File Format: Microsoft Word (.docx) is required for standard text-based manuscripts.
  • Standard Font: Times New Roman for English and other Latin-script manuscript text.
  • Non-Latin Scripts: Authors may use appropriate Unicode-compatible fonts for Chinese and other writing systems where Times New Roman is unsuitable.
  • Font Size: 12 pt for standard prose manuscripts. Specialist notation, footnotes, tables, and other formats may require appropriately adjusted typography.
  • Line Spacing: Double spacing for standard prose manuscripts. Poetry, musical scores, transcripts, and other specialized materials may follow section-specific formatting.
  • Margins: Use standard page margins that provide sufficient space for editorial annotation and review.
  • Page Numbering: Number manuscript pages consecutively.
  • Paragraphs: Apply consistent paragraph breaks and spacing. Avoid excessive manual line breaks or unnecessary empty paragraphs.
  • Headings: Use a logical hierarchy of section headings and subheadings without excessive levels or decorative formatting.
  • Document Structure: Use editable text and standard document formatting rather than embedding the full manuscript as images or scanned pages.
  • Specialized Content: Musical notation, poetry, multimedia, diagrams, and other specialized materials may follow appropriate alternative layouts.

Authors are encouraged to use the journal's Article Templates where a suitable template is available.

3. Manuscript Organization & Headings

Manuscripts should be organized so that readers can readily identify the central question, purpose, argument, evidence, and contribution.

For standard research articles, the structure should be appropriate to the disciplinary method and the questions investigated. Relevant components may include an introduction, literature discussion, conceptual or theoretical framework, sources and methods, analysis, discussion, and conclusion.

The journal does not impose a universal Introduction–Methods–Results–Discussion structure. Historical musicology, philosophical inquiry, musical analysis, ethnographic research, computational studies, and practice-based research may require different forms of scholarly organization.

Creative, documentary, critical, and reflective contributions should adopt structures appropriate to their genre. Authors may use descriptive headings, thematic divisions, musical examples, annotations, or alternative formats where these improve the presentation.

Headings should accurately identify the content that follows. Numbered headings may be used consistently where suitable, but excessive subdivision should be avoided in short-form essays and creative contributions.

4. Citations & References

Resonance follows The Chicago Manual of Style, 18th edition (2024). Authors may use either the Notes and Bibliography system or the Author-Date system, selecting the one best suited to the manuscript's disciplinary context and applying it consistently throughout. The two systems should not be mixed within a single manuscript unless a distinctive source or presentation format requires clarification.

Notes and Bibliography

This system uses consecutively numbered footnotes or endnotes to identify cited sources. Notes should supply the details necessary to identify the source and the relevant passage, with shortened forms for subsequent citations where appropriate. The journal requires a bibliography of works cited for standard scholarly manuscripts using this system. Citations should be adapted to the source type, including books, articles, archival documents, musical scores, recordings, and other research materials.

Author-Date

This system uses concise parenthetical author–date references in the text, with page numbers or other appropriate locators for quotations and specific passages. Every cited source must correspond to a complete entry in the reference list, and identifying information must be consistent across the text and references. For example, (Author 2020, 45) illustrates the form of a parenthetical citation, not an actual bibliographic source.

Reference Accuracy and Verification

  • Verifiable sources: Cite identifiable, authentic works and represent their content accurately; ensure that quotations and paraphrases are traceable to the materials consulted.
  • Essential bibliographic information: Include the authors or creators, titles, dates, publication or collection information, and other details required to identify the exact edition, version, or item examined.
  • Persistent access: Provide a DOI, stable URL, repository identifier, collection number, or other durable locator when one is available and relevant.
  • Language and translation: Preserve sufficient original-language information to identify non-English works, and credit translators and the edition or translation consulted.
  • Independent checking: Verify records supplied by reference managers, search services, or AI-assisted tools against credible source information. Fabricated references, invented quotations, and incorrect identifiers must not appear in the submitted manuscript.

Chicago's 18th edition updates several bibliographic conventions; authors should consult the official Chicago-Style Citation Quick Guide for current examples rather than reusing older templates. Music-specific source identification is addressed in the next section.

5. Music-Specific Source Citation

Music and sound scholarship frequently draws upon sources whose intellectual or artistic identity cannot be adequately established through conventional book and journal citations alone.

