Unwanted Reviews
Overview / 概述
Unwanted Reviews is an editorial section of Silence dedicated to critical review essays that reconsider established scholarly literature, influential interpretations, and dominant research paradigms. The section provides a space for rigorous examination of the intellectual assumptions, conceptual foundations, methodological traditions, and interpretive practices that shape the production, organization, and evaluation of academic knowledge.
「逆流評論」(Unwanted Reviews)是《Silence》專門刊載批判性文獻評論的編輯欄目,致力於重新審視既有學術文獻、具影響力的研究解釋及主導性研究範式。本欄目為嚴謹考察影響學術知識生產、組織與評估的智識預設、概念基礎、方法論傳統及詮釋實踐提供發表空間。
Scholarly reviews perform several important functions, including synthesizing evidence, identifying research developments, clarifying intellectual disagreements, and evaluating the strengths and limitations of existing knowledge. Critical reassessment is an essential part of this broader scholarly activity, particularly when widely accepted interpretations, influential theories, or established research frameworks warrant renewed examination.
學術評論具有多種重要功能,包括綜合研究證據、辨識學術發展、釐清不同觀點之間的智識分歧,以及評估既有知識的優勢與局限。批判性重新評估是此類學術活動的重要組成部分,尤其適用於廣泛接受的研究解釋、具有影響力的理論或既定研究框架值得重新檢驗的情況。
The term "unwanted" does not imply that a contribution lacks scholarly value, must previously have been rejected by another journal, or should adopt an oppositional position for its own sake. Instead, it expresses the section's willingness to consider carefully reasoned arguments that question familiar assumptions, challenge influential interpretations, or reassess established research traditions, including perspectives that may receive limited attention within prevailing scholarly discussions.
「逆流」一詞並不意味著稿件缺乏學術價值、必須曾遭其他期刊拒絕,或需要為反對而反對。其意義在於表明本欄目願意審慎考慮那些具有充分論證依據、質疑常見預設、挑戰具影響力之解釋,或重新評估既有研究傳統的學術觀點,包括在主流學術討論中可能較少受到關注的研究視角。
The purpose of Unwanted Reviews is to advance scholarly understanding through careful criticism, conceptual clarification, analytical reassessment, and constructive intellectual dialogue. Contributions should demonstrate substantial familiarity with the literature under examination, accurately represent the positions being discussed, and develop criticism that can withstand reasoned scholarly scrutiny.
「逆流評論」旨在透過審慎批判、概念釐清、分析性重新評估及建設性智識對話推進學術理解。稿件應展現對所評述文獻的充分認識、準確呈現相關學術立場,並提出能夠接受理性學術檢驗的批判性論證。
Critical scholarship does not acquire value merely by disagreeing with established knowledge. Its contribution depends on whether the reassessment identifies a substantive intellectual problem, evaluates relevant evidence fairly, and clarifies or improves understanding of the subject under examination.
批判性研究並不會僅因其反對既有知識便自動具有學術價值。相關貢獻取決於重新評估是否辨識具有實質意義的智識問題、是否公正評估相關證據,以及能否釐清或深化對所考察主題的理解。
Scope / 收稿範圍
Unwanted Reviews welcomes scholarly review essays that critically examine the conceptual, theoretical, historical, or methodological foundations of existing research. Submissions should engage substantively with relevant literature and develop an identifiable analytical contribution through critical evaluation, reinterpretation, or reconsideration of established scholarly positions.
「逆流評論」歡迎批判性考察既有研究之概念、理論、歷史或方法論基礎的學術評論文章。稿件應與相關文獻進行實質性對話,並透過批判性評估、重新解釋或重新審視既有學術立場,形成可以明確辨識的分析性貢獻。
The section is open to research across disciplinary and interdisciplinary contexts. It does not require authors to adopt a particular theoretical orientation or to challenge an established position in a predetermined manner. The appropriateness of a submission depends on the significance of the question being examined, the adequacy of its engagement with existing scholarship, and the quality of the reasoning supporting its critical conclusions.
本欄目接收不同學科及跨學科背景下的相關研究,不要求作者採取特定理論立場,也不預設必須以某種固定方式挑戰既有觀點。稿件的適切性取決於所考察問題的重要性、與既有學術成果對話的充分程度,以及支持批判性結論的推理品質。
Areas of Particular Interest / 特別關注的研究方向
-
Critical Reassessment of Research Traditions and Paradigms — Analyses that reconsider influential disciplinary traditions, established research models, or assumptions underlying widely adopted approaches. Such contributions should identify the particular features requiring reassessment and explain how the critique affects the interpretation or application of the relevant research tradition.
研究傳統與範式的批判性重估 — 重新審視具有影響力的學科傳統、既定研究模式,或廣泛採用之研究路徑所依據的基本預設。此類稿件應指出需要重新評估的具體特徵,並說明相關批判如何影響研究傳統的解釋或應用。
-
Re-evaluation of Established Theoretical Frameworks — Critical examinations of widely accepted theories, explanatory models, or conceptual relationships, including their scope, underlying assumptions, internal coherence, evidentiary support, and limitations. Authors may identify circumstances in which a framework remains useful as well as those in which modification or further justification is necessary.
