Peer Review Process
Journal of Law, Psychology, and Communication Studies (JLPCS) conducts independent, confidential, double-blind peer review of eligible scholarly manuscripts. This policy explains how submissions are screened, reviewers are selected, scholarly evaluations are conducted, revisions are assessed, and final editorial decisions are reached.
《法律·心理学·传播研究学刊》(JLPCS)对符合条件的研究稿件实行独立、保密的双盲同行评议。本政策说明稿件初审、审稿人遴选、学术评价、修改与复审以及最终编辑决定的程序和责任。
1. Scope and Review Model / 适用范围与评审模式
JLPCS uses a double-blind peer review model for eligible scholarly submissions. Authors are not told the identities of reviewers, and reviewers are not provided with author-identifying information. Manuscripts that satisfy initial editorial screening are normally assessed by at least two independent reviewers with relevant disciplinary or methodological expertise. Scholarly review is intended to provide informed critical assessment, not merely confirmation that a manuscript meets formatting requirements.
JLPCS 对符合条件的学术投稿采用双盲同行评议模式,即在评审期间向审稿人隐去作者身份,同时不向作者披露审稿人身份。通过编辑初审的研究稿件通常由至少两名独立专家评议,审稿人应具备与稿件学科及研究方法相适应的专业能力。同行评议的目的在于开展实质性的学术评价,而非仅检查格式是否合规。
Eligible categories include original empirical and doctrinal research, theoretical or conceptual articles, critical and systematic reviews, comparative studies, case-based and legal analyses, governance and policy studies, methodological papers, and research articles in approved special issues. By contrast, Editorial Materials and journal administrative content—including announcements, editorial notices, corrections, expressions of concern, and retraction notices—are handled through editorial assessment rather than routine external research peer review. Such materials should not be presented as externally peer-reviewed research articles.
适用范围包括原创实证及法教义学研究、理论与概念论文、批判性及系统性综述、比较研究、案例与法律分析、治理与政策研究、方法论论文,以及获批准的专题研究稿件。Editorial Materials(编辑类材料)及期刊公告、编辑通知、更正、关注声明、撤稿通知等出版管理内容,通常由编辑部直接评估,而不作为常规学术研究论文进行外部同行评议。此类材料不得被表述为已经接受外部同行评议的研究论文。
Double-blind review is designed to reduce identity-related bias, but anonymity cannot be guaranteed absolutely when prior publications, preprints, distinctive datasets, public presentations, or a small specialist community make a research project recognizable. Editors and reviewers must nevertheless preserve confidentiality and avoid intentionally seeking author identities. Detailed anonymization procedures appear in the Double-Blind Review Policy.
双盲评议旨在降低身份因素造成的偏差,但作者既有发表成果、预印本、独特数据、公开报告或小型专业学术共同体,可能使研究具有可识别性,因此无法保证绝对匿名。编辑与审稿人仍须遵守保密义务,不得主动追查作者身份。具体匿名化要求参见《双盲同行评议政策》。
2. Peer Review Workflow / 同行评议流程
The following stages describe the normal handling sequence. An editorial return, an additional review, or a further revision may occur whenever needed for an informed decision. No stage, including receipt of favorable reviewer comments, guarantees acceptance.
以下阶段说明通常采用的稿件处理顺序。为作出充分、审慎的学术决定,编辑部可以根据情况要求补充文件、追加评审或再次修改。任何阶段的完成,包括取得积极的审稿意见,均不意味着稿件必然获录用。
Authors upload the anonymized manuscript, metadata, and other required files through the journal's online submission system.
作者通过本刊在线投稿系统提交匿名稿件、元数据及其他必要材料。
The editorial office checks completeness, scope, scholarly merit, anonymity, ethical declarations, and source integrity.
编辑部核查材料完整性、选题范围、基本学术质量、匿名化、伦理声明及来源诚信。
An editor invites independent experts whose subject knowledge and methods match the manuscript.
负责编辑邀请专业领域及方法能力与稿件相符的独立专家。
Reviewers evaluate the research and submit confidential, reasoned recommendations and comments.
审稿人独立评价研究并提交保密、具体且有依据的意见与建议。
The responsible editor weighs reviewer reports with editorial and ethical assessments.
负责编辑综合考虑外审报告、编辑审查及伦理事项。
Authors respond to comments; substantive revisions may require renewed specialist review.
作者回应意见;实质性修改可根据需要重新送交专家评议。
The responsible editor communicates the decision and any remaining requirements through the editorial system.
