Complaints & Appeals
The Journal of Law, Psychology, and Communication Studies (JLPCS) is committed to handling complaints and appeals fairly, confidentially, transparently, and in accordance with the journal’s publication ethics, peer review, research integrity, and editorial independence policies.
《法律·心理学·传播研究学刊》(JLPCS)致力于依据本刊出版伦理、同行评议、研究诚信和编辑独立性政策,公正、保密、透明地处理投诉与申诉。
Fair Process / 公正程序
Confidential Handling / 保密处理
30-Day Appeal Window / 30 天申诉期
Independent Review / 独立评估
Editorial Accountability / 编辑责任
1. Purpose of the Policy / 政策目的
This policy explains how JLPCS receives, assesses, and responds to complaints and appeals concerning editorial decisions, peer review procedures, publication ethics, research integrity, editorial conduct, published content, special issues, and post-publication matters.
The purpose of the policy is to provide a clear, evidence-based, professional, and fair mechanism for addressing concerns while protecting the confidentiality of manuscripts, peer review materials, authors, reviewers, complainants, and editorial participants.
本政策说明 JLPCS 如何接收、评估和回应有关编辑决定、同行评议程序、出版伦理、研究诚信、编辑行为、已发表内容、专题期和出版后事项的投诉与申诉。本政策旨在提供清晰、基于证据、专业且公正的处理机制,同时保护稿件、同行评议材料、作者、审稿人、投诉人和编辑参与者的保密性。
JLPCS distinguishes a complaint about editorial conduct or process from an appeal against a particular decision. The editorial office first identifies the nature of the concern and directs it to the appropriate route. Where a report also alleges research misconduct, authorship irregularity, or a problem with an already published article, the relevant specialist policy informs the substantive assessment; this policy governs the fairness and communication of the complaint or appeal process.
JLPCS 区分针对编辑行为或流程的投诉,以及针对具体决定的申诉。编辑部首先确认问题性质,再采用相应处理路径。若报告同时涉及研究不端、署名异常或已发表文章的问题,应依据相关专门政策评估实质事项;本政策主要规范投诉与申诉处理的公正性、沟通方式及程序责任。
2. Difference Between a Complaint and an Appeal / 投诉与申诉的区别
| Category / 类别 | Meaning / 含义 |
|---|---|
| Complaint 投诉 |
A complaint concerns the journal’s process, conduct, policy implementation, ethical handling, publication record, communication, confidentiality, conflicts of interest, or other procedural or professional matters.
投诉关注期刊程序、人员行为、政策执行、伦理处理、出版记录、沟通、保密、利益冲突或其他专业事项。
|
| Appeal 申诉 |
An appeal is a request to reconsider an editorial decision, research integrity decision, or post-publication action when the appellant believes that there was a factual error, procedural irregularity, significant misunderstanding, conflict of interest, or new evidence.
申诉是请求重新考虑编辑决定、研究诚信决定或出版后措施,理由须涉及事实错误、程序异常、重大误解、利益冲突或新证据。
|
A disagreement with reviewer comments or an unfavorable editorial decision alone is not sufficient grounds for appeal. Appeals should be based on evidence, procedure, factual accuracy, or relevant new information.
A submission may contain both a complaint and an appeal. For example, an author may challenge a rejection while separately alleging a reviewer conflict of interest. The journal should assess the procedural allegation and the request to reconsider the decision without treating one as proof of the other. Complaints do not automatically reopen a decision, and appeals do not automatically establish editorial misconduct.
同一来信可能同时包含投诉与申诉。例如,作者在要求重新考虑拒稿决定时,也可能提出审稿人利益冲突问题。编辑部应分别审视程序性指控及决定复议请求,而不应将其中一种主张自动视为另一种主张的证据。投诉不会自动重启编辑决定,申诉也不自动意味着编辑人员存在不当行为。
3. Scope of Complaints / 投诉范围
JLPCS considers complaints relating to editorial procedure, peer review, publication ethics, research integrity, journal policies, editorial communication, published content, and post-publication matters.
Complaints may concern:
- Delays or irregularities in editorial handling, peer review, revision, production, or publication;编辑处理、同行评议、修改、制作或发表中的延误或程序异常;
- Concerns about reviewer conduct, editor conduct, confidentiality, professional tone, or inappropriate comments;审稿人或编辑行为、保密义务、专业沟通或不当评语方面的问题;
- Potential conflicts of interest involving authors, reviewers, editors, guest editors, sponsors, or institutions;涉及作者、审稿人、编辑、客座编辑、赞助方或机构的潜在利益冲突;
- Alleged plagiarism, duplicate publication, fabricated data, falsified results, authorship concerns, or research misconduct;涉嫌抄袭、重复发表、伪造数据、篡改结果、署名问题或其他研究不端行为;
- Ethics approval, informed consent, participant privacy, sensitive data, legal confidentiality, or data availability concerns;伦理批准、知情同意、参与者隐私、敏感数据、法律保密或数据可得性问题;
- Errors or concerns in published articles, metadata, author information, references, tables, figures, supplementary files, or declarations;已发表文章、元数据、作者信息、参考文献、图表、补充文件或声明的错误;
- Special issue handling, guest editor conflicts, invited manuscript handling, or thematic issue transparency;专题期管理、客座编辑利益冲突、约稿处理或专题期透明度问题;
- APC, waiver, access, licensing, copyright, archiving, or website policy implementation concerns.文章处理费、费用减免、访问、授权、版权、保存或网站政策执行问题。
JLPCS 接受与编辑流程、同行评议、出版伦理、研究诚信、期刊政策执行、编辑沟通、已发表内容和出版后事项有关的投诉。
JLPCS may examine complaints involving a special issue, reviewer confidentiality, author identity, editorial bias, inappropriate citation pressure, accessibility or inaccurate policy information. Matters that primarily concern the reliability of published research are considered in conjunction with the journal’s research integrity and corrections policies. The seriousness of an allegation is evaluated from identifiable facts and supporting material, not the status of the reporting party.
