Data Availability & Reproducibility
The Journal of Law, Psychology, and Communication Studies (JLPCS) promotes responsible access to research data, transparent methods, and credible verification of scholarly findings. Data sharing is encouraged when lawful, ethical, and practicable; it must never override participant privacy, informed consent, legal confidentiality, intellectual property, institutional restrictions, or research security. This policy applies to the diverse evidence used in law, psychology, communication studies, and related interdisciplinary research.
《法律·心理学·传播研究学刊》(JLPCS)支持负责任的研究数据获取、透明的方法报告以及学术结论的可信核验。在符合法律、伦理且实际可行时,本刊鼓励共享研究数据;但共享不得凌驾于研究参与者隐私、知情同意、法律保密义务、知识产权、机构限制或研究安全之上。本政策适用于法学、心理学、传播学及相关交叉研究所使用的不同类型证据。
Core principles: Transparent provenance · Methodological clarity · Proportionate data access · Responsible reuse · Confidentiality and participant protection
核心原则:来源可追溯 · 方法清晰 · 适度数据访问 · 负责任重用 · 保密与参与者保护
1. Purpose of the Policy / 政策目的
This policy describes how authors should explain the availability of research data and materials, document their research processes, support assessment or reproducibility of findings, and identify justified restrictions on access. It also clarifies the responsibilities of authors, reviewers, and editors in assessing data transparency without treating public release as a universal condition for scholarly merit.
本政策说明作者应如何交代研究数据与材料的可获取性、记录研究过程、支持研究结论的评价或可重现性,并说明合理的访问限制;同时明确作者、审稿人与编辑在研究透明度评价中的责任,避免将公开发布原始数据误当作判断学术价值的普遍前提。
For JLPCS, supporting research materials may include datasets, analysis scripts, survey questionnaires, interview or observation protocols, codebooks, legal and policy source lists, archival references, digital-platform records, supplementary tables, and explanatory documentation. Which materials are appropriate depends on whether a study is empirical, qualitative, quantitative, doctrinal, comparative, theoretical, or review-based.
对于 JLPCS,支持研究的材料可能包括数据集、分析脚本、调查问卷、访谈或观察提纲、编码手册、法律与政策来源清单、档案索引、数字平台资料、补充表格及说明文件。具体需要哪些材料,应根据研究属于实证、质性、定量、法教义学、比较、理论或综述等类型确定。
Transparency allows readers to trace the basis of claims and understand analytical choices; reproducibility concerns whether documented procedures and available evidence can support independent verification or rerunning of analyses. Neither concept requires all studies to produce new datasets or to disclose protected records.
透明度使读者能够追踪论据来源并理解分析选择;可重现性则关注已记录的程序及可用证据能否支持独立核验或重复分析。两者均不意味着所有研究都必须产生新数据集,或披露受保护的记录。
2. General Principle / 基本原则
JLPCS encourages authors to make data, code, instruments, legal source lists, research protocols, coding materials, and other pertinent evidence available whenever doing so is ethically, legally, and practically feasible. The expectation is proportional to the work: a statistical study may benefit from shareable code and variable definitions, whereas a legal interpretation paper principally requires accurate legal citations and a traceable method of source selection.
JLPCS 鼓励作者在伦理、法律及实际条件允许时提供数据、代码、研究工具、法律来源清单、研究方案、编码材料及其他相关证据。这一倡议须与研究性质相称:统计研究可通过共享代码及变量定义提高可核查性;法律解释研究则主要依靠准确的法律引证和可追溯的资料筛选方法。
Public release is not required where it would breach participant consent, confidentiality, privacy, intellectual property, institutional agreements, platform conditions, cybersecurity requirements, judicial restrictions, or applicable law. Authors should nevertheless provide an accurate description of the material, the reasons for restrictions, and any legitimate route for verification that does not expose protected information.
当公开共享可能违反参与者同意、保密义务、隐私、知识产权、机构协议、平台条件、网络安全要求、司法限制或适用法律时,不要求公开发布。作者仍应准确说明资料性质、限制原因,以及在不泄露受保护信息的前提下可采用的合法核验方式。
The FAIR principles—findability, accessibility under stated conditions, interoperability, and reusability—provide useful guidance for good data stewardship, not an assertion that JLPCS requires a specific repository, certification, license, or universal open-data deposit. See FAIR Principles for the underlying framework.
