Submission Types
Silence welcomes diverse forms of scholarly inquiry that reflect the complexity of research and knowledge production. The journal recognizes the value of empirical investigation, theoretical reflection, methodological analysis, critical reassessment, and structured scholarly dialogue, including contributions that address uncertainty, unsuccessful research approaches, negative or inconclusive findings, and unresolved intellectual questions.
《Silence》歡迎反映研究與知識生產複雜性的多元學術探究形式。本刊重視實證研究、理論反思、方法論分析、批判性重新評估及結構化學術對話,包括探討不確定性、未成功研究路徑、陰性或尚無定論的研究結果,以及尚未解決之智識問題的學術成果。
To accommodate these approaches, Silence publishes scholarly contributions through six editorial sections. Each section has a distinct intellectual focus and provides an appropriate context for evaluating manuscripts according to their scholarly purpose, mode of inquiry, analytical substance, and form of presentation. These distinctions recognize the different ways in which research can contribute to the development and critical examination of knowledge.
為容納上述研究方式,《Silence》透過六個編輯欄目發表學術成果。各欄目具有不同的智識定位,並根據稿件的學術目的、探究方式、分析內容及呈現形式,提供適當的學術評估情境。此種區分旨在承認研究可以透過不同途徑,對知識的發展與批判性檢驗作出貢獻。
All submissions undergo initial editorial screening. Research-oriented manuscripts that are suitable for further evaluation normally proceed to double-anonymous external peer review, while Silence Notes receive editorial assessment. The journal applies scholarly and ethical standards appropriate to the nature of each contribution without treating unconventional research formats or the absence of positive findings as grounds for lowering academic expectations.
所有投稿均須接受編輯初審。適合進一步評估的研究類稿件通常進入雙匿名外部同行評審程序,而 Silence Notes(寂靜手記)則由編輯進行評估。本刊依不同學術成果的性質適用相應的學術與倫理標準,不會僅因研究形式非傳統或未取得陽性結果而降低學術要求。
Manuscript Length Guidance / 稿件篇幅指引
The length ranges specified for the six editorial sections are recommended guidelines rather than absolute limits. Reference lists are excluded from the suggested word counts for all six sections. Manuscripts should be sufficiently developed to support their scholarly objectives while avoiding unnecessary repetition or material unrelated to the central contribution.
六個編輯欄目所列的篇幅範圍均屬於建議性指引,而非絕對字數限制。所有六個欄目的建議字數均不包含參考文獻列表。稿件應具備足以支持其學術目的的內容深度,同時避免不必要的重複或與核心貢獻無關的材料。
Quiet Research / 寂靜研究
Typical Length: 6,000–10,000 words (excluding references)
建議篇幅:6,000–10,000 詞(不包含參考文獻)
Quiet Research represents the journal's principal format for substantial, full-length scholarly investigations. Contributions are expected to demonstrate conceptual depth, analytical rigor, methodological clarity, and sustained engagement with relevant academic literature. The section accommodates research developed through careful empirical investigation, theoretical development, methodological reflection, conceptual analysis, or interdisciplinary synthesis.
「寂靜研究」是本刊刊載深入、完整學術研究的主要形式。此類稿件應展現概念深度、分析嚴謹性、方法論清晰度,以及與相關學術文獻的充分對話。本欄目接收透過審慎的實證研究、理論發展、方法論反思、概念分析或跨學科綜合而形成的學術成果。
Submissions may include original empirical studies, conceptual investigations, theoretical analyses, methodological studies, and interdisciplinary research. Authors should clearly define the research problem or intellectual objective, explain the analytical approach adopted, justify important methodological decisions, and establish how the contribution relates to existing scholarly knowledge.
稿件可以包括原創實證研究、概念研究、理論分析、方法論研究及跨學科研究。作者應明確界定研究問題或智識目標,說明所採用的分析路徑,解釋重要方法論決策的合理性,並闡明研究成果與既有學術知識之間的關係。
A substantial scholarly investigation should move beyond the presentation of observations or assertions. The manuscript should develop a coherent line of reasoning, evaluate the relevant evidence or theoretical foundations, and explain the significance of its conclusions. Where appropriate, authors should distinguish empirical findings from interpretation, identify the assumptions underlying their analysis, and acknowledge limitations that affect the strength or generalizability of their claims.