投诉范围还可涉及专题期管理、审稿保密、作者身份保护、编辑偏见、不当引用压力、访问障碍或政策信息不准确等事项。主要影响已发表研究可靠性的问题,应结合本刊研究诚信及出版后更正政策处理。编辑部依据可识别事实与支持材料判断问题严重程度,而不是依据报告人的身份或学术地位。
4. Scope of Appeals / 申诉范围
Authors may appeal editorial or research integrity decisions when they believe that the decision was affected by a significant factual error, procedural irregularity, misunderstanding, undisclosed conflict of interest, or relevant new evidence.
Appeals may concern:
- Desk rejection or rejection after peer review;编辑初审拒稿或同行评议后的拒稿决定;
- Research integrity decisions, including decisions related to plagiarism, authorship, data, ethics, or conflicts of interest;涉及抄袭、作者署名、数据、伦理或利益冲突的研究诚信决定;
- Post-publication actions, including correction, expression of concern, retraction, or editorial note;更正、关注声明、撤稿或编辑说明等出版后处理决定;
- Procedural errors in peer review or editorial handling;同行评议或编辑处理中的程序性错误;
- Evidence that reviewer or editor conflicts of interest may have affected the decision;有证据表明审稿人或编辑的利益冲突可能影响决定;
- Clear misunderstanding of the manuscript’s content, method, data, legal materials, or contribution.对稿件内容、方法、数据、法律资料或学术贡献存在可证明的重大误解。
作者可就编辑决定或研究诚信决定提出申诉,但申诉应基于事实错误、程序异常、重大误解、未披露利益冲突或相关新证据,而不应仅基于对结果不满意。
An appeal should explain how the alleged error or irregularity could have materially affected the decision. In law, psychology, and communication studies, this may concern a demonstrably incorrect reading of a statute or judgment, an overlooked methodological detail, a misunderstanding of data interpretation, or a failure to apply the stated peer review procedure. A different scholarly interpretation, by itself, does not establish procedural unfairness.
申诉应说明所指事实错误或程序异常如何可能实质影响原决定。在法律、心理学和传播学研究中,相关问题可能包括对法条或判决的可证明误读、遗漏关键方法细节、误解数据分析结果,或未遵守已公布的同行评议程序。仅存在不同学术解释,本身并不足以证明程序不公。
5. Appeal Deadline / 申诉期限
Appeals should be submitted within 30 days of the editorial decision, research integrity decision, or post-publication notice being communicated to the author or affected party.
Appeals submitted after the 30-day period may be considered only when the appellant provides a reasonable explanation for the delay and relevant evidence that warrants further assessment.
申诉应在编辑决定、研究诚信决定或出版后通知送达作者或相关方之日起 30 天内提交。超过期限的申诉,只有在申诉人提供合理延迟理由和足以支持进一步评估的相关证据时,编辑部才可酌情考虑。
The 30-day period is counted from communication of the relevant editorial decision, integrity decision, or post-publication notice to the affected party. A late appeal must identify the reason for the delay and provide material evidence warranting further examination. This deadline applies to appeals under this policy; it must not be used to dismiss a credible new allegation concerning the integrity of an already published article solely because the article is old.
30 天期限自有关编辑决定、研究诚信决定或出版后通知送达受影响方之日起计算。逾期申诉须说明延迟原因,并提供值得进一步核查的实质证据。本期限适用于本政策所述申诉,不应仅因已发表文章年代久远,便拒绝评估新提出且具有可信证据的出版记录诚信问题。
6. Who May Submit a Complaint or Appeal / 谁可以提交投诉或申诉
Complaints and appeals may be submitted by individuals or organizations with a direct or legitimate interest in the matter.
- Authors, corresponding authors, co-authors, or contributors;作者、通讯作者、共同作者或其他贡献者;
- Reviewers, editors, guest editors, or editorial board members;审稿人、编辑、客座编辑或编委会成员;
- Readers, researchers, institutions, libraries, or indexing bodies;读者、研究人员、机构、图书馆或索引服务机构;
- Research participants, affected individuals, legal representatives, or ethics committees;研究参与者、受影响个人、法律代表或伦理委员会;
- Publishers, funders, sponsors, copyright holders, or other parties with relevant evidence;出版方、资助方、赞助方、版权所有人或掌握相关证据的其他主体;
- Whistleblowers or reporting parties raising publication ethics or research integrity concerns.提出出版伦理或研究诚信问题的举报人及报告人。
投诉和申诉可由对相关事项具有直接或正当利益的个人或机构提出。编辑部也可主动调查在编辑、审稿、出版或出版后环节发现的问题。
For an appeal concerning an author group’s manuscript, communication through the corresponding author supports a clear and consistent record; the journal may contact affected co-authors directly where authorship, consent, or integrity issues require it. Third parties may report credible concerns even when they are not authors. The editorial office assesses the information supplied and does not require a complainant to establish misconduct conclusively before a concern can be considered.
