Overview / 概述

Null Reviews is an editorial section of Silence dedicated to the critical examination of scholarly fields characterized by incomplete evidence, unresolved research questions, conflicting findings, or significant gaps in existing knowledge. The section provides a publication space for rigorous analyses of what is currently known, what remains uncertain, and why particular questions have not yet been adequately resolved.

「空白評論」(Null Reviews)是《Silence》專門刊載學術知識空白與研究不確定性分析的編輯欄目,主要關注現有證據不完整、研究問題尚未解決、研究發現相互衝突,或存在重大知識缺口的學術領域。本欄目為嚴謹考察當前已知的內容、仍然存在的不確定性,以及特定問題尚未得到充分解決的原因提供發表空間。

Scholarly knowledge develops through the accumulation, evaluation, comparison, and revision of research findings. However, the available literature does not always support clear, stable, or sufficiently precise conclusions. Evidence may be limited in quantity, inconsistent across studies, dependent on particular research settings, or difficult to interpret because of methodological, conceptual, and analytical differences.

學術知識透過研究發現的累積、評估、比較與修正而持續發展。然而,現有文獻並不總能支持明確、穩定或足夠精確的結論。相關證據可能在數量上不足、不同研究之間存在不一致、受到特定研究情境限制,或因方法論、概念及分析方式的差異而難以解釋。

Null Reviews recognizes that the disciplined clarification of uncertainty can constitute a meaningful scholarly contribution. Rather than assigning premature certainty to unresolved questions, the section encourages authors to examine the quality, distribution, consistency, and limitations of existing evidence, identify the sources of disagreement or uncertainty, and explain their implications for scholarly understanding.

「空白評論」認為,以嚴謹且有條理的方式釐清不確定性,本身便可能構成有意義的學術貢獻。本欄目鼓勵作者考察現有證據的品質、分布、一致性及局限,辨識學術分歧或不確定性的來源,並解釋其對學術理解的影響,而非對尚未解決的問題過早作出確定性判斷。

The term "null" refers to gaps, limitations, unresolved relationships, and areas where available knowledge remains insufficient to support particular claims. It does not imply that no relevant research exists, that all findings are statistically non-significant, or that an absence of evidence is equivalent to evidence that an effect or relationship does not exist.

「空白」(Null)一詞指向知識缺口、研究局限、尚未釐清的關係,以及現有知識不足以支持特定主張的領域。它並不意味著相關研究完全不存在、所有研究結果均不具統計顯著性,或缺乏證據便等同於已有證據證明某種效應或關係不存在。

The section therefore distinguishes between the existence of a research gap and the evaluation of the evidence surrounding that gap. An unanswered question may arise because relevant studies are absent, because available investigations lack sufficient methodological strength, because findings differ across populations or settings, or because existing theoretical frameworks do not adequately explain the observations. These circumstances require different analytical approaches and should not be treated as interchangeable.

因此,本欄目明確區分研究空白的存在與對其相關證據的評估。某項問題尚未得到解答,可能是因為缺乏直接相關的研究、現有調查的方法論強度不足、不同研究群體或情境中的發現存在差異,或既有理論框架無法充分解釋觀察結果。上述情況需要不同的分析方式,不應相互混用。

The Scholarly Value of Uncertainty / 不確定性的學術價值

The purpose of Null Reviews is not to portray uncertainty as inherently desirable or to dismiss established knowledge. Its purpose is to distinguish well-supported conclusions from provisional interpretations, identify the limits of available evidence, and explain how those limits affect the claims that researchers can reasonably make.

「空白評論」的目的並非將不確定性本身視為值得追求的結果,也不是否定已有充分支持的知識,而是區分證據充分的結論與暫時性解釋、辨識現有證據的適用邊界,並說明相關限制如何影響研究者能夠合理提出的學術主張。

A substantial Null Review should contribute more than an inventory of unanswered questions. It should offer a reasoned assessment of the current research landscape, distinguish different forms and degrees of uncertainty, and demonstrate how an improved understanding of existing limitations can inform scholarly interpretation, methodological development, or subsequent investigation.

具有實質內容的「空白評論」不應僅列舉尚未回答的問題,而應對當前研究狀況作出具有論證依據的評估,區分不同形式與程度的不確定性,並展示對既有局限更加準確的理解,如何支持學術解釋、方法論發展或後續研究。

Scope / 收稿範圍

Null Reviews welcomes scholarly review manuscripts that critically examine research areas in which available findings remain incomplete, contradictory, fragmented, or insufficient to support clearly defined conclusions. Contributions should investigate the conceptual, methodological, evidentiary, or structural conditions that contribute to these uncertainties and explain their implications for the interpretation of existing scholarship.

「空白評論」歡迎批判性考察現有研究發現不完整、相互矛盾、呈現碎片化,或不足以支持明確結論之研究領域的學術評論稿件。相關研究應分析造成此類不確定性的概念、方法論、證據或結構性條件,並解釋其對既有學術成果之理解所產生的影響。

The section is interdisciplinary in orientation and accommodates relevant contributions from the humanities, social sciences, natural sciences, and interdisciplinary research fields. It does not prescribe a single theoretical tradition or review methodology. The suitability of a manuscript depends on the significance of the research problem, the adequacy of the literature considered, the transparency of the analytical approach, and the scholarly contribution of the review.

本欄目具有跨學科定位,接收人文學科、社會科學、自然科學及跨學科研究領域的相關學術成果,不預設單一理論傳統或評論方法。稿件的適切性取決於研究問題的重要性、所考察文獻的充分程度、分析路徑的透明度,以及評論所形成的學術貢獻。

Areas of Particular Interest / 特別關注的研究方向

  • Persistent Inconclusive or Conflicting Findings — Research areas in which findings remain inconsistent, insufficiently replicated, or unable to establish a stable interpretation despite continuing scholarly investigation. Contributions should evaluate the nature of the inconsistency and distinguish genuine evidentiary disagreement from differences arising through study design, measurement, analytical methods, or research context.