负责编辑通过编辑系统通知决定及尚需履行的事项。
3. Editorial Screening and Research Integrity / 编辑初审与研究诚信
Before inviting external reviewers, the editorial office checks whether the submission is complete and suitable for scholarly assessment. This includes its connection to the journal's aims and scope, originality and academic significance, clarity of research question, adequacy of source materials, appropriateness of research design, anonymization, language, references, and compliance with relevant research ethics requirements.
邀请外部审稿人之前,编辑部先确认投稿是否完整且具备学术评价条件。审查内容包括与期刊宗旨及收稿范围的关联、原创性与学术意义、研究问题是否明确、文献和证据是否充分、研究设计是否适当、匿名化情况、语言与引用质量,以及对相关研究伦理要求的遵守情况。
A submission may be returned for technical correction or declined without external review if it is outside scope, does not articulate a credible scholarly contribution, contains serious methodological deficiencies, lacks necessary ethics information, cannot be fairly evaluated because of presentation problems, or presents a substantiated concern about originality or research integrity. An initial editorial decision is distinct from a specialist peer-review recommendation.
不符合收稿范围、缺乏可信的学术贡献、存在严重方法缺陷、缺少必要伦理说明、因表达问题而无法得到可靠评价,或有具体证据显示原创性与学术诚信问题的稿件,可在外审前被退回补正或拒绝。编辑初审决定与外部专家的学术评审意见属于不同程序。
Possible plagiarism, redundant publication, undisclosed textual or data reuse, fabricated citations, or other questionable practices are evaluated using the relevant sources and contextual evidence. An automated text-matching report can assist editorial review where used, but neither a particular software product nor a fixed similarity percentage constitutes a compulsory screening rule or an independent finding of misconduct. Editorial concerns should identify the relevant passages, sources, documentation, or other verifiable evidence.
疑似抄袭、重复发表、未经披露的文字或数据重用、虚构引文及其他学术不当行为,应结合相关原始来源与具体情境证据进行评价。文本匹配报告可在使用时作为辅助材料,但本刊不以指定软件或固定相似度百分比作为强制初审规则,也不单凭百分比认定学术不端。编辑提出疑虑时,应指出有关段落、来源文献、记录或其他可核验的证据。
Where an integrity issue requires further inquiry, the editorial office may seek explanations or underlying documentation and assess the matter under the Publication Ethics policy. Concerns must be handled fairly and confidentially, without equating suspicion with an established finding.
如果学术诚信问题需要进一步核查,编辑部可要求作者提供解释或基础材料,并按照《出版伦理政策》处理。相关程序应公平、保密,不应将尚待核实的怀疑视为已经查明的违规事实。
4. Reviewer Selection and Independence / 审稿人遴选与独立性
The responsible editor selects reviewers according to relevant scholarly expertise, methodological or jurisdictional competence, independence, availability, and ability to provide a reasoned assessment. For interdisciplinary manuscripts, reviewer expertise should collectively cover the principal questions and methods, rather than assuming that one reviewer must be an expert in every field.
负责编辑依据学术领域、研究方法或法域方面的专业能力、独立性、可用性及提供有理据评价的能力遴选审稿人。对交叉学科稿件,应尽可能通过审稿人专业背景的互补覆盖主要研究问题及方法,而不要求每一位审稿人同时精通全部相关学科。
Reviewers are expected to disclose any relationship or interest that could compromise, or reasonably appear to compromise, impartiality. Relevant concerns include recent or ongoing collaboration, personal and family relationships, supervisory or student relationships, shared institutional interests, direct academic competition, financial or legal interests, or previous substantive involvement in the manuscript, dataset, legal matter, or research project. A reviewer who lacks the necessary expertise or cannot complete the review responsibly should decline the invitation.
审稿人须披露可能影响公正判断或足以使人合理怀疑其独立性的关系与利益,包括近期或正在进行的合作、私人或家庭关系、师生及指导关系、机构利益、直接学术竞争、经济或法律利益,以及此前对相关稿件、数据集、法律案件或研究项目的实质性参与。缺乏必要专业能力或无法负责任完成评议的审稿人,应拒绝邀请。
Where a conflict is identified, the editor should arrange an appropriate alternative or independent handling of the manuscript. Reviewers must not contact authors directly about a manuscript under review or use the review process to gain access to research for personal advantage. More detailed instructions are available in the Reviewer Guidelines.