对于涉及共同作者稿件的申诉,优先通过通讯作者联系有助于保持记录清晰一致;在署名、同意或诚信问题需要时,编辑部也可直接联系受影响的共同作者。非作者第三方如掌握可信问题及证据,同样可以报告。编辑部依据已提交信息进行评估,不要求投诉人在提出问题时就对不端行为作出最终证明。
7. How to Submit a Complaint / 如何提交投诉
Complaints should be submitted in writing to the JLPCS Editorial Office. The complaint should be specific, professional, evidence-based, and sufficiently detailed for editorial assessment.
A complaint should include:
- Name, affiliation, and contact information of the complainant, unless anonymity is requested;投诉人的姓名、单位及联系方式;如希望匿名,应注明;
- Manuscript title, submission ID, article title, DOI, issue information, or article URL where applicable;稿件题名、投稿编号、文章题名、DOI、期次资料或文章网址(如适用);
- A clear description of the complaint;对投诉事项的清楚说明;
- Specific evidence, documents, screenshots, correspondence, source links, comparison text, data details, or other supporting materials;具体证据、文件、截图、通信、来源链接、原文比对、数据资料或其他支持材料;
- The date, stage, or publication record to which the complaint relates;问题所涉及的日期、处理阶段或出版记录;
- Names or roles of relevant parties where necessary and appropriate;在必要且适当情况下,所涉人员的姓名或职责;
- The requested action or outcome, if any.希望编辑部采取的措施或达到的处理结果(如有)。
投诉应尽量提供清楚事实、具体证据和相关材料。缺乏证据的笼统指控可能无法启动正式处理程序。
Complaints may be sent to the editorial office at [email protected]. Sensitive personal data, unpublished peer review materials, confidential legal records, and participant information should be limited to what is necessary and transmitted securely. A complainant who wishes to remain anonymous should indicate that preference and provide a safe channel for any follow-up if available; anonymity cannot be guaranteed when disclosure is required by law or a fair investigation.
投诉可发送至 [email protected]。个人敏感资料、未发表评审材料、保密法律档案及参与者信息,应遵循必要性原则并以安全方式传送。希望匿名的投诉人可说明该意愿,并尽可能提供安全的后续联系渠道;但若法律要求或公正调查确有必要,编辑部不能无条件保证身份绝对不被披露。
8. How to Submit an Appeal / 如何提交申诉
An appeal should identify the manuscript and decision, state the specific grounds, and address the relevant reviewer or editorial comments with supporting evidence. Send it to [email protected]; a person with a conflict should not decide the appeal.
申诉应注明稿件及决定,列出具体理由,并结合证据回应相关审稿或编辑意见。请发送至 [email protected];存在利益冲突者不应负责申诉决定。
Appeals should be submitted in writing within the appeal period. An appeal should directly address the basis of the decision and provide evidence that a reconsideration is justified.
An appeal should include:
- Manuscript title, submission ID, article title, DOI, or publication details where applicable;稿件题名、投稿编号、文章题名、DOI 或其他出版信息(如适用);
- The editorial decision, research integrity decision, or post-publication action being appealed;所针对的编辑决定、研究诚信决定或出版后措施;
- A concise explanation of the grounds for appeal;简明、具体的申诉理由;
- Specific evidence of factual error, procedural irregularity, misunderstanding, conflict of interest, or new information;事实错误、程序异常、重大误解、利益冲突或新信息的具体证据;
- A point-by-point response to the editor’s or reviewers’ key concerns, where relevant;在相关情况下,对编辑或审稿人关键意见的逐点回应;
- Any supporting documents, data, ethics materials, permissions, or institutional correspondence;相关文件、数据、伦理材料、许可证明或机构通信记录;
- A professional statement of the requested outcome.对所期望处理结果的专业说明。
申诉应集中回应原决定依据,并提供能够支持重新评估的证据。申诉不应提交为一篇全新稿件,也不应仅重复已被评估过的观点,除非存在新的事实或证据。
The appeal should be sent to [email protected] and should clearly distinguish the original decision, the disputed findings, the evidence relied on, and the requested remedy. An appeal is not a substitute for submitting a substantially rewritten manuscript as a new submission. Reviewers’ identities and confidential correspondence remain protected under the double-blind review policy, even when a decision is reconsidered.
申诉应发送至 [email protected],并清楚区分原决定、争议事项、相关证据及希望获得的处理方式。申诉不能代替将实质重写的研究作为新稿件投稿。即使原决定进入重新评估,审稿人身份与保密通信仍须按照双盲评审政策予以保护。
9. Matters Not Normally Considered as Appeals / 通常不作为申诉处理的事项
JLPCS will not normally consider an appeal when the request does not identify a procedural, factual, ethical, or evidentiary basis for reconsideration.
