Research Integrity
Journal of Law, Psychology, and Communication Studies (JLPCS) upholds research integrity across submission, editorial assessment, peer review, publication and the subsequent scholarly record. This policy addresses the accuracy of research evidence, responsible attribution, participant protection, authorship accountability and the fair examination of integrity concerns.
《法律·心理学·传播研究学刊》(JLPCS)在投稿、编辑评估、同行评议、正式出版及出版后学术记录管理的各个阶段维护研究诚信。本政策涵盖研究证据的准确性、规范来源标注、研究参与者保护、作者责任及诚信疑虑的公正核查。
1. Purpose, Scope and Relationship to Other Policies / 目的、适用范围及相关政策
This policy explains the standards expected of authors and editorial participants and the framework JLPCS uses to receive, assess and address credible questions about the integrity of submitted or published work. It applies to authors, co-authors, contributors, reviewers, editors, guest editors, editorial staff and the published record, including relevant supplementary material.
本政策说明作者与编辑参与方应遵守的研究诚信标准,以及 JLPCS 接收、评估和处理投稿或已发表成果诚信疑虑的基本框架。其适用对象包括作者、共同作者、其他贡献者、审稿人、编辑、客座编辑、编辑部工作人员及已发表记录,并涵盖相关补充材料。
Research integrity is broader than an allegation of misconduct: accurate reporting, full and fair attribution, methodological transparency, ethical authorization, the correction of honest errors and cooperation with legitimate inquiries are continuing responsibilities. The journal distinguishes errors that can be corrected from findings that may be unreliable or conduct that warrants institutional examination.
研究诚信并不限于不端指控,还包括准确报告、充分而公正的来源标注、方法透明、必要的伦理许可、对诚实错误的更正以及对合理核查的配合。这些责任具有持续性。本刊区分能够通过更正解决的错误、可能影响研究可靠性的问题,以及需要机构调查的行为。
This document should be read together with Publication Ethics, Authorship & Contributorship, Human Subjects & Informed Consent, Data Availability & Reproducibility, and Corrections, Retractions & Expressions of Concern. Where a specialized policy governs a particular process, that policy provides the operational detail.
本政策应与出版伦理、作者署名与贡献、人类受试者与知情同意、数据可得性与可复现性及更正、撤稿与关注声明共同理解。涉及特定事项的执行程序,以相应专门政策的规定为准。
2. Core Principles / 核心原则
Honesty, Accuracy and Traceability / 诚实、准确与可追溯性
Research questions, methods, data, documents, analytical steps, legal authorities and findings must be represented faithfully. Authors must distinguish what was directly observed, obtained from original sources, inferred by analysis or advanced as an interpretation. The evidence presented should be sufficiently traceable for critical scholarly evaluation without requiring disclosure of legally or ethically protected information.
研究问题、方法、数据、文献、分析过程、法律依据及研究发现必须真实呈现。作者须区分直接观察所得、原始资料所载、分析推论以及解释性主张。所提供证据应具有足以支持学术核查的可追溯性,但不得因此要求公开受到法律或伦理保护的信息。
Transparency and Proportionality / 透明与相称性
Relevant limitations, exclusions, changes from a declared research plan, sources of support, competing interests and material use of artificial intelligence should be disclosed under the journal’s applicable policies. Editors assess the significance of omissions or discrepancies in their actual scholarly context and choose responses proportionate to the nature and evidentiary basis of the concern.
作者应依据期刊适用政策披露研究限制、样本或资料排除、相对于既定研究方案的重要变更、资助来源、利益冲突及人工智能的实质性使用。编辑须结合具体学术语境判断遗漏或不一致之处的重要性,并根据问题性质与证据强度采取相称措施。
Fairness and Accountability / 程序公正与责任
A concern is not a finding of misconduct. The journal seeks relevant evidence, considers reasonable alternative explanations, manages conflicts of interest and ordinarily invites an appropriate response before making an adverse decision. Authors remain responsible for the accuracy and integrity of their work; independent assessment of individual or institutional misconduct may fall within the remit of research institutions or competent bodies.
提出诚信疑虑并不等于认定研究不端。本刊在作出不利决定前,应收集相关证据、考虑合理的替代解释、管理利益冲突,并通常给予相关方适当的回应机会。作者对其成果的准确性与诚信性承担责任;涉及个人或机构研究不端的正式调查,可能属于研究机构或有权机关的职责范围。
3. Forms of Research and Publication Integrity Concerns / 研究与出版诚信问题类型
The following categories indicate matters that may require clarification or further assessment. They are not automatic findings of misconduct. Their seriousness depends on the evidence, intent where relevant, impact on the reliability of the work, and the applicable scholarly, ethical and legal standards.