深入的學術研究不應僅停留於觀察結果或主張的呈現。稿件應建立連貫的論證,評估相關證據或理論基礎,並說明研究結論的學術意義。在適當情況下,作者應區分實證發現與研究解釋,辨識分析所依據的基本預設,並承認可能影響研究主張之證據強度或適用範圍的局限。
Core Characteristics / 核心特徵
-
A clearly defined research question or intellectual objective明確界定的研究問題或智識目標
-
A rigorous methodological approach or coherent theoretical framework嚴謹的研究方法或連貫的理論框架
-
Substantive engagement with relevant scholarly literature與相關學術文獻進行實質性對話
-
Analytical depth, conceptual clarity, and appropriately supported conclusions分析深度、概念清晰度及具有適當依據的研究結論
A contribution need not report positive or statistically significant findings to qualify as substantial research. Its academic value is assessed through the quality of the investigation, the strength of its reasoning, the appropriateness of its methodology, and the relationship between its claims and the available evidence. Negative, unexpected, or inconclusive findings should be reported accurately rather than selectively omitted or interpreted beyond what the evidence supports.
研究無須取得陽性結果或統計顯著性,才能被視為具有實質內容的學術成果。其學術價值取決於研究品質、論證的合理性、方法論的適切性,以及研究主張與現有證據之間的關係。陰性、非預期或尚無定論的研究結果應予以準確報告,而不得選擇性省略,或作出超出證據支持程度的解釋。
Silence Notes / 寂靜手記
Typical Length: 1,500–3,000 words (excluding references)
建議篇幅:1,500–3,000 詞(不包含參考文獻)
Silence Notes are concise scholarly contributions intended to communicate emerging ideas, preliminary conceptual propositions, methodological observations, or focused analytical reflections. This format provides space for intellectual developments that may not yet constitute full-length research articles but nevertheless warrant critical scholarly consideration.
「寂靜手記」是用於呈現新興思想、初步概念命題、方法論觀察或聚焦性分析反思的簡明學術稿件。此類形式為尚未發展成完整研究論文、但已具有批判性學術討論價值的智識成果提供發表空間。
Contributions may examine a developing theoretical insight, identify a methodological difficulty, reconsider a particular scholarly assumption, or articulate a focused question for further investigation. Authors should explain the intellectual context of their observations, establish the relevance of the issue to existing scholarship, and distinguish preliminary reasoning from established findings.
稿件可以探討正在形成中的理論洞見、辨識方法論困難、重新思考特定學術預設,或提出值得進一步研究的具體問題。作者應說明相關觀察的智識背景,闡明問題與既有學術研究之間的關聯,並區分初步推理與已確立的研究發現。
The purpose of Silence Notes is not merely to record unfinished ideas or personal impressions. A contribution should present an identifiable scholarly proposition, observation, or analytical insight that can be meaningfully evaluated and discussed. Conciseness is encouraged, but brevity must not result in the omission of essential reasoning, relevant sources, or qualifications necessary to understand the contribution.
「寂靜手記」的目的並非僅僅記錄尚未完成的構想或個人感想。稿件應提出可以接受實質評估與討論的學術命題、研究觀察或分析洞見。本欄目鼓勵簡潔表達,但篇幅精簡不得導致必要推理、相關來源或理解學術貢獻所需的重要限制說明被省略。
Core Characteristics / 核心特徵
-
A concise, clearly articulated scholarly argument簡明且清晰表述的學術論證
-
A focused and identifiable intellectual contribution聚焦且能夠明確辨識的智識貢獻
-
The potential to stimulate further research or scholarly discussion促進後續研究或學術討論的潛力
Silence Notes receive editorial assessment rather than the external peer-review procedure normally applied to research-oriented manuscripts. Their concise format and exploratory character do not remove the requirements for scholarly rigor, coherent reasoning, accurate attribution, and appropriate references or evidentiary support. Editorial evaluation considers whether the contribution is sufficiently developed, intellectually relevant, and appropriately presented for its stated purpose.
