Reviewer Guidelines
Introduction / 引言
Peer review is an essential component of responsible scholarly publishing. Reviewers contribute independent academic expertise to the evaluation of submitted manuscripts, helping editors assess scholarly merit, methodological rigor, intellectual originality, and the reliability of the arguments and evidence presented.
同行評審是負責任學術出版的重要組成部分。審稿人透過獨立的學術專業知識參與稿件評估,協助編輯判斷投稿的學術價值、方法論嚴謹性、智識原創性,以及論證與證據的可靠程度。
Silence values the time, expertise, and intellectual contributions of its reviewers. These guidelines explain the responsibilities, ethical expectations, evaluation criteria, and reporting practices applicable to scholars invited to undertake external peer review for the journal. They are intended to support consistent, fair, constructive, and intellectually responsible evaluation across the journal's research-oriented sections.
《Silence》重視審稿人所投入的時間、專業知識及智識貢獻。本指南說明受邀參與本刊外部同行評審的學者所應遵守的責任、倫理要求、評估標準及評審報告原則,旨在支持本刊各研究類欄目採用一致、公正、具有建設性且負責任的學術評估方式。
Research-oriented manuscripts submitted to Silence normally undergo double-anonymous external peer review following initial editorial screening. Under the journal's current section arrangements, Silence Notes receives editorial assessment rather than external peer review. These guidelines therefore primarily address external reviewers of research-oriented submissions.
提交至《Silence》的研究類稿件通常在通過編輯初審後接受雙匿名外部同行評審。根據本刊現行欄目安排,Silence Notes(寂靜手記)採用編輯評估,而非外部同行評審。因此,本指南主要適用於研究類稿件的外部審稿人。
The double-anonymous arrangement is intended to limit the disclosure of author and reviewer identities during evaluation. Reviewers should assess manuscripts on their scholarly content and should not attempt to identify authors. Where authorship becomes apparent through publicly available material or other circumstances, reviewers remain responsible for maintaining confidentiality and disclosing any resulting conflict of interest to the editor.
雙匿名評審旨在限制評估期間作者與審稿人身份資訊的披露。審稿人應根據稿件的學術內容進行判斷,不應主動嘗試辨識作者。如因公開資料或其他情況而得知作者身份,審稿人仍須遵守保密義務,並向編輯披露由此產生的任何利益衝突。
Reviewers provide assessments and recommendations to inform editorial judgment. They do not independently determine whether a manuscript is accepted or rejected. The final editorial decision remains the responsibility of the editor handling the submission, who considers the review reports alongside the manuscript's scholarly quality and the journal's applicable editorial and ethical requirements.
審稿人透過評估意見與建議協助編輯作出判斷,並不獨立決定稿件的錄用或拒絕。稿件的最終編輯決定仍由負責處理該投稿的編輯作出,並綜合考慮評審報告、稿件的學術品質,以及本刊適用的編輯與倫理要求。
Peer review is a form of expert evaluation rather than a guarantee that every conclusion in a manuscript is correct. Reviewers are expected to exercise reasonable scholarly care, identify material concerns within their competence, and explain the basis of their judgments. Their contribution supports the integrity of scholarly communication without transferring responsibility for the research from its authors.
同行評審是一種專家評估,而非對稿件所有結論均完全正確的保證。審稿人應以合理的學術審慎態度進行評估,在自身專業能力範圍內辨識重要問題,並說明判斷的依據。審稿人的工作有助於維護學術交流的完整性,但不會因此將研究本身的責任由作者轉移至審稿人。
Responsibilities of Reviewers / 審稿人責任
Reviewers are expected to assess manuscripts independently, impartially, and constructively. Their reports should help editors understand the strengths and limitations of a submission while providing authors with clear, reasoned feedback on matters relevant to the scholarly quality of their work.
審稿人應以獨立、公正且具有建設性的方式評估稿件。評審報告應協助編輯理解投稿的優勢與局限,同時就與學術品質相關的問題向作者提供清晰且具有論證依據的意見。
A responsible review begins before the invitation is accepted. Prospective reviewers should consider whether the manuscript falls within their expertise, whether they can undertake the assessment within the proposed or mutually agreed period, and whether any competing interests could impair independent judgment. Acceptance of an invitation signifies a commitment to undertake the agreed evaluation with appropriate professional care.
負責任的評審工作始於接受邀請之前。受邀者應考慮稿件是否屬於其專業領域、能否在建議或雙方約定的期間完成評估,以及是否存在可能影響獨立判斷的利益衝突。接受邀請意味著審稿人願意以適當的專業審慎態度履行已同意的評估工作。
Core Responsibilities / 核心責任
-
Academic Merit: Evaluate the manuscript according to its scholarly contribution, relevant evidence, methodological appropriateness, intellectual rigor, and applicable ethical standards rather than the identity, institutional position, or personal characteristics of its authors.
