These guidelines define the responsibilities, ethical expectations, scholarly evaluation criteria, confidentiality safeguards and review-reporting standards for reviewers of the Journal of Law, Psychology, and Communication Studies (JLPCS). They complement the journal’s double-blind peer review policy and are intended to support independent, constructive, evidence-based evaluation across law, psychology, communication studies and interdisciplinary research.

本指南明确《法律·心理学·传播研究学刊》(JLPCS)审稿人的职责、伦理要求、学术评价标准、保密措施及审稿报告规范,并与本刊双盲同行评议政策相衔接。相关要求旨在支持对法学、心理学、传播学及交叉学科研究开展独立、建设性且以证据为基础的学术评价。

1. Role and Scope of Peer Reviewers / 审稿人的角色与评审范围

Reviewers provide independent expert advice to inform editorial decisions and, where revision is possible, to help authors strengthen their work. Their role is to evaluate the manuscript’s scholarly contribution, conceptual and methodological rigor, use of relevant sources, transparency, ethical integrity and clarity of presentation. A review is an assessment of the submitted work, not an evaluation of the author’s status, identity or institutional reputation.

审稿人通过独立的专业判断为编辑决定提供依据,并在稿件可以修改时帮助作者提升研究质量。评审应考察稿件的学术贡献、概念与方法严谨性、相关资料的使用、研究透明度、伦理完整性及表达质量。评审对象是稿件本身,而非作者的身份、资历或所属机构声誉。

JLPCS uses double-blind review for eligible scholarly manuscripts. Reviewers are expected to protect author anonymity and to keep their own identity confidential. The editor may invite reviewers whose expertise addresses different aspects of an interdisciplinary paper; a reviewer should identify any part of the manuscript that falls outside their competence rather than offer unsupported judgments.

JLPCS 对符合条件的学术稿件采用双盲评审。审稿人应保护作者身份的匿名性,并维护自身身份的保密性。对于交叉学科稿件,编辑可能邀请具备不同专业背景的审稿人分别评价相关部分;审稿人应明确说明超出自身专业能力的内容,避免作出缺乏依据的判断。

Reviewer recommendations are advisory. The responsible editor considers the complete editorial record, independent reports, journal scope and research integrity when making a decision; reviewers do not independently accept or reject manuscripts.

审稿人的建议属于咨询性意见。负责编辑综合完整编辑记录、独立评审报告、期刊收稿范围及研究诚信情况作出决定;审稿人不直接决定稿件的录用或拒绝。

2. Before Accepting a Review Invitation / 接受审稿邀请前的审查

An invitation should be accepted only when the prospective reviewer can deliver a competent, impartial, confidential and reasonably timely assessment. The invitation and any accompanying abstract or manuscript information are themselves confidential. Reviewers should respond through the editorial channel specified in the invitation and notify the editorial office promptly if they are unable to take on the assignment.

审稿人只有在能够提供胜任、公正、保密且可在合理期限内完成的评审时,才应接受邀请。审稿邀请及其所附摘要或稿件资料本身也属于保密信息。审稿人应通过邀请中指定的编辑渠道回复;无法承担评审任务时,应尽早通知编辑部。

  • Subject competence: Confirm sufficient knowledge of the manuscript’s disciplinary subject, theory, methodological approach and evidentiary base. 专业胜任能力:确认能够理解并评价稿件的学科问题、理论、研究方法及证据基础。
  • Independence: Consider actual, potential or reasonably perceived conflicts of interest, even if the author’s identity is not disclosed. 评审独立性:即使作者身份未公开,也应审查是否存在实际、潜在或可被合理认为存在的利益冲突。
  • Availability: Check that the agreed review period is realistic and promptly communicate any limitation. 时间安排:确认能够遵守约定的审稿期限,并及时说明可能影响进度的情况。
  • Confidentiality: Do not forward the invitation, abstract or files to colleagues, students or assistants without editorial authorization. 保密责任:未经编辑部授权,不得将审稿邀请、摘要或文件转交同事、学生或助理。
  • Partial expertise: Tell the editor when specialist legal, statistical, clinical, qualitative or computational evaluation is required beyond your competence. 专业局限:当稿件所涉法律、统计、临床、质性或计算研究内容超出自身能力时,应告知编辑。

3. Confidentiality and Protection of Manuscript Materials / 保密义务与稿件材料保护

A manuscript under review, including its data, legal reasoning, unpublished findings, supplementary materials and editorial correspondence, is confidential. Reviewers must use that information solely to perform the authorized review. They must not disclose, distribute, quote, cite or otherwise exploit unpublished material for personal scholarship, commercial activities, professional advantage, litigation, policy advocacy or competition.