FAIR 原则强调资料的可发现性、在明确条件下的可获取性、互操作性与可重用性,可作为良好数据管理的参考指引;并不意味着 JLPCS 已规定特定仓储、认证、许可或全面开放数据的强制制度。有关原则可参见FAIR Principles。
3. Data Availability Statement / 数据可得性声明
Authors should include a Data Availability Statement in the manuscript or relevant declaration file, reflecting the actual research materials used. It should identify the types of data or supporting documents relevant to the principal claims; whether they are public, included in the article, available under conditions, restricted, or inapplicable; and how an authorized reader might locate them.
作者应在稿件或相关声明文件中提供数据可得性声明,如实反映研究使用的材料。声明应说明与核心研究结论相关的数据或支持性文件的类型、是否公开、是否包含于文章、是否可按条件获取、是否受到限制或是否不适用,以及获得授权的读者可如何查找。
For deposited materials, identify the repository or custodian, the dataset title and version, and a stable URL, accession number, or DOI where one genuinely exists. For controlled access, identify the appropriate contact or administrator and the substantive access conditions. A general promise that data are “available on request” is insufficient if the authors lack permission or the practical capacity to provide them.
对于已存储的材料,应说明仓储或保管方、数据集名称及版本,并在确实存在时提供稳定链接、记录编号或 DOI。对于受控访问,应指出适当的联系人或管理方及实质性获取条件。若作者并无分享权限或实际提供能力,笼统声称“可应要求提供数据”并不恰当。
Where sharing is prohibited or impracticable, specify the relevant class of restriction rather than disclosing confidential agreements or identities. An appropriate statement may explain that identifiable interview transcripts cannot be distributed, while aggregated findings, sampling details, a non-identifying coding framework, or other shareable documentation are presented in the article.
当共享受到禁止或确实不可行时,应说明限制类型,而不披露保密协议细节或个人身份。例如,可说明含可识别信息的访谈逐字稿无法外发,但文章已提供汇总结果、抽样说明、去身份化编码框架或其他可共享的说明材料。
In manuscripts that generate no research dataset, describe that fact accurately. A theoretical article, narrative review, or doctrinal legal analysis may rely on cited publications and public legal authorities rather than newly collected data; any independently compiled source corpus or documentary selection process should still be explained.
没有形成研究数据集的稿件,应如实说明。理论论文、叙述性综述或法教义学分析可能主要依赖已引用的出版物与公开法律依据,而非新收集的数据;但如研究自行建立了来源语料库或实施了文件筛选程序,仍应说明其范围及方法。
4. Recommended Statement Types / 推荐声明类型
The following categories help authors select wording that represents the actual access situation. They are descriptive options, not distinct submission tracks or compulsory repository arrangements.
以下类型帮助作者选择准确反映资料获取状况的表述。这些属于描述性选项,并非独立投稿通道或强制仓储安排。
| Statement type / 声明类型 | When it is appropriate / 适用条件 |
|---|---|
| Publicly Available公开可得 | Data, code, or source materials are already deposited in a genuinely accessible public repository, institutional archive, journal supplement, or stable website; include accurate locating information.数据、代码或来源材料已实际存入可访问的公共仓储、机构档案、期刊补充资料或稳定网站,并应提供真实的定位信息。 |
| Available on Reasonable Request合理请求可得 | A designated person is authorized and able to assess legitimate access requests, with stated ethical, legal, institutional, or confidentiality conditions; access is not unconditional.有指定人员具备授权与实际能力,可根据明确的伦理、法律、机构或保密条件评估合理访问请求;不代表无条件提供。 |
| Restricted Access受限访问 | Sharing is limited or prohibited because of privacy, consent, court orders, protected legal files, contracts, platform rules, security, or third-party rights; state the category of restriction.数据因隐私、同意范围、法院命令、受保护卷宗、合同、平台规则、安全或第三方权利而受到限制或禁止共享,应说明限制类别。 |
| Not Applicable不适用 | No research dataset was generated or analyzed; the work rests on cited publications, conceptual reasoning, or public documentary authorities. Do not use this label merely because data are confidential.研究没有产生或分析数据集,主要依赖已引用出版物、概念论证或公开文献依据。不得仅因数据保密就将其标注为“不适用”。 |
| Data Included in Article数据已包含于文中 | Evidence necessary for the reported claims is contained in the article, tables, figures, appendices, or accessible supplementary files, without implying undisclosed raw data are public.支持已报告结论的必要证据包含于正文、表格、图示、附录或可访问的补充文件中,但不意味着未公开的原始数据也可取得。 |
Different components of one project may have different access statuses. For example, aggregate statistical results may be public, analysis scripts may be deposited, and identifiable interviews may remain inaccessible. A composite statement may explain these distinctions more faithfully than assigning a single label to all materials.