    持續存在無定論或相互衝突的研究發現 — 儘管已有持續性學術研究,相關結果仍存在不一致、缺乏充分重複驗證,或尚無法形成穩定解釋的領域。稿件應評估不一致的具體性質,並區分真正的證據分歧,以及研究設計、測量、分析方法或研究情境差異所造成的不同結果。

  • Unresolved Theoretical or Empirical Debates — Scholarly controversies in which competing explanations, theoretical positions, or interpretations of evidence remain insufficiently reconciled. Authors may examine the assumptions underlying different positions, the evidence on which they rely, and the questions that must be resolved before a more coherent interpretation can emerge.

    尚未解決的理論或實證爭論 — 不同解釋、理論立場或證據詮釋之間的分歧仍未得到充分釐清的學術爭議。作者可以考察不同立場所依據的基本預設及相關證據,並辨識形成更加連貫之解釋前仍須解決的問題。

  • Methodological Limitations Restricting Reliable Conclusions — Research fields affected by recurring problems in study design, measurement, sampling, analytical methods, study comparability, or the interpretation of findings. Contributions should explain which conclusions are affected, how the relevant limitations operate, and whether the available evidence nevertheless supports more restricted claims.

    方法論局限制約可靠結論的形成 — 研究設計、測量、抽樣、分析方法、研究間可比較性或結果解釋中反覆出現問題的學術領域。稿件應說明哪些結論受到影響、相關局限如何發揮作用,以及現有證據是否仍能支持範圍較為有限的主張。

  • Insufficient Data or Evidentiary Coverage — Research questions for which available evidence is limited, unevenly distributed, inaccessible, or insufficiently representative of relevant populations, contexts, or phenomena. Authors should examine the consequences of these gaps for generalizability, interpretation, and the ability to evaluate competing explanations.

    資料不足或證據覆蓋不充分 — 現有證據有限、分布不均、難以取得,或不足以適當涵蓋相關研究群體、情境及現象的問題。作者應考察此類缺口對結論的普遍適用性、研究解釋及相互競爭之解釋的評估能力所造成的影響。

  • Underdeveloped Conceptual Frameworks in Emerging Fields — Areas in which important concepts, theoretical relationships, or analytical boundaries have not yet been adequately defined or examined. Contributions may clarify how conceptual ambiguity limits the interpretation and comparison of findings and identify distinctions that could support more rigorous future investigation.

    新興研究領域中尚不完善的概念框架 — 重要概念、理論關係或分析邊界尚未得到充分界定或檢驗的研究領域。稿件可以釐清概念歧義如何限制研究發現的解釋與比較,並辨識能夠支持未來更加嚴謹研究的重要概念區分。

These areas illustrate the section's principal scholarly interests rather than establish an exhaustive list of eligible subjects. Other review topics may be appropriate where the manuscript identifies a consequential limitation in existing knowledge and offers a substantive, evidence-informed analysis of its causes and implications.

上述方向旨在說明本欄目的主要學術關注,而非對可投稿主題作出窮盡性限制。其他評論主題如能辨識既有知識中具有重要影響的局限,並對其成因與影響提出具有實質內容及證據依據的分析,同樣可以納入考慮。

Submissions should identify a specific unresolved problem or knowledge gap and demonstrate why the available literature does not adequately resolve it. Authors should examine relevant findings fairly, identify meaningful areas of agreement and disagreement, and avoid exaggerating uncertainty when existing evidence already supports qualified or context-specific conclusions.

稿件應辨識具體的未決問題或知識空白,並論證現有文獻為何尚不足以充分解決該問題。作者應公正考察相關研究發現、辨識具有實質意義的共識與分歧,並避免在現有證據已能支持附帶條件或具有特定情境適用性的結論時,誇大不確定性。

The existence of disagreement within a field does not automatically establish that no reliable knowledge is available. A strong contribution should explain which questions remain unresolved, which findings are relatively well supported, and how these distinctions affect the overall state of scholarly understanding. It should also distinguish genuine gaps in research from limitations created by the scope of the review itself.

某一研究領域存在學術分歧,並不自動意味著該領域缺乏任何可靠知識。高品質的稿件應說明哪些問題仍未解決、哪些發現已有相對充分的支持,以及這些區分如何影響對整體知識狀況的理解。同時,亦須區分研究本身存在的真正空白,與評論所採用的文獻範圍造成的限制。

Authors should not infer the absence of scholarly research merely because a limited search has failed to identify relevant publications. Where the evidence base is described as sparse, incomplete, or insufficiently representative, the manuscript should explain the basis for that assessment and acknowledge the limitations of the source identification process.

作者不得僅因有限的文獻檢索未能找到相關出版成果,便推定某一主題完全缺乏學術研究。當稿件將證據體系描述為稀少、不完整或代表性不足時,應說明相關判斷的依據,並承認文獻辨識程序本身的局限。

Analytical Orientation / 分析導向

The central purpose of Null Reviews is to clarify the nature, sources, extent, and consequences of uncertainty within existing scholarship. Authors should move beyond identifying unanswered questions and examine why particular claims remain unsupported, disputed, difficult to evaluate, or dependent on evidence that is not yet sufficiently developed.

「空白評論」的核心目的在於釐清既有學術研究中不確定性的性質、來源、程度及影響。作者應超越單純指出未獲解答的問題,進一步考察特定主張為何缺乏充分支持、仍存在爭議、難以評估,或依賴尚未充分發展的證據。

The analytical approach should be grounded in a clearly defined body of relevant literature. Authors should describe the scope of the sources considered, explain the rationale for selecting them, identify the principal questions guiding the review, and acknowledge any important limitations of the literature coverage. The level of methodological detail should be proportionate to the type of review actually undertaken.