下表列出可能需要说明或进一步核查的问题类型,并不意味着出现相应情况即可自动认定研究不端。问题严重程度取决于现有证据、相关情况下的行为意图、对研究可靠性的影响及适用的学术、伦理与法律标准。
| Category / 类型 | Explanation / 说明 |
|---|---|
| Plagiarism / 抄袭 | Presenting another person’s expression, ideas, analyses, data, figures or other intellectual contributions as one’s own without proper attribution.
未经适当注明来源,将他人的文字、思想、分析、数据、图表或其他智力贡献作为个人原创成果呈现。 |
| Fabrication / 伪造 | Inventing interviews, participants, observations, results, legal authorities, documents, citations, datasets or research procedures.
虚构访谈、研究参与者、观察记录、研究结果、法律依据、文件、引文、数据集或研究程序。 |
| Falsification / 篡改 | Misleading modification, suppression or selective presentation of data, images, quotations, coding, analyses, records or findings.
以误导性方式修改、隐瞒或选择性呈现数据、图像、引语、编码、分析、记录或研究结果。 |
| Duplicate Submission / 一稿多投 | Concurrent consideration of substantially the same manuscript by multiple publication venues contrary to the journal’s originality conditions.
违反期刊原创性要求,将实质相同的稿件同时交由多个出版渠道审议。 |
| Redundant Publication / 不当重复发表 | Undisclosed or misleading republication of substantially overlapping work without adequate scholarly justification, attribution or necessary permissions.
未经充分披露、学术解释、标注来源或取得必要许可,重复发表实质重合的成果。 |
| Authorship Misrepresentation / 署名不实 | Gift, guest, ghost or coercive authorship; omitted eligible contributors; or unauthorized author-list changes.
礼物署名、挂名署名、隐名署名或强制署名,遗漏符合资格的贡献者,或未经授权变更作者名单。 |
| Citation Manipulation / 引用操纵 | Fabricated or materially misleading references, irrelevant citations added for improper advantage, or coercive citation demands.
虚构或具有重大误导性的参考文献,为不当利益添加无关引用,或强迫作者引用特定文献。 |
| Ethics and Privacy Failures / 伦理与隐私问题 | Missing required ethics permission or consent, unauthorized identifiable disclosures, misuse of confidential or sensitive data, or material misrepresentation of safeguards.
缺少必要伦理许可或同意,未经授权披露身份信息、不当使用保密或敏感数据,或重大失实地描述保护措施。 |
| Peer Review Interference / 同行评议干预 | False reviewer identities, manipulated reports, concealed editorial conflicts, misuse of confidential manuscripts or interference with independent judgment.
伪造审稿人身份、操纵评审报告、隐瞒编辑利益冲突、滥用保密稿件或干预独立判断。 |
| AI-Related Misrepresentation / AI 相关失实行为 | Fabricated content produced with AI assistance, false or missing material-use declarations, or disclosure of protected material through unauthorized tools.
利用 AI 辅助生成虚假内容、虚假或遗漏重要使用声明,或通过未经授权的工具披露受保护材料。 |
Honest methodological limitations, a disclosed correction, legitimate disciplinary disagreement, or the proper quotation of law, policy and previous scholarship do not by themselves establish misconduct. A concern becomes actionable when the available information identifies a substantive question that warrants assessment.
诚实报告方法局限、主动更正错误、合理的学术分歧,或恰当引用法律、政策与既有研究,本身均不足以认定不端行为。只有当现有信息指向值得实质核查的问题时,才构成需要处理的诚信疑虑。
4. Data, Evidence and Source Integrity / 数据、证据与来源诚信
Authors must accurately describe the provenance, collection, selection, transformation, analysis and interpretation of material supporting their claims. In empirical research, this includes sampling and recruitment, instruments, measurement, coding, exclusions, statistical modeling and relevant uncertainty. Changes to analysis plans and decisions that materially affect results should be explained in a manner appropriate to the study.
作者必须准确说明支持研究主张的资料来源、收集、选择、转换、分析及解释过程。实证研究应交代抽样与招募、研究工具、测量、编码、数据排除、统计模型及相关不确定性。对研究结果具有实质影响的分析方案变更与处理决定,应根据研究性质作出解释。
For doctrinal, comparative or socio-legal research, identify the jurisdiction, authoritative legal texts, relevant dates and versions, judicial decisions, interpretive approach and limits of generalization. Quotations from legislation, judgments, policy instruments and archival documents must not be altered so as to misrepresent legal effect or context. Where materials are translated, the translation should preserve their substantive meaning and be accurately attributed.