同一项目中的不同资料可能具有不同的访问状态。例如,汇总统计结果可以公开,分析脚本可存入仓储,而包含身份信息的访谈记录仍不得提供。与对所有材料赋予单一标签相比,分项说明更能准确呈现实际情况。
5. Sample Data Availability Statements / 数据可得性声明示例
The examples below illustrate the form of a truthful statement; they are not claims about an existing JLPCS dataset or permission to make unsupported access promises. Authors should replace generic descriptions with accurate details for their own study before submission.
以下示例展示如何形成真实、清楚的声明;并非声称存在某个 JLPCS 数据集,也不允许作者作出无法兑现的访问承诺。投稿前应根据实际研究替换概括性描述并补足准确资料。
Public repository / 公共仓储
“The dataset and analysis scripts supporting the reported results are deposited in the institutional repository identified in the accompanying dataset citation. That record provides the version and permanent access link.” Use this only when the deposit has actually been completed and the record is accessible.
“支持本研究结果的数据集及分析脚本已存入数据引用信息中所注明的机构仓储;该记录提供数据版本及永久访问链接。”仅在确已完成存储且记录可以访问时采用。
Reasonable request / 合理请求
“Supporting data can be considered for access through the designated data custodian upon a justified request and completion of applicable ethics and confidentiality checks.” This wording is appropriate only if the custodian has authority and an actual access procedure.
“有合理研究依据的申请人,可联系指定数据保管方提出访问请求;获取资料须完成适用的伦理与保密核查。”只有在保管方确实具备授权及访问程序时,才适合采用这一表述。
Restricted data / 受限数据
“Individual-level interview records are not publicly available because consent and confidentiality commitments do not permit redistribution. The article provides anonymized excerpts and a description of the analytical procedure.” Authors should adapt the kinds of material and restrictions to their evidence.
“由于参与者同意范围及保密承诺不允许再分发,个体层面的访谈资料不对外公开。文章提供去身份化引语及分析程序说明。”作者应根据实际证据与限制条件调整资料类型及表述。
Data included in article / 数据已包含于文中
“The evidence necessary to evaluate the reported findings is provided in the article and its supplementary tables. No separate dataset is available for public deposit.” Use only if the published record actually supports this statement.
“评价本文已报告研究结果所需的证据包含于正文及补充表格中;没有另行可公开存储的数据集。”仅在公开内容确实支持该说明时使用。
Not applicable / 不适用
“No original research dataset was generated or analyzed for this conceptual study. The sources underpinning the argument are identified in the reference list.” A legal or documentary article must still cite its sources adequately.
“本概念性研究未产生或分析原始研究数据集;支持论证的文献均在参考文献中注明。”法律或文献研究仍须充分标明来源。
6. Reproducibility Expectations / 可重现性要求
JLPCS expects methods and analytical decisions to be explained sufficiently for readers and reviewers to assess how claims follow from the evidence. Appropriate detail may include research questions, hypotheses or interpretive premises, sampling and selection rules, observation or data-collection procedures, processing decisions, analysis strategies, software and versions, exclusions, uncertainty, and acknowledged limitations.
JLPCS 要求充分说明研究方法和分析选择,使读者与审稿人能够评价研究结论如何从证据得出。相关信息可包括研究问题、假设或解释前提、抽样与筛选规则、观察或收集程序、数据处理决定、分析策略、软件及版本、排除标准、不确定性和已知局限。
Reproducibility has different meanings across disciplines. Computational work may allow another analyst to rerun code; psychological studies may require clear measures and procedures; qualitative work emphasizes a traceable interpretive process and reflexivity; legal scholarship requires identifiable authorities, jurisdictions and defensible reasoning. Exact replication is not a universal condition for validity in every type of research.