分析應建立在界定清楚的相關文獻基礎之上。作者應說明所考察的資料範圍、文獻選擇依據、指導評論的主要問題,以及文獻涵蓋範圍存在的重要局限。方法論說明的詳細程度應與實際採用的評論研究形式相符。

The review should evaluate evidence in relation to specific scholarly claims. Different questions concerning the same phenomenon may require different types or strengths of evidence. For example, available studies may support the existence of an association while remaining insufficient to establish its causal mechanism, magnitude, generalizability, or significance under particular conditions. Authors should make such distinctions explicit.

文獻評論應結合具體學術主張評估證據。涉及同一現象的不同研究問題,可能需要不同類型或強度的證據。例如,現有研究可能足以支持某種關聯的存在,卻仍不足以確立其因果機制、影響大小、普遍適用性或特定條件下的重要性。作者應明確呈現此類區分。

Principal Analytical Approaches / 主要分析方向

  • Methodological Constraints: Examining whether limitations in research design, measurement, sampling, statistical power, analytical procedures, or study comparability contribute to uncertainty. The analysis should explain how these constraints affect the evidentiary strength, precision, applicability, or interpretation of particular conclusions.

    方法論限制: 考察研究設計、測量、抽樣、統計檢定力、分析程序或研究間可比較性方面的局限,是否造成或加劇知識上的不確定性。分析應說明相關限制如何影響特定結論的證據強度、精確程度、適用性或解釋。

  • Empirical and Theoretical Gaps: Identifying where relevant populations, contexts, observations, concepts, or explanatory relationships remain insufficiently investigated. Contributions should distinguish an actual absence of relevant evidence from situations in which existing research addresses the question only indirectly or under restricted conditions.

    實證與理論空白: 辨識相關研究群體、情境、觀察資料、概念或解釋關係在哪些方面尚未得到充分研究。稿件應區分真正缺乏相關證據的情況,以及既有研究僅間接回應問題或只在有限條件下提供證據的情況。

  • Conflicting Evidence and Interpretations: Comparing findings that appear inconsistent and evaluating whether differences arise from research conditions, definitions, methods, evidence quality, measurement, analytical choices, or genuinely competing explanations. Authors should assess whether the conflict is substantive or can be partly reconciled through a more precise understanding of study differences.

    相互衝突的證據與解釋: 比較表面上不一致的研究發現,並評估相關差異是否源於研究條件、概念定義、方法、證據品質、測量、分析選擇或實質上相互競爭的解釋。作者應判斷相關衝突是否具有實質性,或能否透過更精確地理解不同研究之間的差異而得到部分釐清。

  • Historical Development of Unresolved Questions: Tracing how research problems, conceptual disagreements, or evidentiary limitations have developed and persisted across successive stages of scholarly investigation. Contributions may examine whether changes in research priorities, available methods, terminology, or theoretical assumptions have altered the interpretation of the unresolved problem.

    未決問題的歷史發展: 追溯研究問題、概念分歧或證據局限如何在不同學術研究階段形成、演變並持續存在。稿件可以考察研究重點、可用方法、術語或理論預設的變化,是否改變了對未決問題的理解。

These approaches may be combined when the research problem requires consideration of several sources of uncertainty. For example, a review may examine conflicting findings alongside recurring methodological limitations and changes in the theoretical definitions used across studies. The analytical structure should clarify how these issues are related rather than simply enumerate them.

當研究問題涉及多種不確定性來源時,上述分析方向可以相互結合。例如,評論可以同時考察相互衝突的研究發現、反覆出現的方法論局限,以及不同研究所採用理論定義的變化。分析結構應釐清這些問題之間的關係,而非僅將其逐項列舉。

Authors should evaluate uncertainty in relation to the research question being examined. An evidence base may be adequate for some conclusions while remaining insufficient for others. The manuscript should specify these boundaries rather than treating uncertainty as a single undifferentiated condition.

作者應結合具體研究問題評估不確定性。同一證據體系可能足以支持某些結論,卻仍不足以支持其他判斷。稿件應明確界定這些邊界,而非將所有不確定性視為性質完全相同的情況。

Distinguishing Forms of Uncertainty / 區分不同形式的不確定性

Absence of Evidence / 缺乏證據

Relevant evidence is unavailable, insufficient, inaccessible, or inadequately examined to support a particular conclusion. The absence of accessible or identified research should not automatically be interpreted as proof that no studies exist or that the phenomenon under investigation is absent.

與特定結論相關的證據尚不存在、數量不足、難以取得,或未得到充分考察,因而不足以支持相關判斷。無法取得或未能辨識相關研究,不應自動被理解為完全不存在任何研究,亦不代表所探討的現象不存在。

Evidence Consistent with No Effect / 支持不存在效應或效應足夠小的證據

Findings support the absence of a specified effect or an effect sufficiently small to meet a clearly defined criterion under particular conditions. Such conclusions require consideration of study design, evidentiary strength, precision, uncertainty, and the range of effects compatible with the available observations. A statistically non-significant result alone is not sufficient to establish equivalence or the absence of an effect.

在明確條件下,研究發現支持某項特定效應不存在,或其大小符合清楚界定的足夠小效應標準。相關結論必須考慮研究設計、證據強度、估計精確度、不確定性,以及與現有觀察結果相容的可能效應範圍。單純的統計不顯著結果,不足以證明等效性或效應不存在。

Inconclusive Evidence / 無定論證據

Available findings do not adequately distinguish among relevant explanations or support a sufficiently precise conclusion. This may arise from limited information, substantial uncertainty, measurement problems, insufficient precision, or research designs that cannot adequately address the question under investigation.

現有研究發現不足以充分區分不同的相關解釋,或無法支持足夠精確的結論。此類情況可能源於資訊有限、不確定性較大、測量問題、估計精確度不足,或研究設計無法充分回應待探討的問題。

Conflicting Evidence / 相互衝突的證據

Studies produce findings that differ in direction, magnitude, interpretation, or applicability and require further evaluation to understand the sources and significance of disagreement. Apparent conflict may reflect differences in research conditions, methods, populations, analytical decisions, or genuinely inconsistent observations.

