To accommodate diverse forms of scholarly inquiry and reflect the complexity of knowledge production, Silence organizes its publications into six distinct editorial sections. Each section provides a dedicated forum for a particular approach to academic investigation while sharing the journal's commitment to intellectual rigor, methodological transparency, critical reflection, and responsible scholarly communication.

為容納多元形式的學術探究,並反映知識生產過程的複雜性,《Silence》設立六個具有不同學術定位的編輯欄目。各欄目分別為特定形式的學術研究提供發表空間,同時共同遵循本刊對智識嚴謹性、方法論透明度、批判性反思及負責任學術傳播的基本要求。

Research-oriented submissions normally undergo external double-anonymous peer review, whereas manuscripts submitted to Silence Notes are assessed editorially. Regardless of the section or assessment route, submissions must demonstrate academic integrity, a clearly articulated scholarly purpose, coherent argumentation, appropriate engagement with relevant literature, and sufficient evidentiary or analytical support for their claims.

研究類稿件通常接受外部雙匿名同行評審,而投稿至 Silence Notes(寂靜手記)的稿件則由編輯進行評估。無論所屬欄目或採用何種評估程序,所有稿件均須符合學術誠信要求,具備明確的學術目的、連貫的論證、與相關文獻的適當對話,以及足以支持其主張的證據或分析基礎。

Quiet Research / 寂靜研究

Quiet Research publishes substantial scholarly studies distinguished by conceptual depth, sustained intellectual engagement, and careful methodological reflection. The section provides a forum for well-developed research that advances original arguments, integrates perspectives across disciplines, or critically reconsiders established theoretical and analytical approaches.

「寂靜研究」刊載具有概念深度、持續性智識投入及嚴謹方法論反思的深入學術成果。本欄目為提出原創論證、整合不同學科視角,或批判性重新審視既有理論與分析方法的成熟研究提供發表空間。

Contributions may include original research articles, theoretical analyses, methodological studies, and interdisciplinary investigations that offer substantive insights into complex scholarly questions. Particular attention is given to research that clarifies conceptual frameworks, critically examines methodological assumptions, develops analytical perspectives, or explains how theoretical understandings emerge and change through scholarly investigation.

本欄目可收錄原創研究論文、理論分析、方法論研究及跨學科研究,尤其重視能夠對複雜學術問題提供實質性見解的成果。研究可以著重釐清概念框架、批判性考察方法論預設、發展分析視角,或闡明理論理解如何在學術探究過程中形成與演變。

Quiet Research also welcomes work developed through sustained reflection, successive methodological revisions, or extensive scholarly synthesis. Such contributions may examine the development of research questions, the refinement of conceptual approaches, or the implications of findings that challenge initial assumptions. The scholarly value of these investigations is assessed through their intellectual substance and methodological justification rather than the certainty or anticipated direction of their results.

「寂靜研究」亦歡迎經過持續反思、多次方法論修正或深入學術綜合而逐步形成的研究成果。此類稿件可以考察研究問題的發展、概念方法的完善,或與原有預設不一致的研究發現所帶來的啟示。其學術價值取決於研究的實質內容與方法論依據,而非研究結果的確定程度或是否符合預期。

Authors should establish a clearly defined research purpose, develop their arguments systematically, engage critically with relevant scholarship, and distinguish between conclusions supported by the available evidence and questions that remain unresolved. Methodological decisions, interpretive limitations, and the significance of the contribution should be explained with sufficient detail to support rigorous academic evaluation.

作者應明確界定研究目的,系統性發展論證,與相關學術文獻展開批判性對話,並區分現有證據足以支持的研究結論與仍未解決的問題。稿件應充分說明方法論決策、研究解釋的局限及其學術貢獻,以便進行嚴謹的學術評估。

Silence Notes / 寂靜手記

Silence Notes presents concise scholarly contributions that articulate emerging ideas, preliminary conceptual propositions, methodological observations, or focused theoretical reflections. The section recognizes that intellectual developments may warrant serious scholarly consideration before they have evolved into full-length research articles.