法教义学、比较法及法律社会学研究应明确法域、权威法律文本、相关日期与版本、司法裁判、解释方法及结论适用范围。对立法、判决、政策文件及档案文献的引述,不得以改变法律效果或语境的方式删改;涉及翻译时,应忠实保留实质意义并规范注明来源。
Images, screenshots, recordings, transcripts, questionnaires, codebooks, figures and tables must be authentic or clearly identified as illustrations, simulations or reconstructions. Corrections to routine presentation, anonymization and necessary redaction must not distort evidence. Authors should retain appropriate supporting records for verification where legally, contractually and ethically permissible, taking account of relevant institutional and funder requirements.
图像、截图、录音、转写文本、问卷、代码本、图表等必须真实,或明确标示为示意、模拟或重建内容。常规呈现调整、匿名化及必要的遮盖不得歪曲证据。在法律、合同及伦理允许的范围内,作者应适当保留可供核验的支持性记录,并考虑有关机构与资助方的规定。
The related Data Availability & Reproducibility policy governs data statements, legitimate access restrictions and the treatment of materials that cannot responsibly be made public. Lack of unrestricted public access does not itself show an integrity failure when the restrictions are legitimate and properly explained.
关于数据声明、合理访问限制及无法负责任地公开的材料,适用数据可得性与可复现性政策。若限制具有正当性且已充分说明,数据未向公众无限制开放本身不构成研究诚信违规。
5. Citation, Attribution and Reference Integrity / 引用、来源标注与参考文献诚信
Sources must be cited accurately and in a way that supports the claims for which they are invoked. Authors should verify quotations, authorship, publication dates, titles, DOI or URL information, legal source versions and the relationship between the cited work and the statement made. Secondary citations must not conceal uncertainty about an unexamined original source.
引用必须准确,并能实际支持相应论点。作者应核对引语、作者信息、出版日期、题名、DOI 或网址、法律资料版本及所引来源与具体论述之间的关系。转引不应掩盖作者尚未核查原始来源所带来的不确定性。
Quotation, paraphrase and translation all require appropriate acknowledgement. In legal writing, identifiable statutory provisions, cases, regulatory texts and judgments should be distinguished from the author’s analysis; in psychology and communication studies, instruments, datasets, scales, media content and analytical frameworks should be credited according to their applicable rights and scholarly conventions.
直接引述、改写与翻译均须适当注明来源。法学写作应区分可以识别的法律条文、案例、监管文本、司法裁判与作者自己的分析;心理学和传播学研究应依适用权利规则及学术惯例,对工具、数据集、量表、媒介材料与分析框架作出准确标注。
JLPCS uses APA 7 for its references, subject to accurate presentation of discipline-specific legal authorities. The reference list should not contain invented, irrelevant or misleading entries. Personal communications and other sources not recoverable by readers should be handled in accordance with the applicable referencing rules rather than presented as ordinary retrievable publications.
JLPCS 参考文献采用 APA 7,并应准确呈现学科特有的法律权威资料。参考文献不得包含虚构、无关或误导性条目。私人通信等读者无法检索的资料,应依适用引用规则处理,不应伪装为普通可检索出版物。
6. Originality, Prior Dissemination and Responsible Reuse / 原创性、既有传播与规范重用
JLPCS requires original scholarly contributions and transparent reporting of their relationship to existing work. A manuscript must not present others’ research or an author’s own previously published contributions as new without proper acknowledgement. Assessment considers the actual content, disciplinary context, sources, legitimate quotation, reuse permissions and the extent to which the submitted work adds a distinct scholarly contribution.
JLPCS 要求稿件具有原创性学术贡献,并透明说明其与既有成果的关系。作者不得在缺少适当标注的情况下,将他人成果或本人已发表成果作为新研究呈现。编辑评估应结合具体内容、学科语境、原始来源、正当引述、再利用许可,以及投稿是否形成独立学术贡献进行。
Authors should identify any earlier public form of the work, including preprints, working papers, conference presentations, theses, reports or related publications, and explain substantive overlap when relevant. The existence of an earlier version is not in itself a conclusive finding of improper duplicate publication; its acceptability depends on the journal’s applicable originality conditions, prior dissemination, rights and the editorial assessment of the new submission.