评审中的稿件及其数据、法律论证、未发表发现、补充材料和编辑沟通记录均属于保密信息。审稿人只能为获授权的评审目的使用这些资料,不得向外披露、传播、引用或利用未发表内容谋取个人研究、商业、职业、诉讼、政策倡议或竞争利益。

Reviewers must not share manuscript files with other people, upload them to public systems or third-party platforms, or retain and repurpose them beyond the authorized reviewing process without permission. If a reviewer believes consultation with another specialist is necessary, they must ask the responsible editor first. Reviewers should not directly contact authors, search deliberately for author identities, or disclose their own identities in the report.

未经许可,审稿人不得将稿件文件分享给他人、上传至公共系统或第三方平台,也不得在获授权评审范围之外留存或重新利用有关资料。如确需咨询其他专业人员,应先征得负责编辑同意。审稿人不应直接联系作者、故意查找作者身份,亦不应在审稿报告中暴露自身身份。

Any accidental disclosure, misplaced review file, compromised account, unauthorized sharing or other confidentiality incident should be reported to the editorial office without delay. The editor will evaluate the implications and determine the appropriate response under the journal’s published review and ethics policies.

如发生意外披露、审稿文件遗失、账户安全受损、未经授权的文件传播或其他保密事件,审稿人应及时通知编辑部。编辑将依据期刊公布的评审与伦理政策评估影响并确定适当处理方式。

4. Conflicts of Interest and Recusal / 利益冲突披露与回避

Reviewers must disclose circumstances that could influence, or reasonably appear to influence, their impartiality. Conflicts are not limited to direct financial interests: recent collaboration, personal or family ties, employment or supervisory relationships, competitive interests, involvement in the research being evaluated, and strongly held advocacy positions may also be relevant. A double-blind process does not remove the duty to declare a conflict that becomes apparent from the subject matter or other circumstances.

审稿人必须披露可能影响或被合理认为影响公正判断的情况。利益冲突并不限于直接经济关系;近期合作、亲属或私人关系、雇佣或指导关系、学术竞争、参与被评研究,以及与稿件有关的强烈倡议立场,也可能构成需要披露的利益关系。双盲制度并不免除审稿人在研究主题或其他情况下发现利益冲突后主动披露的义务。

  • Recent or ongoing research, publication, grant or professional collaboration with a potentially identifiable author or team. 与可能识别出的作者或团队近期或正在进行的研究、发表、基金或职业合作。
  • Personal, family, employment, institutional, teaching, supervision, mentoring or former-student relationships. 私人、家庭、雇佣、机构、教学、指导、导师或曾经的学生关系。
  • Financial, commercial, legal, political, policy or advocacy interests connected with the subject. 与研究主题有关的经济、商业、法律、政治、政策或倡议利益。
  • Direct academic competition, strong personal bias or prior participation in the manuscript, case, dataset or research project. 直接学术竞争、强烈个人偏见,或曾参与稿件、案例、数据集或研究项目。
  • Possession of confidential information that could affect impartiality or create an unfair advantage. 持有可能影响公正性或造成不公平优势的保密信息。

A reviewer should decline the invitation or seek editorial guidance whenever impartiality is in doubt. If a conflict emerges after accepting the assignment, the reviewer should stop relevant work and inform the editor so that recusal or another appropriate arrangement can be considered. Disclosing a potential conflict does not itself establish wrongdoing; it enables the editor to protect the review process.