「寂靜手記」收錄簡明的學術成果,內容可包括新興思想、初步概念命題、方法論觀察或聚焦特定問題的理論反思。本欄目認為,部分智識成果即使尚未發展成完整的研究論文,仍可能具有值得嚴肅討論的學術意義。

Contributions may introduce a developing research perspective, examine a particular conceptual difficulty, document a methodological insight, or offer a reasoned reflection on a defined scholarly problem. The purpose is not simply to present unfinished ideas, but to communicate a sufficiently developed observation or argument that can contribute meaningfully to an existing academic discussion.

稿件可以提出正在形成中的研究視角、分析特定概念難題、記錄方法論洞見,或對明確界定的學術問題提出有理據的反思。本欄目的目的並非單純發表尚未完成的構想,而是呈現具有一定發展程度、能夠對既有學術討論作出實質貢獻的觀察或論證。

Authors should identify the intellectual context of their observations, explain the relevance of their arguments to existing scholarship, and make clear which aspects of their contribution are exploratory or provisional. Concise presentation is encouraged, but brevity should result from a focused scholarly purpose rather than the omission of necessary explanation or supporting evidence.

作者應交代相關觀察所處的智識背景,說明其論述與既有學術研究之間的關聯,並清楚指出稿件中具有探索性或初步性質的部分。本欄目鼓勵簡潔表達,但篇幅精簡應源於明確而集中的學術目的,而非省略必要的解釋或支持性證據。

Brevity does not diminish the requirements of analytical clarity, intellectual honesty, or scholarly responsibility. Silence Notes should maintain a coherent intellectual focus, distinguish preliminary propositions from established findings, acknowledge relevant limitations, and provide sufficient reasoning or references to permit meaningful editorial assessment.

篇幅簡短並不意味著可以降低分析清晰度、智識誠實或學術責任的要求。「寂靜手記」應保持連貫的學術焦點,區分初步命題與已確立的研究發現,承認相關研究局限,並提供足夠的推理或文獻依據,以支持具有實質意義的編輯評估。

Failed Experiments / 失敗實驗

Failed Experiments documents and critically examines experiments, methodological approaches, or research projects that did not produce their anticipated outcomes. The section recognizes that unsuccessful investigations can yield valuable knowledge about research design, methodological limitations, unexpected difficulties, and the circumstances under which particular approaches may prove ineffective.

「失敗實驗」記錄並批判性分析未能取得預期結果的實驗、研究方法或研究項目。本欄目認為,未成功的研究仍可能產生有價值的知識,使研究者更深入地理解研究設計、方法論局限、非預期困難,以及特定研究方法可能失效的條件。

In many fields, unsuccessful experiments and abandoned research approaches receive limited attention in formal scholarly publications. Consequently, methodological difficulties may remain insufficiently documented, restricting opportunities for other researchers to learn from previous investigations. Careful reporting of these experiences can support more informed research design, clarify the conditions affecting particular methods, and reduce unnecessary repetition of identifiable problems.

在許多研究領域,未成功的實驗及被放棄的研究方法往往較少進入正式學術出版。因此,方法論困難可能未獲充分記錄,使其他研究者較難從既有研究經驗中獲得啟示。審慎報告此類研究過程,有助於改善後續研究設計、釐清影響特定方法的條件,並減少對已知問題的不必要重複探索。

Contributions should clearly describe the original research objectives, relevant procedures, methodological decisions, and observed outcomes. Authors should explain the expectations underlying the investigation, identify the points at which outcomes diverged from those expectations, and analyze the available evidence concerning possible causes or contributing factors.

稿件應清楚說明原始研究目標、相關程序、方法論決策及實際觀察結果。作者應交代研究開始時所依據的預期,指出實際結果與原先預期出現差異的環節,並根據現有證據分析可能的原因或影響因素。

Where relevant, submissions should discuss methodological adjustments, practical constraints, sources of uncertainty, and the implications of unsuccessful approaches for subsequent research. Authors should distinguish documented explanations from speculative interpretations and avoid attributing unsuccessful outcomes to particular causes without adequate support. The value of a contribution depends on the quality of its documentation and analysis, not merely on the fact that an experiment did not succeed.