发现利益冲突时,负责编辑应安排适当的替代审稿人或独立处理方式。审稿人不得就评审中的稿件直接联系作者,亦不得利用评审获取的研究资料谋取个人利益。具体行为规范参见《审稿人指南》。
5. Academic Review Criteria / 学术评审标准
Review criteria are applied in a manner appropriate to the submission type. A doctrinal legal article should not be judged as though it were a clinical experiment; an empirical psychology paper must nevertheless provide appropriate methods and evidence; a communication or governance analysis must identify its materials and analytical basis. Reviewers are asked to distinguish essential validity concerns from optional suggestions and to give reasons for their evaluation.
评审标准应依据稿件类型合理适用。例如,法教义学论文不应被机械地套用临床实验的评价方法;实证心理学研究则必须提供与其设计相称的方法及证据;传播或治理分析也应明确研究材料及分析依据。审稿人应区分影响研究有效性的关键问题与可供作者选择的改进建议,并解释判断理由。
| Review criterion / 评审维度 | Assessment focus / 主要评价内容 |
|---|---|
| Scope and significance / 范围与意义 | Relevance to JLPCS; clarity and value of the research problem. / 是否符合本刊定位,以及研究问题是否清晰且具有价值。 |
| Original contribution / 原创贡献 | New findings, argument, interpretation, method, comparison, or interdisciplinary insight. / 是否提供新发现、新论证、新阐释、新方法、比较成果或跨学科见解。 |
| Engagement with scholarship / 文献与学术对话 | Accurate treatment of pertinent scholarship, sources, and competing arguments. / 是否准确讨论相关文献、原始来源及不同学术立场。 |
| Conceptual and theoretical basis / 理论基础 | Clarity and coherence of definitions, assumptions, hypotheses, or normative premises. / 概念定义、理论假设、研究命题或规范前提是否清楚且一致。 |
| Design and methods / 研究设计与方法 | Suitability and transparency of empirical methods, doctrinal interpretation, case selection, or analytical strategy. / 实证方法、法教义学解释、案例选择或分析策略是否适宜且透明。 |
| Evidence and analysis / 证据与分析 | Reliability of materials; soundness of reasoning; supported conclusions; recognition of limitations. / 材料是否可靠、推理是否严谨、结论是否得到支持,以及是否承认研究局限。 |
| Ethics and research integrity / 伦理与诚信 | Ethical approval or consent where relevant, privacy protection, accurate attribution, and trustworthy reporting. / 适用的伦理审批或知情同意、隐私保护、准确引注与可信报告。 |
| Transparency and reproducibility / 透明度与可核验性 | Disclosure of relevant data, procedures, funding, interests, and AI assistance, with justified restrictions on access. / 相关数据、程序、资助、利益关系与 AI 辅助的披露,以及数据获取限制的合理说明。 |
| Presentation and disciplinary conventions / 表达与学科规范 | Organization, comprehensibility, referencing accuracy, and fitness for the intended readership. / 结构、可读性、引注准确性与对目标读者的适配程度。 |
6. Review Reports and Editorial Decisions / 评审报告与编辑决定
Review reports should provide a clear overall assessment, identify substantive strengths and weaknesses, and distinguish concerns about methods, evidence, argumentation, ethical compliance, or presentation. Criticism should be professional and evidence-based. Reviewers may recommend a decision, but reviewer recommendations are advisory; they do not themselves constitute acceptance or rejection.
审稿报告应给出清晰的总体评价,指出实质性的优点与不足,并区分方法、证据、论证、伦理合规及表达方面的问题。批评应专业且有证据依据。审稿人可以提出处理建议,但审稿建议属于咨询意见,不能单独构成录用或拒稿决定。
| Editorial outcome / 编辑处理结果 | Meaning / 说明 |
|---|---|
| Accept / 录用 | The manuscript is accepted, subject to remaining editorial and production checks. / 稿件获得正式录用,但仍须完成必要的编辑及出版检查。 |
| Minor revision / 小修 | Specific, limited amendments are required before a final decision. / 作者须完成有限且具体的修改,之后再作最终决定。 |
| Major revision / 大修 | Substantial changes are needed; renewed external review may be required. / 需要重大修改,编辑部可根据需要组织再次外审。 |
| Reject and encourage resubmission / 拒稿后鼓励重投 | The current submission is declined; a substantially new version may be considered through a new submission. / 当前稿件不予录用;实质性重写的版本可作为新投稿重新考虑。 |
| Reject / 拒稿 | The submission is unsuitable for publication in JLPCS. / 稿件不适合在 JLPCS 发表。 |
The responsible editor considers the reviewer reports together with the full editorial record, journal scope, scholarly merit, applicable ethical rules, and the adequacy of any revisions. Divergent reports may require additional editorial assessment or independent advice; the decision is not determined mechanically by a vote count. The decision and substantive reasons should be communicated to the corresponding author through the journal's editorial system.