如对评审公正性存在疑问,审稿人应拒绝邀请或征求编辑部意见。接受任务后才发现利益冲突的,应停止相关工作并通知编辑,以便考虑回避或其他适当安排。披露潜在冲突本身并不意味着存在违规,而是为了使编辑能够保障评审程序的独立性。

5. Scholarly Review Criteria / 学术评审标准

Evaluation must reflect the manuscript’s disciplinary approach and research design. Empirical studies, doctrinal legal analyses, theoretical arguments, case studies and review articles cannot be assessed against one rigid methodological template. The reviewer should distinguish flaws that undermine the validity of the conclusions from matters of clarity, presentation or further development.

评价应适应稿件所属学科及研究设计。实证研究、法教义学分析、理论论证、案例研究与综述论文不能机械地采用单一方法模板。审稿人应区分影响研究结论可靠性的实质性缺陷,以及属于表达、呈现或进一步完善的问题。

Criterion / 评价维度 Questions and evidence / 评审关注点
Scope and relevance
收稿范围与相关性
Does the work address a question within JLPCS’s disciplinary or interdisciplinary remit, with a clearly explained academic purpose?
稿件是否属于本刊单学科或交叉学科范围,是否明确说明学术研究目的?
Originality and contribution
原创性与学术贡献
What new argument, evidence, interpretation, analytical method, comparison or policy insight does the manuscript provide?
稿件在论点、证据、解释、分析方法、比较研究或政策认识方面有哪些原创贡献?
Significance
研究重要性
Why is the research question important to scholarship or relevant practice, and are significance claims proportionate to the evidence?
研究问题为何具有学术或实践意义,其重要性主张是否与证据相称?
Literature and sources
文献与资料基础
Are the relevant debates, authoritative legal sources, primary evidence and recent scholarship appropriately represented and accurately cited?
是否充分、准确地讨论相关学术争议、权威法律来源、原始证据及适当的近期研究?
Conceptual or theoretical framework
概念与理论框架
Are the concepts, hypotheses, normative premises or interpretative frameworks clearly defined, justified and applied consistently?
概念、假设、规范性前提或解释框架是否清楚、合理,且在全文中一致运用?
Research design and methods
研究设计与方法
Are sampling, recruitment, measures, coding, comparative selection, legal jurisdiction, case selection and analytic procedures suitable and transparent?
抽样、招募、测量、编码、比较对象、法律法域、案例选择及分析程序是否适当并有充分说明?
Evidence, analysis and interpretation
证据、分析与解释
Do data and cited materials support the conclusions? Have alternative interpretations, uncertainty and material limitations been considered?
数据及引用资料是否足以支持结论,是否认真处理替代解释、不确定性和重要局限?
Ethics and research transparency
研究伦理与透明度
Are participant safeguards, consent, ethics approval, privacy, funding, competing interests, data availability and AI use addressed when relevant?
适用时是否充分说明参与者保护、知情同意、伦理审批、隐私、经费、利益冲突、数据可得性与 AI 使用?
Clarity and presentation
表达与呈现
Is the manuscript intelligible and organized? Are tables, figures, legal citations and APA 7 references accurate and usable?
结构及表述是否清晰,表格、图示、法律引注及 APA 7 参考文献是否准确且便于核验?

For legal scholarship, reviewers should consider the relevant jurisdiction, authority, current status and date of statutes, regulations and court decisions, as well as the soundness of doctrinal reasoning. For psychology and communication research, reviewers should consider sampling and measurement quality, analytical assumptions, reporting of uncertainty, validity of interpretation and the protection of participants. For systematic or scoping reviews, reviewers should examine the transparency of searching, eligibility assessment and synthesis, with relevant reporting guidance considered according to review design.

对于法学研究,应审查相关法域、法律渊源效力、法律法规及裁判的现行状态与日期,以及法学论证的严谨性。对于心理学和传播学研究,应审查抽样和测量质量、分析假设、不确定性的报告、解释有效性及参与者保护。对于系统综述或范围综述,应审查检索、纳入标准评估与综合过程的透明度,并根据综述设计参考适当的报告指南。

6. Writing a Constructive Review Report / 撰写建设性审稿报告

A useful review report tells the author and editor which findings are credible, which claims remain unsupported, and what revisions would meaningfully improve the work. General judgments such as “the method is weak” should be replaced by specific explanations of the deficiency, its consequences and, where feasible, a practical route to correction. Major concerns should be separated from minor or stylistic matters.