The following are not normally sufficient grounds for appeal:
- General disagreement with reviewer comments without evidence of error or procedural concern;没有事实错误或程序问题证据,仅对审稿意见存在一般分歧;
- Dissatisfaction with rejection, revision, correction, or retraction decisions alone;仅对拒稿、修改、更正或撤稿决定感到不满;
- Requests for guaranteed acceptance, expedited acceptance, or special treatment;要求保证录用、加速录用或特殊待遇;
- Submission of a substantially new manuscript that should instead be submitted as a new submission;提交实质上属于新研究、应作为新稿件投稿的内容;
- Arguments based only on the author’s reputation, institution, funding, title, seniority, or publication need;仅凭作者声望、机构、资助、头衔、资历或发表需要提出主张;
- Abusive, threatening, discriminatory, defamatory, or harassing communications;辱骂、威胁、歧视、诽谤或骚扰性沟通;
- Repeated appeals raising the same points without new evidence.在没有新证据的情况下反复提出相同申诉。
仅对拒稿或审稿意见不满,通常不足以构成申诉理由。申诉应提供可核查的事实、程序、伦理或证据基础。
This section does not prevent the editorial office from separating and evaluating a credible allegation of discrimination, breach of confidentiality, coercive conduct, or research misconduct that is contained within an otherwise unsupported appeal. Inappropriate communication may be managed separately from the underlying factual concern. Such separation protects fair process without rewarding harassment or dismissing valid evidence.
本节并不意味着编辑部可以忽略包含在其他方面证据不足的申诉中的可信歧视、保密违规、胁迫行为或研究不端指控。不当沟通行为可与其所涉及的实质事实问题分开处理。这样既维护公正程序,也不会因沟通失当而自动否定具有可信证据的问题。
10. Complaint Handling Procedure / 投诉处理程序
| Stage / 阶段 | Procedure / 处理程序 |
|---|---|
| Receipt 接收 |
The editorial office records the complaint and checks whether sufficient information has been provided.
编辑部登记投诉,并确认所提交的信息是否足以开展评估。
|
| Initial Assessment 初步评估 |
The complaint is assessed for relevance, specificity, credibility, evidence, urgency, confidentiality, and potential conflicts of interest.
按照相关性、具体性、可信度、证据、紧迫性、保密需求与利益冲突开展初步评估。
|
| Information Gathering 信息收集 |
The editorial office may review submission records, peer review files, correspondence, original source documents, ethics documents, data statements, published materials, or other verifiable evidence.
可查阅投稿记录、同行评议档案、相关通信、来源文件、伦理材料、数据说明、已发表资料及其他具体证据。
|
| Response Opportunity 回应机会 |
Where appropriate, affected authors, reviewers, editors, guest editors, institutions, or other parties may be invited to respond.
在适当情况下,可邀请受影响作者、审稿人、编辑、客座编辑、机构或其他当事人作出回应。
|
| Review and Decision 审查与决定 |
The responsible editor, editorial office, or designated panel determines whether action is required and what action is appropriate.
由适当的无冲突编辑、编辑部或指定小组判断是否需要措施及其适当程度。
|
| Communication 结果告知 |
The complainant is informed of the outcome to the extent appropriate, while respecting confidentiality, data protection, and privacy obligations.
在保护保密信息、个人资料及相关权益的前提下,向投诉人告知可披露的处理结果。
|
Complaint handling begins with sufficient identification of the issue and any immediate need to protect personal information or the published record. Editors assess source documents, relevant passages, editorial correspondence, declared conflicts, ethics records, data documentation, and other verifiable evidence as appropriate. The assessment focuses on documented conduct, source evidence, and the reliability of the editorial or publication record.
投诉处理首先应明确所涉问题,并判断是否需要立即保护个人资料或已发表记录。编辑可视具体情况核查来源文件、相关段落、编辑通信、利益冲突披露、伦理记录、数据说明及其他可核验证据。编辑评估应聚焦于可核查的行为、来源证据以及编辑或出版记录的可靠性。
When possible, the person whose conduct or work is questioned should receive a fair opportunity to respond before a consequential decision is made. Those managing the complaint should record the evidence reviewed, significant conflict-of-interest safeguards, rationale for the outcome, and any necessary follow-up, while limiting disclosure of confidential case materials.
在条件允许时,涉及行为或研究成果受到质疑的当事人,应在作出重要决定前获得合理回应机会。处理人员应记录核查过的证据、重大利益冲突回避措施、决定理由及必要的后续安排,同时控制保密材料的披露范围。
11. Appeal Handling Procedure / 申诉处理程序
Appeals are reviewed separately from the original editorial decision where appropriate. JLPCS may assign the appeal to an independent editor, senior editor, editorial panel, or appropriate editorial representative who was not directly responsible for the original decision.
| Stage / 阶段 | Procedure / 处理程序 |
|---|---|
| Eligibility Check 资格检查 |
The editorial office checks whether the appeal was submitted within the appeal window and whether it provides specific grounds for reconsideration.
检查申诉是否在规定期限内提出,以及是否具有具体重新评估依据;逾期事项依既定例外处理。
|
| Independent Assessment 独立评估 |
An independent editor or editorial panel reviews the appeal materials, editorial record, reviewer reports, author response, and relevant evidence.
由未直接参与原决定且无利益冲突的编辑或编辑小组审阅申诉材料、原编辑记录、审稿意见、作者回应及证据。
|
| Additional Review 补充评审 |
Where necessary, JLPCS may seek advice from an additional reviewer, editorial board member, ethics expert, statistician, legal specialist, or institutional contact.
必要时可请额外审稿人、编委、伦理专家、统计专家、法律专家或机构人员提供意见。
|
| Appeal Decision 申诉决定 |
The appeal may be upheld, partially upheld, rejected, or resolved through another appropriate editorial action.