既有理論框架的重新評估 — 批判性考察被廣泛接受的理論、解釋模型或概念關係,包括其適用範圍、基本預設、內部連貫性、證據支持及局限。作者可以辨識理論框架仍然有效的情況,以及需要修正或補充論證的部分。
-
Identification of Overlooked Scholarly Perspectives — Reviews examining neglected arguments, alternative interpretations, or perspectives insufficiently represented in established academic discussions. Contributions should explain the relevance of these perspectives and evaluate their potential to clarify, challenge, or extend prevailing understandings.
被忽略學術視角的辨識 — 考察既有學術討論中未受到充分關注的論點、替代性解釋或研究視角。稿件應說明相關視角的學術關聯,並評估其對釐清、質疑或延伸主流理解可能具有的貢獻。
-
Analysis of Conceptual Limitations — Investigations of ambiguous definitions, inconsistent terminology, explanatory weaknesses, or conceptual boundaries within existing research fields. Such work should explain how the identified difficulties influence scholarly interpretation, comparison, methodological application, or theoretical development.
概念局限的分析 — 探討既有研究領域中的定義模糊、術語不一致、解釋缺陷或概念適用邊界。此類研究應說明相關問題如何影響學術解釋、研究比較、方法應用或理論發展。
-
Historical Reconsideration of Scholarly Debates — Critical analyses of how academic controversies, influential interpretations, and research traditions have developed or changed over time. Authors may examine the historical circumstances, disciplinary assumptions, or intellectual contexts that shaped particular scholarly positions and reassess their significance in contemporary research.
學術爭論的歷史性重新審視 — 批判性分析學術爭論、具影響力之解釋及研究傳統如何隨時間發展或改變。作者可以考察塑造特定學術立場的歷史條件、學科預設或智識脈絡,並重新評估其對當代研究的意義。
These areas illustrate the section's principal intellectual interests rather than establish an exhaustive list of eligible subjects. Other forms of critical review may be appropriate when they address a clearly defined scholarly problem, engage with relevant sources, and offer a substantive contribution to the understanding of existing research.
上述方向旨在說明本欄目的主要智識關注,而非對可投稿主題作出窮盡性規定。其他形式的批判性評論,只要探討明確界定的學術問題、與相關文獻進行充分對話,並能對既有研究的理解作出實質貢獻,同樣可以納入考慮。
Submissions should move beyond descriptive summaries by presenting a clear interpretive or evaluative argument. A contribution may consist of identifying an overlooked assumption, demonstrating a conceptual inconsistency, reconsidering an established interpretation, evaluating a neglected line of scholarship, or proposing a more coherent or better-supported framework for understanding the literature.
稿件應超越描述性文獻總結,提出明確的解釋性或評價性論證。其學術貢獻可以體現在揭示被忽略的預設、論證概念上的不一致、重新評估既有解釋、考察受到忽略的研究脈絡,或提出更加連貫且具有充分依據的文獻理解框架。
The section does not require authors to reject the literature they review. A reasoned reassessment may reaffirm certain established conclusions while identifying qualifications, limitations, unresolved questions, or alternative interpretations that deserve closer examination. The legitimacy of a critique depends on its scholarly justification rather than the extent of its disagreement with prevailing positions.
本欄目不要求作者必須否定所評論的文獻。合理的重新評估可以在承認既有研究部分結論的同時,辨識值得進一步考察的適用條件、研究局限、未決問題或替代性解釋。批判的正當性取決於其學術論證依據,而非與主流立場存在多大程度的分歧。
Analytical Orientation / 分析導向
Contributions to Unwanted Reviews should demonstrate a clear analytical orientation. Authors are expected to examine the scholarly arguments under review alongside the assumptions, methods, conceptual frameworks, evidentiary foundations, and interpretive choices that shape those arguments.
提交至「逆流評論」的稿件應具有明確的分析導向。作者除考察所評論的學術論點外,亦應分析塑造相關論點的基本預設、研究方法、概念框架、證據基礎及解釋選擇。
Critical review essays should establish the scope of the literature considered and explain the reasoning behind the selection of principal sources. The selection approach should be appropriate to the manuscript's purpose and to the claims made about the state of existing scholarship. Authors should make clear whether the work is a focused critical essay, a broader literature review, or another form of scholarly synthesis.
批判性評論文章應界定所考察的文獻範圍,並說明主要文獻的選擇依據。文獻選擇方式應與稿件的研究目的,以及其對既有學術狀況所提出的主張相符。作者應清楚說明其研究屬於聚焦性批判評論、範圍較廣的文獻評論,或其他形式的學術綜合研究。
The scope and method of source selection have direct implications for the conclusions that a review can reasonably support. A focused selection of influential texts may be sufficient for a critical examination of a particular argument, but it does not necessarily justify generalizations about every publication or perspective within the field. Authors should therefore align the breadth of their claims with the literature actually examined.