可重现性在不同学科有不同含义。计算分析可能允许其他研究者重新运行代码;心理学研究需要清楚说明测量工具与程序;质性研究强调可追溯的解释过程及研究者反思;法学研究则强调可识别的法律依据、法域与可辩护的论证。不能将“完全复制同一结果”作为所有研究类型的普遍有效性条件。
Authors should distinguish planned analyses from exploratory ones when the distinction matters, and report deviations from protocols, unavailable observations, uncertain measurements or competing interpretations rather than concealing them. Preregistration, registered protocols, and field-specific reporting guidelines may improve transparency when used, but this policy does not establish a blanket requirement to preregister every JLPCS submission.
在有助于解释结论时,作者应区分预先规划与探索性分析,并如实报告研究方案偏离、缺失观察值、测量不确定性或其他可能解释,而非予以掩盖。预注册、研究方案登记和学科报告指南在适当采用时有助于提高透明度,但本政策并未规定所有 JLPCS 稿件均须预注册。
7. Quantitative and Experimental Research / 定量与实验研究
Quantitative, survey, psychological, experimental, statistical, and computational submissions should explain the sampling frame, recruitment or case selection, sample size, eligibility criteria, exclusions, data cleaning, missing-data treatment, measures, scale construction, and relevant reliability or validity evidence. For interventions and experiments, explain assignment, conditions, procedures and any departures from an approved or registered protocol where relevant.
定量、问卷、心理学、实验、统计与计算研究应说明抽样框、招募或案例选取、样本量、纳入条件、排除情况、数据清理、缺失值处理、测量指标、量表构建,以及相关信度或效度依据。对于干预和实验研究,还应按需要说明分组、条件、程序以及对获批或已登记研究方案的偏离。
Analytical reporting should identify the statistical model or estimation procedure, key assumptions, software and material version information, variable transformations, treatment of outliers, and sensitivity or robustness checks where these affect interpretation. Report effect estimates, uncertainty, and limitations in a manner suitable to the research design; numerical significance alone should not substitute for substantive interpretation.
分析报告应指出统计模型或估计方法、主要假设、软件及关键版本、变量转换、异常值处理,以及影响解释的敏感性或稳健性检验。应根据研究设计报告效应估计、不确定性和局限,而不能仅凭统计显著性替代实质解释。
When data and code may be shared, provide intelligible file descriptions, a variable dictionary, instructions to reproduce central figures and tables, and a record of packages or dependencies. Where individual-level data are protected, consider whether de-identified aggregates, example code with non-sensitive inputs, or sufficiently detailed methods can support verification without unlawful disclosure.
在可以共享数据及代码时,宜提供清楚的文件说明、变量字典、复算主要图表的步骤,以及软件依赖信息。若个体层面资料受到保护,应考虑能否通过去身份化汇总结果、不含敏感内容的示例代码或充分的方法细节实现核验,避免违法披露。
8. Qualitative Research / 质性研究
In interviews, focus groups, ethnography, fieldwork, discourse analysis, qualitative media studies and related research, transparency is primarily established through the description of recruitment, context, data generation, fieldwork period, coding or interpretive method, researcher position and the development of themes or conclusions. Repeating a conversation or social setting exactly may be neither feasible nor an appropriate criterion for validity.
对于访谈、焦点小组、民族志、田野研究、话语分析、质性媒体研究等,透明度主要依靠说明招募方式、研究情境、资料形成过程、田野时期、编码或解释方法、研究者立场,以及主题或结论的形成过程。完全复现某次对话或社会情境可能既不可行,也不适合作为有效性的判断标准。
Authors may describe interview guides, category definitions, analytic memos, coding summaries or examples of decision rules, when disclosure is consistent with participant agreements. The evidentiary basis of themes should be represented faithfully, including discrepant cases and limits on generalization. Reflexivity helps readers understand how researcher position and interactions may have affected collection or interpretation.
在符合参与者协议时,作者可说明访谈提纲、类别定义、分析备忘录、编码摘要或决策规则示例。主题所依据的证据应得到真实呈现,包括不一致个案及概括范围的局限。研究者反思有助于读者理解研究者立场及互动过程如何影响资料收集或解释。
Full transcripts, identifiable quotations, recordings, field notes and small-community descriptions can expose participants even after names are removed. Authors should not promise general access to such records when consent or confidentiality rules prevent it. A non-identifying methodological description or carefully selected excerpt may offer a more ethical form of transparency.