不同研究在效應方向、大小、解釋或適用性方面存在差異,需要進一步分析分歧的來源及重要性。表面上的衝突可能反映研究條件、方法、群體、分析決策的差異,也可能涉及真正相互不一致的觀察結果。

These categories should not be treated as interchangeable. In particular, a statistically non-significant result does not automatically establish the absence of an effect, just as the presence of conflicting studies does not automatically establish that every conclusion in the literature is unreliable. Authors should consider the strength, precision, relevance, and consistency of the available evidence before drawing conclusions about what is known or unknown.

上述類型不應相互混用。尤其需要注意的是,統計不顯著的結果不會自動證明某種效應不存在;同樣,研究之間存在衝突,也不代表相關文獻中的所有結論均不可靠。作者在判斷哪些內容已知、哪些仍未知時,應充分考察現有證據的強度、精確程度、相關性與一致性。

A rigorous assessment should identify the particular claims that are affected by uncertainty. Where evidence supports a limited conclusion, the manuscript should preserve that conclusion while explaining the questions it cannot resolve. Where the evidence is genuinely inconclusive, authors should not transform uncertainty into a definitive negative or positive finding.

嚴謹的證據評估應指出哪些具體主張受到不確定性的影響。若現有證據能夠支持有限範圍的結論,稿件應保留該結論,同時說明其無法解決的問題。若證據確實尚無定論,作者不得將不確定性轉化為確定性的陰性或陽性發現。

Characteristics of Submissions / 稿件的學術特徵

Manuscripts submitted to Null Reviews should combine careful engagement with relevant literature, transparent assessment of uncertainty, conceptual precision, and an identifiable contribution to understanding unresolved research problems. The presence of a knowledge gap alone does not establish sufficient scholarly merit. Contributions should demonstrate why the identified limitation matters, how it can be evaluated, and what can reasonably be learned from the available evidence.

提交至「空白評論」的稿件應結合對相關文獻的審慎考察、不確定性的透明評估、概念精確性,以及對未決研究問題具有可辨識的學術貢獻。僅指出知識空白的存在,並不足以證明稿件具有充分的學術價值。稿件應展示所辨識的局限為何重要、應如何評估,以及現有證據能夠合理提供哪些學術認識。

Comprehensive Engagement with Literature / 與相關文獻的充分對話

Authors should demonstrate familiarity with the principal research findings, relevant theories, and methodological approaches within the area under review. The manuscript should explain how relevant sources were identified, why the selected literature is appropriate for evaluating the question, and how the scope of the review affects the conclusions that can be drawn.

作者應充分了解所評論領域中的主要研究發現、相關理論及方法論路徑。稿件應說明相關文獻如何被辨識、所選研究成果為何適合用於評估待探討的問題,以及評論範圍如何影響能夠合理提出的結論。

The review should represent existing scholarship accurately and acknowledge findings that support different interpretations. Authors should avoid claiming that a topic has received no scholarly attention solely because relevant publications were absent from a limited or poorly defined search. The literature selection should not be restricted in a manner that systematically excludes directly relevant evidence without adequate justification.

文獻評論應準確呈現既有研究,並承認支持不同解釋的相關發現。作者不得僅因範圍有限或界定不清的文獻檢索未發現相關出版成果,便宣稱某一主題完全缺乏學術研究。文獻選擇亦不應在缺乏充分理由的情況下,系統性排除與研究問題直接相關的證據。

Comprehensive engagement does not automatically require a systematic review methodology. A focused critical or narrative review may be appropriate when its scope and purpose are clearly explained. However, manuscripts described as systematic reviews, scoping reviews, or other methodologically defined forms of evidence synthesis must accurately report the procedures actually undertaken and should not claim a degree of coverage, reproducibility, or methodological rigor that their methods cannot support.

充分的文獻對話並不自動意味著必須採用系統性綜述方法。當評論的範圍與目的得到清楚說明時,聚焦性批判評論或敘述性綜述同樣可以適用。然而,若稿件被界定為系統性綜述、範疇性綜述或其他具有明確方法論要求的證據綜合研究,便須準確報告實際執行的程序,不得宣稱超出研究方法所能支持的文獻涵蓋程度、可重複性或方法論嚴謹程度。

Where a review includes a structured search or screening process, authors should explain the relevant procedures sufficiently for readers to understand the basis of the evidence selection. Such information may include the sources searched, the search period, the general selection criteria, and important restrictions affecting coverage. The detail required should correspond to the research method and the strength of the claims made about the literature.

如評論涉及結構化文獻檢索或篩選程序,作者應充分說明相關步驟,使讀者能夠理解證據選擇的基礎。相關資訊可以包括檢索來源、檢索時間範圍、主要選擇標準,以及影響文獻涵蓋程度的重要限制。所需說明的詳細程度應與研究方法及對文獻所提出主張的強度相符。

Authors should distinguish gaps in the published literature from limitations in the material accessible to their review. Relevant research may exist in different languages, disciplinary traditions, publication formats, or repositories. When the review's coverage is restricted, those limitations should be considered before making broad claims about the absence of scholarship.

作者應區分已發表文獻本身的空白,與其評論所能取得材料的限制。相關研究可能存在於不同語言、學科傳統、出版形式或知識庫之中。當評論的涵蓋範圍受到限制時,應先考慮相關局限,再對學術研究是否缺乏作出廣泛主張。

Critical Analysis of Uncertainty / 不確定性的批判性分析

The manuscript should explain the nature of the uncertainty identified and examine why existing research has not resolved the relevant question. Possible contributing factors include insufficient data, methodological weaknesses, incompatible definitions, limited comparability, inconsistent findings, and the absence of adequate theoretical explanations.