學術價值: 根據稿件的學術貢獻、相關證據、方法論適切性、智識嚴謹性及適用倫理標準進行評估,而非依據作者身份、機構地位或個人特徵作出判斷。
-
Balanced and Constructive Assessment: Identify both strengths and weaknesses, distinguish essential scholarly concerns from individual preferences, and provide criticism proportionate to the issues identified. Recommendations should be directed toward improving scholarly accuracy, clarity, and integrity.
平衡且具建設性的評估: 指出稿件的優勢與不足,區分重要學術問題與個人偏好,並提出與所辨識問題的重要程度相稱的批評。相關建議應有助於改善研究的準確性、清晰度及完整性。
-
Reasoned Judgment: Support major assessments with identifiable examples, relevant disciplinary standards, appropriate references, or clear analytical reasoning. Reviewers should distinguish demonstrated limitations from plausible but unverified concerns.
具有依據的判斷: 以可以辨識的具體例證、相關學科標準、適當文獻或清晰的分析推理支持重要評價。審稿人應區分已確認的研究局限與合理但尚未核實的疑慮。
-
Confidentiality: Protect manuscripts, unpublished research information, review correspondence, and other confidential materials encountered through the review process. Such materials must not be disclosed, circulated, or used for unauthorized purposes.
保密義務: 保護評審過程中接觸的稿件、未公開研究資訊、評審通信及其他保密材料,不得未經授權披露、傳播或用於其他目的。
-
Timeliness and Communication: Respond to review invitations responsibly, follow the agreed review schedule, and notify the editorial office promptly when circumstances prevent timely or competent completion of the assessment. Relevant limitations or difficulties should be communicated rather than concealed.
時效與溝通: 負責任地回應評審邀請、遵守約定的評審安排,並在無法及時或充分完成評估時迅速通知編輯部。相關限制或困難應主動說明,而非隱瞞。
Before accepting an invitation, reviewers should consider whether they possess sufficient expertise, have adequate time to complete the work, and can provide an impartial assessment. An invitation should be declined when these essential conditions cannot reasonably be met. Where a manuscript addresses several specialized fields, reviewers may indicate the parts they are competent to evaluate and identify areas outside their expertise.
審稿人在接受邀請前,應確認自身是否具備足夠的專業能力、能否安排適當時間完成評審,以及是否能夠維持公正判斷。若無法合理滿足上述基本條件,應拒絕評審邀請。如稿件涉及多個專門領域,審稿人可以說明自身能夠評估的部分,並辨識超出其專業範圍的內容。
Reviewers should not accept an assignment merely to gain access to unpublished research, nor should they continue an assessment they cannot complete competently. If an unforeseen limitation arises after acceptance, the reviewer should inform the editor so that the assignment can be reconsidered or appropriate supplementary expertise obtained.
審稿人不得僅為取得未公開研究內容而接受邀請,也不應在已無法提供充分專業評估的情況下繼續審稿。如接受邀請後出現未能預見的限制,應通知編輯,以便重新考慮評審安排或尋求適當的補充專業意見。
Confidentiality / 保密義務
Manuscripts supplied for peer review are confidential editorial materials. Reviewers must handle the manuscript and associated communications responsibly and must not disclose protected information obtained through the review process without appropriate authorization or another applicable lawful basis.
供同行評審使用的稿件屬於保密編輯材料。審稿人必須負責任地處理稿件及相關通信,不得在缺乏適當授權或其他適用法律依據的情況下,披露透過評審程序取得的受保護資訊。
Confidentiality protects the intellectual contributions of authors, the integrity of editorial deliberation, and the privacy of individuals whose information may appear in research materials. The obligation covers the submitted manuscript, supplementary data and files, unpublished findings, review invitations, reviewer comments, editorial correspondence, and other information received in a confidential capacity.
保密義務旨在保護作者的智識貢獻、編輯討論的完整性,以及研究材料中相關人士的隱私。其範圍包括投稿稿件、補充資料與檔案、未公開研究發現、評審邀請、審稿意見、編輯通信,以及其他以保密方式取得的資訊。
Confidentiality Requirements / 保密要求
-
Unauthorized Sharing: Do not forward manuscripts, supplementary materials, unpublished data, or confidential review correspondence to other individuals without the editor's authorization. The review invitation does not grant permission to circulate the material to colleagues, students, or collaborators.