申诉可获支持、部分支持、不获支持,或通过其他适当编辑措施解决。
|
| Final Communication 最终告知 |
The appellant is informed of the outcome. A rejected appeal normally closes the matter unless new, substantive evidence becomes available.
将申诉结果告知相关方;申诉不获支持后,除非出现新的实质证据,否则通常不再重复审查。
|
申诉通常由未直接参与原决定的独立编辑、资深编辑或编辑小组评估。必要时,JLPCS 可邀请额外专家意见。
Independence means that the appeal is not resolved solely by the person whose decision is challenged or by anyone with a relevant conflict of interest. The reviewing editor may obtain the original decision rationale and may consult further expertise when necessary, but a fresh round of external peer review is not an automatic entitlement. An upheld appeal may lead to reconsideration or additional assessment; it does not guarantee acceptance.
独立评估意味着申诉不能仅由原决定作出者或存在相关利益冲突的人决定。负责复议的编辑可以查阅原决定理由,并在必要时征询专业意见,但追加一轮外部同行评议并非申诉人的自动权利。申诉获得支持可能导致重新考虑或进一步评估,并不保证稿件被录用。
12. Possible Outcomes / 可能处理结果
| Outcome / 结果 | Meaning / 含义 |
|---|---|
| No Further Action 不采取进一步措施 |
The complaint or appeal is not supported by sufficient evidence, or the original decision/process is found to be appropriate.
现有证据不足以支持投诉或申诉,或确认原处理决定及程序适当。
|
| Clarification 解释说明 |
The editorial office provides clarification about policy, procedure, decision rationale, publication status, or next steps.
编辑部对政策、程序、决定理由、出版状态或后续步骤作出解释。
|
| Process Correction 流程纠正 |
The journal corrects a procedural issue, communication problem, metadata error, or administrative mistake.
纠正程序、沟通、元数据或行政管理方面的错误。
|
| Reassessment 重新评估 |
The manuscript, decision, post-publication notice, or integrity matter is reassessed by an independent editor or panel.
由无冲突编辑或小组重新评估稿件、决定、出版后通知或诚信问题。
|
| Additional Review 追加评审 |
An additional reviewer, ethics expert, legal expert, statistician, or editorial board member may be consulted.
在必要时征询额外审稿人、伦理专家、法律专家、统计专家或编委的意见。
|
| Editorial Action 编辑措施 |
Possible actions include revised decision, request for correction, correction notice, expression of concern, retraction, reviewer replacement, editor recusal, or institutional notification.
可能包括调整编辑决定、要求更正、发布更正或关注声明、撤稿、更换审稿人、编辑回避或通知机构。
|
| Policy Improvement 政策改进 |
The journal may update policies, guidance, workflow, reviewer instructions, website information, or editorial procedures to prevent similar issues.
完善政策、指南、工作流程、审稿人说明、网站信息或编辑程序,以减少类似问题。
|
Actions should be proportionate to the verified issue and to the stage of the manuscript or article. An editorial communication error may warrant clarification or a process correction; an unreliable published article may require a publicly linked correction, expression of concern, or retraction under the post-publication policy. Where an appeal succeeds, the journal should explain what aspect of the original decision or process has changed without disclosing protected reviewer identities or unrelated confidential information.
处理措施应与已核实问题的性质及稿件或文章所处阶段相称。编辑沟通错误可能只需解释或纠正程序;已发表文章若存在可靠性问题,则可能需要依出版后政策发布与原文相互链接的更正、关注声明或撤稿通知。申诉获得支持时,期刊应说明原决定或程序中哪些事项发生变化,同时保护审稿人身份及无关保密信息。
13. Confidentiality and Data Protection / 保密与数据保护
JLPCS handles complaints and appeals confidentially to the extent possible. Information is shared only with individuals or organizations that need to be involved in assessment, response, investigation, correction, or publication record management.
- Submitted manuscripts, reviewer identities, reviewer reports, editorial communications, and unpublished materials are confidential;投稿稿件、审稿人身份、评审报告、编辑通信及未发表材料均属保密信息;
- Complainants, appellants, authors, reviewers, and editors should not disclose confidential information publicly while a matter is under assessment;投诉人、申诉人、作者、审稿人和编辑在事项评估期间不应公开受保护的保密信息;
- Confidential, personal, sensitive, legal, institutional, or participant-related information should be handled securely;保密、个人、敏感、法律、机构或研究参与者相关资料应安全处理;
- Anonymous complaints may be considered when they contain sufficient evidence, but anonymity may limit the editorial office’s ability to investigate or respond;有充分证据的匿名投诉可以被考虑,但匿名可能限制编辑部调查或回应的能力;
- Information may be shared with institutions, ethics committees, publishers, funders, or authorities where necessary and appropriate.在必要且适当的情况下,可向有关机构、伦理委员会、出版方、资助方或主管机关共享信息。
JLPCS 在可能范围内对投诉与申诉进行保密处理。涉及稿件、审稿意见、作者身份、审稿人身份、受试者信息、法律材料或机构资料的内容,应严格保护。
Confidentiality does not prevent a person from reporting a concern through legitimate institutional, regulatory, or legal channels. At the same time, confidentiality in double-blind peer review prohibits unnecessary disclosure of reviewer identities, unpublished manuscripts, and sensitive case material. JLPCS should share the minimum information necessary for a fair evaluation and respect applicable data protection and professional obligations.
