Editorial Decision Process
The Journal of Law, Psychology, and Communication Studies (JLPCS) makes editorial decisions through an independent, evidence-based process that considers the suitability, originality, scholarly merit and ethical integrity of each submission. This policy explains who is responsible for decisions, how peer-review evidence is weighed, the meaning of each decision category, and how revisions, concerns and appeals are handled.
《法律·心理学·传播研究学刊》(JLPCS)依照独立、透明且以证据为基础的程序作出编辑决定,综合考量稿件的范围适配性、原创性、学术质量与研究伦理。本政策说明决定权责、审稿意见的使用方式、各类决定的含义,以及修改、伦理疑虑和申诉的处理原则。
1. Decision-Making Principles and Responsibility / 编辑决定的原则与责任
Editorial decisions are based on the research question and contribution, relevance to the journal’s aims and scope, originality, methodological or doctrinal rigor, quality and verifiability of evidence, analytical soundness, transparency, clarity and compliance with applicable research and publication ethics. The weight assigned to each consideration depends on the manuscript type and discipline: legal analysis, psychological research, communication studies and interdisciplinary work are evaluated against methods appropriate to their respective questions.
The responsible handling editor, operating under the journal’s editorial arrangements, makes or communicates decisions on the basis of the complete editorial record. Reviewer recommendations are expert advice rather than votes that automatically determine acceptance or rejection. Neither a favorable review nor completion of all review stages guarantees acceptance. The editor must consider substantive concerns, reviewer reasoning, author responses and any unresolved integrity issues before reaching a judgment.
JLPCS evaluates submissions without regard to the authors’ nationality, gender, institutional affiliation, academic rank, professional status or ability to pay publication charges. The journal’s accepted distinction between externally reviewed scholarly manuscripts and editorially assessed Editorial Materials also applies to editorial decisions; materials not subject to external peer review are not represented as externally reviewed research.
编辑决定以研究问题与贡献、期刊宗旨及收稿范围、原创性、研究方法或法学论证的严谨性、证据的可靠性与可核验性、分析质量、信息透明度、学术表达及适用伦理规范为依据。不同类型稿件采用与其学科及研究设计相称的评价标准,不以单一实证方法衡量所有法学、心理学、传播学或跨学科研究。
负责编辑根据完整编辑记录作出或传达决定。审稿意见属于专业咨询意见,不是自动决定录用或拒稿的投票结果;有利的评审报告或完成评审流程本身均不保证录用。编辑须综合审稿意见的实质依据、作者回应及未解决的研究诚信问题作出判断。
编辑决定不受作者国籍、性别、所属机构、学术职称、专业身份或支付能力影响。对适用外部同行评议的学术稿件与仅接受编辑评估的 Editorial Materials,本刊采用相应的处理程序,不将未经外审的编辑材料表述为经过外部同行评议的研究论文。
2. Stages of Editorial Decision-Making / 编辑决策阶段
Decision-making begins at submission and may continue across screening, external review, revision and final assessment. The stages below describe the journal’s established editorial route; a manuscript may be returned or declined at an earlier stage if it does not meet the applicable requirements.
编辑决策从投稿开始,可能经过文件检查、编辑初审、外部评审、作者修改及最终评估。下列阶段说明本刊的主要工作路径;不符合条件的稿件可在较早阶段被退回或拒绝,并非所有稿件都必须经历全部步骤。
| Stage / 阶段 | Editorial assessment and next step / 评估内容与后续处理 |
|---|---|
| 1. Submission and technical check 投稿与技术检查 |
The editorial office checks required files, submission metadata, author declarations, anonymity, readable formatting and completeness.
编辑部核查所需文件、投稿元数据、作者声明、匿名化、文件可读性及完整性。 |
| 2. Editorial screening 编辑学术初审 |
The editor assesses scope, scholarly contribution, originality, ethical documentation, methodological or legal reasoning and suitability for external assessment.
负责编辑评估范围适配性、学术贡献、原创性、伦理材料、研究方法或法律论证以及外审适宜性。 |
| 3. Research integrity consideration 研究诚信核查 |
Concerns about source attribution, duplication, data, citations or other integrity matters are considered in context. Any similarity report is supporting information, not an automatic numerical decision rule.