禁止未經授權分享: 未經編輯授權,不得向他人轉發稿件、補充材料、未公開資料或保密評審通信。收到評審邀請並不代表獲准向同事、學生或合作研究者傳閱相關材料。
-
External Discussion: Do not disclose or discuss confidential manuscript content with persons outside the authorized review process. Reviewers must not use the review assignment as a basis for independent contact with authors concerning the manuscript without editorial authorization.
外部討論: 不得向獲授權評審程序以外的人員披露或討論保密稿件內容。未經編輯授權,審稿人不得以評審工作為由私下聯絡作者討論稿件。
-
Misuse of Unpublished Research: Do not appropriate or exploit confidential unpublished ideas, data, methods, findings, interpretations, or other intellectual contributions encountered during review for personal research, professional advantage, or another unauthorized purpose.
禁止濫用未發表研究: 不得為個人研究、職業利益或其他未獲授權目的,挪用或利用評審過程中取得的保密未發表思想、資料、方法、研究發現、解釋或其他智識貢獻。
-
Third-Party Services and Digital Tools: Do not upload confidential manuscripts, supplementary files, unpublished research information, or review correspondence to unauthorized external services, including generative artificial intelligence systems. Any proposed use of external assistance must first be discussed with the editor and must comply with applicable confidentiality, privacy, and intellectual property requirements.
第三方服務與數位工具: 不得將保密稿件、補充文件、未公開研究資訊或評審通信上傳至未獲授權的外部服務,包括生成式人工智慧系統。如擬使用外部協助,應事先向編輯說明,並確保符合適用的保密、隱私及智慧財產權要求。
Reviewers should not invite another person to assist with a review without prior editorial authorization. Where assistance is authorized, the roles of those involved and the handling of confidential materials should remain transparent to the editor. The invited reviewer remains responsible for the accuracy, intellectual substance, and independence of the assessment submitted under their name.
審稿人未經編輯事先授權,不應邀請其他人員協助評審。若相關協助已獲授權,參與者的角色及保密材料的處理方式應向編輯保持透明。受邀審稿人仍須對以其名義提交之評估的準確性、智識內容及獨立性負責。
Generative AI and Reviewer Accountability / 生成式人工智慧與審稿責任
The confidentiality risks associated with generative AI require particular care. Reviewers must not provide confidential manuscript text, figures, tables, data, or unpublished arguments to external AI systems unless the journal has expressly authorized the specific arrangement and the applicable safeguards have been established. Such authorization must not be presumed from the general availability or convenience of a tool.
生成式人工智慧所涉及的保密風險需要特別審慎處理。除非本刊已明確授權特定使用安排,且相關保障措施已獲確認,否則審稿人不得向外部 AI 系統提供保密稿件文字、圖表、資料或未公開論證。不能僅因某項工具容易取得或使用方便,便推定其已獲授權。
The reviewer's professional judgment must not be replaced by automated evaluation. Decisions about a manuscript's originality, validity, methodological adequacy, ethical concerns, and scholarly significance require accountable human assessment. Where a permitted tool is used for limited language or presentation assistance, the reviewer should ensure that the assistance does not compromise confidentiality, introduce inaccurate statements, or obscure responsibility for the final report. Relevant use should be disclosed to the editor.
審稿人的專業判斷不得由自動化評估取代。涉及稿件原創性、有效性、方法論充分性、倫理疑慮及學術重要性的判斷,必須由能夠承擔責任的人員進行。如獲准使用工具提供有限的語言或呈現協助,審稿人應確保相關使用不會破壞保密性、引入不準確內容,或模糊最終評審報告的責任歸屬,並向編輯披露相關使用情況。
Continuing Confidentiality / 持續性的保密義務
Confidentiality obligations concerning unpublished materials and review communications continue after the review process or editorial decision has concluded. Publication of an article does not automatically make previously confidential editorial correspondence, reviewer identities, or unpublished materials public.
對未公開材料及評審通信的保密義務,在評審程序或編輯決定結束後仍然持續。文章正式發表不會自動使先前保密的編輯通信、審稿人身份或未公開材料轉為公開資訊。
The journal accepts previously disclosed preprints in accordance with its Preprint Policy. Public availability of a preprint does not remove the confidential status of the journal's review process or unpublished communications. Once an article is formally published, its public content is governed by the applicable publication license, while material not lawfully made public remains subject to its relevant protections.
本刊依照 Preprint Policy(預印本政策)接受先前已公開的預印本稿件。預印本的公開狀態不會取消期刊評審程序或未公開通信的保密性。文章正式發表後,其公開內容依適用的出版授權管理,而未依法公開的材料仍受到相關保護。
Conflict of Interest / 利益衝突
Reviewers must disclose circumstances that could reasonably affect, or appear to affect, the independence and impartiality of their evaluation. A conflict of interest may arise from financial, professional, academic, institutional, or personal relationships associated with the manuscript or its authors.