文獻選擇的範圍與方法,直接影響評論能夠合理支持的結論。對特定論證進行批判性考察時,聚焦選取若干具有影響力的文本可能已經足夠,但這並不必然支持對整個研究領域的所有出版成果或觀點作出概括。因此,作者應確保論述範圍與實際考察的文獻相符。
Principal Analytical Approaches / 主要分析方向
-
Examination of Prevailing Assumptions — Identifying the theoretical, methodological, or epistemological premises informing established interpretations and evaluating their justification. Authors should distinguish assumptions explicitly articulated in the literature from those inferred through their own analysis and explain the evidence supporting such inferences.
既有預設的檢驗 — 辨識影響主流解釋的理論、方法論或認識論前提,並評估其合理性。作者應區分文獻明確提出的預設與經自身分析推導出的隱含預設,並說明支持相關推論的證據。
-
Identification of Conceptual Tensions — Analyzing inconsistencies, ambiguities, or unresolved relationships among concepts, arguments, and findings in existing scholarship. Contributions should clarify whether the identified tensions reflect incompatible definitions, competing theoretical commitments, methodological differences, or limitations in explanatory scope.
概念張力的辨識 — 分析既有學術成果中概念、論證及研究發現之間的不一致、歧義或尚未解決的關係。稿件應釐清相關張力是否源於不相容的定義、相互競爭的理論立場、方法論差異,或解釋範圍的局限。
-
Exploration of Alternative Interpretations — Assessing whether competing perspectives or explanatory frameworks offer a more coherent or better-supported understanding of the research under discussion. Alternative interpretations should be evaluated in relation to relevant evidence, conceptual consistency, explanatory adequacy, and their limitations rather than accepted solely because they differ from dominant positions.
替代性解釋的探索 — 評估不同研究視角或解釋框架能否對所討論的研究提供更加連貫或具有更充分依據的理解。替代性解釋應根據相關證據、概念一致性、解釋充分程度及其局限進行評估,而不能僅因其不同於主流立場便予以接受。
-
Historical and Intellectual Reconsideration — Examining the development of scholarly traditions and considering how institutional, disciplinary, historical, or intellectual contexts have influenced their interpretation. Authors may trace changes in terminology, theoretical priorities, research methods, or scholarly reception, provided that relevant historical claims are grounded in appropriate sources.
歷史與智識層面的重新審視 — 考察學術傳統的發展,並分析制度、學科、歷史或智識脈絡如何影響相關研究的解釋。作者可以追溯術語、理論重點、研究方法或學術接受情況的變化,但涉及歷史事實的主張應具有適當來源支持。
These approaches may be combined where appropriate. A manuscript might, for example, examine the historical development of a theoretical assumption while demonstrating its consequences for contemporary research interpretations. The analytical structure should nevertheless remain coherent, and each component of the critique should contribute to the central scholarly argument.
上述分析方向可以在適當情況下相互結合。例如,稿件可以考察某項理論預設的歷史形成過程,同時分析其對當代研究解釋的影響。然而,整體分析結構仍應保持連貫,批判的各個部分均須對核心學術論證作出貢獻。
The critique should distinguish what the reviewed sources explicitly argue from the author's own interpretation or evaluation. Assertions about weaknesses in prior research should be supported by identifiable examples, accurate references, or appropriate analytical reasoning. Where the evidence admits more than one plausible interpretation, the relevant uncertainty should be acknowledged.
批判性分析應區分所評論文獻明確提出的論點與作者自身的解釋或評價。對先前研究缺陷的判斷,應以可以辨識的具體例證、準確的文獻引用或適當的分析推理作為支持。當現有證據允許多種合理解釋時,應承認相關不確定性。
A critical review does not need to claim that an entire field or theoretical tradition is fundamentally mistaken. A precise demonstration of an overlooked limitation, an unjustified assumption, an interpretive inconsistency, or a neglected alternative explanation can itself constitute a meaningful scholarly contribution.
批判性評論不需要宣稱整個學科領域或理論傳統存在根本性錯誤。對被忽略的局限、缺乏充分依據的預設、解釋上的不一致,或未受到重視的替代性解釋作出精確論證,本身便可能構成有意義的學術貢獻。
Characteristics of Submissions / 稿件的學術特徵
Manuscripts submitted to Unwanted Reviews should demonstrate substantive engagement with relevant scholarship, a coherent analytical argument, conceptual precision, and an identifiable contribution to academic understanding. Critical originality must be accompanied by accurate representation of the work under examination, fair assessment of relevant evidence, and reasoning that supports the conclusions advanced.
提交至「逆流評論」的稿件應展現與相關學術成果的實質性對話、連貫的分析論證、概念精確性,以及可以明確辨識的學術貢獻。批判性的原創觀點必須建立在準確呈現所評論研究、公正評估相關證據,以及具有充分依據之推理的基礎之上。
Comprehensive Engagement with Literature / 與相關文獻的充分對話
Authors should demonstrate a sound understanding of the principal arguments, influential publications, theoretical developments, and relevant debates within the body of literature they examine. The manuscript should identify its scope and explain why the selected sources are appropriate for the research question or critical argument being developed.