作者应披露作品此前公开传播的形式,包括预印本、工作论文、会议报告、学位论文、研究报告或相关出版物,并在存在实质重合时予以解释。存在既有版本并不必然构成不当重复发表;是否可以接受,应依据期刊适用的原创性条件、既有传播情况、相关权利及编辑对新投稿的实质评估判断。
An overlap in wording can arise from correctly attributed legal language, standardized technical terms, necessary methodological descriptions or properly quoted material. Such context matters, but proper source acknowledgement and permission remain necessary. Concerns about unattributed or misleading reuse should be examined against the original documents and the authors’ explanation, rather than treated as a purely numerical question.
文字重合可能来自已规范标注的法律文本、标准化专业术语、必要的方法描述或恰当引用的材料。对此应考虑学术语境,但仍必须履行适当的来源标注与许可义务。对未经标注或具有误导性的材料重用,应核对原始文献和作者说明,而不把问题简化为单一数字判断。
A credible concern should identify the passages, documents or underlying contributions in question, explain why the attribution or originality may be misleading, and give the authors an appropriate opportunity to clarify. The editorial assessment of plagiarism or redundant publication must remain distinct from decisions about the scholarly value or suitability of the manuscript.
具有实质依据的疑虑应指出相关段落、文献或原始学术贡献,解释来源标注或原创性为何可能具有误导性,并给予作者适当澄清机会。对抄袭或不当重复发表的判断,应与稿件学术价值及收稿适宜性的评估相区分。
7. Human Participants, Consent, Privacy and Sensitive Materials / 人类受试者、知情同意、隐私与敏感材料
Studies involving interviews, surveys, experiments, behavioral observation, psychological assessments, children or other vulnerable participants, clinical or educational records, online communities, or identifiable personal information must meet relevant ethical, institutional and legal obligations. Authors should document ethics approval or exemption where required, identify the basis of any applicable waiver and explain the consent process in sufficient detail for editorial evaluation.
涉及访谈、问卷、实验、行为观察、心理测量、儿童及其他易受伤害参与者、医疗或教育记录、网络社群或可识别个人信息的研究,必须满足相关伦理、机构与法律义务。作者应在需要时说明伦理批准或豁免,交代适用豁免的依据,并充分说明知情同意程序,以便编辑评估。
Consent to participate in research and consent to publish identifiable material are not necessarily the same. Authors should assess the risk of re-identification from quotations, case narratives, photographs, audio, location details and combined datasets. They must not release protected material merely because it is technically accessible or posted on a public platform.
参与研究的同意与公开发表可识别个人材料的同意并非必然相同。作者应评估引语、个案叙述、照片、音频、地点细节及合并数据造成重新识别的风险。材料在技术上可取得或已发布于公开平台,并不代表可以忽视其隐私与伦理保护要求。
Legal, professional or institutional duties of confidentiality must be observed in the use of court records, case files, legal advice, internal communications and sensitive institutional documents. Authors may need to redact or generalize identifying information while preserving the evidence necessary to understand their analysis.
使用法院记录、个案文件、法律意见、内部通信及敏感机构文献时,必须遵守适用的法律、专业或机构保密义务。作者可根据需要隐去或概括具有识别性的细节,同时保留理解分析所必需的证据。
For specific requirements and limitations, consult Human Subjects & Informed Consent and Data Availability & Reproducibility.
具体要求与限制参阅人类受试者与知情同意以及数据可得性与可复现性。
8. Authorship and Contributorship Integrity / 作者署名与贡献诚信
Authorship must represent substantial, identifiable scholarly contribution and responsibility. All named authors should have approved the submitted work and its authorship arrangements, and should cooperate in addressing concerns about the integrity of the work. Providing funding, seniority, supervision or general administrative support alone should not be misrepresented as authorship when authorship criteria are not met.
作者署名必须真实反映实质且可识别的学术贡献及相应责任。所有署名作者应同意投稿成果与署名安排,并在出现研究诚信疑虑时配合处理。仅提供经费、担任高级职务、一般监督或行政支持,而未满足作者资格条件的情形,不应被错误表示为作者贡献。
Gift, guest, ghost and coercive authorship, unauthorized alteration of author order, and omission of eligible contributors undermine accountability. Contributors who do not meet the criteria for authorship should be acknowledged appropriately, with due attention to their consent and privacy where relevant.
礼物署名、挂名署名、隐名署名、强制署名、未经授权改变作者顺序,以及遗漏符合作者资格的贡献者,均会损害学术责任的可追溯性。不符合作者资格的贡献者应获得适当致谢,并在必要时尊重其同意与隐私。
Requests to add, remove or reorder authors after submission should be supported by a clear explanation and the necessary agreement of affected authors, consistent with the journal’s dedicated policy. Where an unresolved dispute concerns who made the work or who may speak for a co-author, the editorial office may defer action pending reliable documentation or relevant institutional resolution.