保密义务不应阻止个人通过正当的机构、监管或法律渠道报告问题。同时,双盲评审的保密要求禁止不必要地披露审稿人身份、未发表稿件及敏感案件材料。JLPCS 应以公正评估所需的最少信息为原则,遵守适用的数据保护及专业义务。
14. Conflicts of Interest in Complaint or Appeal Handling / 投诉或申诉处理中的利益冲突
Individuals with an actual, potential, or perceived conflict of interest should not make final decisions on complaints or appeals where their impartiality may reasonably be questioned.
- An editor whose decision is being appealed should not be the sole decision-maker on the appeal;原决定作出者不应独自决定针对该决定的申诉;
- A reviewer or editor accused of misconduct should not handle the complaint about their own conduct;受到不当行为指控的审稿人或编辑不得处理针对自身行为的投诉;
- Guest editors should not handle complaints or appeals involving manuscripts where they have conflicts;客座编辑不得处理与其存在利益冲突的稿件相关投诉或申诉;
- Where conflicts are identified, the matter may be reassigned to an independent editor, senior editor, editorial panel, or the editorial office;发现利益冲突时,可将事项移交无冲突的独立编辑、资深编辑、编辑小组或编辑部其他适当人员;
- Relevant conflict management steps may be documented in the editorial record.利益冲突的披露、回避和重新分配等重要步骤可记录于编辑档案。
存在实际、潜在或表面利益冲突的人员,不应对相关投诉或申诉作出最终决定。必要时,编辑部应重新分配处理人员或邀请独立编辑小组评估。
When a complaint concerns the Editor-in-Chief, a senior editor, or the editorial office itself, a person with no relevant conflict should oversee its handling; referral to an appropriate publisher representative may be necessary for conduct or administrative issues. Publisher involvement in a complaint must not become a means of directing scholarly acceptance decisions. The original editor can supply factual records while remaining outside the independent final judgment.
当投诉涉及主编、资深编辑或编辑部本身时,应由无相关利益冲突的适当人员负责处理;对于行为或行政问题,必要时可转交出版方适当代表。出版方参与投诉处理不得成为干预学术录用决定的方式。原负责编辑可以提供事实记录,但不应主导独立的最终判断。
15. Complaints About Editorial Conduct / 关于编辑行为的投诉
Complaints about editor conduct, communication, conflict of interest, confidentiality, tone, delay, or procedural fairness should be directed to the JLPCS Editorial Office. If the complaint concerns the responsible editor, the matter may be reviewed by another editor, senior editor, editorial board representative, or the publisher where appropriate.
Such complaints may involve:
- Alleged breach of confidentiality;涉嫌违反保密义务;
- Undisclosed conflict of interest;未披露的利益冲突;
- Unprofessional, discriminatory, or inappropriate communication;不专业、歧视性或不当的沟通;
- Unreasonable or unexplained delay;不合理或未作说明的延误;
- Failure to follow stated journal policy;未遵循已经公布的期刊政策;
- Improper influence by financial, institutional, political, personal, or commercial interests;财务、机构、政治、个人或商业利益的不当影响;
- Inadequate handling of publication ethics or research integrity concerns.对出版伦理或研究诚信疑虑处理不充分。
关于编辑行为的投诉应由无利益冲突的适当人员处理。编辑部应保护相关方权益,并根据事实和证据进行评估。
An allegation concerning the conduct of an editor should be distinguished from disagreement with the academic judgment itself. Reviewers and editors are expected to observe confidentiality, disclose relevant interests, communicate respectfully, and apply published procedures. If the complaint concerns the person who would ordinarily receive it, reassignment to an unconflicted editor or appropriate publisher representative prevents a conflict in the complaint route.
针对编辑行为的投诉,应与单纯不同意其学术判断加以区分。审稿人及编辑应遵守保密义务、披露相关利益关系、保持专业沟通,并遵循已公布程序。如投诉对象正是通常负责接收投诉的人员,应将事项交由无冲突编辑或出版方适当代表处理,避免投诉渠道本身存在利益冲突。
16. Complaints About Peer Review / 关于同行评议的投诉
Complaints about peer review may concern procedure, confidentiality, reviewer conduct, reviewer expertise, conflicts of interest, inappropriate comments, or possible manipulation of the review process.
- Reviewers must maintain confidentiality and must not use unpublished manuscript content for personal advantage;审稿人必须保密,不得利用未发表稿件内容谋取个人利益;
- Reviewer comments should be professional, specific, constructive, and evidence-based;审稿意见应专业、具体、具有建设性,并以证据为依据;
- Reviewers with conflicts of interest should decline review or disclose the conflict;存在利益冲突的审稿人应拒绝评审邀请或主动披露;
- Authors should not attempt to identify, contact, influence, or pressure reviewers under the double-blind process;在双盲评审制度下,作者不得试图识别、接触、影响或施压审稿人;
- Allegations of peer review manipulation, fabricated reviewer identity, coercive citation, or confidentiality breach may trigger research integrity assessment.操纵评审、虚构审稿人身份、强制引用或违反保密义务的指控,可进入研究诚信评估程序。
对同行评议的投诉将根据双盲评审政策、审稿人指南、利益冲突政策和研究诚信要求进行处理。
Complaints about peer review should identify the specific review step, comment, confidentiality concern, or alleged manipulation. The reviewing editor should consider the substance and professionalism of the reports, whether potential conflicts were managed, and whether the journal’s double-blind procedure was respected. Replacing a reviewer or obtaining further advice may be appropriate, but disagreement with a recommendation does not alone invalidate an otherwise fair review.