Depending on the material, authors should supply:

  • Musical Compositions: Composer, title, composition or publication date where known, edition, publisher, catalog or opus number, and relevant movement or measure information.
  • Musical Scores: Composer or creator, title, editor or arranger, edition, publication information, and cited measures, pages, or sections.
  • Sound Recordings: Title, principal creators or performers, recording or release date where known, label or producer, catalog information, and relevant track or timing details.
  • Live Performances: Relevant performers, location, date, event or program title, and the source of any recorded or documentary evidence.
  • Film and Audiovisual Works: Title, relevant creators, production details, release date, and a timestamp or scene reference where appropriate.
  • Field Recordings: Recording date, location where disclosure is permissible, relevant performers or participants, collection information, and access conditions.
  • Archival Sources: Collection title, repository, reference or catalog identifier, document date, and relevant restrictions.
  • Digital Music Sources: Relevant platform or publisher, recording or publication identity, access information, and a stable URL or identifier where available.
  • Interviews and Oral Histories: Participant identification where authorized, interview date, interviewer or collection information, and the location or status of the source material.

For recordings and audiovisual sources, timestamps should be sufficiently precise to support the passage being analyzed. When a source exists in several editions, performances, remasters, or platform versions, authors should identify the version actually examined.

Confidential, restricted, or culturally sensitive sources must be cited without disclosing protected information unnecessarily.

6. Quotations, Translation & Transcription

Quotations, translations, and transcriptions must preserve the relevant meaning of the original materials and be presented in a manner that allows appropriate scholarly evaluation.

  • Direct Quotations: Use quotation marks or block quotation formatting as appropriate, maintaining fidelity to the source.
  • Omissions and Alterations: Indicate meaningful omissions, additions, corrections, or editorial changes in accordance with the selected citation style.
  • Translations: Identify the translator and distinguish author-produced translations from published translations.
  • Original-Language Material: Retain relevant original-language expressions where their form, terminology, or cultural significance is important to the argument.
  • Interview Transcripts: Identify relevant transcription practices, speaker conventions, editing decisions, and translation arrangements.
  • Musical Transcriptions: Explain important notation conventions, analytical reductions, editorial interventions, or uncertainties.
  • Automated Processing: AI-assisted transcription or translation must be verified against the source materials and disclosed where required.

An edited interview passage should not be described as verbatim when substantive editing has occurred. Similarly, reconstructed or normalized musical notation should not be presented as an unmodified original source.

Where translation choices or transcription conventions materially affect interpretation, authors should explain the relevant decisions.

7. Musical Examples, Scores & Notation

Musical examples should be accurate, legible, appropriately sourced, and directly relevant to the manuscript's argument or artistic presentation.

Authors should observe the following requirements:

  • Numbering: Number musical examples consecutively and refer to them consistently in the text.
  • Captions: Provide descriptive captions identifying the relevant work, excerpt, performer, transcription, source, or analytical purpose.
  • Legibility: Supply high-resolution notation suitable for editorial evaluation and publication.
  • File Formats: Use appropriate image or PDF formats for individual examples and follow relevant section instructions for complete scores.
  • Consistency: Apply consistent notation conventions, measure numbering, instrument names, terminology, and analytical symbols.
  • Editorial Intervention: Identify material changes, reconstructions, reductions, transpositions, or adaptations made to an original source.
  • Permissions: Obtain any necessary rights to reproduce musical notation or other protected material.
  • Accessibility: Where feasible, explain the musical features discussed so that the argument does not depend exclusively on a visual example.

The Score Page: Submit the musical score as a PDF together with the commentary or notes required by the section. Section-specific length requirements are summarized in Section 12 below.

8. Figures, Tables & Illustrations

Figures, tables, illustrations, maps, screenshots, photographs, and diagrams should support the interpretation or presentation of the manuscript rather than serve merely decorative purposes.

  • Separate Numbering: Number tables, figures, and musical examples in their respective sequences.
  • Text References: Refer to every substantive figure or table in the manuscript and explain its relevance.
  • Captions and Notes: Provide concise, informative captions, appropriate legends, necessary explanatory notes, and relevant source information.
  • Readability: Ensure that labels, symbols, text, axes, and legends remain legible at normal publication sizes.
  • Data Consistency: Values shown in tables and figures must correspond accurately to the underlying analysis and accompanying narrative.
  • Original and Adapted Materials: Identify materials adapted from other publications and obtain necessary permissions where applicable.
  • Accessible Presentation: Avoid relying on color alone to communicate essential distinctions. Provide meaningful descriptions where practicable.

The Editorial Office may request higher-quality source images, editable tables, revised captions, separate production files, or clarification of reproduction rights where necessary.

9. Audio, Video & Multimedia Materials

The journal supports the use of recordings, audiovisual documentation, and other media where these contribute meaningfully to the scholarly or artistic value of a submission.