投稿后要求增加、删除作者或调整署名顺序的,应按照本刊专门政策提供清楚说明及相关作者必要的同意。若对实际贡献或共同作者的授权存在尚未解决的争议,编辑部可在取得可靠文件或相关机构处理结果前暂缓相应程序。
See the Authorship & Contributorship policy for the applicable authorship and change-request procedures.
适用的作者资格与变更程序详见作者署名与贡献政策。
9. Generative AI and Research Integrity / 生成式人工智能与研究诚信
Material use of generative or AI-assisted systems in drafting, translation, analysis, coding, data processing, literature organization or image generation must be disclosed in accordance with the journal’s AI policy. Disclosures should identify the tool, relevant function and scope of assistance. Authors remain responsible for independently verifying sources, legal authorities, calculations, methods, images and the resulting scholarly claims.
在撰稿、翻译、分析、编码、数据处理、文献整理或图像生成中实质性使用生成式或 AI 辅助系统时,应依据期刊 AI 政策披露工具名称、有关功能及协助范围。作者仍须独立核实来源、法律依据、计算、方法、图像与由此形成的学术主张。
AI systems cannot meet authorship responsibilities and must not be named as authors. AI-generated text, invented citations, fictitious judgments, fabricated interviews or survey data, synthetic observations presented as actual evidence, and unverified claims must not be represented as authentic research. The use of a tool does not transfer liability for errors or omissions away from human authors.
AI 系统不能承担作者责任,也不得列为作者。不得将 AI 生成的虚假文本、虚构引文或判决、伪造访谈或问卷数据、冒充真实证据的合成观察以及未经核实的论断作为真实研究内容呈现。使用工具并不转移人类作者对错误或遗漏应承担的责任。
Editors and reviewers have separate confidentiality obligations. Submitted manuscripts, unpublished data, reviewer reports, editorial correspondence and identifiable participant materials must not be disclosed to unauthorized AI systems or third parties in ways that compromise confidentiality, privacy, copyright or editorial independence.
编辑和审稿人负有独立的保密义务。不得以损害保密、隐私、版权或编辑独立性的方式,向未经授权的 AI 系统或第三方披露投稿稿件、未发表数据、审稿意见、编辑通信及可识别研究参与者的材料。
The detailed journal requirements are in the AI Use Policy.
详细期刊要求见AI 使用政策。
10. Identification and Reporting of Integrity Concerns / 研究诚信问题的发现与报告
Research integrity concerns can be raised during submission, editorial screening, peer review, revision, production or after publication. Information may come from author self-disclosure, source-document examination, questions raised by reviewers or editors, reports from participants or readers, institutional notifications, discrepancies in data or records, or other specific credible evidence.
研究诚信问题可在投稿、编辑初审、同行评议、修改、制作及出版后任何阶段提出。相关信息可能来自作者主动披露、原始文献核验、审稿人与编辑提出的问题、研究参与者或读者的报告、机构通知、数据或记录中的具体不一致之处,以及其他有实质依据的证据。
A report should identify the manuscript or published article, explain the alleged problem and provide the most specific supporting information reasonably available. Relevant materials may include original sources, exact passages, documents, data records, communication history, ethics or permissions records, and information about how the concern affects interpretation or reliability. A reporting party may request confidential treatment of identifying details.
报告应注明相关稿件或已发表文章、说明疑虑的具体内容,并尽可能提供明确证据。相关材料可包括原始文献、确切段落、文件、数据记录、通信经过、伦理或许可文件,以及问题如何影响研究解释或可靠性的说明。提出报告者可要求对其身份信息予以保密处理。
Reports are considered on their substance, not only the identity or status of the person raising them. An anonymous concern with specific verifiable information may still merit examination; an unsupported accusation does not by itself establish a breach. Anyone submitting materials should avoid unnecessary circulation of confidential manuscripts or personal data.
编辑部应以报告的实质内容而非仅以报告人身份或地位判断是否核查。即使匿名报告,只要包含具体且可核验的信息,也可能值得审查;缺乏证据的指控本身不足以证明违规。报告人提交材料时,应避免不必要地传播保密稿件或个人数据。
11. Assessment and Handling of Integrity Concerns / 研究诚信疑虑的评估与处理程序
The journal’s handling seeks a fair, documented and proportionate editorial response. The pathway depends on the evidence, the stage of the work and the responsibilities of the journal and any relevant institution. The stages below describe the existing framework; they do not establish an automatic sanction or a new fixed investigation timetable.
