Resonance: Journal of Global Music Studies asks reviewers to provide independent, informed, and constructive assessments that help editors reach defensible publication decisions and help authors understand the strengths and limitations of their work. This guide follows the reviewer's practical workflow—from an invitation through manuscript evaluation, report preparation, recommendation, and final submission—while the Review Criteria defines the substantive standards of evaluation.

Reviewers should first confirm their expertise, availability, and independence; then assess the complete materials, prepare a clear report, and submit the recommendation through the authorized journal review workflow. Comments for authors and confidential comments for the editor serve different purposes and must be placed in the appropriate fields or files.

Original research manuscripts proceeding to external review are assessed under the journal's double-blind procedure by at least two independent qualified reviewers. Other forms of music and sound scholarship—including translations, scores, interviews, and creative or documentary work—may receive editorial or specialist assessment. Reviewers should follow the specific assignment they have accepted rather than assume every content type requires the same research-article standards.

1. Before Accepting a Review Invitation

Before accepting, examine the invitation and any permitted summary of the manuscript. Decide whether you have sufficient subject and methodological expertise, can meet the proposed deadline, and can act independently. Accepting an invitation represents a commitment to complete the specified assessment or to notify the editor promptly if circumstances change.

  • Relevant Expertise: Accept invitations only when sufficiently familiar with the manuscript's subject, methods, materials, or scholarly field. Inform the editor if substantial parts of the work fall outside your expertise.
  • Availability: Confirm that the review can reasonably be completed within the proposed deadline. Respond promptly if an invitation must be declined or additional time is required.
  • Conflicts of Interest: Disclose relevant personal, professional, institutional, financial, supervisory, collaborative, or other relationships that could influence or appear to influence the evaluation.
  • Scholarly Independence: Decline assignments where personal rivalry, direct competition, close collaboration, financial interests, or other circumstances prevent an impartial review.
  • Review Scope: Read the invitation carefully and confirm whether the assignment involves original research peer review, a specialist technical assessment, a translation check, or another form of editorial evaluation.
  • Confidentiality: Treat the invitation and any information about the manuscript as confidential, including when declining the assignment.

Disclose a potential conflict before accepting or beginning the review and follow the handling editor's instructions. A conflict can arise from recent collaboration, supervisory relationships, personal ties, financial interests, direct academic competition, or involvement in the work. Where a concern emerges after acceptance, suspend affected review activity and inform the editor.

Review assignments are personal and must not be delegated to students, colleagues, assistants, or external services without the editor's prior authorization. If a qualified co-reviewer is authorized, disclose their identity and contribution to the Editorial Office; both reviewers remain subject to the journal's confidentiality and conflict-of-interest requirements.

2. Confidentiality & Responsible Handling of Manuscripts

Unpublished submissions and associated review communications are confidential materials supplied solely for authorized editorial assessment. A reviewer must not treat access to a manuscript as permission to circulate it, incorporate its unpublished content into their own work, or investigate its authorship.

  • Do Not Disclose: Do not distribute, publish, forward, or discuss the manuscript or review correspondence outside the authorized editorial process.
  • Do Not Misuse: Do not use unpublished arguments, findings, methodologies, musical examples, scores, recordings, translations, or other materials for personal or professional advantage.
  • Protect Research Materials: Handle participant data, fieldwork recordings, archival materials, restricted cultural knowledge, and other sensitive evidence according to applicable confidentiality and ethical restrictions.
  • Maintain Reviewer Anonymity: Do not reveal your identity to the author during double-blind review or contact the author directly without editorial permission.
  • Secure Storage: Keep downloaded manuscript files and review materials reasonably secure and restrict access to authorized persons.
  • After Review: Retain or securely dispose of downloaded files according to the journal's instructions and any applicable institutional or legal requirements. Confidentiality continues after a review assignment ends.

These obligations apply even if the authors previously released a preprint, performed the work publicly, or discussed related research at a conference. Reviewers should not search for an author's identity as part of double-blind review. Downloaded files and notes should be managed securely and disposed of or retained only as instructed by the journal and applicable institutional obligations.

3. Reading and Understanding the Manuscript

Read the complete manuscript and review-accessible supplements within the scope of the assignment before reaching a recommendation. A first reading should establish what the author seeks to show; a second should test the relationship between evidence, reasoning, methods, and conclusions. Do not infer problems from an abstract or introduction alone.