Authors should ensure that multimedia materials are:

  • Clearly Identified: Supply a descriptive file title, source details, date where relevant, and appropriate creator or performer attribution.
  • Relevant: Include media that support a research question, musical example, documentary claim, artistic contribution, or interpretation.
  • Referenced in the Manuscript: Identify relevant audio tracks, video segments, or supplementary files through consistent labels and appropriate timestamps.
  • Accessible: Use reasonably accessible formats and provide explanatory descriptions, captions, or transcripts where practicable.
  • Technically Suitable: Provide media of sufficient quality for the relevant scholarly or artistic evaluation.
  • Rights-Compliant: Obtain the necessary recording, performance, audiovisual, and other permissions for the intended publication and reuse.
  • Authentically Represented: Disclose material editing, restoration, reconstruction, synthetic generation, or transformation where such changes affect interpretation or evidentiary status.
  • Appropriately Protected: Do not publicly deposit identifiable or restricted recordings where consent, confidentiality, cultural protocols, or rights conditions prohibit such dissemination.

External audio or video links may supplement the publication, but their availability can change. Authors should not assume that a publicly accessible platform link constitutes permanent preservation of the underlying material.

Where a media file is essential to the manuscript's analysis and is not publicly available, the Editorial Office may request an appropriately authorized copy or sufficient documentation for confidential evaluation.

10. Required Metadata & Author Information

Authors must provide accurate bibliographic and author metadata through the journal's submission system. The required fields depend on the contribution category and applicable section policy.

Required English metadata and abstract guidance
Item or Section Requirement
English Title Required for every submission.
Research Articles English abstract of up to 300 words.
Other Standard Scholarly Submissions English abstract of up to 300 words unless the selected section specifies otherwise.
Forum: Author Replies and Scholarly Exchange English abstract of up to 150 words.
Everyday Resonances English abstract of 150–200 words, as required by the section's specific instructions.
Resonant Verses: Poetry and Music English title and abstract required. Follow the section's translation and contextual requirements.
Other Creative or Special Sections Follow the applicable section-specific abstract, commentary, translation, and documentation rules.
Keywords Four to six English keywords for standard scholarly submissions, unless otherwise specified.
Author Biography A 100–150-word biographical note written in the third person.
Author Details Complete and accurate names, affiliations, email addresses, and ORCID identifiers where available.

Abstract Content: Research abstracts should summarize the central research question or problem, objective, approach, principal findings or argument, and scholarly contribution.

Abstracts for other scholarly or creative sections should accurately describe the purpose, form, focus, and principal contribution of the work in a manner appropriate to its genre.

Metadata Consistency: Titles, abstracts, keywords, names, affiliations, and other details entered in the online submission system must correspond accurately to the manuscript and final accepted publication.

Where identifying author information is not suitable for double-blind review, it must be provided separately from the anonymized manuscript.

11. Manuscript Anonymization

Standard original research manuscripts must be prepared for double-blind peer review. Authors should remove identifying information from the manuscript supplied to reviewers while preserving accurate scholarly citations.

Authors should:

  1. Remove author names, affiliations, email addresses, ORCID identifiers, biographies, and direct identifying statements from the review manuscript.
  2. Place author details, acknowledgments, funding information, and identifying declarations in separate submission materials where appropriate.
  3. Review file names, document properties, tracked changes, comments, and other metadata for identifying information.
  4. Cite the authors' relevant previous publications accurately without unnecessary self-identifying descriptions.
  5. Examine supplementary scores, figures, recordings, transcripts, and other files for unintended identifying information where anonymization is required.
  6. Supply complete and accurate author information through the online submission system.

Some projects may be identifiable because of public performances, preprints, distinctive archives, highly specialized research, or earlier public dissemination. Authors should nevertheless take reasonable steps to preserve anonymity where practicable.

Non-research contributions may follow alternative identification requirements appropriate to their creative, critical, or documentary nature.

12. Section-Specific Presentation Requirements

The journal publishes diverse forms of research and creative contribution. General presentation rules should therefore be applied in conjunction with the intended section's specific requirements.

  • Research Articles: Normally 6,000–10,000 words; use a structure and methodological explanation appropriate to the research. Abstracts and keywords follow Section 10.
  • Timeless Resonance: East–West Music Review: Present a coherent critical or interpretive argument with appropriate music-related evidence, cultural context, and scholarly references.
  • Sound Archives: Fieldwork and Memory: Provide relevant source provenance, fieldwork context, archival documentation, recording details, and ethical or access restrictions.
  • Voices Now: Contemporary Soundscapes: Identify relevant sonic practices, media sources, contemporary settings, and analytical or documentary methods.
  • The Score Page: Provide the musical score in PDF format and accompanying commentary or notes, normally 1,000–3,000 words.
  • Dialogues & Interviews: Identify relevant participants, interviewing arrangements, recording or transcription practices, and publication consent.
  • Performance Notes: Present sufficient musical and contextual information for readers to understand the performance, interpretation, or artistic reflection.
  • Book & Media Reviews: Identify the reviewed work accurately and provide substantive critical evaluation rather than promotional description.
  • Translations & Source Texts: Provide the required English translation, source information, introductory essay or critical commentary, and appropriate permissions.
  • Forum: Author Replies and Scholarly Exchange: Present a focused, constructive scholarly response supported by appropriate sources.
  • Resonant Verses: Poetry and Music: Preserve literary and musical form; non-English works require an English translation under the section instructions.
  • Everyday Resonances: Prepare a focused, accessible, analytically grounded essay, normally 2,500–4,000 words.