有效的审稿报告应说明哪些研究发现具有说服力、哪些结论尚缺乏充分支持,以及何种修改能够实质性改善稿件。对于“方法较弱”等笼统判断,应具体指出缺陷、其对研究结论的影响,以及在可行情况下的改进路径。主要问题应与次要问题或文字表达问题分开。

Reviewers should assess both strengths and limitations, referring to sections, figures, tables, arguments or passages where possible. Requests for additional experiments, analyses, literature or legal materials must be proportionate to the research question and necessary to support its conclusions. Reviewers should not demand that authors perform an entirely new study merely to pursue a different research agenda.

审稿人应同时指出研究的优点与局限,并尽可能引用相关章节、图表、论点或具体段落。增加实验、分析、文献或法律资料的要求,应与研究问题相称,并且确有助于支撑文章结论。审稿人不应仅因个人研究兴趣不同,就要求作者完成完全不同的新研究。

  • Summary: Present the manuscript’s question, approach, findings and claimed contribution accurately and briefly. 内容概述:准确、简要地概括研究问题、研究路径、主要发现及所主张的贡献。
  • Major strengths: Identify significant contributions and methodological or analytical merits. 主要优点:指出重要学术贡献及研究方法或分析的优势。
  • Major concerns: Explain matters affecting validity, integrity, significance or the interpretation of results. 主要问题:说明影响研究有效性、完整性、重要性或结果解释的问题。
  • Minor comments: Note correctable matters concerning clarity, layout, terminology, visuals and references. 次要意见:说明表达、版式、术语、图示及引用方面可修改的问题。
  • Actionable revisions: State what evidence, explanation, correction or qualification would be sufficient to address each concern. 可执行的修改建议:指出解决相应问题所需的证据、说明、修正或适当限定。
  • Recommendation: Provide an editorial recommendation that is supported by the substance of the report. 处理建议:根据报告中提出的实质性评审理由形成相应编辑建议。

7. Recommended Review Report Template / 建议采用的审稿报告模板

The following template provides an orderly structure for reviewer reports and can be adapted to the type of manuscript. It is a practical guide rather than a claim about the configuration of any particular review form in the online system. Comments intended for authors should remain separate from confidential comments and the final recommendation supplied to the editor.

以下模板为审稿报告提供便于使用的结构,可根据稿件类型调整。它属于实务指引,并不表示线上系统必然配置完全相同的表单字段。提供给作者的意见应与仅供编辑查看的保密意见及最终处理建议分开。

Report section / 报告项目 What to address / 撰写指导
7.1 Summary of the manuscript
稿件内容概述
State the research question, materials or approach, central findings or arguments, and claimed contribution without extensive repetition.
概述研究问题、资料或研究方法、核心发现或论证及文章所主张的贡献,避免重复大量正文。
7.2 Significance and originality
重要性与原创性
Explain the study’s significance, what is new and how it relates to the journal’s subject areas.
说明研究的重要性、创新之处及其与本刊学科范围的关系。
7.3 Literature and theoretical framework
文献与理论框架
Evaluate the accuracy, balance and completeness of sources and the coherence of concepts and theoretical reasoning.
评价资料的准确性、平衡性和完整性,以及概念与理论论证的一致性。
7.4 Methods, sources and analysis
方法、资料与分析
Assess research design, legal or empirical sources, sampling, measurement, coding, analytical procedures and limitations.
评价研究设计、法律或实证资料、抽样、测量、编码、分析程序及研究局限。
7.5 Ethics and transparency
伦理与透明度
Identify relevant issues in participant protection, consent, privacy, funding, competing interests, data availability or AI disclosure.
指出涉及参与者保护、知情同意、隐私、经费、利益冲突、数据可得性或 AI 披露的问题。
7.6 Language, structure and references
语言、结构与引用
Comment on clarity, organization, discipline-appropriate legal citations, APA 7 references, figures and tables.
评价表达、组织结构、适用于相关法域的法律引注、APA 7 参考文献及图表。
7.7 Specific major and minor revisions
具体修改建议
Provide prioritized, actionable changes, distinguishing issues central to the conclusions from presentational improvements.
按照优先程度提出可执行修改事项,并区分影响研究结论的问题与呈现方面的改进。
7.8 Confidential comments to the editor
仅供编辑查看的保密意见
Report substantiated integrity concerns, conflicts or sensitive editorial matters confidentially; do not place private allegations in author-facing comments.
保密报告有依据的诚信疑虑、利益冲突或其他敏感编辑事项;不要在作者可见意见中作未经核实的私人指控。
7.9 Reviewer recommendation
审稿人处理建议
Select a recommendation consistent with the review evidence and explain the principal reasons if the system permits.
依据评审证据选择适当建议,并在系统允许时简要说明主要理由。