審稿人必須披露可能合理影響,或看似可能影響其評估獨立性與公正性的情況。利益衝突可能源於與稿件或作者有關的財務、職業、學術、機構或個人關係。
Conflicts of interest are not limited to direct financial benefits. Academic rivalry, recent collaborative relationships, supervisory responsibilities, personal disputes, and other circumstances may also affect the perception or reality of impartiality. Reviewers should assess potential conflicts before accepting an invitation and remain attentive to information that becomes apparent during the review.
利益衝突並不限於直接財務利益。學術競爭、近期合作關係、指導職責、私人爭議及其他情況,亦可能實際影響或使人合理質疑評估的公正性。審稿人應在接受邀請前考慮潛在衝突,並持續關注評審期間新出現的相關資訊。
Potential Conflicts / 可能的利益衝突
-
Recent or Close Collaboration: Research partnerships, coauthorship, supervision, mentorship, joint projects, or other professional relationships that could compromise independent assessment.
近期或密切合作: 可能影響獨立判斷的研究合作、共同署名、指導關係、共同項目或其他職業聯繫。
-
Institutional Relationships: Shared affiliations, recent institutional connections, or other institutional arrangements that create a meaningful concern about impartiality.
機構關係: 共同所屬機構、近期機構聯繫或其他可能對公正評估構成實質疑慮的機構安排。
-
Financial or Professional Interests: Relevant funding arrangements, commercial interests, financial relationships, professional competition, or potential benefits associated with the research or its outcomes.
財務或職業利益: 與研究或其結果相關的資助安排、商業利益、財務關係、職業競爭或潛在利益。
-
Personal Relationships: Close personal relationships, serious disputes, or other circumstances that could influence professional judgment or reasonably create an appearance of partiality.
個人關係: 可能影響專業判斷,或使人合理質疑公正性的密切私人關係、重大爭議或其他相關情況。
Reviewers should notify the editorial office promptly when a potential conflict becomes apparent, including when relevant information is identified after accepting an invitation. Where the conflict is substantial, reviewers should decline or withdraw from the assignment. Other disclosed circumstances should be assessed by the editor before the review proceeds.
一旦發現潛在利益衝突,審稿人應及時通知編輯部,包括接受邀請後才發現相關資訊的情況。若利益衝突具有重大影響,審稿人應拒絕或退出評審;其他已披露情況則應由編輯評估後,再決定是否繼續安排。
A shared academic field or general intellectual disagreement does not automatically constitute a disqualifying conflict. The relevant question is whether the circumstances could reasonably compromise an independent, evidence-based evaluation. Reviewers who are uncertain about a relationship or interest should disclose it to the editor rather than independently assume that it is immaterial.
處於同一學術領域,或存在一般性的學術觀點分歧,並不自動構成必須迴避的利益衝突。判斷重點在於相關情況是否可能合理影響獨立且以證據為基礎的評估。審稿人如不確定某項關係或利益是否構成衝突,應向編輯披露,而非自行假定其不具重要性。
Recognizing an author's identity during double-anonymous review does not necessarily invalidate the assessment. However, where that recognition reveals a relevant relationship, competition, or other potential conflict, the reviewer must inform the editor. The editor can then determine whether the assignment remains appropriate in light of the journal's review requirements.
在雙匿名評審期間辨識作者身份,並不必然使評估失效。然而,如相關辨識揭示了重要關係、競爭情況或其他潛在衝突,審稿人必須通知編輯,再由編輯依據本刊評審要求判斷相關安排是否仍然適當。
Evaluation Criteria / 評估標準
Reviewers should evaluate submissions according to their scholarly purpose, article type, disciplinary context, and methodological approach. The criteria below provide a common framework, but their application should reflect the nature of the contribution under consideration. Reviewers should not impose a single disciplinary convention or preferred research outcome on submissions that legitimately employ different scholarly methods.
審稿人應根據稿件的學術目的、文章類型、學科背景及方法論路徑進行評估。以下標準提供共同的評價框架,但具體適用方式應反映待評估稿件的性質。審稿人不應將單一學科慣例或偏好的研究結果強加於合理採用不同研究方法的投稿。
Relevance to the Journal / 與期刊的契合度
The manuscript should address questions relevant to the aims and scope of Silence and demonstrate a meaningful relationship to the intellectual orientation of the selected editorial section. Reviewers should assess its relevance without imposing narrower disciplinary preferences than the journal's published scope permits.
稿件應探討與《Silence》宗旨及收稿範圍相關的問題,並與所選編輯欄目的智識定位具有實質聯繫。審稿人應評估其相關性,但不應施加比期刊已公布收稿範圍更加狹窄的個人學科偏好。
Interdisciplinary contributions should be considered in light of the research question and the appropriateness of the perspectives combined. A manuscript should not be regarded as unsuitable merely because it crosses disciplinary boundaries, uses an unfamiliar but defensible method, or addresses an unconventional scholarly problem.