结合具体来源、重复使用情况、数据和引文证据审查诚信疑虑。相似度报告仅是辅助材料,不采用自动数值判定。 |
| 4. External peer review, when applicable 适用时外部同行评议 |
Eligible scholarly manuscripts are normally assessed by at least two independent experts using the journal’s double-blind process. Editorial Materials follow their own editorial assessment route.
符合条件的学术稿件通常由至少两名独立专家进行双盲同行评议;编辑材料按照其适用的编辑评估程序处理。 |
| 5. Evaluation and revision 综合评估与修改 |
The editor considers the review reports and may request clarification, revision, an additional opinion or further assessment before deciding.
编辑综合审稿报告,必要时要求澄清、修改、增加独立意见或进一步评估。 |
| 6. Decision and communication 决定及通知 |
The editorial office communicates the decision and the next steps. Formal acceptance is distinguished from a request for revision or an invitation to submit a new manuscript.
编辑部传达决定及后续要求,明确区分正式录用、修改后继续评估及重新投稿。 |
3. Editorial Decision Categories / 编辑决定的类别
JLPCS uses the five decision categories below in its editorial guidance. Their significance lies in the action required and the status of the manuscript; none of the revision or resubmission categories constitutes an acceptance decision.
JLPCS 的编辑指引采用以下五类决定。各类别的关键区别在于稿件状态及作者下一步需要采取的行动;修改或重投均不等于录用。
| Decision / 决定 | Meaning and author action / 含义与作者行动 |
|---|---|
| Accept 录用 |
The manuscript has received a formal positive editorial decision and proceeds to required copyediting, production, licensing, metadata, author verification and publication checks. Acceptance does not mean all production work has been completed.
稿件获得正式录用决定,进入文字编辑、制作、许可、元数据、作者信息及出版前核查。录用不代表所有制作工作已完成。 |
| Minor Revision 小修 |
Targeted changes or clarification are required. The editor evaluates the response and may decide directly or seek further expert input. The outcome remains open.
稿件需进行有限且明确的修改或澄清;编辑可直接评估修改情况或征求进一步意见,结果尚未确定。 |
| Major Revision 大修 |
Substantial changes to argument, evidence, methodology, legal analysis, interpretation or structure are needed. Revised work may undergo another review round, and acceptance is not assured.
稿件在论证、证据、研究方法、法律分析、解释或结构方面需要实质修改,可能再次外审,不保证最终录用。 |
| Reject and Encourage Resubmission 拒稿后鼓励重新投稿 |
The current submission is closed because the changes needed exceed ordinary revision. Authors may prepare a substantially redesigned paper and submit it as a new submission, which is assessed independently and has no promised outcome.
原投稿因需要重大重新设计而被拒绝;作者可将实质重构后的稿件作为新投稿提交,新稿重新接受独立评估,不预先保证送审或录用。 |
| Reject 拒稿 |
The manuscript will not proceed to publication under the current submission. Reasons may include scope mismatch, insufficient scholarly contribution, methodological or evidential problems, unresolved ethical concerns or other substantial deficiencies.
当前稿件不予录用,原因可能包括范围不符、学术贡献不足、方法或证据问题、尚未解决的伦理疑虑或其他重大缺陷。 |
Editorial clarification: “Reject and Encourage Resubmission” is a rejection of the existing submission, not an assurance that a later manuscript will be reviewed or accepted. “Minor Revision” and “Major Revision” likewise require further editorial assessment.
编辑说明:“拒稿后鼓励重新投稿”意味着当前投稿已被拒绝,不保证未来新稿送审或录用;“小修”和“大修”也都需要进一步编辑评估。
4. Return Before Review and Desk Rejection / 送审前退回与编辑初审拒稿
A technical return and a desk rejection have different implications. A technical return asks authors to correct missing files, insufficient anonymization, incomplete metadata or other remediable submission defects. Desk rejection is a substantive editorial judgment that the manuscript should not proceed to external review in its current form. In either case, the communication should identify the main reason with sufficient clarity to guide the author’s next step.
Reasons for pre-review action can include a topic outside JLPCS’s scope, an insufficiently developed research question or contribution, inappropriate or inadequately explained methods, unsupported arguments, unverifiable legal or empirical sources, serious problems with references or presentation, failure to meet required ethics and disclosure obligations, or indications of duplicate submission, plagiarism or improper reuse.