Reviewers should distinguish factual observations, professional interpretations and unresolved suspicions. Concerns that cannot be established from the manuscript should be communicated as questions or matters for verification, not as proven misconduct. The editor determines whether further inquiry is warranted.

审稿人应区分事实观察、专业判断与尚未核实的疑虑。无法依据稿件确认的问题,应作为待核查事项或具体疑问提出,而不应直接认定为已经证实的学术不端。是否需要进一步调查由编辑判断。

8. Editorial Recommendations / 审稿建议类型

JLPCS uses the following recommendation categories in the source guidelines. Recommendations should reflect the severity of the concerns identified, the feasibility of revision and the manuscript’s overall contribution. They do not amount to a publication decision.

JLPCS 原有指南采用以下五类审稿建议。建议应反映问题的严重程度、修改的可行性及稿件的整体贡献,但不等同于正式录用决定。

Recommendation / 建议 Appropriate use / 适用情况
Accept
接受
The manuscript is suitable for publication without substantive scholarly changes, although editorial and production checks may remain.
稿件不需要实质性学术修改即可达到发表要求,但仍可能需要完成编辑及出版制作检查。
Minor Revision
小修
The main findings or arguments are sound, but limited clarification, presentation or modest analytical corrections are needed.
主要发现或论证基本可靠,但需要有限的解释、表达或局部分析修正。
Major Revision
大修
The work may become suitable after substantial changes to its framework, evidence, method, interpretation, ethics or structure.
稿件经过理论框架、证据、方法、解释、伦理或结构的较大幅度修改后,可能达到发表要求。
Reject and Encourage Resubmission
拒稿后鼓励重新投稿
The submitted version is not acceptable; a fundamentally redesigned study may be assessed as a new submission, without a guarantee of review or acceptance.
当前稿件不符合录用要求;经过根本性重写后可作为新稿重新考虑,但不保证送审或录用。
Reject
拒稿
The manuscript is outside scope or has deficiencies that make it unsuitable for publication in JLPCS.
稿件不符合期刊范围,或存在使其不适合在 JLPCS 发表的重要问题。

A reviewer should not promise acceptance, communicate an editorial decision directly to the author, or withhold relevant evidence to manipulate the outcome. The responsible editor weighs the review reports alongside other editorial considerations and communicates the journal’s decision through official channels.

审稿人不得向作者承诺录用、直接传达编辑决定,或故意隐瞒相关证据以影响结果。负责编辑结合评审报告和其他编辑考量作出决定,并通过正式渠道向作者通知处理结果。

9. Reporting Research Integrity and Ethical Concerns / 研究诚信与伦理问题的报告

Reviewers are not expected to conduct formal investigations of suspected misconduct. They are, however, expected to alert the editor to specific, credible concerns and to identify the supporting passages, sources, data or inconsistencies that prompted them. Concerns should normally be raised through confidential comments, without publicly accusing the author or contacting third parties independently.