13. Copyright, Permissions & Publication Ethics

Authors are responsible for ensuring that the materials submitted for publication satisfy the journal's ethical and legal requirements.

Relevant responsibilities include:

  • Originality: Ensure that the work is appropriately original and accurately acknowledges relevant sources and earlier dissemination.
  • Copyright: Identify third-party content and obtain permissions where necessary for the intended publication and reuse.
  • Performer and Recording Rights: Address applicable rights in compositions, lyrics, scores, performances, sound recordings, and audiovisual works.
  • Human Participants: Meet applicable consent, confidentiality, privacy, and institutional ethics requirements.
  • Cultural Responsibilities: Respect legitimate community restrictions, traditional knowledge, sacred materials, and culturally sensitive research sources.
  • AI Disclosure: Identify substantive AI assistance in manuscript preparation, translation, data processing, analysis, musical production, or other relevant activities.
  • Research Integrity: Avoid fabricated sources, falsified recordings, manipulated evidence, misleading translations, and other forms of academic misconduct.
  • Licensing: Clearly identify third-party materials that are not covered by the article's applicable open-access license.

Permission to access or cite material does not automatically authorize its reproduction, adaptation, translation, redistribution, or publication under an open-access license.

Where the proposed publication involves identifiable participants or sensitive materials, the Editorial Office may request additional clarification or supporting documentation before acceptance or publication.

Authors should consult the Publication Ethics, Plagiarism Policy, AI Use Policy, Fieldwork & Interview Ethics Policy, and Open Access Policy.

14. Supplementary Files & Production Preparation

Supplementary materials should be organized in a manner that facilitates editorial evaluation, publication production, reader access, and appropriate preservation.

Authors should:

  • Label supplementary files clearly and refer to them consistently in the manuscript.
  • Supply relevant file descriptions, captions, credits, source information, and access conditions.
  • Ensure that manuscript references correspond accurately to the submitted supplementary files.
  • Avoid unnecessary duplicates, obsolete versions, corrupted files, or unrelated supporting materials.
  • Retain appropriate original files and permissions documentation for editorial clarification where necessary.
  • Provide suitable replacement or production-quality files when requested during revision or typesetting.
  • Identify any components that must remain confidential or restricted from public dissemination.

The Editorial Office may request clearer notation, higher-resolution figures, revised metadata, properly labeled recordings, an accessible alternative file, or other technical corrections when needed for publication quality.

Changes made during copyediting and typesetting should preserve the scholarly, artistic, and documentary integrity of the accepted contribution.

Authors should carefully review proofs supplied during production, checking titles, names, affiliations, quotations, references, figures, tables, musical notation, captions, media links, and other relevant content.

15. Final Submission Checklist

Before submitting a manuscript, authors should confirm that:

  1. The contribution fits the journal and its intended section, and its length, language, layout, and file format follow the applicable requirements.
  2. The English title and the required abstract, keywords, author information, and submission metadata are complete and consistent with the manuscript.
  3. The selected Chicago 18th-edition citation system has been applied consistently, and all references, quotations, translations, and source identifiers have been verified.
  4. Musical examples, scores, figures, tables, recordings, and supplementary files are legible, accurately identified, numbered where appropriate, and cited in the text.
  5. Research manuscripts are anonymized for double-blind peer review, with identifying declarations supplied separately as instructed.
  6. Permissions, participant consent, cultural restrictions, privacy safeguards, and relevant research-ethics documentation have been addressed.
  7. Funding, competing interests, earlier dissemination, and substantive AI assistance have been disclosed as required, and all authors have approved the submission.
  8. Submitted and supporting files are complete, usable, and appropriate for editorial assessment.

16. Editorial Formatting Review & Compliance

The Editorial Office may examine the manuscript's compliance with these guidelines during initial screening, revision, acceptance, or production.

Minor and readily correctable formatting issues may be returned to authors for adjustment. More substantial problems involving incomplete files, inaccurate references, unreadable musical notation, missing documentation, or unsuitable publication format may require additional revision before evaluation or publication can proceed.

Manuscript formatting compliance does not guarantee acceptance. Editorial and review decisions remain dependent on the contribution's scholarly or artistic quality, relevance, integrity, and applicable assessment procedures.

The journal may permit reasonable exceptions or alternative presentation arrangements where justified by the linguistic, musical, historical, documentary, or creative characteristics of the work.

For additional information about assessment procedures, see the Peer Review Process. Manuscript templates and the broader submission requirements are linked above.

Editorial Inquiries: [email protected].