关于同行评议的投诉,应指出具体评审步骤、意见、保密疑虑或被指称的操纵行为。负责处理的编辑应核查评审意见的学术依据与专业性、相关利益冲突是否得到管理,以及双盲评审程序是否得到遵守。必要时可更换审稿人或征询额外意见,但仅不同意审稿建议,并不足以否定程序公正的评审。
17. Complaints About Published Content / 关于已发表内容的投诉
Complaints about published content may be handled under JLPCS’s publication ethics, research integrity, plagiarism, data availability, authorship, conflict of interest, human subjects, and corrections and retractions policies.
Published content complaints may involve:
- Significant factual, legal, analytical, statistical, translation, or production errors;重要的事实、法律、分析、统计、翻译或制作错误;
- Plagiarism, duplicate publication, unattributed reuse of earlier material, or fabricated references;抄袭、重复发表、未经充分标注的既有内容重用或虚构参考文献;
- Data fabrication, falsification, unsupported findings, image manipulation, or unavailable data;数据伪造、数据篡改、缺乏证据支持的结论、图像操纵或数据可得性问题;
- Ethics approval, informed consent, privacy, sensitive data, or participant protection concerns;伦理批准、知情同意、隐私、敏感数据或研究参与者保护问题;
- Authorship misrepresentation, omitted contributors, undisclosed conflicts of interest, or funding concerns;不当署名、遗漏贡献者、未披露利益冲突或资助方面的问题;
- Copyright, permission, third-party material, confidentiality, or legal concerns.版权、许可、第三方资料、保密义务或法律问题。
出版后投诉可能导致更正、编辑说明、关注声明、撤稿、访问限制或其他适当措施,具体取决于问题性质、证据强度和对学术记录的影响。
Complaints about published content should be evaluated according to the nature and significance of the evidence. A correctable mistake does not necessarily warrant retraction, while a serious unresolved concern may justify a public expression of concern. If a notice is issued, it should clearly identify the affected publication and be linked to the record. Mere lack of public access to legally or ethically restricted data is not, by itself, proof of research misconduct.
已发表内容投诉须依据问题性质、证据强度及其影响作出判断。可以修正的错误不一定需要撤稿;重大但尚未查明的问题则可能需要公开关注声明。若发布正式通知,应清楚标识受影响文章,并与原出版记录建立关联。因法律或伦理原因无法公开受限数据,本身并不能证明存在研究不端。
18. Timeliness / 处理时效
JLPCS aims to acknowledge complaints and appeals promptly and to handle them as efficiently as possible. The time required depends on the complexity of the matter, availability of evidence, need for author or institutional response, editorial workload, and whether external expert consultation is required.
- Simple administrative or communication issues may be resolved quickly;简单的行政或沟通事项可能较快得到解决;
- Editorial appeals may require review of the full editorial record and reviewer reports;编辑决定申诉可能需要重新检查完整的编辑记录和审稿意见;
- Research integrity or publication ethics complaints may require additional documentation, author response, expert advice, institutional communication, or post-publication assessment;研究诚信或出版伦理投诉可能需要补充文件、作者回应、专家意见、机构沟通或出版后评估;
- Complex cases may require longer handling time, especially when legal, privacy, human subjects, data, authorship, or institutional issues are involved;涉及法律、隐私、人类参与者、数据、署名或机构调查的复杂案件,可能需要更长处理时间;
- The editorial office may provide interim updates where appropriate.在适当情况下,编辑部可提供阶段性进展信息。
JLPCS 将尽量及时确认并处理投诉与申诉。复杂伦理、数据、署名、法律或机构调查事项可能需要较长时间。
The 30-day appeal submission window is a deadline for bringing an appeal, not a promise that every appeal will be resolved within 30 days. JLPCS does not establish a fixed complaint-investigation or appeal-decision period in this policy. The editorial office should communicate material requests for information and significant developments as the case permits, without compromising confidentiality or ongoing institutional investigations.
30 天申诉期限是提出申诉的期限,并非承诺所有申诉均在 30 天内审结。本政策不另设固定的投诉调查或申诉决定完成期限。编辑部应在案件条件允许时沟通必要的补充材料要求及重要进展,同时避免影响保密义务或正在进行的机构调查。
19. Professional Conduct and Non-Retaliation / 专业行为与禁止报复
JLPCS expects all parties involved in complaints and appeals to communicate professionally, honestly, and respectfully. Good-faith complaints and appeals will not result in retaliation.
- Complainants and appellants should provide accurate information and avoid unsupported accusations;投诉人及申诉人应提供准确资料,避免缺乏依据的指控;
- Authors, reviewers, editors, and institutions should cooperate with reasonable requests for clarification;作者、审稿人、编辑和相关机构应配合合理的澄清请求;
- Abusive, threatening, discriminatory, defamatory, harassing, or bad-faith communications may be declined or handled under appropriate policy;辱骂、威胁、歧视、诽谤、骚扰或恶意沟通可被拒绝或依适用政策处理;
- Knowingly false allegations may be treated as a publication ethics concern;明知不实的指控可能构成出版伦理问题;
- Good-faith whistleblowers should be treated respectfully and protected from unnecessary disclosure where possible.善意举报人应得到尊重,并在可能范围内免于不必要的身份披露。
所有投诉与申诉沟通均应保持专业、客观和尊重。善意投诉、申诉或举报不应遭受报复;但恶意、骚扰性或明知不实的指控可能构成伦理问题。
Good-faith reporting includes raising a concern on the basis of information honestly believed to be relevant, even if the allegation is not ultimately substantiated. JLPCS should not disadvantage individuals for making such reports. Knowingly false allegations, intimidation, or misuse of confidential information are distinct issues to be assessed on their own evidence; an unproven allegation is not automatically a malicious one.