审稿人不承担正式调查学术不端的职责,但应将具体、可信的疑虑报告编辑,并指出引发疑虑的段落、来源、数据或不一致之处。相关问题通常应通过保密意见提出,不应公开指责作者或自行联系第三方调查。

  • Unattributed or improper reuse: Possible plagiarism, duplicate publication, misleading paraphrase, inappropriate reuse or concealed overlap with earlier work. 不当重用:可能存在抄袭、重复发表、误导性改写、不当重用或隐瞒与既有成果的重合。
  • Data and evidence integrity: Possible fabrication, falsification, misleading image alteration or conclusions not supported by the evidence. 数据与证据完整性:可能存在伪造、篡改、误导性图像处理或缺乏证据支持的结论。
  • Citation manipulation: Non-existent, inaccurate or irrelevant sources, fabricated legal authority, or unjustified citation demands. 引用操纵:不存在、不准确或不相关的来源,虚构的法律依据,或缺乏学术理由的引文要求。
  • Participant protection: Possible absence of necessary ethics approval or informed consent, privacy safeguards or lawful access to sensitive records. 研究参与者保护:可能缺少必要的伦理审批、知情同意、隐私保护,或未合法取得敏感记录。
  • Transparency and rights: Potentially undisclosed funding, conflicts of interest, AI use, authorship or copyright and third-party permissions issues. 透明度与权利:可能存在未经披露的经费、利益冲突、AI 使用、作者资格,或版权及第三方许可问题。

A textual similarity score alone cannot determine plagiarism or originality. Where overlap raises concern, a reviewer should explain which material is duplicated, whether attribution is adequate, and why the reuse is problematic in context. The editor evaluates the evidence under the applicable publication ethics policy rather than applying an automatic percentage cutoff.

文本相似度分数本身不能直接判定抄袭或原创性。对于有疑虑的重合内容,审稿人应说明具体重复材料、引用和署名是否充分,以及该重用在具体语境中为何存在问题。编辑依据适用的出版伦理政策评估证据,而不应以自动化百分比门槛替代专业判断。

10. Use of Generative AI and External Tools by Reviewers / 审稿人使用生成式 AI 与外部工具

Reviewers must protect the confidentiality, privacy and intellectual property of unpublished submissions. They must not upload manuscripts, excerpts, datasets, figures, reviewer correspondence or identifiable information to generative AI services, public translation systems or external tools that can retain, process or reuse that content unless the editorial office has expressly authorized the specific use and the relevant confidentiality and data-protection safeguards are satisfied.

审稿人必须保护未发表稿件的保密性、个人隐私及知识产权。未经编辑部就具体用途明确授权且相关保密与数据保护措施得到满足,不得将稿件、段落、数据集、图示、审稿沟通或可识别信息上传至可能存储、处理或重新利用这些资料的生成式 AI 服务、公共翻译系统或外部工具。

AI-generated responses and automated citation or data checks do not replace specialist evaluation. Reviewers remain responsible for reviewing the underlying work, verifying any tool-assisted observations and ensuring that their reports are accurate, independent and professionally expressed. Any substantive assistance from generative AI in preparing a review should be disclosed to the editorial office in accordance with the journal’s applicable requirements.

AI 生成的回复以及自动化引用或数据核查不能替代专业学术评估。审稿人仍须亲自评估原始研究、核实工具辅助产生的观察结果,并确保审稿报告准确、独立且表达专业。使用生成式 AI 对审稿报告形成实质性帮助时,应依期刊适用要求向编辑部披露。

The restrictions above also apply to seemingly routine tasks such as summarizing a manuscript or translating confidential passages when an outside provider would receive the text. When uncertain about an external system, reviewers should seek editorial guidance before using it.

上述限制同样适用于看似常规的稿件摘要生成或保密段落翻译,只要外部服务商会接触相关文本就须考虑保密风险。对于不确定的外部系统,审稿人应在使用前征询编辑部意见。

11. Professional Tone, Fairness and Responsible Citation Requests / 专业表达、公正评价与合理引文建议

Review reports must be respectful, precise and evidence-based. Strong criticism is appropriate where the manuscript has serious weaknesses, but it should address the research rather than the personal characteristics or presumed identity of the author. Harassment, discriminatory remarks, sarcasm, personal attacks and defamatory statements are unacceptable.