作者應充分理解所考察文獻體系中的主要論點、具影響力的研究成果、理論發展及相關學術爭論。稿件應界定評論範圍,並說明所選文獻為何適合支持正在展開的研究問題或批判性論證。
Comprehensive engagement does not necessarily require an exhaustive or systematic search of every publication in a field. A focused review may be grounded in a carefully justified selection of representative or influential sources. However, authors should avoid selective citation practices that misrepresent the state of the literature, disregard directly relevant counterevidence, or omit significant perspectives that materially challenge their interpretation.
充分的文獻對話並不必然要求對某一領域的全部出版成果進行窮盡性或系統性檢索。聚焦性評論可以建立在經過合理說明的代表性或具影響力文獻選擇之上。然而,作者應避免透過選擇性引用扭曲既有研究狀況、忽略直接相關的相反證據,或省略可能對自身解釋形成重大挑戰的重要視角。
Where the literature under examination contains conflicting findings or interpretations, authors should describe the nature of those disagreements accurately. Differences in research design, conceptual definitions, disciplinary context, source selection, or evidentiary standards may help explain why scholarly conclusions diverge. Such distinctions should be examined before attributing disagreements to intellectual error or methodological inadequacy.
當所考察文獻存在相互衝突的研究發現或解釋時,作者應準確描述相關分歧的性質。研究設計、概念定義、學科背景、文獻選擇或證據標準的差異,可能有助於解釋不同學術結論的形成。在將分歧歸因於智識錯誤或方法論不足之前,應先考察上述區別。
The adequacy of literature engagement should be judged in relation to the manuscript's stated analytical purpose. Authors should avoid claiming comprehensive coverage where the work has examined only a limited set of materials. Equally, a review should not be considered inadequate merely because it concentrates on a clearly delimited debate or a specific body of influential texts.
文獻對話是否充分,應根據稿件所提出的分析目的進行判斷。作者如僅考察有限數量的材料,不應聲稱已全面涵蓋相關領域。同樣,評論文章若聚焦於明確界定的學術爭論或特定具有影響力的文本體系,也不應僅因範圍有限便被視為學術內容不足。
Critical Interpretation / 批判性解釋
A critical review should evaluate the strengths, assumptions, limitations, and implications of existing scholarship rather than merely restate its conclusions. Authors should explain the basis for their criticism, consider relevant counterarguments, and distinguish demonstrated problems from questions that remain open to interpretation.
批判性評論應評估既有研究的優勢、基本預設、局限及影響,而非僅重述相關結論。作者應解釋批判的依據,考慮相關反對意見,並區分已得到論證的問題與仍存在解釋空間的爭議。
Criticism must be directed toward scholarly claims, research methods, conceptual frameworks, evidentiary interpretations, or other academically relevant matters. Personal attacks, unsupported allegations, and dismissive characterizations of researchers or academic communities do not constitute acceptable substitutes for scholarly analysis.
批判應針對學術主張、研究方法、概念框架、證據解釋或其他具有學術相關性的問題。針對研究者或學術共同體的人身攻擊、缺乏證據支持的指控及貶抑性描述,均不能取代正當的學術分析。
Authors should distinguish criticism of a claim from criticism of the researcher who advanced it. An argument may be incomplete, based on contestable assumptions, or limited by its evidence without implying misconduct, incompetence, or improper motives on the part of its authors. Allegations involving research integrity must not be inferred from scholarly disagreement alone.
作者應區分對學術主張的批判與對提出該主張之研究者的批判。某項論證可能不完整、建立在有爭議的預設上,或受到證據局限的影響,但這並不必然意味著其作者存在學術不端、能力不足或不當動機。不得僅憑學術分歧便推定存在研究誠信問題。
A rigorous interpretation should recognize the strongest reasonable formulation of the position being examined. When an existing theory or research tradition has demonstrable explanatory value, that value should be acknowledged even if the manuscript ultimately argues for revision, qualification, or rejection of particular propositions.
嚴謹的批判性解釋應準確把握所考察立場最具合理性的論證形式。當既有理論或研究傳統具有可被證明的解釋價值時,即使稿件最終主張修正、限制或否定其中某些命題,仍應承認其相關學術價值。
Conceptual Clarity / 概念清晰度
Manuscripts should define central concepts clearly and use terminology consistently. Where the criticism concerns conceptual ambiguity, authors should identify the competing definitions, explain their consequences for research interpretation, and justify any alternative conceptual distinctions they propose.
稿件應清楚界定核心概念並保持術語一致。如批判涉及概念歧義,作者應辨識相互競爭的定義,解釋其對研究解釋的影響,並為提出的替代性概念區分提供合理依據。
Conceptual criticism should distinguish substantive disagreements about meaning or theoretical application from differences in terminology that do not materially affect scholarly conclusions. When a concept is used differently across disciplines, historical periods, or research traditions, authors should establish the relevant context before evaluating apparent inconsistencies.
概念批判應區分涉及意義或理論應用的實質分歧,以及不會對學術結論造成重大影響的術語差異。當某項概念在不同學科、歷史時期或研究傳統中具有不同用法時,作者應先界定相關脈絡,再評估表面上存在的不一致。
An argument should develop through identifiable analytical steps. Claims about theoretical inconsistency, methodological inadequacy, explanatory weakness, or conceptual confusion should be connected to the relevant sources and supported by reasoning sufficient for readers to evaluate the criticism independently.