稿件應說明所辨識的不確定性具有何種性質,並考察既有研究為何尚未解決相關問題。可能涉及的因素包括資料不足、方法論缺陷、概念定義不一致、研究間可比較性有限、研究發現相互衝突,以及缺乏充分的理論解釋。

Authors should distinguish limitations demonstrated by the literature from explanations that remain hypothetical. When conflicting findings are discussed, the analysis should consider whether apparent disagreement may be attributable to differences in research design, populations, settings, measurements, analytical decisions, or the interpretation of findings. Causal explanations for disagreement should not be treated as established without sufficient support.

作者應區分文獻已證實的局限與仍屬假設性的解釋。討論相互衝突的研究發現時,應考察表面上的分歧是否可能源於研究設計、研究群體、研究情境、測量方式、分析決策或結果解釋的差異。若缺乏充分依據,不得將對分歧成因的推測視為已確立的因果解釋。

The analysis should specify the claims that remain insufficiently supported and, where possible, distinguish uncertainty about the existence of a phenomenon from uncertainty about its magnitude, mechanisms, context dependence, or broader implications. These distinctions are necessary to avoid presenting a partially resolved question as though no meaningful knowledge has been established.

分析應明確指出哪些主張仍缺乏充分支持,並在可能情況下區分對某一現象是否存在的不確定性,以及對其大小、作用機制、情境依賴性或更廣泛影響的不確定性。此類區分有助於避免將部分已獲解答的問題,錯誤表述為完全不存在有意義的學術知識。

Where quantitative evidence is relevant, authors should consider whether the conclusions reflect the magnitude and precision of reported estimates rather than relying solely on statistical significance thresholds. Where qualitative or interpretive evidence is central, the review should examine the contextual basis of findings, the consistency of interpretations, and the extent to which available materials support broader theoretical claims.

當量化證據與評論相關時,作者應考察結論是否充分反映所報告估計值的大小與精確程度,而非僅依賴統計顯著性門檻。當質性或詮釋性證據構成評論核心時,應考察研究發現的情境基礎、解釋的一致性,以及現有材料在多大程度上能夠支持更廣泛的理論主張。

The objective is not to maximize the amount of uncertainty described, but to characterize uncertainty accurately. A credible review should recognize the strongest conclusions the evidence supports, identify the limits of those conclusions, and explain the specific questions that remain unresolved.

本欄目的目的並非盡可能擴大對不確定性的描述,而是準確界定不確定性的性質。具有可信度的評論應承認現有證據所能支持的最充分結論、辨識其適用邊界,並說明仍未解決的具體問題。

Conceptual Clarity / 概念清晰度

Authors should define the principal concepts and research questions clearly. Where different studies use the same terminology in different ways, the manuscript should examine the consequences of these differences for comparing evidence and interpreting conclusions.

作者應清楚界定主要概念及研究問題。若不同研究以不同方式使用相同術語,稿件應分析相關差異對證據比較及研究結論解釋所產生的影響。

The manuscript should avoid treating broad labels such as "uncertainty," "research gap," or "lack of consensus" as self-explanatory findings. These terms should be connected to identifiable evidence, clearly specified questions, and the particular limitations under examination. Authors should identify whether the problem concerns conceptual definition, empirical observation, explanatory mechanisms, methodological comparability, or another identifiable dimension of scholarly knowledge.

稿件不應將「不確定性」、「研究空白」或「缺乏共識」等概括性標籤直接當作無須論證的研究發現。這些術語應與可以辨識的證據、界定明確的研究問題及具體待分析的局限建立聯繫。作者應指出相關問題究竟涉及概念定義、實證觀察、解釋機制、方法論可比較性,或學術知識中的其他特定面向。

Conceptual clarity is especially important when the literature combines findings from different disciplines or research traditions. Identical terminology does not necessarily indicate identical constructs, measures, or explanatory assumptions. Conversely, different terminology may sometimes describe substantially overlapping phenomena. Reviews should examine these relationships before concluding that research findings are inherently contradictory.

當文獻涉及不同學科或研究傳統的發現時,概念清晰度尤其重要。相同術語並不必然代表相同的研究構念、測量方式或解釋預設;相反,不同術語有時也可能指向高度重疊的現象。評論應先考察這些關係,再判斷研究發現是否存在實質矛盾。

Where a review proposes a refined conceptual distinction or alternative interpretive framework, authors should explain how the proposal addresses the identified ambiguity and what limitations remain. New terminology should improve scholarly understanding rather than merely rename an unresolved problem.

如評論提出更加精確的概念區分或替代性解釋框架,作者應說明相關方案如何回應已辨識的歧義,以及仍存在何種局限。新的術語應有助於深化學術理解,而非僅為尚未解決的問題重新命名。

Future Research Perspectives / 未來研究方向

Where appropriate, authors should identify future investigations that could address the limitations revealed by the review. Recommendations may concern improved research designs, clearer concepts, additional data, more suitable analytical methods, comparative studies, replication, or closer examination of unresolved theoretical relationships.

在適當情況下,作者應指出能夠回應評論所揭示局限的後續研究方向。建議可以涉及改善研究設計、釐清概念、補充資料、採用更合適的分析方法、開展比較研究、進行重複驗證,或進一步考察尚未解決的理論關係。

Future research proposals should follow logically from the gaps and uncertainties actually identified. General statements that "more research is needed" should be accompanied by an explanation of what remains unknown, why existing approaches have been insufficient, and what kind of inquiry might provide more informative evidence.

未來研究建議應從已辨識的空白與不確定性合理推導而來。若作者提出「需要更多研究」的主張,便應進一步說明哪些內容仍未知、既有研究方式為何不足,以及何種後續探究可能提供更具解釋力的證據。

Recommendations should distinguish questions that require additional empirical evidence from those that could be advanced through conceptual clarification, methodological reassessment, improved access to existing materials, or more appropriate interpretation of already available findings. Not every knowledge gap necessarily requires a new study; in some cases, a more rigorous analysis of existing research may be informative.