「寂靜手記」採用編輯評估,而非通常適用於研究類稿件的外部同行評審程序。篇幅簡短或具有探索性,並不意味著可以免除學術嚴謹性、連貫推理、準確來源標示,以及提供適當文獻或證據支持的要求。編輯評估將考慮稿件是否具有充分發展的學術內容、明確的智識相關性,以及符合其目的的呈現形式。
Failed Experiments / 失敗實驗
Typical Length: 4,000–7,000 words (excluding references)
建議篇幅:4,000–7,000 詞(不包含參考文獻)
Failed Experiments documents and critically examines experiments, methodological approaches, or research projects that did not produce their anticipated outcomes. The section recognizes that unsuccessful investigations can generate valuable methodological insights, clarify the limitations of existing approaches, and inform the design and interpretation of subsequent research.
「失敗實驗」記錄並批判性分析未能取得預期結果的實驗、研究方法或研究項目。本欄目認為,未成功的研究仍可能產生有價值的方法論洞見,協助釐清既有研究路徑的局限,並為後續研究的設計與解釋提供參考。
Submissions should explain the original research objectives, design, procedures, analytical decisions, and observed outcomes. Authors should examine the difficulties encountered, identify the stages at which results diverged from expectations, and assess possible explanations for unexpected or unsuccessful outcomes. The relationship between the initial research assumptions and the evidence ultimately obtained should be presented accurately.
稿件應說明原始研究目標、研究設計、實施程序、分析決策及實際觀察結果。作者應考察研究過程中遭遇的困難,辨識研究結果與原先預期產生差異的階段,並分析非預期或未成功結果的可能原因。原始研究預設與最終取得的證據之間的關係應獲得準確呈現。
Where a project involved methodological adjustments, practical constraints, incomplete procedures, or abandoned approaches, the manuscript should explain those circumstances when they are material to the analysis. Authors should differentiate observed facts from inferred explanations and avoid attributing an unsuccessful outcome to a particular cause without adequate evidentiary support.
當研究項目涉及方法論調整、實際條件限制、未完成的程序或被放棄的研究路徑,且相關情況對分析具有實質影響時,稿件應予以適當說明。作者應區分實際觀察事實與推論性解釋,避免在缺乏充分證據的情況下,將未成功結果歸因於特定因素。
Core Characteristics / 核心特徵
-
Clear documentation of the research question, objectives, and design清楚記錄研究問題、研究目標及研究設計
-
Transparent reporting of procedures, methodological decisions, and observations透明呈現研究程序、方法論決策及觀察結果
-
Evidence-informed analysis of unexpected or unsuccessful outcomes以證據為基礎分析非預期或未成功的研究結果
-
Critical reflection on limitations and implications for future research批判性反思研究局限及其對後續研究的啟示
An unsuccessful outcome does not necessarily indicate a flawed research method. Authors should distinguish unexpected or negative results from methodological limitations, preventable research errors, and circumstances in which the evidence remains insufficient for a definitive conclusion. The scholarly value of a contribution depends on the reliability of its documentation, the quality of its analysis, and the insight it provides into the research process.
未能取得預期結果,並不必然代表研究方法存在缺陷。作者應區分非預期或陰性結果、方法論局限、本可避免的研究錯誤,以及現有證據不足以支持確定結論的情況。此類稿件的學術價值取決於研究記錄的可靠性、分析品質,以及其對研究過程所提供的洞見。
Unwanted Reviews / 逆流評論
Typical Length: 5,000–8,000 words (excluding references)
建議篇幅:5,000–8,000 詞(不包含參考文獻)
Unwanted Reviews publishes critical review essays that reconsider established research literature, influential interpretations, and dominant theoretical paradigms. These contributions examine how scholarly assumptions, methodological traditions, conceptual frameworks, and established interpretive practices shape the production and evaluation of knowledge.
「逆流評論」刊載重新審視既有研究文獻、具影響力的學術解釋及主導性理論範式的批判性評論文章。此類稿件考察學術預設、方法論傳統、概念框架及既有解釋慣例如何影響知識的生產與評估。
Rather than providing descriptive summaries alone, authors should formulate a clear critical argument, engage closely with relevant scholarship, and examine both the strengths and limitations of existing approaches. Contributions may challenge prevailing assumptions, identify overlooked perspectives, analyze conceptual inconsistencies, or propose alternative interpretations when supported by appropriate scholarly reasoning.