論證應透過清晰可辨的分析步驟展開。對理論不一致、方法論不足、解釋缺陷或概念混淆的判斷,應與相關文獻建立明確聯繫,並提供足以使讀者獨立評估其合理性的推理依據。
Where a manuscript proposes revised terminology, alternative definitions, or a new conceptual framework, the author should explain how the proposal addresses the identified difficulty and what limitations remain. The introduction of new terminology does not itself establish an intellectual advance unless it improves analytical clarity, explanatory adequacy, or the understanding of relevant scholarly relationships.
如稿件提出修訂術語、替代性定義或新的概念框架,作者應說明相關方案如何回應已辨識的問題,以及仍存在何種局限。創造新的術語本身並不足以構成智識進展,除非它能夠改善分析清晰度、解釋充分性,或促進對相關學術關係的理解。
Scholarly Contribution / 學術貢獻
Contributions should clarify how their critical reassessment advances understanding of the literature, research problem, or theoretical framework under discussion. This advancement may involve correcting an influential interpretation, identifying an overlooked assumption, refining a conceptual distinction, evaluating competing explanations, or proposing a more productive direction for subsequent investigation.
稿件應清楚說明其批判性重新評估如何推進對相關文獻、研究問題或理論框架的理解。這種推進可能體現在修正具影響力的解釋、辨識被忽略的預設、深化概念區分、評估相互競爭的解釋,或為後續研究提出更具建設性的方向。
A meaningful contribution need not consist of replacing an established paradigm with an entirely new theory. It may result from clarifying the scope of a well-supported conclusion, demonstrating that a disagreement rests on distinct conceptual assumptions, or showing that a commonly accepted interpretation requires qualification under particular conditions.
具有實質意義的學術貢獻,不必以全新理論取代既有範式為必要條件。釐清具有充分支持之結論的適用範圍、說明某項學術分歧其實建立在不同概念預設之上,或論證廣泛接受的解釋在特定條件下需要受到限制,都可能形成有價值的研究成果。
The contribution should be proportionate to the evidence and argument presented. Authors are not required to resolve every controversy associated with a research tradition, but they should specify what their analysis establishes, which interpretations remain contestable, and what questions require further examination.
學術貢獻的主張應與所提供的證據及論證相稱。作者無須解決某一研究傳統所涉及的全部爭議,但應明確說明其分析已確認的內容、哪些解釋仍可受到質疑,以及哪些問題需要進一步考察。
Recommendations for subsequent research should follow logically from the analysis rather than appear as unrelated proposals. Where a new framework or interpretation is advanced, the manuscript should explain its comparative strengths, the questions it addresses, and the limitations that remain unresolved.
對後續研究的建議應由分析合理推導,而非提出與核心論證缺乏關聯的研究構想。如稿件提出新的框架或解釋,應說明其相對優勢、所能回應的問題,以及仍未解決的局限。
Rigorous criticism requires intellectual fairness. Authors should represent opposing arguments accurately, acknowledge relevant evidence even when it challenges their position, distinguish established limitations from disputed interpretations, and support disagreement through scholarly analysis rather than rhetorical intensity.
嚴謹的批判需要智識上的公正。作者應準確呈現不同立場的論證,即使相關證據可能挑戰自身觀點,仍應予以承認;同時區分已確認的研究局限與仍存在爭議的解釋,並以學術分析而非修辭上的激烈程度支持批判。
Types of Contributions / 可投稿的學術形式
Unwanted Reviews accommodates different forms of critical scholarly review and reassessment. Contributions should be grounded in a clearly defined question or analytical objective and should demonstrate how their engagement with existing scholarship leads to an identifiable critical insight. The examples below describe suitable approaches within this editorial section and do not constitute additional formal article categories.
「逆流評論」接收不同形式的批判性學術評論與重新評估。稿件應以明確界定的研究問題或分析目標為基礎,並展示其與既有學術成果的對話如何形成可辨識的批判性洞見。以下示例說明適合本欄目的研究方式,並不構成另行設立的正式文章分類。
-
Critical Review Essays on Established Research Paradigms — Reviews examining the underlying assumptions, analytical boundaries, methodological conventions, and evidentiary foundations of influential research traditions. Authors should explain the basis for their reassessment and identify how the critique affects the understanding or application of the paradigm.
既定研究範式的批判性評論 — 考察具有影響力之研究傳統的基本預設、分析邊界、方法論慣例及證據基礎的評論文章。作者應說明重新評估的依據,並辨識相關批判如何影響對該範式的理解或應用。
-
Conceptual Critiques of Dominant Theoretical Frameworks — Analyses reconsidering the definitions, explanatory assumptions, internal consistency, or applicability of influential theoretical models. Such contributions may identify conceptual ambiguities, examine conflicts between theoretical propositions, or propose more precise distinctions supported by scholarly reasoning.