负责编辑应结合审稿报告、完整编辑记录、期刊范围、学术质量、适用伦理规范及作者修改的充分程度作出判断。审稿意见出现分歧时,可开展进一步编辑评估或征求独立专家意见;决定不应机械地由审稿意见票数决定。处理结果及其主要理由应通过期刊编辑系统通知通讯作者。
7. Revision, Re-Review and Author Responses / 修改、复审与作者回复
When revision is invited, the corresponding author should coordinate the response and submit a clean revised manuscript, a point-by-point response letter, and a marked version if requested. The response must indicate where material changes were made and provide a reasoned explanation for any reviewer suggestion not adopted. All authors remain responsible for the accuracy of the revised content and should approve any substantial scholarly changes.
编辑部邀请修改时,通讯作者应协调修改工作,提交干净版修改稿、逐条回复信,并在要求时提交标注修改的版本。回复信应注明主要修改位置,并对未采纳的审稿建议作出有理据的解释。全体作者对修改后内容的准确性继续承担责任,实质性学术修改应获得所有作者认可。
Revisions may require corrections to theory, legal sources, research design, statistical analyses, interpretations, references, consent or ethical disclosures, data statements, or AI-use information. The editor may assess a limited revision directly or send a substantial revision back to existing or additional independent reviewers. A request for revision does not guarantee eventual acceptance.
修改可能涉及理论框架、法律来源、研究设计、统计分析、结果解释、参考文献、知情同意或伦理披露、数据声明或 AI 使用信息。编辑可直接评估有限修改,亦可将重大修改送交原审稿人或其他独立专家复审。收到修改邀请并不保证最终录用。
Authors must maintain anonymity in revised files sent for double-blind review. They should neither attempt to discover reviewers' identities nor contact or exert pressure on them. If an author identifies a substantive mistake, undisclosed overlap, authorship dispute, or ethical concern during review, the editorial office should be informed promptly.
对于仍需双盲复审的修改稿,作者须继续维护匿名状态,不得试图确认审稿人身份,也不得联系、施压或影响审稿人。评审期间如发现重大错误、未披露的内容重用、作者署名争议或伦理问题,应及时告知编辑部。
8. Review Timelines and Communication / 评审时程与沟通
The duration of editorial screening, reviewer recruitment, external evaluation, revision, and final decision depends on manuscript complexity, reviewer availability, ethical or technical questions, the extent of revisions, and editorial workload. The journal's published estimates and stage-by-stage information are maintained in the dedicated Review Timeline page. These estimates should not be understood as guaranteed decision or publication dates.
编辑初审、审稿人邀请、外部评议、作者修改及最终决定所需时间,会受到稿件复杂性、审稿人可用性、伦理或技术问题、修改幅度及编辑工作量等因素影响。期刊公布的预计周期及阶段说明统一见《评审时间表》专页。这些预计时间不构成保证作出决定或完成出版的固定期限。
The corresponding author should use the journal's online submission system for manuscript status, revisions, and editorial correspondence. Where a substantial delay or procedural concern arises, the author may contact the editorial office with the manuscript identifier and a concise description of the issue. Author inquiries do not override independent review or editorial standards.
通讯作者应通过本刊在线投稿系统查询稿件状态、提交修改稿和开展编辑沟通。如出现明显延误或程序性疑问,可向编辑部提供稿件编号及简要情况说明。作者咨询不会改变独立评议及编辑决策标准。
9. Confidentiality, Anonymity and Responsible Technology Use / 保密、匿名与技术工具使用
Submitted manuscripts, supplementary files, reviewer reports, editorial correspondence, and internal decision documents are confidential. Editors, reviewers, and editorial staff must not disclose, copy, circulate, or use unpublished material for purposes unrelated to legitimate editorial assessment. Reviewers must not use privileged information for personal, competitive, commercial, political, or legal advantage.