First Reading: Understand the Contribution

  • Identify the central question, purpose, argument, interpretation, or scholarly contribution.
  • Determine the manuscript's disciplinary and cultural context.
  • Identify the research approach, principal sources, musical evidence, or creative and documentary methods.
  • Note important strengths, distinctive insights, and potentially significant limitations.
  • Consider whether the manuscript is appropriate for the journal and the intended publication category.

Second Reading: Evaluate the Evidence

  • Examine the coherence of the argument and whether important claims are adequately supported.
  • Assess the appropriateness and transparency of the research methods or interpretive approach.
  • Evaluate the use of relevant scholarship, historical sources, fieldwork evidence, or musical materials.
  • Inspect figures, tables, musical examples, recordings, translations, and supplementary documents where necessary for the assigned evaluation.
  • Identify material uncertainties, alternative explanations, insufficient documentation, or unsupported conclusions.
  • Record precise page, section, paragraph, table, or musical example references for important comments.

If a score, recording, translation, dataset, appendix, or other material essential to the evaluation is missing, inaccessible, or outside your competence, notify the handling editor. Identify precisely what cannot be assessed instead of making assumptions or contacting the author directly.

4. Applying the Evaluation Criteria

Use the journal's Review Criteria as the substantive reference. For practical report preparation, check the relevant dimensions below and identify the passages, musical examples, or documents supporting each important conclusion:

  • Originality and Contribution: The significance and credibility of the contribution.
  • Relevance: Alignment with the journal's scholarly scope and the questions addressed.
  • Theoretical and Methodological Rigor: Appropriateness of conceptual approaches, methods, and analytical procedures.
  • Structure and Clarity: Coherence of presentation, argumentation, and academic communication.
  • Engagement with Scholarship: Accuracy and relevance of the manuscript's relationship to existing research.
  • Sources and Media: Quality of evidence, source documentation, musical examples, recordings, and relevant supplementary materials.
  • Ethical Integrity: Research honesty, attribution, consent, permissions, confidentiality, and required disclosures.

Discipline-Specific Judgment

The journal accepts historical, ethnomusicological, theoretical, philosophical, qualitative, quantitative, computational, interpretive, and practice-based work. Judge the credibility and transparency of the approach used by the author in relation to the manuscript's research question rather than demanding another disciplinary method.

Statistical testing, hypotheses, fieldwork, cross-cultural comparison, and formal models are not universal requirements. A documented study of one repertoire, cultural practice, historical source, or artistic process can be significant when its evidence and reasoning justify the claims made.

Non-Research and Specialist Contributions

For specialist assignments involving translations, musical scores, performance records, interviews, archival sources, or creative work, assess the specified elements—such as language accuracy, provenance, musical notation, documentary reliability, artistic context, consent, or rights—within your competence. State limitations to the editor rather than treating a targeted specialist assessment as the equivalent of complete original-research peer review.

5. Structuring the Review Report

A useful report connects its recommendation to reasons that the editor can evaluate and the author can address. Organize comments by importance and, where possible, cite page numbers, section headings, tables, musical examples, line numbers, or recording timestamps. Clearly distinguish corrections needed for reliability from optional suggestions.

A. Summary of the Manuscript

In your own words, identify the central question or purpose, disciplinary context, approach, main evidence, and claimed contribution. Acknowledge the manuscript's main strengths before discussing concerns; simply repeating the abstract does not demonstrate an adequate assessment.

B. Major Comments

Identify issues that materially affect originality, scholarly validity, source reliability, interpretation, or suitability for publication. For each major issue, explain what the problem is, why it matters, where it appears, and what a satisfactory revision would need to address. Examples include:

  • Research questions or central contributions that are not adequately defined or justified
  • Serious weaknesses in methods, source selection, evidence, reasoning, or historical interpretation
  • Important omissions in relevant literature, cultural context, or documentary verification
  • Findings or conclusions that extend beyond the evidence, including misleading musical or recording claims
  • Missing essential sources or inaccessible supporting materials preventing proper assessment

Request additional analyses, comparisons, fieldwork, or technical work only when their relevance to the manuscript's aims is clearly justified. Report serious ethical concerns separately to the handling editor, without prematurely presenting suspicions as findings of misconduct.