稿件不應僅停留於描述性文獻總結。作者應提出明確的批判性論證,深入考察相關學術成果,並分析既有研究路徑的優勢與局限。此類稿件可以質疑主流預設、辨識被忽略的研究視角、分析概念上的不一致,或在具有適當學術論證依據的情況下提出替代性解釋。
A critical review should accurately represent the positions it examines and identify the specific propositions, assumptions, or interpretations under reconsideration. Authors should explain why the proposed critique is justified and how it contributes to a more precise understanding of the subject. Critical disagreement is most valuable when it clarifies intellectual problems or advances scholarly discussion rather than merely expressing opposition to established positions.
批判性評論應準確呈現所考察的學術立場,並明確指出需要重新評估的具體命題、預設或研究解釋。作者應說明所提出的批判為何具有合理依據,以及如何促進對研究主題更加準確的理解。當批判性分歧能夠釐清智識問題或推進學術討論,而非僅僅表達對既有立場的反對時,其學術價值尤為明確。
Core Characteristics / 核心特徵
-
Substantive and analytical engagement with existing scholarship與既有學術文獻進行實質性及分析性對話
-
Critical evaluation of theoretical assumptions or research paradigms批判性評估理論預設或既有研究範式
-
Identification of overlooked perspectives, conceptual tensions, or unresolved debates辨識被忽略的視角、概念張力或尚未解決的學術爭論
Critical disagreement should be directed toward scholarly arguments, methods, evidence, and interpretations rather than individuals. Contributions are expected to represent the relevant literature accurately, acknowledge the merits of competing perspectives where justified, and maintain a fair and reasoned assessment of alternative positions.
批判性分歧應針對學術論證、研究方法、證據與研究解釋,而非研究者個人。稿件應準確呈現相關文獻,在具有依據時承認不同視角的合理之處,並對替代性學術立場保持公正而有理據的評估。
Void Dialogue / 留白對話
Typical Length: 3,000–6,000 words (excluding references)
建議篇幅:3,000–6,000 詞(不包含參考文獻)
Void Dialogue presents structured scholarly exchanges between two or more researchers who collaboratively examine complex intellectual questions. The section treats dialogue as a form of inquiry through which participants can compare perspectives, reconsider assumptions, clarify theoretical tensions, and develop ideas through sustained discussion.
「留白對話」呈現兩名或多名研究者共同探討複雜智識問題的結構化學術交流。本欄目將對話視為一種探究形式,使參與者能夠透過持續討論比較不同視角、重新思考既有預設、釐清理論張力,並進一步發展學術思想。
Contributions may address evolving theoretical perspectives, competing interpretations, conceptual uncertainties, or unresolved methodological questions. The exchange should demonstrate meaningful intellectual interaction among participants, with arguments and responses that build upon, refine, or critically examine one another. Participants need not reach agreement, but their differences should be presented in a way that helps readers understand the substance of the discussion.
稿件可以探討演變中的理論視角、相互競爭的研究解釋、概念不確定性或尚未解決的方法論問題。對話應展現參與者之間具有實質內容的智識互動,並透過論證與回應,進一步發展、完善或批判性檢驗彼此的觀點。參與者不必最終達成一致,但應以有助於讀者理解討論實質內容的方式呈現不同立場。
The academic value of a dialogue depends on the questions it clarifies, the reasoning it develops, and the insights produced through interaction. A manuscript may reveal unresolved disagreements, identify limitations in existing interpretations, or formulate new questions for subsequent investigation. These outcomes can constitute meaningful scholarly contributions even when the discussion remains open-ended.