主導性理論框架的概念批判 — 重新評估具影響力之理論模型的概念定義、解釋預設、內部一致性或適用性的分析。此類稿件可以辨識概念歧義、考察理論命題之間的衝突,或提出具有學術推理支持的更精確概念區分。
-
Reassessments of Influential Scholarly Debates — Contributions revisiting prominent academic controversies, comparing competing interpretations, and evaluating whether established conclusions remain adequately supported by the relevant evidence and reasoning. Authors should represent the different positions fairly and distinguish changes in evidence from differences in interpretation.
具影響力學術爭論的重新評估 — 重新考察重要學術爭議、比較不同解釋,並評估既有結論是否仍具有充分證據及推理支持的研究。作者應公正呈現不同立場,並區分證據本身的變化與研究解釋上的分歧。
-
Historical Analyses of Research Traditions — Studies tracing the conceptual, methodological, or intellectual development of scholarly traditions and critically evaluating their changing interpretations. Contributions may examine how historical circumstances, disciplinary developments, or shifts in scholarly priorities influenced the reception and application of particular research frameworks.
研究傳統發展的歷史分析 — 追溯學術傳統在概念、方法論或智識層面的發展,並批判性評估其解釋如何演變的研究。稿件可以考察歷史情況、學科發展或學術關注重點的轉變,如何影響特定研究框架的接受及應用。
Submissions may employ conceptual analysis, historical interpretation, comparative theoretical examination, critical literature synthesis, or other suitable scholarly methods. The approach should be appropriate to the question under consideration and clearly explained in the manuscript. Different methodological traditions may require different forms of explanation and source evaluation.
稿件可以採用概念分析、歷史詮釋、比較理論研究、批判性文獻綜合或其他適當的學術方法。所採用的研究路徑應與待探討的問題相符,並在稿件中得到清楚說明。不同方法論傳統可能需要採用不同形式的分析說明及文獻評估。
Where authors characterize their work as a systematic review, scoping review, or another methodologically defined form of evidence synthesis, the manuscript should accurately describe the procedures actually undertaken. Relevant methodological details may include the search strategy, source selection, eligibility criteria, and approach to analysis or synthesis, as appropriate to the review design. A focused critical essay must not be presented as a comprehensive systematic review unless its methods justify that description.
如作者將稿件界定為系統性綜述、範疇性綜述或其他具有明確方法論特徵的證據綜合研究,便應準確說明實際執行的研究程序。根據評論研究的設計,相關方法論資訊可能包括文獻檢索策略、資料來源選擇、納入條件,以及分析或綜合方式。未具備相應方法論基礎的聚焦性批判評論,不得被描述為全面的系統性綜述。
The distinction between review formats matters because different methods support different kinds of claims. Authors should avoid describing their source selection as exhaustive, reproducible, or systematic unless the procedures undertaken substantiate those descriptions. Conversely, a well-argued critical essay does not need to adopt systematic-review procedures when its purpose is a focused conceptual, theoretical, or interpretive reassessment.
區分不同評論形式具有重要意義,因為不同方法能夠支持的學術主張並不相同。除非實際執行的程序具有相應依據,作者不應將文獻選擇描述為窮盡性、可重複或系統性。另一方面,當稿件旨在對特定概念、理論或研究解釋進行聚焦性重新評估時,具有充分論證的批判性評論亦無須強行採用系統性綜述的研究程序。
Manuscript Length / 稿件篇幅
5,000–8,000 Words
Typical manuscript length, excluding references
建議稿件篇幅:5,000–8,000 詞,不包含參考文獻。
Manuscripts submitted to Unwanted Reviews typically range from 5,000 to 8,000 words, excluding the reference list. This range is intended to provide sufficient space for establishing the scholarly context, examining relevant literature, developing a sustained critical argument, considering alternative perspectives, and explaining the significance of the proposed reassessment.
提交至「逆流評論」的稿件,建議篇幅為 5,000 至 8,000 詞,不包含參考文獻列表。此建議篇幅旨在為交代學術背景、考察相關文獻、展開充分的批判性論證、考慮不同研究視角,以及說明重新評估的學術意義提供適當空間。
The recommended word range is an editorial guideline rather than an absolute limit. Manuscripts requiring a longer discussion may be considered where the extent of the literature, complexity of the theoretical issues, historical scope, or depth of the critical analysis reasonably justifies additional space. Additional length should contribute directly to the scholarly argument and should not result from unnecessary repetition or the inclusion of material unrelated to the manuscript's central purpose.
上述建議字數屬於編輯指引,而非絕對限制。如所考察文獻的廣度、理論問題的複雜程度、歷史分析範圍或批判性研究的深度,能夠合理支持更長篇幅,相關稿件亦可納入考慮。增加的篇幅應直接服務於學術論證,而不應來自不必要的重複或與稿件核心目的無關的材料。
The manuscript should be clearly organized and should ordinarily establish the purpose and scope of the review, its relationship to existing scholarship, the rationale for selecting sources, the central analytical argument, consideration of relevant counterarguments, and the conclusions or implications supported by the review. Its structure may be adapted to disciplinary conventions, the nature of the critical inquiry, and the methodology actually employed.