审稿报告应保持尊重、准确并以证据为依据。稿件存在严重缺陷时可以提出明确批评,但应针对研究本身,而非作者的个人特征或推测身份。骚扰、歧视性言论、嘲讽、人身攻击及诽谤性表述均不符合审稿规范。

Reviewers may recommend additional literature only when it is relevant to the manuscript’s argument or evidence base. They must not demand irrelevant citations, insist on references merely to increase their own citation counts, or exploit the review to advance a personal research programme. Reviewers should consider the language, regional context and disciplinary conventions of the work without applying discriminatory standards.

审稿人可以在确有助于稿件论证或证据基础时建议补充文献,但不得要求无关引用、仅为提高自身被引次数而要求添加参考文献,或借助审稿推动个人研究计划。评价还应合理考虑文章语言、区域背景和学科传统,避免采用歧视性标准。

Constructive example: “The methods section should clarify the sampling frame, exclusion criteria and coding reliability so that readers can assess the robustness of the findings.”

建设性表述示例:“建议在方法部分进一步说明抽样框架、排除标准及编码信度,使读者能够评价研究结论的稳健性。”

Inappropriate example: “The authors clearly do not understand their method.” This offers a personal judgment without identifying a verifiable problem or a path to correction.

不当表述示例:“作者显然不理解研究方法。”这种表述对作者本人作出主观评价,却没有指出可核验的问题或可执行的修正方向。

12. Timeliness, Extensions and Further Review / 审稿时效、延期与复审

Reviewers should respond to invitations promptly and complete reports within the period agreed with the editorial office. The agreed deadline is assignment-specific; this guideline does not establish an additional universal review-time guarantee. If an unexpected delay, conflict or inability to complete the review arises, reviewers should inform the editor as soon as practicable so that the manuscript can be managed appropriately.

审稿人应及时回复邀请,并在与编辑部约定的期限内完成报告。约定截止日期取决于具体任务,本指南不另行设定统一的审稿时限保证。如果出现意外延误、利益冲突或无法完成评审的情况,应尽早通知编辑,以便妥善安排稿件处理。

When asked to evaluate a revised submission, reviewers should consider whether the authors have meaningfully addressed the earlier concerns, whether the revisions have introduced new problems, and whether the conclusions remain supported. A second review should focus on unresolved substantive issues rather than endlessly adding unrelated requirements. Whether further review is necessary remains an editorial determination.

受邀评价修改稿时,审稿人应审查作者是否实质回应此前问题、修改是否引入新问题,以及结论是否继续得到支持。复审应聚焦尚未解决的主要问题,而非不断增加无关要求。是否需要再次评审仍由编辑决定。

  • Accept an assignment only when you can meet the agreed timeframe; decline early if not available. 只有在能够遵守约定期限时才接受任务;无法承担时应尽早拒绝。
  • Notify the editor promptly when additional time or a different specialist is needed. 需要延期或其他领域专家参与时,应及时通知编辑。
  • For revised papers, assess the response letter and remaining substantive concerns rather than restarting the review from an unrelated premise. 对于修改稿,应结合逐条回复信评价未解决的实质性问题,避免以无关理由重新启动评审。

13. Reviewer Checklist / 审稿人检查清单

Before submitting the report, reviewers can use the following checklist to confirm that the assignment has been conducted responsibly. A reviewer who cannot affirm an item should clarify the issue with the editor rather than submit an incomplete or misleading assessment.