跨學科研究應根據其研究問題及所整合視角的適切性加以評估。稿件不應僅因跨越學科邊界、採用審稿人較不熟悉但具有合理依據的方法,或探討非傳統學術問題,便被認定不適合發表。
Originality / 原創性
Reviewers should consider whether the manuscript offers an identifiable contribution through new evidence, conceptual clarification, theoretical reconsideration, methodological insight, critical synthesis, or another appropriate form of scholarly advancement. Originality should be assessed in relation to the relevant literature and the specific aims of the contribution.
審稿人應考察稿件是否透過新證據、概念釐清、理論重新評估、方法論洞見、批判性綜合或其他適當形式形成可辨識的學術貢獻。原創性應結合相關文獻與稿件的具體學術目的加以判斷。
Originality does not necessarily require a positive result, a completely new theory, or an unprecedented research topic. A carefully supported reassessment, a transparent analysis of an unsuccessful investigation, or a clarification of unresolved evidence may constitute an original contribution when it adds meaningful scholarly understanding beyond what is already available.
原創性並不必然要求陽性結果、完全全新的理論或前所未有的研究主題。具有充分依據的重新評估、對未成功研究的透明分析,或對未決證據的釐清,只要能超越現有成果並提供具有實質意義的學術理解,均可能構成原創貢獻。
Methodological Rigor / 方法論嚴謹性
The research design, evidence sources, analytical methods, and interpretive procedures should be appropriate to the research question and described with sufficient transparency. Reviewers should consider whether the conclusions follow from the available materials and whether relevant limitations have been acknowledged.
研究設計、證據來源、分析方法及解釋程序應與研究問題相符,並具有足夠的透明度。審稿人應考察結論是否由現有材料合理推導,以及作者是否適當承認相關局限。
Methodological rigor should be evaluated according to the research tradition employed. For empirical studies, this may involve the adequacy of research design, measurement, data collection, analysis, and reporting. For theoretical, historical, conceptual, or interpretive research, it may involve the clarity of assumptions, treatment of sources, consistency of reasoning, and justification of interpretations.
方法論嚴謹性應依據所採用的研究傳統進行判斷。對實證研究而言,可能涉及研究設計、測量、資料收集、分析及報告的充分程度;對理論、歷史、概念或詮釋性研究而言,則可能涉及基本預設的清晰性、資料來源的處理、推理一致性及研究解釋的合理依據。
Reviewers should distinguish between methodological limitations that materially undermine a claim and limitations that appropriately restrict its scope. Where evidence is incomplete or uncertain, the assessment should consider whether the authors have represented that uncertainty accurately instead of demanding conclusions that the available material cannot support.
審稿人應區分實質削弱某項主張的方法論缺陷,以及僅對其適用範圍形成合理限制的研究局限。當證據不完整或存在不確定性時,應考察作者是否準確呈現相關情況,而非要求提出現有材料無法支持的結論。
Clarity and Structure / 清晰度與結構
The manuscript should present its central question, reasoning, evidence, and conclusions in a coherent and understandable manner. Reviewers should distinguish problems that materially obstruct interpretation from minor stylistic or editorial preferences.
稿件應以連貫且易於理解的方式呈現核心問題、推理過程、研究證據及結論。審稿人應區分實質妨礙理解的問題與一般性的寫作風格或編輯偏好。
Comments concerning language and presentation should identify difficulties that affect the accurate communication of scholarly meaning. Reviewers should not require unnecessary stylistic conformity when the manuscript is sufficiently clear and its terminology is appropriate to the discipline.
涉及語言與呈現方式的意見,應指出實際影響學術意義準確傳達的問題。當稿件已足夠清晰,且術語符合相關學科慣例時,審稿人不應要求無必要的風格一致化修改。
Engagement with Literature / 文獻對話
The manuscript should engage accurately and sufficiently with scholarship directly relevant to its research question. Reviewers may identify important omissions, inaccurate interpretations, or unsupported claims concerning prior research, while recognizing that the expected breadth of a literature review varies by article type.
稿件應準確且充分地考察與研究問題直接相關的學術成果。審稿人可以指出重要文獻遺漏、不準確的研究解釋,或對先前研究缺乏依據的主張,但也應認識到不同文章類型對文獻評論廣度的要求可能有所不同。
Recommendations for additional literature should be justified by relevance to the manuscript's argument, evidence base, or interpretation. Reviewers must not use citation requests to increase references to their own work or that of associates without a legitimate scholarly reason. Relevant counterevidence and alternative interpretations should receive fair consideration.