相關建議應區分需要補充實證證據的問題,以及可以透過概念釐清、方法論重新評估、改善既有材料的取得方式,或更加適當地解釋現有研究結果而取得進展的問題。並非所有知識空白都必然需要新的研究;在某些情況下,對既有成果進行更加嚴謹的分析,同樣可以提供有價值的認識。

The likely value of a proposed research direction should be explained in relation to the uncertainty it is intended to address. Authors should avoid presenting future methods as guaranteed solutions and should acknowledge practical, methodological, ethical, or evidentiary constraints that may continue to affect subsequent investigation.

後續研究方向的潛在價值應與其擬解決的不確定性建立明確聯繫。作者不應將未來研究方法描述為必然有效的解決方案,亦應承認可能持續影響後續探究的實務、方法論、倫理或證據限制。

The scholarly contribution of a Null Review lies in the quality of its analysis of existing knowledge and uncertainty. Identifying a gap is a starting point; demonstrating its relevance, evidentiary basis, limitations, and implications is what establishes the intellectual value of the review.

「空白評論」的學術貢獻取決於其對既有知識與不確定性的分析品質。辨識空白只是起點;論證空白的相關性、證據基礎、局限及其影響,才是確立評論智識價值的關鍵。

Types of Contributions / 可投稿的學術形式

Null Reviews accommodates different forms of scholarly review focused on incomplete knowledge, unresolved questions, and limitations of existing research. Contributions should demonstrate a coherent analytical purpose and explain how the selected literature supports an assessment of uncertainty. The examples below describe suitable approaches within this editorial section and do not establish additional formal article categories.

「空白評論」接收不同形式的學術評論,重點關注知識不完整、尚未解決的研究問題及既有研究的局限。稿件應展現連貫的分析目的,並說明所選文獻如何支持對不確定性的評估。以下示例說明適合本欄目的研究方式,並不構成另外設立的正式文章類型。

  • Analytical Reviews of Inconclusive Research Fields — Critical syntheses examining why a body of research has not yet established sufficiently clear, consistent, or precise conclusions. Contributions should evaluate the available evidence and distinguish unresolved questions from findings that are already supported within identifiable limits.

    無定論研究領域的分析性評論 — 批判性綜合既有文獻,考察某一研究領域為何尚未形成足夠明確、一致或精確的結論。稿件應評估現有證據,並區分尚未解決的問題與在明確條件下已有充分支持的研究發現。

  • Reviews of Persistent Methodological Limitations — Analyses identifying recurring constraints in research design, measurement, sampling, analysis, or interpretation that affect the reliability or applicability of existing knowledge. Authors should explain how these limitations contribute to particular uncertainties and identify their implications for subsequent research.

    持續性方法論局限的評論 — 辨識反覆出現的研究設計、測量、抽樣、分析或解釋限制,並分析其如何影響既有知識的可靠程度或適用性的研究。作者應解釋這些限制如何造成特定不確定性,並指出其對後續研究的影響。

  • Assessments of Conflicting Empirical Evidence — Reviews comparing divergent findings and evaluating whether differences can be explained by research conditions, methods, definitions, populations, analytical decisions, or other identifiable factors. Contributions should distinguish unresolved contradictions from variations that can be understood through differences in study context.

    相互衝突之實證證據的評估 — 比較不同研究的分歧結果,並評估相關差異能否由研究條件、方法、定義、研究群體、分析決策或其他可辨識因素加以解釋。稿件應區分尚未得到解決的實質矛盾,以及可以透過研究情境差異得到理解的結果變化。

  • Reviews of Unresolved Conceptual Questions — Scholarly analyses examining underdeveloped concepts, unsettled theoretical relationships, and explanatory gaps within existing frameworks. Contributions may clarify competing definitions, investigate assumptions that limit conceptual development, or identify distinctions needed for more coherent theoretical and empirical inquiry.

    未決概念問題的評論 — 考察尚未充分發展的概念、未獲釐清的理論關係,以及既有框架中解釋空白的學術分析。稿件可以釐清相互競爭的定義、檢驗限制概念發展的基本預設,或辨識促進理論與實證研究連貫性所需的重要區分。

Contributions may adopt critical narrative review, comparative literature analysis, conceptual synthesis, methodological appraisal, or other appropriate approaches. Authors should clearly describe the review method employed, identify the limitations of the material considered, and ensure that the strength of their conclusions is consistent with the available evidence and the scope of the review.

稿件可以採用批判性敘述綜述、比較文獻分析、概念綜合、方法論評價或其他適當研究路徑。作者應清楚說明實際採用的評論方法、辨識所考察材料的局限,並確保結論的強度與現有證據及文獻評論的涵蓋範圍相符。

Where authors undertake a systematic review, scoping review, or other methodologically defined evidence synthesis, the manuscript should accurately document the procedures used to identify, select, evaluate, and synthesize relevant material. Applicable research reporting guidance can inform transparent presentation, but a specific review label should not be used unless the actual methods justify it. A focused narrative review need not be represented as a systematic review to constitute a valid scholarly contribution.

如作者進行系統性綜述、範疇性綜述或其他具有明確方法論特徵的證據綜合研究,稿件應準確記錄用於辨識、選取、評估及綜合相關材料的程序。適用的研究報告指引可協助提高呈現透明度,但只有在實際方法具備相應依據時,才應使用特定評論研究名稱。聚焦性的敘述性評論無須被描述為系統性綜述,也可以構成有效的學術貢獻。

Null Reviews focuses on patterns of incomplete or uncertain knowledge across relevant scholarship. A manuscript centered primarily on the unsuccessful outcome of a particular investigation may be better suited to Failed Experiments. A manuscript primarily challenging an established paradigm, influential theory, or dominant interpretation may be more appropriate for Unwanted Reviews.