Where source overlap or possible misconduct is suspected, the editor considers the source texts, the nature and extent of reuse, attribution, quotation, legitimate methodological repetition and the surrounding evidence. JLPCS does not apply a fixed similarity-percentage threshold as an automatic basis for acceptance, rejection or progression to review. Software-generated similarity scores, if available, require contextual examination and are not findings of misconduct in themselves.
技术性退回与初审拒稿应明确区分。技术性退回通常要求作者补齐文件、完成匿名化、修改元数据或纠正其他可修复的投稿缺陷;初审拒稿则是编辑认为稿件现阶段不宜进入外部评议的实质性决定。通知应充分说明主要原因,以便作者理解后续处理方式。
送审前处理可能涉及范围不符、研究问题或学术贡献不足、方法说明不充分、论证缺乏依据、法律或实证材料无法核验、引用与表达存在严重问题、适用的伦理或披露材料缺失,以及一稿多投、抄袭或不当重用等疑虑。
涉及文本重合或学术不端疑虑时,编辑应核对原始来源、重用的性质与程度、引用和引号使用情况、方法描述中合理的重复以及其他具体证据。本刊不以固定相似度百分比自动判定稿件能否进入评审或是否存在不端;任何相似度软件报告如被使用,也必须结合上下文进行专业判断。
5. Use of Peer Review Reports and Disagreements / 审稿报告的使用与意见分歧
Reviewers assess the scholarly merits and limitations of a submission, but editorial responsibility is not delegated to them. The handling editor considers whether each report identifies verifiable concerns, explains their significance, evaluates evidence consistently and distinguishes fundamental problems from optional improvements. The number of favorable or unfavorable recommendations does not replace substantive editorial judgment.
When expert reports conflict, the editor can compare the underlying evidence, ask the reviewers to clarify their reasoning, seek an additional independent assessment, or determine that the existing record is sufficient for a reasoned decision. In particular, disagreements about statistical interpretation, legal authority, qualitative analysis or ethical safeguards should be addressed on their merits rather than resolved solely by counting recommendations.
Reviews communicated to authors should preserve scientifically material criticism while respecting reviewer confidentiality and professional standards. Editorial clarification or removal of offensive, identifying or irrelevant remarks does not imply that substantive concerns have been dismissed. Authors should receive clear explanations of issues requiring revision.
审稿人提供专业评价,但编辑不能将最终决定权简单转交审稿人。负责编辑应评估各报告是否指出可核验的问题、说明其重要性、合理解释证据,并区分影响研究结论的核心缺陷与可选择的改进建议。赞成与反对意见的数量不能代替实质判断。
当审稿意见存在明显分歧时,编辑可比较其证据基础、要求审稿人澄清、邀请其他独立专家,或依据充分的现有材料作出有理由的决定。统计解释、法律依据、质性分析或伦理保护方面的争议,应根据具体学术问题解决,而非简单统计审稿建议。
向作者传达的审稿意见应保留重要学术批评,同时维护审稿人保密与专业沟通要求。必要的文字整理或删除攻击性、泄露身份及无关内容,不代表编辑忽略实质问题。作者应能够明确理解需要解决的主要问题。
6. Revision Decisions, Responses and Re-Review / 修改决定、作者回复与复审
A request for revision is an opportunity for further consideration, not a conditional acceptance. Authors should respond to every substantive editorial and reviewer concern in a reasoned, point-by-point letter, identify the corresponding changes in the manuscript, and explain respectfully when a particular suggestion has not been adopted. The revised manuscript should preserve the anonymization required for any further double-blind review.
A revision package ordinarily includes a clean revised manuscript, a marked version if requested, a detailed response letter, and updated references, data, analyses or disclosures where the changes affect them. Where concerns involve research ethics, informed consent, provenance of legal material, data integrity, author contributions or AI use, the response should provide the clarification or supporting material necessary for editorial evaluation.
Minor revisions may be examined by the editor; major revisions may return to one or more original reviewers or be assessed by additional independent experts. The editor determines whether further evaluation is needed. More than one round of revision can be requested, and an unresolved material concern may lead to rejection even after extensive revision.