補充文獻的建議應以其與稿件論證、證據基礎或研究解釋的關聯為依據。審稿人不得在缺乏正當學術理由的情況下,藉由引用要求增加本人或相關人士著作的被引用次數。相關相反證據及替代性解釋應獲得公正考慮。
Scholarly Contribution / 學術貢獻
Reviewers should assess how the manuscript advances or clarifies understanding of its subject. A contribution may establish new knowledge, identify meaningful limitations, refine existing interpretations, reveal unresolved problems, or improve the basis for future research.
審稿人應評估稿件如何推進或釐清對相關主題的理解。學術貢獻可以體現在建立新知識、辨識具有意義的局限、深化既有解釋、揭示未決問題,或改善後續研究的基礎。
The significance of a contribution should be considered in relation to the evidence and reasoning actually presented. Reviewers should avoid equating importance solely with immediate practical application, statistical significance, conventional novelty, or agreement with established interpretations. A well-supported clarification of existing knowledge can also advance scholarship.
學術貢獻的重要性應結合稿件實際提出的證據與推理進行判斷。審稿人不應將重要性僅等同於即時實務應用、統計顯著性、傳統意義上的新穎性,或與既有解釋保持一致。對現有知識作出具有充分依據的釐清,同樣可以推進學術研究。
Evaluation Across Article Types / 不同文章類型的評估
Failed Experiments: Evaluate the transparency and analytical value of unsuccessful, negative, unexpected, or inconclusive research without requiring favorable findings. Particular attention should be given to the distinction between a hypothesis that lacks support, evidence that remains inconclusive, and a procedure that did not function as intended.
失敗實驗: 評估未成功、陰性、非預期或無定論研究的透明度及分析價值,而非要求研究必須取得正面結果。尤其應區分未獲支持的假設、仍無定論的證據,以及未按預期運作的研究程序。
Unwanted Reviews: Assess the accuracy of literature representation, fairness of criticism, conceptual precision, and strength of arguments that reconsider established scholarly positions. A critical interpretation should be evaluated according to its evidence and reasoning, not whether it agrees with prevailing views.
逆流評論: 評估文獻呈現的準確性、批判的公正性、概念精確性,以及重新審視既有學術立場所依據之論證的充分程度。批判性解釋應根據其證據與推理品質評估,而非取決於是否符合主流觀點。
Void Dialogue: Consider the substance of interaction, conceptual development, accuracy of participant representation, and scholarly contribution arising from the exchange. Reviewers should distinguish genuine intellectual dialogue from disconnected statements or purely descriptive interviews and consider the accuracy of any editorial reconstruction.
留白對話: 考察交流的實質內容、概念發展、參與者言論呈現的準確性,以及對話所形成的學術貢獻。審稿人應區分具有實質智識互動的對話與彼此缺乏聯繫的陳述或純描述性訪談,並關注編輯重構的準確性。
Null Reviews: Evaluate the identification and interpretation of knowledge gaps, conflicting evidence, methodological limitations, and unresolved research questions. Reviewers should distinguish absence of evidence from evidence supporting the absence of an effect and assess whether the review accurately represents the limits of available knowledge.
空白評論: 評估對知識空白、相互衝突的證據、方法論局限及未決研究問題的辨識與解釋。審稿人應區分缺乏證據與支持效應不存在的證據,並考察評論是否準確呈現現有知識的適用邊界。
Quiet Research: Assess the depth, coherence, methodological transparency, and scholarly significance of the sustained research argument. Intellectual depth should be judged by the quality of the inquiry and reasoning rather than manuscript length or unnecessary complexity.
寂靜研究: 評估完整研究論證的深度、連貫性、方法論透明度及學術意義。智識深度應根據探究與推理的品質判斷,而非僅以稿件篇幅或不必要的複雜性衡量。
Reviewers must not treat statistical non-significance as automatic evidence of no effect, nor reject exploratory or critical scholarship merely because it does not conform to established expectations. Evaluation should focus on what the evidence and reasoning can legitimately support.
審稿人不得將統計不顯著自動視為不存在效應的證據,也不應僅因探索性或批判性研究不符合既有預期便予以否定。評估應重視證據與推理能夠合理支持的結論。
The journal's section-specific formats do not remove the expectation of academic rigor. Rather, they require reviewers to apply scholarly standards in ways appropriate to different research purposes. An assessment should identify whether a manuscript makes the contribution it claims to make and whether the supporting evidence, reasoning, and reporting are sufficient for that purpose.