在適用情況下,稿件亦應討論研究方法的調整、實際條件限制、不確定性的來源,以及未成功研究路徑對後續研究的啟示。作者應區分有證據支持的解釋與推測性判斷,避免在缺乏充分依據時將未成功的結果歸因於特定因素。稿件的價值取決於研究記錄與分析的品質,而非僅在於實驗未能成功這一事實。

An unsuccessful experiment is not necessarily a methodologically unsound experiment. The section distinguishes unexpected, negative, or inconclusive outcomes from preventable research errors and evaluates contributions according to the reliability of their documentation, the quality of their analysis, and the strength of their methodological reasoning.

實驗未能取得預期結果,並不必然意味著其研究方法存在缺陷。本欄目區分非預期、陰性或尚無定論的研究結果與本可避免的研究錯誤,並根據研究記錄的可靠性、分析品質及方法論推理的充分程度評估稿件。

Unwanted Reviews / 逆流評論

Unwanted Reviews publishes critical review essays that reconsider established assumptions, dominant research paradigms, influential interpretations, or widely accepted theoretical frameworks. The section provides a forum for scholarly arguments that question prevailing perspectives through substantive and carefully reasoned engagement with existing literature.

「逆流評論」刊載重新審視既有學術預設、主導性研究範式、具影響力的研究解釋或廣泛接受的理論框架之批判性評論文章。本欄目為透過深入文獻分析及審慎推理質疑主流觀點的學術論證提供發表空間。

Rather than providing descriptive summaries alone, contributions should identify the intellectual assumptions, methodological orientations, evidentiary limitations, or interpretive conventions that shape established scholarly debates. Authors may examine neglected perspectives, unresolved conceptual tensions, alternative explanations, or inconsistencies within influential bodies of research.

此類稿件不應僅停留於描述性文獻總結,而應辨識塑造既有學術爭論的智識預設、方法論取向、證據局限或解釋慣例。作者可以考察被忽視的研究視角、尚未解決的概念張力、替代性解釋,或具影響力的研究文獻中存在的不一致之處。

Critical reassessment should be grounded in accurate representation of the literature and coherent analytical reasoning. Arguments that challenge established scholarship should identify the specific propositions, interpretations, or assumptions under examination and explain why reconsideration is warranted. Relevant evidence, conceptual analysis, or defensible theoretical interpretation should support the proposed critique.

批判性重估應建立在對既有文獻的準確呈現及連貫分析之上。對傳統學術觀點提出質疑時,作者應明確指出所考察的特定命題、研究解釋或理論預設,並說明重新評估的必要性。相關批判應以適當證據、概念分析或具有合理依據的理論詮釋作為支持。

The section values constructive intellectual criticism rather than opposition for its own sake. A persuasive critical review should clarify what existing scholarship explains effectively, where its limitations arise, and how alternative interpretations might refine or extend scholarly understanding. Disagreement with prevailing views is academically meaningful when it contributes to a more precise and balanced understanding of the subject.

本欄目重視具有建設性的智識批判,而非僅為反對既有觀點而提出異議。具有說服力的批判性評論應釐清既有研究能夠有效解釋的問題、其局限產生的原因,以及替代性詮釋如何完善或拓展學術理解。當對主流觀點的質疑有助於形成更加準確而平衡的認識時,這種學術分歧便具有實質意義。

Void Dialogue / 留白對話

Void Dialogue presents structured scholarly exchanges in which researchers collaboratively examine developing ideas, theoretical uncertainties, competing interpretations, or unresolved intellectual questions. The section treats dialogue as a mode of academic inquiry through which different perspectives can be compared, questioned, clarified, and further developed.

「留白對話」呈現結構化的學術交流,使研究者能夠共同考察正在發展的思想、理論不確定性、相互競爭的解釋或尚未解決的智識問題。本欄目將對話視為一種學術探究方式,藉此比較、質疑、釐清並進一步發展不同的研究視角。

Contributions may consist of exchanges between two or more scholars addressing a shared topic, theoretical problem, methodological question, or interdisciplinary issue. Participants may articulate contrasting positions, reconsider initial assumptions, respond to one another's reasoning, or collectively identify matters that require further investigation.