學術對話的價值取決於其所釐清的問題、所發展的推理,以及透過互動形成的洞見。稿件可以揭示尚未解決的分歧、辨識既有解釋的局限,或提出供後續研究探討的新問題。即使討論最終仍保持開放性,上述成果亦可能構成有意義的學術貢獻。
Core Characteristics / 核心特徵
-
A structured and substantive exchange between participants參與者之間結構清晰且具有實質內容的交流
-
Exploration of evolving ideas, theoretical perspectives, or conceptual questions探索演變中的思想、理論視角或概念問題
-
Reflective, analytical, and reasoned scholarly dialogue具有反思性、分析性及合理論證的學術對話
Authors should preserve the dialogical character of the manuscript while ensuring a coherent intellectual focus, clear identification of the participants' contributions, and appropriate engagement with relevant scholarly literature. The presentation should make the progression of ideas and responses intelligible to readers. A collection of unrelated statements or opinions does not, by itself, constitute a substantive scholarly dialogue.
作者應在保留稿件對話特徵的同時,確保學術焦點連貫、參與者的貢獻清晰可辨,並與相關學術文獻進行適當對話。文本呈現應使讀者能夠理解思想與回應的發展脈絡。缺乏相互關聯的陳述或觀點集合,本身並不足以構成具有實質意義的學術對話。
Null Reviews / 空白評論
Typical Length: 4,000–7,000 words (excluding references)
建議篇幅:4,000–7,000 詞(不包含參考文獻)
Null Reviews examines research areas in which available evidence is limited, fragmented, inconsistent, or inconclusive. These contributions critically assess gaps in existing knowledge, unresolved theoretical debates, and methodological barriers that have prevented particular questions from receiving adequately supported answers.
「空白評論」考察現有證據有限、碎片化、相互矛盾或尚無定論的研究領域。此類稿件批判性評估既有知識中的空白、尚未解決的理論爭論,以及使特定研究問題難以獲得充分證據支持之解答的方法論障礙。
Rather than advancing conclusions beyond the available evidence, authors should clarify what is currently known, what remains uncertain, and why important questions have resisted resolution. The discussion should be grounded in a critical assessment of relevant literature and should distinguish genuine knowledge gaps from insufficient engagement with existing scholarship.
作者不應提出超出現有證據支持程度的結論,而應釐清目前已知的內容、仍存在的不確定性,以及重要研究問題尚未獲得解決的原因。相關分析應建立在對學術文獻的批判性評估之上,並區分真正的知識空白與因文獻掌握不足而產生的表面空白。
A substantive Null Review should define the boundaries of the literature under examination and assess the quality, relevance, and limitations of the available evidence. Where published studies present conflicting findings, authors should consider whether differences in study design, measurement, analytical methods, theoretical assumptions, or research contexts may contribute to the inconsistency.
具有實質內容的「空白評論」應界定所考察文獻的範圍,並評估現有證據的品質、相關性及局限。當不同已發表研究提出相互衝突的結果時,作者應考察研究設計、測量方式、分析方法、理論預設或研究情境的差異,是否可能造成相關不一致。
Core Characteristics / 核心特徵
-
Critical analysis of limitations and gaps in current knowledge批判性分析現有知識的局限與空白
-
Examination of methodological barriers or unresolved theoretical questions考察方法論障礙或尚未解決的理論問題
-
Identification of evidence-based priorities for further investigation根據現有證據辨識後續研究的優先方向
Null Reviews focuses on the limitations, evidentiary foundations, and unresolved questions of an existing body of knowledge. It should not be confused with a report of statistically non-significant or null findings from a single empirical study. Insufficient evidence does not, by itself, establish the absence of a phenomenon or relationship. Authors should therefore distinguish uncertainty about a proposition from evidence supporting its rejection.
「空白評論」主要關注既有知識體系的局限、證據基礎及未決問題,不應與單項實證研究中統計不顯著或零效應結果的報告混為一談。證據不足本身,並不能直接證明某種現象或關係不存在。因此,作者應區分對某項命題仍存在不確定性,以及已有證據支持否定該命題這兩種不同情況。
General Requirements for All Submission Types / 所有稿件類型的一般要求
Although the six editorial sections accommodate different modes of scholarly inquiry, all manuscripts must meet the journal's common standards for academic integrity, intellectual clarity, methodological accountability, and responsible research communication. Differences in presentation format or research objectives do not remove the obligation to substantiate scholarly claims, acknowledge relevant sources, and represent the limitations of the contribution accurately.