投稿稿件、补充文件、审稿报告、编辑通信及内部决定文件均属保密材料。编辑、审稿人和编辑部工作人员不得为正当编辑评估以外的目的披露、复制、传播或使用未发表资料。审稿人不得借助评审中获得的非公开信息谋取个人、竞争、商业、政治或法律利益。
Reviewer identities and confidential reports must be protected. If identities are accidentally disclosed, the editorial office should assess whether impartiality has been compromised and determine a proportionate response, such as correcting an anonymized file, replacing an affected reviewer, or seeking another independent assessment. The handling of such incidents should be documented as appropriate.
审稿人身份及保密报告必须得到保护。如评审身份意外暴露,编辑部应判断是否影响公正性,并根据实际情况采取适当措施,例如修正匿名文件、更换受到影响的审稿人或征求新的独立意见,必要时在编辑记录中说明处理情况。
Confidential manuscripts or reviewer reports must not be uploaded to publicly accessible generative AI services or other external systems without explicit editorial authorization and appropriate safeguards. Assistance tools do not replace reviewers' independent professional judgment, and any permitted use must remain consistent with the journal's confidentiality, data-protection, and research-integrity obligations.
未经编辑部明确授权并落实适当保护措施,不得将保密稿件或审稿报告上传至公众可访问的生成式 AI 服务或其他外部系统。辅助工具不能替代审稿人的独立专业判断;任何获准的工具使用均须符合本刊保密、数据保护及研究诚信要求。
10. Conflicts of Interest and Allegations of Misconduct / 利益冲突与学术不当行为疑虑
Editors and reviewers must disclose actual, potential, or reasonably perceived conflicts of interest as soon as they become apparent. A conflicted person should not continue handling or reviewing the manuscript where impartiality could be affected. The editorial office should arrange another independent editor or reviewer when needed. Conflicts may arise from collaboration, supervisory or institutional relationships, personal ties, financial interests, academic rivalry, advocacy, or prior participation in the research.
编辑与审稿人一旦发现实际、潜在或足以引起合理疑虑的利益冲突,应及时披露。可能影响公正判断的人员不应继续处理或评审该稿件;必要时应由编辑部另行安排独立编辑或审稿人。利益冲突可能来自合作、指导或机构关系、私人关系、财务利益、学术竞争、倡议立场或此前参与相关研究。
When reviewers identify potential plagiarism, inaccurate citations, duplicated findings, manipulated evidence, undisclosed competing interests, or ethically questionable methods, they should report the specific concern privately to the editor with supporting references or documentation. They should not investigate authors independently or make public allegations. The editor evaluates the evidence and follows the applicable publication ethics procedures, including seeking author explanations where appropriate.
审稿人发现疑似抄袭、错误引文、重复研究结果、证据操纵、未披露利益关系或研究伦理疑虑时,应向负责编辑保密报告具体问题,并尽可能提供相关来源或文件依据。审稿人不应擅自调查作者或公开指控。编辑应核验相关证据,并根据适用的出版伦理程序处理,必要时要求作者解释。
Reports generated by similarity-checking software, when available, can point to text requiring closer assessment; they are not substitutes for a comparison of sources, an evaluation of the nature of reuse, and editorial judgment. The journal does not use a fixed percentage as proof of misconduct.
相似度检索报告如获使用,可提示哪些文本值得进一步核查,但不能代替原始来源比对、对重用性质的分析及编辑专业判断。本刊不将固定百分比视为学术不端的证据或认定标准。
11. Responsibilities of Editors, Reviewers and Authors / 编辑、审稿人与作者的责任
Editors and Editorial Office / 编辑及编辑部
Editors manage the scholarly evaluation process, assess scope and integrity, select qualified reviewers, manage competing interests, safeguard confidentiality, and issue decisions on academic grounds. They should ensure that material criticisms are assessed fairly and that questions involving scientific, legal, or ethical evidence receive proportionate attention. Editors must not make acceptance contingent on publication payments or waiver outcomes.
编辑负责管理学术评价程序、判断范围与研究诚信、遴选合格审稿人、管理利益冲突、保护保密信息,并依据学术标准作出决定。对重要批评意见应公平评估;涉及科学、法律或伦理证据的问题应得到与其严重程度相称的处理。录用不得以支付出版费用或减免结果为条件。
Reviewers / 审稿人
Reviewers should evaluate manuscripts impartially and constructively, explain their judgments, identify significant limitations and relevant missing scholarship, and complete reviews within the agreed period or notify the editor about delays. They must preserve confidentiality, decline conflicted or unsuitable assignments, avoid personal attacks and discriminatory language, and refrain from coercive or irrelevant self-citation requests.