本刊的处理旨在形成公正、有记录且与问题相称的编辑回应。实际程序取决于证据、稿件所处阶段,以及期刊与相关机构各自的职责。下列步骤说明现有处理框架,不构成自动处罚,也不另设固定调查期限。
| Stage / 阶段 | Editorial handling / 编辑处理 |
|---|---|
| Initial assessment / 初步评估 | The responsible editor determines whether the concern is sufficiently specific, relevant and credible to examine; separates an ordinary scholarly disagreement from a question of accuracy, conduct or publication reliability.
负责编辑判断问题是否足够具体、相关且可信,并区分一般学术分歧与涉及准确性、行为或出版可靠性的疑虑。 |
| Record and confidentiality / 记录与保密 | The editorial office documents the concern and relevant correspondence, limits disclosure to those with a legitimate role and identifies any conflict of interest in its handling.
编辑部记录问题及相关通信,将信息披露限制在具有正当职责的人员范围内,并识别处理过程中的利益冲突。 |
| Documentary examination / 文献与证据核查 | Where necessary, compare original sources, manuscript versions, data records, permissions, ethics approvals, editorial records and identified statements. Seek appropriate subject or methodological expertise when needed.
必要时核对原始来源、稿件版本、数据记录、许可文件、伦理批准、编辑记录及具体陈述,并在需要时寻求相关学科或方法专家意见。 |
| Opportunity to respond / 回应机会 | Request an explanation and relevant documentation from the author or other affected party where appropriate. Evaluate the response and any reasonable alternative explanation before an adverse determination.
在适当情况下要求作者或其他相关方说明并提供文件,在作出不利认定前评估回应及合理的替代解释。 |
| Consultation or referral / 咨询或转介 | If the matter needs institutional fact-finding, independent specialist assessment or attention from a competent authority, consider a proportionate referral consistent with confidentiality and applicable obligations.
若问题需要机构事实调查、独立专家评估或有权机关处理,应在保密及适用义务允许的范围内考虑相称的转介措施。 |
| Editorial outcome / 编辑处理结果 | Determine and document the appropriate action under the journal’s policies. Where published material is affected, evaluate whether a correction, expression of concern, retraction or other notice is necessary.
根据期刊政策决定并记录适当的编辑措施;涉及已发表材料时,评估是否需要更正、关注声明、撤稿或其他通知。 |
The journal may pause consideration or production while an unresolved concern directly affects its ability to make a responsible editorial decision. This is a procedural measure, not a finding of misconduct. The editor’s responsibility for the journal’s scholarly record is distinct from an institution’s authority to investigate an individual researcher.
如未解决的问题直接影响编辑部作出负责任决定的能力,期刊可暂停稿件审议或制作。这属于程序性措施,并不等于认定不端。期刊维护发表记录的编辑责任,与研究机构调查个别研究者的权限应予区分。
12. Proportionate Editorial Actions and the Published Record / 相称编辑措施与已发表记录
The appropriate response depends on whether the manuscript is under consideration or already published, whether the concern affects reporting accuracy or fundamental reliability, whether the issue has been explained or corrected, and the available evidence. The journal must not presume that every honest error constitutes misconduct or that every misconduct allegation requires a retraction.
适当措施取决于稿件尚在审议中还是已经发表、问题影响的是报告准确性还是研究根本可靠性、是否已得到说明或更正,以及现有证据的强度。本刊不应将所有诚实错误推定为不端,也不应认定每项不端指控都必然导致撤稿。
- Before publication, the editor may request clarification, corrections, original documentation or further independent assessment; return, pause or reject a manuscript when justified by the evidence and applicable policies. / 出版前,编辑可依证据及适用政策要求澄清、更正、提供原始材料或追加独立评估;在有充分依据时退回、暂停或拒绝稿件。
- After publication, a correction may address identifiable errors that do not fundamentally invalidate the main scholarly contribution. / 出版后,如可识别错误尚未根本动摇文章主要学术贡献,可采用更正方式处理。
- An expression of concern may alert readers to substantial unresolved questions or a pending inquiry that cannot yet support a definitive outcome. / 当存在重大而尚未解决的问题,或调查仍在进行且尚不足以形成最终判断时,可发布关注声明以提醒读者。
- A retraction may be appropriate when the published work is seriously unreliable or its integrity is fundamentally compromised, whether arising from misconduct or material honest error. / 若已发表成果严重不可靠,或其完整性受到根本性损害,无论源于不端行为还是重大诚实错误,均可能需要撤稿。
- Institutional or other notifications may be appropriate where the issue requires powers or information beyond the journal’s editorial remit. / 如果问题需要期刊编辑权限之外的调查能力或信息,可在适当情况下通知有关机构或其他有权主体。
Post-publication notices should identify the affected publication, explain the decision in clear terms, and remain linked to the article and relevant metadata wherever practicable. Restriction or removal of published material should not be treated as the default response when an adequately labeled scholarly record can be preserved, subject to legitimate legal, privacy or safety requirements.