稿件應具有清晰結構,通常需要交代評論目的與範圍、與既有研究的關係、文獻選擇依據、核心分析論證、對相關反對論證的考察,以及評論所支持的結論或研究啟示。具體結構可根據學科慣例、批判性探究的性質及實際採用的方法論適當調整。
The exclusion of references from the recommended word count does not remove the obligation to provide a complete, relevant, and accurately formatted reference list. Authors should acknowledge the sources necessary to substantiate their analysis and must follow the journal's required American Psychological Association (APA) style for in-text citations and references.
參考文獻不計入建議字數,並不免除作者提交完整、相關且格式準確之參考文獻列表的義務。作者應確認支持其分析所必需的資料來源,並須依本刊規定的美國心理學會(APA)格式處理正文引用與參考文獻。
Authors should consult the journal's Author Guidelines for requirements concerning submission language, abstracts, keywords, formatting, citation style, and submission procedures. Silence accepts manuscripts in English or Chinese. Under the journal's general manuscript requirements, submissions should include an abstract of no more than 300 words and four to six keywords.
作者應參閱本刊 Author Guidelines(投稿指南),了解投稿語言、摘要、關鍵詞、稿件排版、引用格式及投稿程序等要求。《Silence》接受英文或中文稿件。依據本刊一般稿件要求,投稿應包含不超過 300 詞的摘要,以及 4 至 6 個關鍵詞。
All submissions must comply with the journal's applicable publication ethics requirements. Authors should ensure the originality of their analysis, accurately identify the intellectual contributions of others, disclose relevant conflicts of interest, and avoid plagiarism, misleading representations of source material, fabricated references, or unsupported allegations concerning other researchers.
所有投稿均須遵守本刊適用的出版倫理要求。作者應確保分析具有原創性、準確確認他人的智識貢獻、披露相關利益衝突,並避免剽竊、對來源材料作出具有誤導性的表述、捏造參考文獻,或對其他研究者提出缺乏證據支持的指控。
Editorial Screening and Peer Review / 編輯初審與同行評審
Submissions to Unwanted Reviews undergo initial editorial screening and, when suitable for further scholarly evaluation, normally proceed to double-anonymous external peer review. Initial screening considers the manuscript's relevance to the journal's aims and scope, suitability for the section, compliance with submission requirements, and the presence of a sufficiently developed scholarly argument.
提交至「逆流評論」的稿件須接受編輯初審,適合進一步學術評估的稿件通常進入雙匿名外部同行評審程序。初審將考慮稿件與期刊宗旨及收稿範圍的契合程度、是否適合本欄目、是否符合投稿要求,以及是否已形成具有充分發展程度的學術論證。
Peer-review evaluation considers the accuracy and adequacy of engagement with the relevant literature, intellectual fairness, conceptual clarity, methodological or interpretive justification, strength of analytical reasoning, originality, and scholarly significance of the contribution. Reviewers should assess whether the manuscript's criticism is substantiated rather than whether its conclusions agree with established academic positions.
同行評審將考慮與相關文獻對話的準確性及充分程度、智識公正性、概念清晰度、方法論或解釋依據、分析推理的可靠性、原創性,以及稿件的學術意義。審稿人應評估稿件的批判是否具有充分論證依據,而非以其結論是否符合既有學術立場作為判斷標準。
A manuscript's disagreement with an established interpretation does not, by itself, justify rejection or acceptance. Editorial decisions depend on the scholarly quality of the work and its compliance with the journal's applicable editorial and ethical policies. A critical position is neither a substitute for scholarly evidence nor a reason for excluding a well-supported contribution from consideration.
稿件與既有學術解釋存在分歧,本身既不構成拒稿理由,也不代表應予錄用。編輯決策取決於研究的學術品質,以及其是否符合本刊適用的編輯與倫理政策。批判性立場不能取代學術證據,也不應成為排除具有充分依據之學術成果的理由。
Authors may be asked to revise unsupported claims, improve engagement with contrary evidence, clarify the basis for selecting sources, correct inaccurate representations of prior scholarship, or acknowledge the limitations of their analysis. Revision requests should be considered carefully and addressed through appropriate amendments or reasoned explanations. A request for revision does not guarantee acceptance.
作者可能被要求修訂缺乏依據的主張、加強對相反證據的討論、釐清文獻選擇的依據、修正對先前研究的不準確描述,或承認分析所存在的局限。作者應審慎考慮修訂要求,並透過適當修改或有理據的說明作出回應。修訂要求不代表稿件必然獲得錄用。
Authors preparing manuscripts for double-anonymous review should follow the journal's anonymization requirements while maintaining accurate scholarly citations. The conduct of peer review, consideration of revisions, and final editorial decisions remain governed by the journal's Peer Review Policy.
準備接受雙匿名評審的作者應遵守本刊的匿名化要求,同時維持學術引用的準確性。同行評審的實施、修訂稿件的評估及最終編輯決策,均依據本刊 Peer Review Policy(同行評審政策)執行。
Contribution to Scholarly Dialogue / 對學術對話的貢獻
Unwanted Reviews reflects the broader commitment of Silence to intellectual openness, methodological reflection, and responsible scholarly criticism. By encouraging the reconsideration of established research traditions, the section seeks to make academic debate more attentive to the assumptions, limitations, historical circumstances, and alternative interpretations that shape existing knowledge.