「空白評論」主要關注相關學術文獻中知識不完整或不確定性的整體模式。若稿件主要分析某項具體研究未成功的結果,則可能更適合 Failed Experiments(失敗實驗);若稿件主要旨在挑戰既定研究範式、具影響力的理論或主導性解釋,則可能更適合 Unwanted Reviews(逆流評論)。

These distinctions concern the principal scholarly purpose of a manuscript rather than rigid boundaries between subjects. A review of uncertain evidence may challenge an influential interpretation, and a critical examination of a research paradigm may reveal important knowledge gaps. Authors should select the section that most closely reflects the central question, analytical emphasis, and intended contribution of their work.

上述區別主要取決於稿件的核心學術目的,而非不同研究主題之間存在絕對界限。對不確定證據的評論可能挑戰具影響力的解釋,而對研究範式的批判性考察亦可能揭示重要知識空白。作者應根據稿件的核心問題、分析重點及預期學術貢獻,選擇最適合的欄目。

Manuscript Length / 稿件篇幅

4,000–7,000 Words

Typical manuscript length, excluding references

建議稿件篇幅:4,000–7,000 詞,不包含參考文獻。

Manuscripts submitted to Null Reviews typically range from 4,000 to 7,000 words, excluding the reference list. This range is intended to provide sufficient space to define the research problem, establish the scope of the literature, evaluate existing evidence, analyze relevant uncertainties, and explain the contribution to scholarly understanding.

提交至「空白評論」的稿件,建議篇幅為 4,000 至 7,000 詞,不包含參考文獻列表。此篇幅旨在為界定研究問題、說明文獻範圍、評估現有證據、分析相關不確定性,以及闡述對學術理解的貢獻提供適當空間。

The recommended range is an editorial guideline rather than an absolute limit. A manuscript may require additional space where the relevant literature is extensive, the analytical problem involves several distinct forms of uncertainty, or the methodology requires a more detailed explanation. Manuscripts outside the typical range may be considered when their scholarly purpose and analytical substance justify the variation.

上述建議篇幅屬於編輯指引,而非絕對限制。如相關文獻範圍廣泛、分析問題涉及多種不同形式的不確定性,或所採用方法需要更加詳細的說明,稿件可能需要額外篇幅。若學術目的及分析內容足以支持相應差異,超出一般建議範圍的稿件亦可納入考慮。

Manuscripts should be organized coherently and should ordinarily explain the central question, the scope and selection of relevant literature, the principal findings and disagreements, the limitations of existing evidence, and the implications of the identified knowledge gaps. The precise structure may be adapted to the nature of the review and relevant disciplinary conventions.

稿件應具有連貫結構,通常需要說明核心研究問題、相關文獻的範圍與選擇方式、主要研究發現及分歧、現有證據的局限,以及所辨識知識空白的影響。具體結構可以根據評論研究的性質及相關學科慣例適當調整。

The manuscript should provide sufficient analytical detail to support its conclusions without relying on unnecessary repetition or extended descriptions unrelated to the review's principal purpose. When several forms of uncertainty are considered, the presentation should make clear how they relate to one another and why the distinctions matter.

稿件應提供足以支持結論的分析細節,同時避免不必要的重複或與評論核心目的缺乏關聯的冗長描述。當研究涉及多種不確定性時,應清楚呈現其相互關係,並說明相關區分的重要性。

The exclusion of references from the recommended word count does not remove the obligation to provide a complete, accurate, and relevant reference list. Authors must acknowledge the scholarship necessary to support their analysis. In-text citations and references should follow the journal's required American Psychological Association (APA) style.

參考文獻不計入建議字數,並不免除作者提供完整、準確且相關之參考文獻列表的義務。作者必須確認支持其分析所需的學術資料來源。正文引用與參考文獻應遵循本刊規定的美國心理學會(APA)格式。

Authors should consult the journal's Author Guidelines for general requirements concerning manuscript language, abstracts, keywords, formatting, citation style, ethical declarations, and submission procedures. Silence accepts manuscripts in English or Chinese. Under the journal's general manuscript requirements, submissions should include an abstract of no more than 300 words and four to six keywords.

作者應參閱本刊 Author Guidelines(投稿指南),了解投稿語言、摘要、關鍵詞、稿件排版、引用格式、倫理聲明及投稿程序等一般要求。《Silence》接受英文或中文稿件。依據本刊一般稿件要求,投稿應包含不超過 300 詞的摘要,以及 4 至 6 個關鍵詞。

All submissions must comply with the journal's applicable publication ethics requirements. Authors should ensure the originality of their analysis, accurately represent the work of other scholars, disclose relevant competing interests, and avoid plagiarism, fabricated references, selective misrepresentation of findings, or unsupported claims about the absence of research.

所有投稿均須遵守本刊適用的出版倫理要求。作者應確保分析具有原創性、準確呈現其他學者的研究成果、披露相關利益衝突,並避免剽竊、捏造參考文獻、選擇性歪曲研究發現,或對學術研究是否缺乏作出沒有充分依據的主張。

Editorial Screening and Peer Review / 編輯初審與同行評審

Submissions to Null Reviews undergo initial editorial screening and, when suitable for further scholarly evaluation, normally proceed to double-anonymous external peer review. Initial screening considers the relevance of the topic, suitability for the section, presence of a substantive analytical argument, and compliance with the journal's submission requirements.

提交至「空白評論」的稿件須接受編輯初審,適合進一步學術評估的稿件通常進入雙匿名外部同行評審程序。初審將考慮研究主題的相關性、是否適合本欄目、是否具有實質性的分析論證,以及是否符合期刊投稿要求。

Peer-review evaluation considers the appropriateness and sufficiency of the literature covered, transparency of the review approach, accuracy of the evidence assessment, conceptual and analytical rigor, fairness toward competing interpretations, clarity of argument, and scholarly significance of the identified uncertainties. Reviewers should assess the quality of the review's reasoning rather than assume that a larger number of identified knowledge gaps necessarily constitutes a stronger contribution.