修改决定表示稿件可以在回应问题后继续接受评估,并非附条件录用。作者应通过逐条回复信回应所有实质意见,准确标明修改位置,并在未采纳建议时提供有依据且尊重专业意见的解释。如修改稿仍需双盲送审,必须继续保持匿名。
修改材料通常包括清洁版稿件、编辑要求时的修订标记版、逐条回复信,以及因修改受到影响的参考文献、数据、分析或声明。涉及研究伦理、知情同意、法律资料来源、数据诚信、作者贡献或 AI 使用的问题,应提供必要解释与可核验材料。
小修稿可由编辑直接评估;大修稿可送回原审稿人或交由新邀请的独立专家复审。是否需要再次评审,由编辑根据具体问题判断。稿件可能经历多轮修改;若重要问题仍未解决,修改后仍可能被拒绝。
7. Formal Acceptance and Publication Preparation / 正式录用与出版准备
An article is formally accepted only when the responsible editor or editorial office issues an acceptance decision. Earlier communications inviting revision, requesting additional documents or indicating that the work is promising must not be interpreted as an acceptance notice. After formal acceptance, editorial and production staff verify the information needed to prepare an accurate and legally compliant publication record.
Post-acceptance work can include confirmation of authors’ names, affiliations, corresponding-author information and ORCID iDs; checks of citations, references, tables, figures, supplementary materials and publication metadata; clarification of copyright, licenses and third-party permissions; copyediting; typesetting; author proof review; and assignment to the appropriate issue. These steps serve to prepare the accepted work for publication and do not replace the preceding scholarly assessment.
JLPCS does not charge a submission or peer review fee. The Article Processing Charge is dealt with following formal acceptance under the journal’s separate fee policy. Any applicable waiver consideration is handled separately from scholarly review and editorial decision-making.
只有负责编辑或编辑部正式发出录用决定,稿件才视为被录用。此前的修改邀请、资料补充要求或积极评价不能理解为录用通知。正式录用后,编辑与制作人员核查出版记录所需的信息与权利事项。
出版准备可包括作者姓名、单位、通讯作者及 ORCID 信息确认,文献、表图、补充材料和出版元数据检查,版权、许可及第三方材料授权核实,文字编辑、排版、作者校样以及期号安排。这些步骤用于确保出版记录准确、完整,不取代先前的学术评审。
JLPCS 不收取投稿费或同行评议费。文章处理费按照独立费用政策在正式录用后处理,适用的费用减免问题与学术审查及录用决定相互独立。
8. Ethical and Research Integrity Concerns / 伦理与研究诚信疑虑
Concerns about possible misconduct or serious ethical deficiencies may arise during screening, review, revision, production or after publication. These issues are assessed separately from routine judgments about scholarly quality. Editors should examine the available evidence, identify what requires clarification, respect confidentiality and avoid treating an unverified allegation or a similarity score as proof of misconduct.
Relevant concerns include plagiarism, undisclosed duplicate or overlapping publication, fabricated or falsified data, manipulated images, fabricated references, inaccurate quotation of legal authorities, absent ethics approval or consent where required, inappropriate disclosure of personal or sensitive data, concealed conflicts of interest, authorship disputes, undisclosed AI-assisted content and missing permissions for third-party material.
The editorial office may seek clarification or supporting evidence from the author, obtain additional expert input, or defer a decision while a substantive issue is evaluated. The appropriate course depends on the nature of the concern and the journal’s established ethics policies; any necessary post-publication action belongs under the journal’s publication-ethics and correction policies rather than being presumed from a review-stage decision alone.
学术不端或重大伦理疑虑可能在初审、同行评议、修改、出版制作乃至发表后出现,处理时应与一般学术质量判断相区分。编辑应审查现有证据、明确需要澄清的问题、维护保密性,不能把未经核实的指控或单一相似度分数直接视为不端事实。
相关问题包括抄袭、未披露的重复或重叠发表、数据伪造或篡改、图像操纵、虚构引文、法律权威资料的不准确引述、必要伦理审批或知情同意缺失、个人或敏感信息不当披露、隐瞒利益冲突、作者署名争议、未披露的不当 AI 使用,以及第三方材料授权不足。
编辑部可向作者要求解释与支持材料、征求额外专业意见,或在实质问题核实期间暂缓决定。具体做法应依据问题性质及本刊已公布的出版伦理政策;发表后的更正或撤稿等处理应遵循相应独立程序,不由审稿阶段的单一判断自动推导。
9. Appeals, Complaints and Reconsideration / 申诉、投诉与重新评估
Authors who believe an editorial decision rests on a material factual error, a significant misunderstanding of the manuscript, a procedural irregularity or a demonstrable conflict of interest may write to the JLPCS Editorial Office to request reconsideration. An appeal should distinguish evidence of an error in the decision process from ordinary disagreement with an expert’s academic judgment. A request for reconsideration does not itself suspend or reverse the original decision.