「逆流評論」體現《Silence》對智識開放、方法論反思及負責任學術批判的整體承諾。透過鼓勵重新審視既有研究傳統,本欄目期望促進學術討論更加重視塑造既有知識的基本預設、研究局限、歷史條件及替代性解釋。
Critical reassessment can contribute to academic understanding by clarifying the boundaries of established explanations, distinguishing durable conclusions from contested assumptions, examining tensions among theoretical perspectives, and identifying questions that warrant renewed investigation. Such work may help scholars recognize where existing frameworks remain useful and where modification, qualification, or further evidence is needed.
批判性重新評估可以透過釐清既有解釋的適用邊界、區分具有穩固依據的結論與仍存在爭議的預設、考察不同理論視角之間的張力,以及辨識值得重新研究的問題,推進學術理解。此類工作有助於學者認識現有框架在何處仍具有價值,又在何處需要修正、補充限制條件或增加證據。
The section recognizes that scholarly progress does not require continuous rejection of previous knowledge. It may also emerge from a more precise understanding of established theories, a fair comparison of competing perspectives, a reconstruction of overlooked intellectual developments, or a careful revision of claims whose scope has been overstated.
本欄目認為,學術進步並不需要不斷否定先前知識。對既有理論形成更精確的理解、公正比較相互競爭的視角、重新梳理被忽略的思想發展脈絡,或審慎修正適用範圍被過度擴大的研究主張,同樣可能構成重要的知識發展。
Constructive scholarly criticism requires intellectual independence as well as responsibility toward the academic record. Authors should be free to question influential interpretations while remaining accountable for the accuracy of their citations, the fairness of their representations, and the evidentiary basis of their conclusions. The strength of a critical argument lies in the quality of its analysis rather than the forcefulness of its language.
建設性的學術批判既需要智識獨立,也需要對學術記錄承擔責任。作者可以自由質疑具影響力的研究解釋,但仍須對引用的準確性、不同立場呈現的公正性,以及結論的證據基礎負責。批判性論證的說服力來自分析品質,而非語言表達的強烈程度。
Through rigorous review, intellectual fairness, conceptual precision, and constructive disagreement, Unwanted Reviews aims to support scholarly dialogue in which established interpretations can be questioned without abandoning the standards of evidence, accuracy, and reasoned argument on which academic inquiry depends.
透過嚴謹的文獻評論、智識公正、概念精確性及建設性分歧,「逆流評論」期望支持一種既允許質疑既有解釋,又不放棄證據、準確性及理性論證等學術基本標準的知識交流環境。
Relationship to Null Reviews / 與空白評論欄目的區別
Unwanted Reviews focuses primarily on the critical reassessment of existing scholarship, theories, influential interpretations, and research traditions. Its central concern is how established knowledge has been constructed, justified, interpreted, challenged, or revised. Manuscripts are expected to develop a substantive critical argument concerning the scholarship under review.
「逆流評論」主要關注對既有學術成果、理論、具影響力的研究解釋及研究傳統的批判性重新評估。其核心問題在於既有知識如何被建構、論證、解釋、質疑或修正。稿件應針對所考察的學術成果提出具有實質內容的批判性論證。
By contrast, Null Reviews focuses on areas in which the available scholarly evidence is insufficient, fragmented, inconsistent, or inconclusive. Manuscripts primarily concerned with mapping the limitations of an evidence base, identifying unresolved questions across a field, or analyzing why the available literature cannot support particular conclusions may be more appropriate for Null Reviews.
相較之下,「空白評論」(Null Reviews)主要關注現有學術證據不足、碎片化、相互矛盾或尚無定論的研究領域。若稿件的主要目的在於梳理某一領域的證據局限、辨識尚未解決的研究問題,或分析現有文獻為何無法支持特定結論,則可能更適合投稿至「空白評論」。
The distinction between the two sections concerns the principal intellectual purpose of a manuscript rather than an absolute separation of research topics. A critical reassessment may reveal gaps in knowledge, while an investigation of unresolved evidence may question an established interpretation. Authors should select the section corresponding most closely to the central question, analytical emphasis, and intended scholarly contribution of their work.
兩個欄目的區別主要取決於稿件的核心智識目的,而非研究主題之間存在絕對界限。批判性重新評估可能揭示知識空白,而對未決證據的研究亦可能質疑既有解釋。作者應根據稿件的核心問題、分析重點及預期學術貢獻,選擇最適合的投稿欄目。
The broader purpose of Unwanted Reviews is not to promote disagreement as an end in itself, but to encourage careful, fair, and intellectually productive reassessment. By examining established scholarship with both openness and critical discipline, the section seeks to contribute to a more precise, transparent, and continually developing understanding of academic knowledge.
「逆流評論」更廣泛的目的並非將分歧本身視為終點,而是鼓勵審慎、公正且具有智識建設性的重新評估。透過以開放態度與批判性紀律考察既有學術成果,本欄目期望促進對學術知識更加精確、透明且持續發展的理解。
Reassessment · Critique · Dialogue
重估 · 批判 · 對話