同行評審將考慮所考察文獻的適切性與充分程度、評論方法的透明度、證據評估的準確性、概念及分析的嚴謹性、對相互競爭之解釋的公正性、論證清晰度,以及所辨識不確定性的學術意義。審稿人應評估評論推理的品質,而非假定辨識出的知識空白越多,學術貢獻便越大。

The identification of unresolved questions does not automatically establish that a manuscript should be accepted. Editors and reviewers may request clarification of the literature selection, correction of unsupported claims, consideration of contrary evidence, more precise differentiation among forms of uncertainty, or a clearer explanation of the limitations and implications of the review.

稿件辨識出尚未解決的研究問題,並不自動代表應獲錄用。編輯及審稿人可能要求作者釐清文獻選擇方式、修正缺乏依據的主張、考慮相反證據、更加精確地區分不同形式的不確定性,或更清楚地說明評論研究的局限與影響。

Authors preparing manuscripts for double-anonymous review should follow the journal's anonymization instructions while maintaining accurate scholarly citations. Revisions should address substantive editorial and reviewer concerns through appropriate amendments or reasoned explanations. A request for revision does not guarantee acceptance, and final editorial decisions remain governed by the journal's Peer Review Policy.

準備接受雙匿名評審的作者應遵守本刊的匿名化指引,同時維持學術引用的準確性。修訂稿件應透過適當修改或具有合理依據的說明,回應實質性的編輯與審稿意見。修訂要求不代表稿件必然獲得錄用,最終編輯決策仍依據本刊 Peer Review Policy(同行評審政策)執行。

Publication in Null Reviews follows the journal's established open-access and copyright policies. Authors retain copyright in their original scholarly work, and all formally published articles are licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0). Silence operates under a Diamond Open Access model without submission fees or article processing charges.

「空白評論」的正式出版遵循本刊既定的開放取用及版權政策。作者保留其原創學術作品的版權,所有正式發表文章均統一採用知識共享署名 4.0 國際授權條款(CC BY 4.0)。《Silence》採用鑽石開放取用模式,不收取投稿費或文章處理費。

Contribution to Scholarly Understanding / 對學術理解的貢獻

Null Reviews reflects the broader commitment of Silence to intellectual honesty, methodological reflection, and transparent scholarly communication. By examining gaps and uncertainties in existing research, the section seeks to support a more accurate and critically informed understanding of the current state of knowledge.

「空白評論」體現《Silence》對智識誠實、方法論反思及透明學術交流的整體承諾。透過考察既有研究中的知識空白與不確定性,本欄目期望促進對當前學術知識狀況更加準確且具有批判性基礎的理解。

Recognizing the limits of available evidence can be as important as identifying well-supported conclusions. A careful review may clarify which claims are justified, where uncertainty remains substantial, how different interpretations arise, and what kinds of evidence would be needed to strengthen, refine, or revise existing scholarly understanding.

認識現有證據的局限,可能與辨識具有充分支持的結論同樣重要。審慎的文獻評論可以釐清哪些主張具有合理依據、哪些方面仍存在重大不確定性、不同解釋如何形成,以及需要何種證據才能加強、深化或修正既有學術理解。

The section recognizes that uncertainty is not necessarily a sign of inadequate scholarship. Some questions remain unresolved because of the complexity of the phenomena under investigation, the limits of available methods, differences between research contexts, the difficulty of obtaining relevant evidence, or the evolving state of the literature. Understanding these conditions can improve the interpretation and design of subsequent research.

本欄目認為,不確定性並不必然意味著學術研究品質不足。某些問題之所以尚未解決,可能與研究現象的複雜性、現有方法的限制、研究情境之間的差異、取得相關證據的困難,或文獻仍在持續發展有關。理解這些條件,有助於改善後續研究的解釋與設計。

At the same time, the existence of uncertainty should not be used to dismiss findings that are already well supported. Responsible scholarship requires conclusions proportionate to the available evidence, fair assessment of competing findings, and a clear distinction between established knowledge, provisional interpretations, and unresolved questions.

同時,不確定性的存在亦不應被用來否定已有充分證據支持的研究發現。負責任的學術研究要求結論與現有證據相稱、公正評估相互競爭的研究發現,並清楚區分已確立的知識、暫時性解釋及尚未解決的問題。

A Null Review may contribute to academic understanding by identifying the conditions under which existing findings can be interpreted reliably, explaining why certain research conclusions remain tentative, clarifying disagreements that arise from different concepts or methods, or demonstrating how the available evidence can be reorganized into a more coherent account of current knowledge.

「空白評論」可以透過辨識既有研究發現得以可靠解釋的條件、說明某些結論為何仍屬初步判斷、釐清不同概念或方法造成的分歧,或展示如何將現有證據重新組織為更加連貫的知識理解框架,對學術研究作出貢獻。

The section also supports more responsible communication of research limitations. Readers, researchers, and other users of scholarly findings benefit when authors explain not only what existing studies suggest but also the confidence that can reasonably be placed in those interpretations. Such clarity reduces the risk of overstating evidence, overlooking important qualifications, or portraying contested claims as established facts.

本欄目亦支持更加負責任地傳達研究局限。當作者不僅說明既有研究可能支持哪些判斷,也清楚交代相關解釋具有何種合理可信程度時,讀者、研究者及其他學術成果使用者便能形成更準確的理解。此種清晰性有助於降低誇大證據、忽略重要限制條件,或將存在爭議的主張呈現為已確立事實的風險。

Through critical examination of incomplete evidence and unresolved scholarly questions, Null Reviews aims to contribute to a more comprehensive, precise, and reflective academic record. Its purpose is to clarify the boundaries of current understanding, distinguish the questions that have been answered from those that remain open, and identify productive directions through which future research may advance.

透過批判性考察不完整的證據與尚未解決的學術問題,「空白評論」期望促進更加全面、精確且具有反思性的學術記錄。其目的在於釐清當前知識的邊界、區分已獲解答與仍然開放的問題,並辨識後續研究可能取得實質進展的方向。

Uncertainty · Rigor · Exploration

不確定性 · 嚴謹 · 探索