完整逐字稿、可识别引语、录音、田野笔记以及小型社群的细节描述,即使删除姓名,仍可能暴露参与者。若同意范围或保密义务不允许共享,作者不得承诺普遍开放这类记录。去身份化的方法说明或审慎选取的引文,可能是更合乎伦理的透明呈现方式。
9. Legal, Policy, and Documentary Research / 法律、政策与文献研究
Doctrinal legal analysis, comparative law, legal-empirical research, governance studies, institutional analysis and documentary inquiry should enable readers to identify the authorities and materials supporting key propositions. Where available and relevant, cite the issuing body, jurisdiction, case or document number, adoption or decision date, legal status and a stable official source. Historical law and current law should not be conflated.
法教义学分析、比较法、法律经验研究、治理研究、制度分析与文献研究,应使读者能够识别支持关键主张的法律依据和材料。资料具备时,应按相关性注明发布机关、法域、案件或文件编号、颁布或裁判日期、法律效力及稳定的官方来源。不得混淆历史法律状态与现行法。
Authors should explain the choice of jurisdictions, courts, archives, databases, time periods, legal sources or policy documents when selection affects the analysis. The interpretive framework, comparison criteria, documentary search strategy and distinction between primary authority and secondary commentary should be sufficiently explicit to permit reasoned assessment.
当选择范围影响结论时,作者应说明法域、法院、档案、数据库、时间范围、法律来源或政策文件的选择理由。法律解释框架、比较标准、文献检索策略,以及一手法律依据与二手评论的区分,应足够明确,以支持有依据的学术评估。
Restricted case files, sealed court records, confidential client materials, sensitive institutional documents and personal interviews must not be uploaded or redistributed contrary to governing obligations. Authors can describe provenance, custodianship, access authorization and the limits of verification without disclosing privileged or identifying content.
受限制卷宗、密封司法记录、保密当事人材料、敏感机构文件与个人访谈资料,不得违反相关义务上传或再分发。作者可以说明资料来源、保管方、访问授权和核验限制,而不披露受特权保护或可识别个人的信息。
10. Code, Software, and Analytical Materials / 代码、软件与分析材料
Where computational scripts, model settings, statistical code, classification rules or notebooks materially support the findings, authors should document their function and availability. Useful documentation includes software or package versions, execution requirements, inputs, analysis order, parameter choices, relevant random seeds, expected outputs and a clear description of how results relate to article tables or figures.
当计算脚本、模型设定、统计代码、分类规则或计算笔记本对研究结论具有实质作用时,作者应说明其功能及可获取性。有用的说明包括软件或程序包版本、运行要求、输入数据、分析顺序、参数选择、必要的随机种子、预期输出,以及结果与论文图表的对应关系。
Shareable code should have sufficiently informative filenames and supporting instructions. Before deposit or external transfer, authors should remove credentials, passwords, access tokens, API keys, personal identifiers, confidential paths and protected datasets. If proprietary software or licensed data cannot be redistributed, describe the dependency and what can lawfully be checked by others.
可共享代码应使用便于理解的文件名并附必要说明。存储或传输前,应删除凭证、密码、访问令牌、API 密钥、个人身份信息、保密路径和受保护数据集。对于不能再分发的专有软件或许可数据,应说明依赖关系及他人可以合法核验的范围。
Authors should identify third-party code, adapted scripts, licensed instruments and software resources accurately. A research article’s open-access license does not automatically grant permission to republish protected source code, proprietary datasets, instruments or other third-party research materials.
作者应准确标明第三方代码、改编脚本、获许可的研究工具及软件资源。研究论文适用开放获取许可,并不自动授权重新发布受保护的源代码、专有数据集、测量工具或其他第三方研究材料。
11. Restrictions on Data Sharing / 数据共享限制
JLPCS recognizes legitimate limits arising from privacy, the risk of re-identification, consent conditions, confidentiality, protected psychological or health information, child protection, sensitive legal proceedings, contracts, institutional approvals, platform terms, national or local law, security concerns and third-party intellectual property. Data may remain entirely inaccessible when no lawful or ethical disclosure route exists.
JLPCS 承认由隐私、重新识别风险、知情同意条件、保密义务、受保护的心理或健康资料、儿童保护、敏感司法程序、合同、机构批准、平台条款、国家或地方法律、安全风险及第三方知识产权所产生的合理限制。当不存在合法且合乎伦理的提供途径时,资料可以完全不对外开放。
Restrictions should be described accurately but without reproducing confidential clauses, consent forms containing names, or security-sensitive instructions. If feasible, authors can provide aggregates, variables, a description of collection procedures, non-identifying excerpts, synthetic demonstration inputs explicitly labeled as such, or code stripped of restricted content. Such alternatives must not be presented as if they were the underlying original observations.