Authors should identify the manuscript title and submission ID, the decision at issue, the precise grounds for the appeal, and supporting evidence, together with a concise, professional explanation addressing the relevant editorial or reviewer comments. Under the journal’s separately published Complaints & Appeals Policy, an appeal should be submitted within 30 days after the relevant decision or notice is communicated. Late appeals may be considered only if a reasonable explanation for delay and evidence warranting further assessment are provided. Where appropriate, an independent editor or panel not directly responsible for the original decision evaluates the appeal; clarification or additional expert advice can be sought before an outcome is communicated. The detailed procedure is governed by that dedicated policy.
Complaints concerning confidentiality, undisclosed conflicts, inappropriate reviewer or editor conduct, unfair procedures or administrative communication may likewise be reported to the editorial office. Such concerns should be described factually and supported by relevant correspondence or documentation. The journal should handle them consistently with its publication-ethics obligations while protecting the confidentiality of parties and unpublished work.
作者如认为编辑决定依据重大事实错误、对稿件的重要误解、程序异常或有证据支持的利益冲突作出,可以联系 JLPCS 编辑部申请重新审查。申诉应明确区分决定程序或事实基础存在错误,与单纯不同意专家的学术判断。提交申诉并不自动中止或推翻原决定。
作者应提供稿件题名、投稿编号、所申诉的决定、具体申诉理由及相关证据,并以专业、简明的方式回应涉及的编辑或审稿意见。根据本刊另行公布的《投诉与申诉政策》,申诉应在有关决定或通知送达后 30 天内提交;逾期申诉只有在申请人提供合理延迟解释及足以支持进一步审查的相关证据时,才可酌情考虑。适当情况下,可由未直接作出原决定的独立编辑或编辑小组评估申诉,并在必要时要求澄清或征求额外专家意见。具体处理程序以独立政策为准。
有关保密泄露、未披露利益冲突、审稿人或编辑不当行为、程序公正性及行政沟通的投诉,也可向编辑部提出。投诉应以事实为基础并附上相关通信或证据;处理时应遵循本刊出版伦理责任,并保护有关人员和未发表稿件的保密性。
10. Editorial Independence, Conflicts and Confidentiality / 编辑独立性、利益冲突与保密
Editorial judgments must remain independent of the publisher’s fee administration and of authors’ institutional status, personal characteristics, funding arrangements or capacity to pay. APC payment or waiver applications are not criteria for whether a manuscript is invited for review, revised, accepted or rejected. Decisions should be defensible by reference to the scholarly record and applicable journal policies.
Editors and reviewers must disclose actual, potential or reasonably perceived conflicts of interest affecting impartiality. Such conflicts can arise through close personal or supervisory relationships, recent collaboration, direct competition, financial interests or involvement in the work under consideration. If a conflict compromises independent assessment, the matter should be handled by an appropriate unconflicted editor or reviewer consistent with the journal’s peer-review policy.
Submitted manuscripts, reviewer identities, confidential reports, editorial correspondence and non-public deliberations must be protected. Authors receive the editorial decision and appropriate review comments without unauthorized disclosure of reviewer identities or private editorial material. Information obtained through manuscript handling may not be used for personal or professional advantage.
编辑判断须独立于出版费用管理、作者所属机构、个人特征、资助安排或支付能力。APC 缴纳及费用减免申请均不是决定稿件送审、修改、录用或拒稿的标准。每项决定均应能够依据学术记录和适用期刊政策加以解释。
编辑与审稿人应披露任何实际、潜在或可能被合理认为影响公正性的利益冲突,包括密切私人或指导关系、近期合作、直接学术竞争、经济利益,以及对受审研究的既有参与。如利益冲突妨碍独立判断,应按照本刊同行评议政策交由不存在相应冲突的人员处理。
投稿稿件、审稿人身份、保密评审报告、编辑通信和未公开的决策讨论均应受到保护。作者可以获知编辑决定和适当的审稿意见,但不得因此获得未经授权的审稿人身份或内部保密资料。参与稿件处理所获信息不得用于个人或专业利益。
11. Decision Letters, Communication and Records / 决定通知、沟通与编辑记录
An editorial decision letter should identify the outcome and, when further action is required, explain the main issues and next step clearly enough for authors to respond. For revision decisions, the communication may include reviewer comments and specific editorial priorities, along with instructions and any deadline set for that submission. For desk rejections, a concise explanation of the principal scope, quality or compliance concern helps distinguish a definitive decision from a correctable technical return.