审稿人应公正、建设性地评价稿件,解释学术判断,指出重要局限及相关遗漏文献,并在约定时间内完成评议;如有延误应及时通知编辑。审稿人须遵守保密义务,回避有冲突或不胜任的任务,避免人身攻击和歧视性语言,不得提出强制性或与研究无关的自引要求。
Authors and Corresponding Author / 作者与通讯作者
Authors must present original work accurately, disclose material research and publication information, preserve double-blind anonymity when required, and respond to editorial queries and reviewer comments in good faith. The corresponding author coordinates submission communications, revision files, author approvals, and resolution of questions affecting the submission, while all authors retain responsibility for the work.
作者须准确呈现原创研究,披露重要研究和出版信息,在要求时维护双盲匿名,并善意回应编辑询问及审稿意见。通讯作者负责协调投稿通信、修改文件、作者批准及与稿件有关的问题处理;所有作者仍对作品承担相应责任。
12. Editorial Independence and Publication Fees / 编辑独立性与出版费用
JLPCS charges no submission fee or external peer-review fee. Its Article Processing Charge (APC), where applicable, is requested only after a formal acceptance decision. Payments, fee reductions, waiver requests, institutional affiliation, nationality, seniority, or professional reputation must not influence reviewer selection, editorial screening, review recommendations, or acceptance. Current financial details are maintained solely in the Article Processing Charges (APC) policy.
JLPCS 不收取投稿费或外部同行评议费。适用的文章处理费(APC)仅在正式录用决定作出后收取。费用支付、减免申请、作者机构背景、国籍、资历或专业声誉均不得影响审稿人遴选、编辑初审、外审建议或录用决定。现行费用细节统一以《文章处理费(APC)政策》为准。
Editorial independence also requires that reviewer invitations, assessments, and decisions are not directed by personal, institutional, financial, or ideological preferences unrelated to the manuscript's academic merit. The responsible editor retains final authority within the journal's published governance arrangements.
编辑独立性还要求审稿邀请、学术评价与处理决定不受与稿件学术质量无关的个人、机构、经济或意识形态偏好支配。负责编辑在期刊已公布的编辑治理框架内行使最终学术决定权。
13. Review Exceptions and Publication-Related Materials / 评审例外与出版管理材料
Editorial notes, journal announcements, calls for papers, corrections, retractions, expressions of concern, publisher notices, and policy updates are distinguished from original research articles. They may be evaluated by the responsible editor or editorial office rather than sent through the standard two-reviewer double-blind route. The nature of the content and its assessment should not be represented inaccurately to readers. Research articles in special issues remain subject to the applicable standards of independent review and editorial integrity.
编辑说明、期刊公告、征稿启事、更正、撤稿、关注声明、出版方通知及政策更新,与原创研究论文属于不同类型的出版内容。此类材料可由负责编辑或编辑部直接评价,而无须适用通常由两名审稿人参与的双盲外审程序。期刊应准确呈现这些材料的性质及其审核方式。专题中的研究论文仍应遵守适用的独立评审及编辑诚信标准。
The same ethical principles of accuracy, transparency, appropriate attribution, accountability, and correction of the scholarly record apply to journal communications and publication notices even when those materials are not externally peer reviewed.
即便相关内容不进行外部同行评议,期刊公告及出版通知仍须遵守准确性、透明度、适当署名、责任承担与维护学术记录等伦理原则。
14. Contact and Related Policies / 联系方式与相关政策
For questions about review status, reviewer comments, revisions, confidentiality, or editorial decisions, contact the JLPCS Editorial Office through the journal's editorial system or at [email protected]. Authors should submit new and revised manuscripts through the journal's online submission system and not by informal email correspondence.
如需咨询评审状态、审稿意见、修改稿、保密事项或编辑决定,请通过期刊编辑系统或邮箱 [email protected] 联系JLPCS 编辑部。新稿及修改稿应通过本刊在线投稿系统提交,而非依赖非正式电子邮件作为投稿方式。
For the authoritative requirements of each distinct policy area, consult the dedicated pages listed below.
有关不同政策领域的具体规定,请查阅以下专门页面。
Reviewer recommendations are advisory. Acceptance and rejection decisions are made by the responsible editor following consideration of the relevant reviewer reports, research evidence, publication ethics, and the journal's editorial policies.
审稿建议属于编辑决策的参考材料。负责编辑根据相关审稿报告、研究证据、出版伦理和期刊编辑政策作出最终录用或拒稿决定。