稿件可以採取兩名或多名學者圍繞共同研究主題、理論問題、方法論議題或跨學科問題進行交流的形式。參與者可以闡述不同立場、重新審視原有預設、回應彼此的推理,或共同辨識仍需進一步研究的問題。

Although contributions may retain an exploratory and open-ended character, they should demonstrate a coherent intellectual focus and substantive engagement among participants. Productive scholarly dialogue requires more than the juxtaposition of separate opinions. It involves critical examination, reasoned responses, and the progressive development or clarification of ideas through interaction.

儘管此類稿件可以保持探索性與開放式特徵,仍應具備連貫的學術焦點,並展現參與者之間具有實質內容的思想交流。有效的學術對話不僅是不同意見的並列呈現,更應透過批判性考察、有理據的回應及持續互動,促進思想的發展或概念的釐清。

Authors should provide sufficient context for readers to understand the questions being discussed, the perspectives represented, and the significance of the exchange. Where disagreements remain unresolved, participants should identify their substantive points of divergence and explain the conceptual, methodological, or evidentiary considerations underlying them.

作者應提供充分背景,使讀者能夠理解對話所涉及的問題、不同參與者所代表的視角,以及交流本身的學術意義。當分歧尚未獲得解決時,參與者應指出彼此之間具有實質意義的不同立場,並說明其背後的概念、方法論或證據考量。

The section does not require participants to reach a unified conclusion. Its scholarly value may lie in clarifying competing assumptions, refining arguments, revealing unresolved conceptual difficulties, or identifying new directions for research. Nevertheless, the dialogue must remain academically grounded, intellectually constructive, and sufficiently developed to permit meaningful evaluation.

本欄目不要求參與者最終形成一致結論。其學術價值可以體現在釐清相互競爭的理論預設、完善論證、揭示尚未解決的概念困難,或辨識新的研究方向。然而,對話仍須具備充分的學術基礎、建設性的智識交流,以及足以接受實質評估的內容深度。

Null Reviews / 空白評論

Null Reviews examines areas of scholarship in which existing evidence is insufficient, fragmented, inconsistent, or inconclusive. The section focuses on identifying and critically assessing gaps in established knowledge, unresolved research questions, and methodological or conceptual limitations that prevent scholars from reaching adequately supported conclusions.

「空白評論」考察現有證據不足、碎片化、相互矛盾或尚無定論的學術研究領域。本欄目聚焦於辨識並批判性評估既有知識中的空白、尚未解決的研究問題,以及阻礙研究者形成充分證據支持之結論的方法論或概念性局限。

Contributions may examine methodological barriers, deficiencies in empirical data, inconsistencies across studies, unresolved theoretical disputes, or structural limitations in existing research practices. Authors should explain how these difficulties affect current understanding and distinguish genuine gaps in available evidence from questions that have already received adequate consideration in the relevant literature.

稿件可以探討方法論障礙、經驗資料不足、不同研究之間的結果不一致、尚未解決的理論爭論,或既有研究實踐中的結構性局限。作者應說明上述問題如何影響當前的學術理解,並區分真正存在的證據空白與相關文獻已充分處理的研究問題。

A contribution should establish the boundaries of the literature under consideration, assess the quality and relevance of available evidence, and identify the specific reasons why a question remains unresolved. Where findings conflict, authors should examine whether differences in research design, measurement, analytical methods, theoretical assumptions, or contextual conditions may account for the apparent inconsistencies.

稿件應明確界定所考察文獻的範圍,評估現有證據的品質與相關性,並指出特定研究問題仍未獲得解決的具體原因。當不同研究結果存在衝突時,作者應分析研究設計、測量方式、分析方法、理論預設或研究情境的差異,是否可能解釋這些表面上的不一致。

The purpose of Null Reviews is to develop a more precise understanding of what is currently known, what remains uncertain, and why particular questions have resisted satisfactory resolution. Through careful examination of the available literature and its limitations, these contributions may clarify the boundaries of existing knowledge and identify productive directions for future investigation.