出版后通知应注明受影响的文章,以清楚语言解释决定,并尽可能与原文和相关元数据保持链接。在能够适当标注并保留学术记录的情况下,不应默认通过限制访问或删除材料处理问题,但仍须遵守正当法律、隐私或安全要求。
The detailed criteria and record-management process are provided in Corrections, Retractions & Expressions of Concern.
详细的处理标准及记录管理程序见更正、撤稿与关注声明政策。
13. Appeals and Reconsideration / 申诉与重新审议
A person affected by a research integrity decision may request reconsideration when there is a specific factual error, significant misunderstanding, procedural irregularity, relevant conflict of interest or material new evidence. Disagreement with an outcome, without an identifiable basis, does not itself require reversal. The appeal should specify the affected manuscript or article, the decision challenged, supporting documentation and the requested reconsideration.
研究诚信决定的相关当事人如认为存在具体事实错误、重大误解、程序不规范、相关利益冲突或重要新证据,可申请重新审议。仅对结果不满意而未提出可识别依据,不构成必须撤销决定的理由。申诉应说明受影响的稿件或文章、所争议的决定、支持文件及请求重新审议的事项。
Appeal window: Under JLPCS’s published Complaints & Appeals policy, appeals should be submitted within 30 days after the editorial decision, research integrity decision or post-publication notice is communicated to the affected party. A later appeal may be considered when a reasonable explanation for the delay and pertinent evidence warrant further review.
申诉期限:根据 JLPCS 已公布的《投诉与申诉》政策,申诉应在编辑决定、研究诚信决定或出版后通知送达相关当事人之日起 30 天内提交。逾期申诉如提供合理的延迟理由和足以支持进一步核查的相关证据,编辑部可酌情考虑。
The journal should evaluate the grounds and record of the appeal with attention to conflicts of interest and appropriate independence of review. Possible outcomes include confirmation of the original decision, reconsideration, corrected notice, additional consultation or another proportionate response. An appeal does not guarantee acceptance, reversal of the original decision or removal of a published notice.
编辑部应结合申诉理由和既有记录评估,并关注利益冲突及重新审议的适当独立性。结果可能包括维持原决定、重新评估、修订通知、追加咨询或采取其他相称措施。申诉不保证稿件录用、原决定撤销或已发布通知被删除。
Procedural details are set out in the Complaints & Appeals policy.
具体程序详见投诉与申诉政策。
14. Confidentiality, Conflicts of Interest and Procedural Fairness / 保密、利益冲突与程序公正
The journal handles integrity concerns confidentially to the extent compatible with an effective investigation, the correction of the publication record, legal requirements and relevant rights of affected parties. Access to allegations, unpublished files, participant information and correspondence should be limited to those who need the information for assessment or authorized action.
本刊在不妨碍有效核查、学术记录更正、法律要求及相关方正当权利的范围内,对研究诚信问题予以保密处理。关于指控、未发表文件、参与者信息及通信的访问,应限于履行评估或获授权采取行动所必需的人员。
Editors, guest editors and reviewers must disclose relevant financial, institutional, personal, professional or other conflicts and refrain from handling a matter when their impartiality is reasonably in question. Where possible, an unconflicted editor or appropriate independent person should be assigned. Reports should be judged by evidentiary content and not used to harass, retaliate against or publicly discredit individuals.
编辑、客座编辑和审稿人须披露相关财务、机构、个人、专业或其他利益冲突。其公正性受到合理质疑时,应退出相应处理。条件允许时,应由无冲突的编辑或适当独立人员负责。相关报告应按证据内容判断,不得被用于骚扰、报复或未经核实的公开诋毁。
The journal seeks an appropriate opportunity for those concerned to respond, while recognizing that exceptional legal, privacy, participant-protection or evidence-preservation circumstances can affect the order and extent of communication. Care should be taken to avoid premature conclusions or disclosure of identifying information that is not necessary to resolve the matter.
本刊原则上给予相关方适当回应机会,同时承认法律、隐私、参与者保护或证据保全的特殊情况可能影响沟通顺序与范围。处理过程中应避免过早下结论,并避免披露与解决问题无关的身份信息。
15. Author Research Integrity Checklist / 作者研究诚信核对清单
Before submission and when responding to subsequent editorial questions, the corresponding author should coordinate a factual check with the author team. The checklist is a practical summary of obligations already described in this policy and the referenced specialist policies.