C. Minor Comments

List local corrections that improve clarity or presentation without requiring substantive reconsideration of the core contribution. Typical examples include ambiguous wording, minor bibliographic inaccuracies, inconsistent terminology, mislabeled musical examples, or incomplete figure captions. Identify their locations where practicable; a reviewer is not expected to rewrite the manuscript or perform full copyediting.

D. Final Recommendation

Choose a recommendation that follows from the report's reasoning and indicates the seriousness of remaining concerns. If the online workflow provides a separate field for comments intended only for the editor, use it to disclose conflicts, limits of expertise, confidential integrity concerns, or reasons for additional specialist input; do not place such matters in author-facing materials when doing so could compromise a fair assessment.

6. Selecting a Final Recommendation

Choose the category that best captures your assessment. The journal's four principal recommendation categories are summarized below; where the online review form uses different wording, select the closest available option and explain any important distinction in the written report.

Reviewer recommendation categories
Recommendation When to Select It
Accept The manuscript meets the applicable publication standards and requires no substantive revision. Routine copyediting or production corrections may remain.
Minor Revisions The central contribution is sufficiently sound, but limited clarification, reference corrections, explanation, or presentation improvements are necessary.
Major Revisions The manuscript has potential but requires substantial changes to the argument, evidence, methods, interpretation, context, or organization before a new editorial decision can be made.
Reject Fundamental deficiencies, insufficient contribution, serious reliability problems, or a substantial scope mismatch make publication unsuitable within the current submission.

Consistency of recommendation: Major Revisions requires substantive improvements that the report identifies and explains. Reject should be supported by decisive reasons why the current manuscript is unsuitable. Do not recommend Accept while listing unresolved fundamental defects. Suggestions for minor presentation changes should not be framed as grounds for rejection.

Your recommendation is advisory, not an editorial decision. The handling editor evaluates the reports and the manuscript's scholarly and ethical suitability. Authors invited to revise may undergo further assessment, and an invitation to revise does not guarantee acceptance.

7. Tone, Language & Constructive Criticism

Professional criticism may be direct and rigorous, including when a manuscript has serious defects. Reviewers should critique arguments, sources, methods, and evidence rather than the author's identity, character, institutional prestige, or linguistic background.

  • Be Specific: Explain the precise problem and identify where it occurs in the manuscript.
  • Be Constructive: Recommend realistic changes that would improve the reliability, clarity, or significance of the work.
  • Acknowledge Strengths: Identify valuable contributions alongside significant limitations.
  • Distinguish Requirements from Preferences: Make clear which revisions are essential to publication quality and which are optional suggestions.
  • Respect Methodological Diversity: Do not demand a different theory, method, geographic comparison, or research design without demonstrating its relevance to the manuscript's aims.
  • Avoid Personal Attacks: Do not use discriminatory, insulting, humiliating, or dismissive language.
  • Maintain Linguistic Fairness: Focus on communication and scholarly clarity rather than personal stylistic preferences or assumptions about authors working in different languages.
  • Avoid Coercive Citations: Recommend additional literature only where it makes a substantive contribution to the evaluation.

Disagreement with a theory or interpretation is not itself a scholarly defect. Explain whether the author's claims can reasonably be sustained by the available evidence and an appropriate method. Different but defensible interpretations should be recognized as such.

8. Reviewing Musical, Archival & Audiovisual Materials

In music and sound studies, evaluating the written argument may require examining a specific score, historical edition, sound recording, archival document, translation, musical example, or digital tool. Assess the relationship between the submitted claims and the materials actually available for review.

  • Scores and Musical Examples: Evaluate whether the notation, cited passages, editions, analytical references, and relevant technical descriptions are sufficiently clear and accurate.
  • Recordings: Assess whether sound examples are appropriately identified and whether relevant editing, processing, reconstruction, or recording conditions are explained.
  • Historical Sources: Consider archival provenance, authorship, dating, textual versions, interpretation, and relevant limitations.
  • Fieldwork and Interviews: Evaluate the appropriateness of documentation, research relationships, contextual interpretation, consent, and confidentiality.
  • Translations: Consider terminological consistency, interpretation, source reliability, and significant editorial interventions, within the reviewer's linguistic expertise.
  • Digital Platforms and Computational Tools: Assess whether relevant software, data, versions, analytical procedures, and technical limitations are adequately described.
  • Culturally Sensitive Material: Recognize restrictions relating to community knowledge, ritual practices, sacred music, performer rights, and culturally specific research protocols.