儘管六個編輯欄目接收不同形式的學術探究,所有稿件仍須遵守本刊對學術誠信、智識清晰度、方法論責任及負責任研究傳播的共同標準。研究形式或研究目標的差異,並不免除作者為學術主張提供適當依據、確認相關資料來源,以及準確呈現研究局限的責任。
All Submissions Must Demonstrate / 所有稿件均須符合
-
Relevance to the journal's aims and scope與本刊宗旨及收稿範圍相符
-
Clear scholarly objectives, argumentation, and organization明確的學術目標、清晰的論證及連貫的文本結構
-
Appropriate engagement with relevant academic literature與相關學術文獻進行適當對話
-
Reasoning, evidence, or methodological justification appropriate to the contribution與稿件性質相符的推理、證據或方法論依據
-
Compliance with applicable research and publication ethics standards遵守適用的研究倫理與出版倫理標準
-
Adherence to the journal's manuscript preparation, formatting, and submission requirements遵守本刊稿件準備、排版及投稿要求
Authors should consult the journal's Author Guidelines for requirements concerning submission languages, manuscript structure, abstracts, keywords, citation style, and submission procedures. The suggested manuscript lengths on this page are advisory and should be interpreted consistently with the Author Guidelines. All six sections exclude reference lists from their recommended word counts. This exclusion does not remove the requirement to provide complete and accurate references in the journal's prescribed citation style.
作者應參閱本刊 Author Guidelines(投稿指南),了解投稿語言、稿件結構、摘要、關鍵詞、引用格式及投稿程序等要求。本頁所列篇幅屬於建議性指引,應與投稿指南中的相關規定一致理解。六個欄目的建議字數均不包含參考文獻列表。此項排除並不免除作者依本刊規定的引用格式提供完整且準確參考文獻的義務。
Editorial Assessment and Peer Review / 編輯評估與同行評審
Every submission undergoes initial editorial screening. Research-oriented submissions normally undergo double-anonymous external peer review when suitable for further scholarly evaluation, while Silence Notes receive editorial assessment. The procedure applicable to each manuscript is governed by the journal's Peer Review Policy. A favorable initial assessment does not guarantee acceptance for publication.
所有稿件均接受編輯初審。適合進一步學術評估的研究類稿件通常採用雙匿名外部同行評審,而 Silence Notes(寂靜手記)由編輯進行評估。各類稿件所適用的具體程序,應遵循本刊的 Peer Review Policy(同行評審政策)。通過初步評估並不代表稿件必然獲得錄用。
Editorial evaluation considers the scholarly purpose and characteristics of the submission, including the suitability of the selected section, the clarity of the argument, methodological or conceptual justification, engagement with relevant literature, and the evidentiary support for the conclusions presented. The journal's recognition of diverse scholarly forms does not imply a relaxation of academic standards.
編輯評估將考慮稿件的學術目的與特徵,包括所選欄目的適切性、論證清晰度、方法論或概念依據、與相關文獻的對話,以及研究結論所獲得的證據支持。本刊對多元學術形式的認可,並不意味著降低學術標準。
Authors should select the editorial section that most closely reflects the central purpose of their manuscript. A contribution may involve issues relevant to more than one section, but its principal scholarly objective and form of argumentation should guide the selection. Regardless of the chosen section, the manuscript must communicate a defensible contribution and comply with the journal's editorial and ethical requirements.
作者應選擇最符合稿件核心目的的編輯欄目。一篇稿件可能同時涉及多個欄目的研究議題,但應以其主要學術目標及論證形式作為選擇依據。無論選擇何種欄目,稿件均須提出具有合理依據的學術貢獻,並遵守本刊的編輯與倫理要求。
The journal's sectional structure is intended to facilitate rigorous evaluation without imposing a single model of research presentation on every scholarly contribution. Across all six sections, intellectual honesty, analytical clarity, accurate attribution, and methodological transparency remain essential foundations of publication.
本刊的欄目架構旨在促進嚴謹的學術評估,同時避免以單一研究呈現模式衡量所有學術貢獻。對全部六個欄目而言,智識誠實、分析清晰度、準確來源標示及方法論透明度,始終是學術出版的重要基礎。
Form · Clarity · Argument
形式 · 清晰 · 論證