投稿前及回应后续编辑询问时,通讯作者应与作者团队共同核实相关事实。本清单是对本政策及所引用专门政策现有义务的实用汇总,并不另行创设新的投稿条件。
| No. | Review item / 核对事项 |
|---|---|
| 1 | The work is original, has an identifiable contribution, is not improperly under concurrent review elsewhere, and earlier related dissemination has been disclosed. / 稿件具有原创性和可识别的学术贡献,不存在不当的一稿多投,并已披露相关既有传播。 |
| 2 | Data, legal sources, quotations, statistics, evidence and any accompanying materials accurately represent what was collected, examined and concluded. / 数据、法律来源、引语、统计结果、证据及相关材料真实反映收集、核查和分析所得。 |
| 3 | Methods, limitations and any material change in the research or analysis process are explained with appropriate transparency. / 研究方法、局限及研究或分析过程中的重要变更得到适当说明。 |
| 4 | References are genuine, relevant and verifiable, and all quotation, paraphrase, translation and reuse have been properly attributed. / 参考文献真实、相关、可核查,引述、改写、翻译和材料重用均已规范注明来源。 |
| 5 | All named authors meet the journal’s authorship conditions, have approved the manuscript and agree on the submitted author information. / 所有署名作者符合期刊作者资格条件,已批准稿件并同意投稿署名信息。 |
| 6 | Required ethics approval, consent, privacy protection, data-access limitations, funding and conflict-of-interest information has been accurately reported. / 必要伦理批准、同意、隐私保护、数据访问限制、资助和利益冲突信息已准确说明。 |
| 7 | Substantive AI assistance has been disclosed under journal policy and all AI-assisted content has been independently verified by human authors. / 已依期刊政策披露 AI 的实质性辅助使用,且所有 AI 辅助内容均经人类作者独立核实。 |
| 8 | Third-party rights, confidential materials and participant-identifying information have been handled with necessary permissions and safeguards. / 第三方权利、保密材料及参与者身份信息已获得必要许可并采取保护措施。 |
| 9 | The authors understand that corrections, evidence requests and scholarly accountability may continue after publication. / 作者理解更正、证据核查与学术责任可持续至出版后。 |
16. Contact and Related Policies / 联系方式与相关政策
Questions, documented integrity concerns, requests to correct the scholarly record and appeals concerning research integrity may be directed to the JLPCS Editorial Office. Communications should identify the manuscript or published work and explain the matter in sufficient detail to enable responsible assessment. Sensitive data should be shared only through suitable authorized channels.
有关研究诚信的咨询、有证据支持的疑虑、学术记录更正请求及相关申诉,可联系 JLPCS 编辑部。来信应注明有关稿件或已发表作品,并充分说明问题以便负责任地进行评估。敏感数据应仅通过适当的授权渠道传送。
Editorial Office: [email protected]. Manuscript submission: the journal’s online submission system.
编辑部邮箱:[email protected]。投稿入口:本刊在线投稿系统。
For case-specific requirements, authors and reporting parties should consult the related policies directly rather than infer obligations or outcomes from a general description.
对于个案的具体要求,作者与报告人应直接参阅相关专门政策,不应仅凭一般性说明推定尚未明确的义务或处理结果。
- Publication Ethics / 出版伦理
- Authorship & Contributorship / 作者署名与贡献
- Human Subjects & Informed Consent / 人类受试者与知情同意
- Data Availability & Reproducibility / 数据可得性与可复现性
- AI Use Policy / AI 使用政策
- Peer Review Process / 同行评议流程
- Corrections, Retractions & Expressions of Concern / 更正、撤稿与关注声明
- Complaints & Appeals / 投诉与申诉
Important Note. Research integrity responsibilities apply throughout submission, review, production and after publication. Concerns are examined on their merits and the available documentary evidence. JLPCS may request clarification, pause editorial processing, correct the publication record or take other justified action under its relevant policies. A concern is not itself proof of misconduct, and a revision or appeal does not guarantee acceptance or reversal of an editorial decision.
重要说明。研究诚信责任贯穿投稿、评审、制作及出版后全过程。编辑部根据问题实质和可核查的文件证据进行判断,并可按照相关政策要求澄清、暂停编辑处理、修正已发表记录或采取其他有依据的措施。提出疑虑本身并不能证明存在不端行为,修改或申诉也不保证稿件录用或原编辑决定被撤销。