限制条件应准确交代,但不得公开保密条款、含有姓名的同意书或涉及安全风险的操作细节。可行时,作者可以提供汇总数据、变量说明、收集程序描述、去身份化引文、明确标注为示范用途的合成输入,或已删除受限内容的代码。这些替代材料不得冒充研究所依据的真实原始观察值。
Access under a data-use agreement or by an authorized custodian does not mean the journal can promise delivery, ownership, indefinite storage or independent authorization. The data availability statement should distinguish what the authors control from material managed by courts, agencies, institutions, commercial providers or other third parties.
依据数据使用协议或由授权保管方控制的访问,不等于期刊能够保证交付、取得所有权、无限期保管或独立批准共享。数据可得性声明应区分作者能够管理的资料与法院、行政机构、研究机构、商业提供者或其他第三方管理的资料。
12. Repository and Supplementary Materials / 数据仓储与补充材料
Authors may deposit appropriate data, code, research protocols, instruments, appendices, source lists and supplementary material in a disciplinary or institutional repository, a funder-designated platform, or an approved journal supplement. Choose a location suited to the material and to the access, consent and preservation conditions; this policy does not designate a single mandatory repository or guarantee that JLPCS hosts unrestricted datasets.
作者可以将适当的数据、代码、研究方案、研究工具、附录、来源清单和补充材料存入学科或机构仓储、资助方指定平台,或适当的期刊补充文件。应根据资料性质、访问条件、同意范围与保存要求选择地点;本政策没有指定唯一的强制仓储,也不保证 JLPCS 无限制托管数据集。
When material is deposited, useful accompanying information includes a descriptive title, creators and contributors, collection dates, dataset version, file inventory, variable dictionary or codebook, README, data provenance, software dependencies, restrictions, permissions, and an appropriate citation or persistent identifier when genuinely available. Updates should preserve enough version information to identify which data supported the published analysis.
完成存储时,适宜附带描述性标题、创建者及贡献者、收集日期、数据版本、文件清单、变量字典或编码手册、README、资料来源、软件依赖、访问限制、使用许可,以及确实存在时的引用信息或持久标识符。后续更新应保留足够版本信息,使读者能够识别支持已发表分析的是哪一版资料。
Repository access and dataset reuse rights must be determined separately from the license governing the published article. Authors should check copyright ownership, dataset licensing, consent and third-party rights before selecting a reuse license. Author deposit of the published article is a distinct matter governed by the journal’s Repository Policy; long-term preservation of published files is addressed in Archiving & Digital Preservation.
仓储访问安排与数据集重用权利应和已发表论文适用的许可分别判断。作者在选择数据重用许可前,应核查版权归属、数据许可、同意范围及第三方权利。已发表论文的作者自存档另受本刊Repository Policy(作者存档政策)约束;正式出版文件的长期保存由Archiving & Digital Preservation(数字典藏与长期保存)说明。
13. AI-Generated or AI-Assisted Data / AI 生成或 AI 辅助数据
Generative AI and automated systems must not be used to fabricate empirical observations, interview transcripts, survey responses, case law, citations, images, data or analyses and then present them as authentic evidence. AI-generated content is not automatically factual, traceable or free of intellectual-property and confidentiality risks. Authors remain accountable for checking inputs, processes and substantive outputs.
不得使用生成式 AI 或自动化系统伪造实证观察值、访谈逐字稿、调查回答、判例、引用、图像、数据或分析,并将其冒充为真实证据。AI 生成内容不当然具有事实性、可追溯性,亦不当然免除知识产权及保密风险。作者仍须对输入、处理过程及实质性输出进行核验。
Synthetic or simulated data can have a legitimate methodological role—for example, in model evaluation, methodological demonstrations or privacy-preserving code examples—provided their artificial origin, generation procedure, assumptions and purpose are explicitly reported, and they are not misrepresented as real participant observations. A simulated dataset cannot silently substitute for restricted empirical data in support of factual claims.