Confidential field recordings, restricted archives, unpublished compositions, participant information, and culturally sensitive material must not be demanded for unrestricted public access merely in the name of transparency. Where material cannot legitimately be shared, note whether the description of access limits and alternative supporting evidence is sufficient for an informed evaluation.

9. Handling Possible Ethical or Research Integrity Concerns

During review, concerns may arise about unattributed reuse, duplicate publication, fabricated sources, manipulated recordings, unreliable data, inappropriate author attribution, participant consent, or undisclosed competing interests. Identify the concrete reason for concern without treating suspicion as an established finding.

Report suspected integrity problems confidentially to the handling editor, with specific references or documentation available within the authorized review. Do not alert third parties, initiate independent investigations of authors or participants, or include unverified allegations in a publicly shareable report.

  • Do not make public allegations or contact the author's institution without authorization from the journal.
  • Do not independently contact research participants, interviewees, performers, or other third parties in ways that compromise confidentiality.
  • Do not characterize ordinary methodological disagreement or alternative interpretation as misconduct.
  • Do not rely solely on similarity scores, automated AI-detection results, or unsupported suspicions as proof of unethical conduct.
  • Inform the editor when additional specialist assessment or source verification appears necessary.

The Editorial Office determines whether further inquiry or specialist assessment is warranted under Publication Ethics. Similarity scores, AI-detection reports, and disagreement over scholarly interpretation do not independently establish research misconduct.

10. Artificial Intelligence in Peer Review

Reviewers must comply with the AI Use Policy. The reviewer's own scholarly judgment, written assessment, and recommendation cannot be delegated to an AI system. Confidential submission content must not be supplied to public or unauthorized AI services for summarization, analysis, translation, or drafting.

  • No Unauthorized Uploads: Do not upload manuscripts, abstracts obtained through confidential review, figures, tables, datasets, unpublished scores, recordings, translations, supplementary materials, or editorial correspondence to public or unauthorized AI services.
  • Independent Scholarly Evaluation: Do not rely on AI systems to read and judge the manuscript in place of your own expert assessment.
  • Limited Language Assistance: AI-assisted polishing of the reviewer's own independently written comments may be permissible where no confidential manuscript information is disclosed and journal policy permits the use.
  • Verification: The reviewer remains responsible for the accuracy, fairness, relevance, and originality of all comments and references.
  • Transparency: Disclose any substantive AI assistance used in preparing the review when required by the Editorial Office or the applicable journal policy.
  • No Fabrication: Do not create fictitious citations, evidence, quotations, review observations, or findings with AI tools.

Use of a tool to improve a reviewer's own independently written prose does not authorize transfer of unpublished manuscript material. Any permissible assistance must preserve confidentiality, comply with journal instructions, and be reviewed for accuracy and fairness by the human reviewer.

Further details, including disclosure and confidentiality requirements, are set out in the AI Use Policy.

11. Reviewing Revised Manuscripts

When reassessing a revision, read the revised manuscript together with the authors' point-by-point response and your previous report. Concentrate on whether the concerns that affected the earlier recommendation have been resolved and whether new material has introduced any significant problems.

  • Review the Response Letter: Examine the author's point-by-point responses alongside the revised manuscript.
  • Assess Substantive Changes: Determine whether the central concerns about research design, evidence, analysis, interpretation, or contextualization have been resolved.
  • Consider Reasoned Disagreement: Authors may propose justified alternatives to reviewer suggestions. Evaluate whether those responses adequately address the underlying scholarly issue.
  • Avoid Unnecessary New Demands: Do not introduce unrelated major requirements at each review round unless significant new material, important errors, or ethical concerns justify them.
  • Identify Remaining Issues: Clearly distinguish resolved concerns from unresolved substantive problems and minor outstanding corrections.
  • Update the Recommendation: Provide a recommendation reflecting the revised manuscript's current quality rather than simply repeating the previous decision.