本刊不同欄目的學術形式並不降低嚴謹性要求,而是要求審稿人以符合不同研究目的的方式運用學術標準。評估應確認稿件是否實際形成其所主張的貢獻,以及支持性證據、推理與研究報告是否足以支持該項目的。
Constructive Feedback / 建設性評審意見
A useful review report should communicate the reviewer's overall assessment while identifying specific issues that inform editorial judgment and, where appropriate, enable meaningful manuscript revision. Feedback should be professional, evidence-informed, and proportionate to the nature of the concerns raised.
有價值的評審報告應清楚呈現審稿人的整體判斷,同時指出有助於編輯決策的具體問題,並在適當情況下協助作者進行有意義的稿件修訂。評語應保持專業、具有證據依據,並與所提出問題的性質相稱。
An effective report explains the scholarly implications of identified problems rather than merely listing preferences or issuing unexplained judgments. Reviewers should make clear which matters affect the central argument, which concern the interpretation or reliability of findings, and which are primarily editorial or presentational.
有效的評審報告應解釋所辨識問題的學術影響,而非僅列舉個人偏好或提出缺乏說明的判斷。審稿人應清楚區分影響核心論證的問題、涉及研究結果解釋或可靠性的問題,以及主要屬於編輯或呈現方式的事項。
Elements of Constructive Feedback / 建設性意見的主要內容
-
Identify Strengths and Limitations: Describe the manuscript's meaningful contributions alongside the issues that limit its present scholarly value. Reviewers should recognize well-supported aspects of the work even when substantial revisions are necessary.
指出優勢與局限: 說明稿件具有意義的學術貢獻,以及目前限制其學術價值的問題。即使稿件需要大幅修改,審稿人仍應承認其中具有充分依據的部分。
-
Explain Substantive Concerns: Identify the passages, methods, interpretations, evidentiary limitations, or conceptual assumptions underlying important criticisms. The explanation should enable the editor to understand the nature and significance of the concern.
解釋實質問題: 指出重要批評所涉及的具體段落、研究方法、研究解釋、證據局限或概念預設,使編輯能夠理解問題的性質及重要程度。
-
Suggest Appropriate Improvements: Recommend clarification, stronger analysis, additional explanation, or greater methodological transparency when such changes could reasonably improve the manuscript. Proposed revisions should remain proportionate to the study's aims and the evidence required to support its claims.
提出適當改進建議: 在相關修改能合理改善稿件品質的情況下,建議釐清論述、加強分析、補充說明或提高方法論透明度。修訂要求應與研究目的及支持其主張所需的證據相稱。
-
Identify Relevant Scholarship: Recommend directly relevant literature where its omission materially affects the argument, while avoiding unnecessary or self-serving citation requests. Suggestions should clarify the significance of the missing scholarship rather than simply demand an increased reference count.
指出相關學術文獻: 當重要文獻的遺漏實質影響論證時,建議補充直接相關的研究成果,同時避免不必要或出於個人利益的引用要求。相關建議應說明缺失文獻的重要性,而非僅要求增加參考文獻數量。
Reviewers should distinguish major concerns affecting the validity or scholarly contribution of a manuscript from minor matters of language, presentation, or style. They should avoid requiring unnecessary changes that do not materially improve the work.
審稿人應區分影響稿件有效性或學術貢獻的重大問題,以及語言、呈現方式或寫作風格方面的次要事項。對無法實質改善研究品質的修改,不應提出不必要的要求。
Disagreement should be expressed through reasoned scholarly criticism rather than personal attacks, hostile language, or unsupported accusations. Reviewers should assess the work presented rather than speculate about the authors' intentions, character, or personal circumstances.
學術分歧應透過具有論證依據的批評表達,而非透過人身攻擊、敵意語言或缺乏證據的指控。審稿人應評估稿件本身,而非推測作者的意圖、人格或個人情況。
A reviewer should not insist that authors undertake a fundamentally different research project when the submitted study can be evaluated fairly on its stated aims and design. Additional experiments, data collection, or analyses should be recommended when they are necessary to substantiate important claims, resolve material deficiencies, or clarify the limitations of the conclusions. Where those additions are not feasible or proportionate, an appropriately qualified interpretation may be preferable to an unsupported claim.
當稿件能夠根據其既定目標與設計接受公正評估時,審稿人不應強制作者將其改造成根本不同的研究項目。只有在補充實驗、資料收集或分析對支持重要主張、解決實質缺陷或釐清結論局限具有必要性時,才應提出相應建議。如相關補充工作不可行或與問題的重要程度不相稱,適當限制結論的解釋範圍,可能比維持缺乏依據的主張更加合理。
Where a reviewer identifies an issue that is primarily ethical, confidential, or related to possible misconduct, the concern should be communicated through the appropriate editorial channel. The author-facing report should remain focused on fair, substantiated scholarly feedback, without disclosing protected information or presenting unresolved allegations as established facts.