Substantive author correspondence and revision responses should be sent through the journal’s online submission system so that the responsible editors can review the relevant record. Questions about a received decision can be directed to the editorial office; authors should supply the submission ID and manuscript title when available. Reviewers’ identities and confidential internal assessments remain protected throughout these communications.
The editorial record should support consistency and accountability: decisions are considered in the context of submissions, reviewer reports where applicable, author responses, identified ethical concerns and the reasoned editorial assessment. A documented decision process does not imply that every internal discussion or confidential report will be publicly released.
编辑决定信应明确告知处理结果;需要作者采取后续行动时,应清楚说明主要问题与下一步要求。修改决定可附审稿意见、编辑优先处理事项、该次投稿适用的提交说明及期限;初审拒稿则宜简明解释主要范围、质量或合规问题,以区别于可以修正的技术性退回。
与稿件相关的实质性通信及修改回复应通过本刊在线投稿系统提交,便于负责编辑查阅完整记录。作者对决定有疑问时,可以联系编辑部,并尽可能提供投稿编号和稿件题名;审稿人身份及保密的内部意见在沟通过程中仍须受到保护。
编辑记录应支持决策一致性与责任追溯,综合保存与处理投稿、适用的审稿报告、作者回复、伦理疑虑及编辑判断有关的信息。记录完整并不意味着内部讨论或保密报告需要向公众公开。
12. Editorial Decision Timelines / 编辑决定时间说明
The time required for screening, review, revisions and final decisions varies according to manuscript complexity, reviewer availability, the extent of requested changes, the need for additional independent assessment and any ethical or technical questions. The journal maintains a separate Review Timeline page containing its currently published estimated stages. Those estimates are planning information, not guarantees of a decision or acceptance by a particular date.
Authors should consult the current status in the journal’s online submission system and the instructions in their decision letter. If a review or decision appears substantially delayed, the corresponding author may contact the editorial office with the manuscript title, submission ID and relevant dates. This page does not duplicate numerical turnaround estimates that are maintained in the dedicated timeline policy.
编辑初审、同行评议、作者修改及最终决定所需时间,取决于稿件复杂程度、审稿人可用性、修改幅度、是否需要额外独立评估,以及伦理或技术问题。本刊另设 Review Timeline(评审时间表) 页面公布各阶段预计时间。预计时间仅用于流程参考,不构成在固定日期决定或录用的承诺。
作者应优先查看在线投稿系统中的稿件状态及决定信所列要求。若实际处理时间显著超过预期,通讯作者可提供稿件题名、投稿编号和相关日期联系编辑部。本页不重复独立时间政策中的具体周数,以免不同栏目更新后出现冲突。
Current timing guidance: Review Timeline / 评审时间表
13. Submission, Contact and Related Policies / 投稿、联系方式与相关政策
Editorial decisions operate within the journal’s broader author, peer review, integrity and publication framework. Authors should consult the relevant dedicated page for detailed preparation requirements, double-blind review safeguards, publication ethics, current processing estimates and article processing charges, rather than treating this decision policy as a substitute for those documents.
编辑决定须与本刊作者指南、同行评议、出版伦理和费用制度相协调。稿件准备、双盲评审保护、伦理要求、时间估计及文章处理费的详细规定,以相应独立政策页面为准;本页不替代这些专门文件。
Official submission: Authors should submit and track manuscripts through the journal’s online submission system. Editorial decision, revision and status inquiries may be addressed to the JLPCS Editorial Office at [email protected].
正式投稿: 作者应通过本刊在线投稿系统提交并追踪稿件。有关编辑决定、修改或稿件状态的咨询,可联系 JLPCS 编辑部:[email protected]。
Important: A favorable peer-review report, revision invitation or request for production information is not equivalent to formal acceptance. Only an explicit editorial acceptance decision establishes the manuscript’s accepted status.
重要说明:积极的审稿意见、修改邀请或出版资料补充要求均不等于正式录用。只有明确的编辑部录用决定,才表示稿件已获得录用。