Authors may reasonably propose a different method or interpretation from the one recommended. Assess whether their response resolves the underlying problem, not whether it adopts your exact preferred solution. The editor decides whether further revision or review is necessary.

12. Submitting the Review Report

Submit the report through the journal's online reviewer workflow associated with the invitation. Depending on the platform configuration and assignment, the journal may provide fields for author-facing comments and confidential comments to the editor, an upload option, or a combined form. Follow the instructions shown on your assignment rather than assuming every review screen is identical.

  1. Access the Assignment: Sign in through the journal's Reviewer Portal using the authorized account associated with the review invitation.
  2. Check the Review Instructions: Confirm the manuscript category, review deadline, required fields, and any additional editorial requests.
  3. Enter Comments for the Author: Provide the manuscript summary, major comments, minor comments, and other appropriate feedback in the designated field or attached report.
  4. Enter Confidential Comments: Provide relevant editorial concerns separately where the system offers a confidential field. Do not assume that all uploaded files or text fields are visible only to editors.
  5. Choose the Recommendation: Select the appropriate recommendation in the online workflow. Where platform labels differ from this guide, use the corresponding available option and clarify the intended recommendation in the report if necessary.
  6. Review the Submission: Verify that the comments are complete, appropriately anonymized, professional, and consistent with the selected recommendation.
  7. Finalize the Review: Complete the formal submission action in the journal system. Saving a draft or uploading a document does not necessarily constitute final submission.

If the assignment is inaccessible, a required file is missing, an extension is needed, or a conflict of interest arises, contact the Editorial Office through the authorized workflow. Keep review material confidential when describing technical problems.

Important: Check that the assignment status shows the review as submitted. Saving a draft or attaching a document may not complete the workflow. The editor—not the reviewer—makes the publication decision after considering the submitted evaluation and any other relevant reports.

Recommended Review Report Format

The following compact outline is a drafting aid for reviewer reports. Adjust the depth of each part to the manuscript's complexity and the journal's actual review fields. Detailed substantive standards belong in the Review Criteria.

A. Summary and Overall Assessment

State the manuscript's question, approach, main contribution, principal strengths, and overall level of scholarly readiness.

B. Major Comments

For each substantial concern, identify its location, explain its consequence, and indicate what a defensible correction or clarification should accomplish.

C. Minor Comments

List concise, location-specific corrections to wording, citations, musical examples, figures, tables, or other presentation details.

D. Recommendation and Editor-Only Comments

Select Accept, Minor Revisions, Major Revisions, or Reject. Put confidential integrity issues, conflicts, or limits of expertise in the designated editor-only channel, when available.

A concise report containing specific, prioritized observations is more useful than a long list of vague or repetitive demands. Before submission, confirm that the recommendation matches the seriousness of the problems described.

Final Checklist for Reviewers

Before final submission, check the content of your report, its confidentiality, the selected recommendation, and the completion status of the online review workflow:

  1. You have evaluated the complete manuscript and relevant materials within the agreed review scope.
  2. Any conflicts of interest or limitations in expertise have been disclosed.
  3. The principal contribution has been summarized accurately and fairly.
  4. Major and minor comments are distinguished clearly.
  5. Substantive criticisms are supported by specific reasoning or identifiable examples.
  6. Suggested revisions are proportionate to the manuscript's scholarly objectives.
  7. The report is respectful, constructive, and free from personal or discriminatory comments.
  8. Confidential manuscript information has not been disclosed to unauthorized individuals or AI systems.
  9. Any potential ethical concerns have been communicated through the appropriate editorial channel.
  10. The final recommendation is consistent with the review report.
  11. The review has been formally submitted through the authorized journal workflow.

Editorial Note: The quality of peer review depends on expert judgment, independence, transparent reasoning, and respectful communication. These practical instructions support the journal's formal review standards; reviewers should use the relevant editorial policies for procedural questions rather than treating this guide as a substitute for them.

For substantive evaluation standards and journal-wide procedures, consult Review Criteria, Peer Review Process, Publication Ethics, and Special Issues & Non-Research Content Review Policy.

For questions about review assignments, submission difficulties, deadlines, or conflicts of interest, contact the Resonance Editorial Office: [email protected].