提交报告前,审稿人可使用下列清单检查评审过程是否符合责任要求。对于无法确认符合的项目,应向编辑说明有关情况,而不应提交不完整或具有误导性的评审意见。

Check / 核查项目 Reviewer responsibility / 审稿人责任
1. Expertise
专业能力
I have sufficient expertise for the aspects assessed and have declared any limits to my competence.
我具备所评内容所需的专业知识,并说明了自身能力的局限。
2. Conflicts of interest
利益冲突
I have assessed possible conflicts and disclosed any actual, potential or perceived concerns.
我已审查可能存在的冲突,并披露实际、潜在或可被合理认为存在的问题。
3. Confidentiality
保密义务
I have protected confidential material and have not shared it through unauthorized persons or services.
我已保护保密资料,未将其交给未经授权的个人或服务。
4. Double-blind integrity
双盲完整性
I have not deliberately sought or contacted the authors or disclosed my own identity.
我没有故意识别或联系作者,也没有披露自身身份。
5. Evidence-based assessment
证据导向评价
My findings rest on the manuscript, appropriate sources, relevant disciplinary standards and identified evidence.
我的评价依据稿件、适当来源、相关学科标准与具体证据。
6. Constructive comments
建设性意见
I have distinguished major issues from minor matters and proposed feasible actions when appropriate.
我已区分主要问题与次要事项,并在适当情况下提出可执行建议。
7. Research integrity
研究诚信
I have confidentially reported any specific ethics or integrity concerns and avoided unsubstantiated accusations.
我已保密报告具体伦理或诚信疑虑,并避免缺乏依据的指控。
8. Timeliness and responsibility
时效与责任
I have met the agreed deadline or informed the editor promptly of any necessary change.
我已遵守约定期限,或及时通知编辑需要调整的情况。

14. Editorial Independence and Publication Fees / 编辑独立性与出版费用

Reviewers must evaluate manuscripts independently of financial considerations. JLPCS does not charge authors a submission fee or a peer review fee; its Article Processing Charge applies after formal acceptance under the journal’s separate fee policy. Reviewers must not request, negotiate or condition their recommendations on publication payments or waiver requests.

审稿人必须独立于财务因素评价稿件。JLPCS 不向作者收取投稿费或同行评议费;文章处理费依本刊独立收费政策在稿件正式录用后适用。审稿人不得要求、协商或以出版费用支付及减免申请作为形成审稿建议的条件。

Author identity, nationality, institution, career stage, academic reputation, financial circumstances and requests for fee relief must not influence the substantive review. The editor’s final decision is based on academic merit, scope, methodological and evidentiary soundness, ethical standards and the editorial record.

作者身份、国籍、所属机构、职业阶段、学术声誉、经济状况及费用减免申请,均不应影响实质性评审。编辑根据学术质量、范围适配性、方法与证据的可靠性、伦理标准及完整编辑记录作出最终决定。

15. Contact and Related Peer Review Guidance / 联系渠道与相关评审指引

Reviewers who need clarification about invitations, confidentiality, conflicts of interest, review deadlines, manuscript-specific issues or suspected research misconduct should communicate with the JLPCS Editorial Office through the appropriate editorial channel. Correspondence about a particular assignment should remain within the journal’s authorized review process.

审稿人对于邀请、保密义务、利益冲突、审稿期限、特定稿件问题或疑似研究不端有疑问时,应通过适当的编辑渠道联系 JLPCS 编辑部。涉及具体审稿任务的沟通应始终在期刊获授权的评审程序内进行。

Editorial Office: JLPCS Editorial Office. Email: [email protected]. Related policy: Peer Review Process.

编辑部:JLPCS 编辑部。电子邮箱:[email protected]。相关政策:同行评议流程。

For questions about the protection of author and reviewer identities, refer to the journal’s double-blind review policy. For questions concerning scholarly misconduct, publisher or editorial accountability, consult the journal’s relevant publication ethics policies rather than using the review report as an investigative or public-disclosure channel.

关于作者与审稿人的身份保护,应参阅本刊双盲同行评议政策。涉及学术不端、出版者或编辑责任的问题,应依据本刊相关出版伦理政策处理,而不是将审稿报告作为开展调查或公开披露的渠道。

Important Principle / 重要原则

Peer review is a confidential scholarly advisory process. A reviewer’s obligation is to deliver a fair, competent and constructive assessment, disclose relevant limitations or concerns, and protect unpublished material. The final editorial decision belongs to the responsible editor and cannot be guaranteed or determined by a reviewer recommendation.

同行评议是具有保密要求的学术咨询程序。审稿人的责任在于提供公正、胜任、具有建设性的评价,披露相关局限或疑虑,并保护未发表材料。最终编辑决定由负责编辑作出,不能由审稿人的建议保证或直接决定。