合成或模拟数据可以具有正当的方法学用途,例如模型评估、方法演示或保护隐私的代码示例;但必须明确报告其人工生成性质、生成程序、假设与用途,不得伪称为真实参与者观察结果。模拟数据不能在未加说明的情况下替代受限实证资料来支持事实性结论。
Where AI materially assists transcription, translation, coding, classification, summarization or analysis, describe the tool or model sufficiently to understand its role, the material operations it performed, and human verification. Tool details should not require disclosure of confidential prompts, identifiable participant content or proprietary access credentials. Applicable disclosure responsibilities are addressed further in the AI Use Policy.
AI 如实质性参与转录、翻译、编码、分类、摘要或分析,应充分说明工具或模型的作用、执行的关键操作及人工核验方式。但披露工具信息不意味着需要公开保密提示词、可识别参与者资料或专有访问凭证。相关披露责任详见AI Use Policy(AI 使用政策)。
14. Reviewer and Editor Responsibilities / 审稿人与编辑责任
Reviewers and editors assess whether data availability statements, source documentation, methods and analytical explanations are adequate for the manuscript type. They should distinguish missing explanations from justified access restrictions, and should not infer unreliable scholarship solely because personal data, privileged legal records or protected interview transcripts cannot be released.
审稿人与编辑应结合稿件类型,评估数据可得性声明、来源文件、研究方法及分析说明是否充分。应区分说明不足与合理的访问限制,不能仅因为个人数据、受特权保护的法律记录或受保护访谈逐字稿无法公开,就推定研究不可靠。
Reviewers may recommend clarifications of variables, source selection, analysis code, materials, protocol deviations or access conditions. Requests for sensitive or identifiable underlying records should be handled through authorized editorial channels and limited to what is necessary, lawful, proportionate and ethically permissible. A reviewer is not entitled to obtain confidential data for independent use merely by participating in peer review.
审稿人可建议澄清变量、来源筛选、分析代码、研究材料、方案偏离或访问条件。涉及敏感或可识别底层资料的请求,应经授权编辑渠道处理,并限定于必要、合法、相称且符合伦理的范围。审稿人不能仅因参与同行评议,就取得为个人用途使用保密数据的权利。
Confidential submissions, datasets, tables, images, legal files, peer-review correspondence and unpublished code must not be copied, circulated, exploited or uploaded to unauthorized third-party services, including public AI platforms. Editors may request reasonable additional evidence or independent expertise where needed while preserving the journal’s double-blind review arrangements and editorial independence.
保密稿件、数据集、表格、图像、法律文件、评审往来及未发表代码,不得被擅自复制、传播、利用或上传至未经授权的第三方服务,包括公共 AI 平台。编辑可在必要时要求合理的补充证据或独立专业意见,同时维护本刊的双盲评审制度及编辑独立性。
15. Editorial Assessment and Possible Actions / 编辑评估与可能措施
JLPCS may request clarification or revision when a data availability statement is absent, inaccurate, inconsistent with the paper, or insufficient to explain how evidence was obtained and analyzed. The journal may ask for a better source list, code documentation, methodological description, confirmation of access restrictions, or supporting records that can lawfully be reviewed. Such requests are considered in the context of the article’s disciplinary methods and actual research design.
当数据可得性声明缺失、不准确、与稿件矛盾,或不足以解释证据如何取得与分析时,JLPCS 可要求补充或修订说明。本刊可要求更完整的来源清单、代码文档、方法描述、访问限制依据,或能够合法核查的支持性记录。相关请求须结合文章所属学科及实际研究设计判断。
Where credible concerns about fabricated data, altered records, unsupported conclusions or other integrity problems arise, editors may seek a factual explanation, ask for appropriate evidence, consult independent expertise, and pause the relevant editorial stage while the matter is evaluated. A limitation on lawful data sharing is not in itself evidence of misconduct; a substantive decision must rest on the nature of the concern and the available record.
若出现有关伪造数据、篡改记录、缺乏证据的结论或其他诚信问题的可信疑虑,编辑可要求事实说明、核查适当证据、咨询独立专家,并在调查期间暂停相关编辑流程。合法的数据共享限制本身并不构成学术不端证据;实质性决定必须依据具体疑虑与可用材料。
When the published record requires action, a correction, expression of concern or retraction may be considered under the journal’s established post-publication procedures, taking account of the reliability of the article, the response of relevant parties and the seriousness of the issue. The Research Integrity and Corrections, Retractions & Expressions of Concern policies provide the broader framework.