「空白評論」旨在更加準確地辨識哪些知識已獲得現有證據支持、哪些問題仍存在不確定性,以及特定研究問題為何尚未獲得令人滿意的解答。透過審慎考察現有文獻及其局限,此類稿件有助於釐清既有知識的適用邊界,並為後續研究指出具有價值的探索方向。

Null Reviews is concerned primarily with the state, limitations, and evidentiary foundations of existing knowledge. It should not be confused with an empirical report of statistically non-significant or null findings. Insufficient evidence for a proposition does not, by itself, establish that the corresponding phenomenon or relationship is absent.

「空白評論」主要關注現有知識的狀態、局限及其證據基礎,不能與報告統計不顯著或零效應結果的實證研究混為一談。缺乏支持某項命題的充分證據,本身並不能直接證明相關現象或關係不存在。

Integration Across Sections / 跨欄目整合

Although the six sections of Silence address different forms of scholarly inquiry, they share a common editorial foundation: intellectual rigor, methodological transparency, analytical clarity, and responsible engagement with existing knowledge. The distinctions among sections concern their primary scholarly objectives, intellectual orientations, and forms of contribution rather than differences in their commitment to academic quality.

儘管《Silence》的六個欄目分別關注不同形式的學術探究,但它們具有共同的編輯基礎:智識嚴謹性、方法論透明度、分析清晰度,以及對既有知識的負責任回應。各欄目之間的差異主要體現在學術目的、智識導向與貢獻形式,而非對學術品質要求的不同。

Authors should select the section that most closely corresponds to the principal purpose, intellectual focus, and presentation format of their manuscripts. A contribution may engage with themes associated with several sections; however, its central research objective and primary form of scholarly contribution should guide the choice of the most appropriate editorial category.

作者應根據稿件的主要目的、學術焦點及呈現形式,選擇最為契合的投稿欄目。一篇稿件可能同時涉及多個欄目的研究主題,但其核心研究目標及主要學術貢獻形式,仍應作為選擇適當欄目的主要依據。

The journal recognizes that scholarly work may cross conventional boundaries between empirical investigation, theoretical reflection, methodological analysis, critical review, and academic dialogue. Such overlap is consistent with the interdisciplinary orientation of Silence, provided that the manuscript maintains a coherent intellectual purpose, presents an appropriately developed argument, and clearly communicates its scholarly contribution.

本刊認為,學術研究可能跨越經驗研究、理論反思、方法論分析、批判性評論及學術對話之間的傳統界限。只要稿件保持連貫的智識目的、提出充分發展的論證,並清楚說明其學術貢獻,此類交叉特徵便符合《Silence》的跨學科編輯定位。

Section Selection / 欄目選擇

Authors should consult the journal's current submission guidelines and select the section most appropriate to their manuscript's scholarly purpose and presentation format. The editorial assessment or peer-review procedure applicable to a submission should be understood in accordance with the journal's published editorial and peer-review policies.

作者應參閱本刊現行投稿指南,並根據稿件的學術目的與呈現形式選擇最適當的投稿欄目。稿件所適用的編輯評估或同行評審程序,應以期刊正式公布的編輯政策與同行評審政策為準。

The journal's sectional structure is intended to facilitate appropriate scholarly evaluation while preserving openness to different approaches to knowledge production. It enables contributions to be considered within contexts that reflect their intellectual purposes without imposing a single model of research presentation across all forms of scholarship.

本刊的欄目架構旨在促進適當的學術評估,同時保持對不同知識生產方式的開放性。透過依據各類稿件的智識目的建立相應的學術評估情境,本刊避免以單一研究呈現模式衡量所有形式的學術貢獻。

Collectively, these six sections reflect the journal's commitment to a scholarly record that recognizes research outcomes alongside the processes, methodological revisions, uncertainties, and intellectual exchanges through which knowledge develops. Their shared purpose is to support a more comprehensive understanding of scholarly inquiry without compromising standards of academic integrity, analytical rigor, or responsible interpretation.

這六個欄目共同體現本刊的學術理念:在重視研究成果的同時,也重視推動知識發展的研究過程、方法論修正、不確定性與智識交流。其共同目的在於促進對學術探究更加完整的理解,同時維持學術誠信、分析嚴謹性及負責任研究詮釋的基本標準。

Investigation · Rigor · Reflection

探究 · 嚴謹 · 反思