善意报告是指基于报告人诚实相信相关的信息提出问题,即使最终未能证实指控,也不当然失去善意性质。JLPCS 不应因个人善意报告问题而使其遭受不利对待。明知不实的指控、恐吓或滥用保密信息属于需要独立依据核查的不同问题;未获证实的指控并不自动等于恶意指控。
20. Complaints and Appeals Checklist / 投诉与申诉检查清单
| No. / 序号 | Checklist Item / 检查项目 |
|---|---|
| 1 |
The matter is identified as either a complaint or an appeal.
已明确有关事项属于投诉还是申诉。
|
| 2 |
The manuscript title, submission ID, article DOI, issue details, or URL is provided where applicable.
已提供稿件题名、投稿编号、文章 DOI、期次或网址等适用识别信息。
|
| 3 |
The concern or appeal ground is stated clearly and professionally.
已清楚、专业地陈述问题或申诉理由。
|
| 4 |
Specific evidence, documents, data, screenshots, correspondence, comparison text, or source materials are attached where available.
在可获得的情况下,附上具体证据、文件、数据、截图、通信、原文比对或来源材料。
|
| 5 |
For appeals, the request is submitted within 30 days or explains why late submission should be considered.
申诉在 30 天内提交,或解释为何应考虑逾期申请。
|
| 6 |
The appeal identifies factual error, procedural irregularity, misunderstanding, conflict of interest, or new evidence.
申诉指出事实错误、程序异常、重大误解、利益冲突或新证据。
|
| 7 |
The requested outcome is realistic, specific, and related to the issue raised.
希望获得的结果现实、具体,并与所提出的问题相关。
|
| 8 |
The communication is professional, evidence-based, and free from personal attacks or unsupported allegations.
沟通专业、以证据为依据,且不包含人身攻击或无依据指控。
|
The checklist is a preparation aid, not a substitute for a clear explanation and supporting evidence. A credible complaint may still be examined if some administrative details are unavailable, particularly where anonymity, confidentiality, or participant safety is at stake. For an appeal, the confirmed 30-day window and the documented late-submission exception continue to apply.
本清单用于帮助整理材料,不能代替对问题的清楚说明和证据支持。如果因匿名、保密或参与者安全等原因无法提供部分行政资料,仍可根据可信证据考虑投诉。申诉则继续适用已经确定的 30 天期限及具备合理理由与证据时的逾期例外。
21. Contact / 联系方式
Complaints and appeals concerning editorial decisions, peer review, publication ethics, research integrity, post-publication matters, or journal policy implementation may be directed to the JLPCS Editorial Office.
有关编辑决定、同行评议、出版伦理、研究诚信、出版后事项或期刊政策执行的投诉与申诉,可联系 JLPCS 编辑部。
Contact Editorial Office / 联系编辑部 Editorial Decision Process / 编辑决定流程
Email: [email protected]
Please identify the matter in the email subject as a complaint or appeal and include the relevant manuscript or article reference when available. The editorial office receives correspondence at [email protected]. Relevant related pages include Editorial Decision Process, Research Integrity, Publication Ethics, and Corrections, Retractions & Expressions of Concern. The journal’s online submission system remains the channel for new manuscript submissions; a complaint or appeal is not a new submission.
来信主题宜注明“投诉”或“申诉”,并在可获得时提供相关稿件或文章识别信息。编辑部邮箱为 [email protected]。相关政策包括《编辑决定流程》《研究诚信》《出版伦理》及《更正、撤稿与关注声明》。新稿件仍通过本刊在线投稿系统提交;投诉或申诉不属于新的稿件投稿。
Related policies / 相关政策:Research Integrity / 研究诚信 · Publication Ethics / 出版伦理 · Corrections, Retractions & Expressions of Concern / 更正、撤稿与关注声明
Important Note / 重要说明
Complaints and appeals are handled according to the journal’s editorial policies, peer review process, publication ethics, research integrity policy, and confidentiality requirements. An appeal does not guarantee reversal of an editorial decision, acceptance of a manuscript, or withdrawal of a post-publication notice. Decisions are based on the editorial record, available evidence, journal policy, and scholarly standards.
投诉与申诉将依据本刊编辑政策、同行评议流程、出版伦理、研究诚信政策和保密要求处理。申诉并不保证原编辑决定被撤销、稿件被录用或出版后通知被撤回。处理结果将基于编辑记录、可用证据、期刊政策和学术标准作出。
Fair process does not promise a particular result. When a concern is substantiated, JLPCS selects a response based on the evidence, the relevant published policy, the interests of affected parties, and the integrity of the scholarly record. Editorial independence, confidentiality, the opportunity to respond, and proportionality remain central throughout.
公正程序不代表承诺特定结果。当问题得到证实时,JLPCS 根据证据、相关已公布政策、受影响方权益及学术出版记录的完整性选择适当措施。编辑独立、合理保密、当事人回应机会及措施相称性应贯穿整个处理过程。