当已发表学术记录需要采取措施时,可依据本刊既有出版后程序,结合文章可靠性、相关当事人的说明及问题严重程度,考虑更正、关注声明或撤稿。有关较完整的处理框架,请参阅Research Integrity(研究诚信)及Corrections, Retractions & Expressions of Concern(更正、撤稿与关注声明)。
16. Author Checklist / 作者检查清单
Before submitting, authors should confirm that their statements and supporting documentation accurately represent the study. The checklist assists preparation and does not override legitimate ethical or legal restrictions.
投稿前,作者应核对声明及支持文件是否真实反映研究状况。本清单用于协助准备稿件,不得凌驾于合理的伦理或法律限制之上。
| No. / 序号 | Checklist item / 核对事项 |
|---|---|
| 11 | The manuscript contains an accurate Data Availability Statement appropriate to the article type.稿件包含与文章类型相符且内容准确的数据可得性声明。 |
| 22 | The statement identifies which data, code, materials, or sources are public, restricted, available on request, included in the article, or genuinely not applicable.声明区分公开、受限、可请求获取、文中已有及真正不适用的数据、代码、材料或来源。 |
| 33 | Privacy, consent, confidentiality, legal, contractual, platform, institutional and intellectual-property restrictions are described without revealing protected information.已说明隐私、同意、保密、法律、合同、平台、机构及知识产权限制,同时避免披露受保护信息。 |
| 44 | Research design, sources, legal authorities, methods, analytical decisions, software and limitations are described sufficiently for relevant scholarly assessment.研究设计、资料来源、法律依据、方法、分析决定、软件及局限足以支持相应的学术评价。 |
| 55 | Code, instruments, source selection rules, supplementary documentation or other verification materials are identified and shared when ethically and legally feasible.已说明代码、工具、来源筛选规则、补充说明或其他核验材料,并在伦理及法律许可时进行共享。 |
| 66 | Confidential, personal, sensitive, restricted or third-party data are not disclosed contrary to law, consent or permissions.未违反法律、同意范围或使用许可而披露保密、个人、敏感、受限或第三方数据。 |
| 77 | Material AI assistance in data processing, coding, translation, transcription, summarization or analysis is accurately disclosed and verified.对数据处理、编码、翻译、转录、摘要或分析中的实质性 AI 协助,已准确披露并核验。 |
| 88 | The authors can explain data provenance, research decisions and justified access restrictions when legitimate editorial questions arise.面对合理的编辑问题,作者能够解释数据来源、研究决定及正当的访问限制。 |
17. Contact and Related Policies / 联系方式与相关政策
For questions about data availability statements, research transparency, reproducibility, supplementary files, data restrictions, code sharing or data-related integrity concerns, contact the JLPCS Editorial Office at [email protected]. Formal manuscripts must be submitted through the journal's online submission system; email correspondence is not a substitute for an official submission record.
有关数据可得性声明、研究透明度、可重现性、补充文件、数据限制、代码共享或数据相关的研究诚信问题,可联系 JLPCS 编辑部:[email protected]。正式稿件应通过本刊在线投稿系统提交,不能以电子邮件往来替代正式投稿记录。
Detailed related requirements are available in the Instructions for Authors, Human Subjects & Informed Consent, Repository Policy, AI Use Policy and Publication Ethics. Where issues overlap, the relevant specialized policy provides additional detail.
相关具体要求参阅Instructions for Authors(作者指南)、Human Subjects & Informed Consent(人类研究参与者与知情同意)、Repository Policy(作者存档政策)、AI Use Policy(AI 使用政策)和Publication Ethics(出版伦理政策)。涉及不同政策交叉适用时,应结合相应专门政策理解具体要求。
Important Note / 重要说明
Data availability does not mean that every dataset must be public. JLPCS encourages openness proportionate to the type of research and subject to the rights, safety and confidentiality of participants and third parties. Transparency also depends on honest disclosure of evidence, methods, restrictions and limitations. Authors must not expose personal or protected information in the name of reproducibility, and should not claim that restricted data can be supplied when they lack permission to do so.
数据可得性不等于所有数据都必须公开。JLPCS 鼓励与研究类型相称的开放实践,同时尊重参与者及第三方的权利、安全和保密利益。透明度还取决于对证据、方法、限制和局限的真实说明。作者不得以可重现性为由公开个人或受保护信息,也不得在缺乏授权时承诺提供受限数据。