如審稿人發現主要涉及倫理、保密或疑似學術不端的問題,應透過適當的編輯渠道反映。提供予作者的評審報告應維持公正且具有依據的學術回饋,不得披露受保護資訊,亦不得將尚未解決的指控描述為已確認事實。
Review Recommendations / 評審建議
At the conclusion of an evaluation, reviewers may provide a recommendation reflecting their assessment of the manuscript. Recommendations should be consistent with the substantive comments in the review report and should identify the seriousness of any unresolved concerns.
審稿人在完成評估後,可以根據對稿件的判斷提出評審建議。建議應與評審報告中的實質意見保持一致,並反映尚未解決問題的重要程度。
A recommendation should reflect the reviewer's assessment of whether the manuscript meets the relevant scholarly standards and, if not, whether identified concerns can reasonably be addressed through revision. Reviewers should distinguish limitations that require correction from differences of interpretation that do not necessarily invalidate a defensible scholarly contribution.
評審建議應反映審稿人對稿件是否符合相關學術標準的判斷;如未達標準,亦應考慮所辨識的問題能否透過合理修訂解決。審稿人應區分需要修正的實質局限,以及不必然否定合理學術貢獻的研究解釋分歧。
Possible Recommendations / 可能的評審建議
-
Accept Without Revision: The reviewer considers the manuscript suitable for publication without substantive revisions. Minor production or editorial corrections may still be addressed through the journal's normal preparation process.
建議直接錄用: 審稿人認為稿件無須進行實質性修改即可考慮發表。一般文字編輯或出版製作上的細微修正,仍可透過正常準備程序處理。
-
Minor Revisions Required: Limited corrections, clarifications, or improvements are recommended before the manuscript can be reconsidered. The identified issues should not require a fundamental reconstruction of the study or its central argument.
建議小修: 建議作者進行有限的修正、釐清或改善,以供稿件進一步評估。相關問題通常不應涉及研究或核心論證的根本性重構。
-
Major Revisions Required: Substantial changes are recommended to address significant concerns involving the argument, methodology, evidence, interpretation, or presentation. The reviewer should explain which matters require substantive attention and why they affect the manuscript's scholarly adequacy.
建議大修: 建議作者針對論證、方法論、證據、解釋或內容呈現方面的重要問題進行實質性修改。審稿人應說明哪些事項需要重點處理,以及它們為何影響稿件的學術充分性。
-
Reject: The reviewer considers the manuscript unsuitable for publication in its present form or identifies concerns that cannot reasonably be resolved through revision. The recommendation should be supported by specific scholarly reasons rather than a conclusory statement alone.
建議拒稿: 審稿人認為稿件目前不適合發表,或存在無法透過合理修訂充分解決的問題。相關建議應具有具體學術理由,而非僅提供缺乏說明的結論性判斷。
Reviewer Recommendation and Editorial Decision / 評審建議與編輯決定
Reviewer recommendations are advisory. The editor considers the substance of the reports, the manuscript's scholarly quality, and applicable editorial and ethical requirements before making a decision. A recommendation for minor revision is not an automatic commitment to acceptance after revision.
審稿人的建議屬於專業參考意見。編輯在作出決定前,須考慮評審報告的實質內容、稿件的學術品質,以及適用的編輯與倫理要求。建議小修並不代表稿件在完成修訂後必然獲得錄用。
Reviewers should avoid presenting their recommendations to authors as final editorial decisions. Where the journal's review process provides separate channels for comments to authors and confidential comments to editors, reviewers should distinguish substantive author-facing feedback from sensitive editorial concerns.
審稿人不應將自身的評審建議向作者表述為最終編輯決定。如評審程序設有面向作者的意見與僅供編輯查看的保密意見,審稿人應區分可供作者理解與修訂的實質評語,以及需要由編輯審慎處理的敏感問題。
Confidential comments to the editor should not be used to conceal substantive criticisms that authors reasonably need in order to understand or address the review. Where confidentiality or ethical considerations prevent direct disclosure, the reviewer should explain the circumstances to the editor, who remains responsible for determining the appropriate communication.
審稿人不應利用僅供編輯查看的保密意見,隱藏作者為理解或回應評審所合理需要的重要批評。如因保密或倫理因素而不宜直接披露,審稿人應向編輯說明情況,再由編輯決定適當的溝通方式。
Different reviewers may reasonably reach different recommendations. Reviewers should make the evidence and reasoning underlying their judgments clear so that the editor can evaluate the substance of each report. Their role is to provide a defensible professional assessment rather than to secure a predetermined editorial outcome.
不同審稿人可能合理地提出不同建議。審稿人應清楚呈現判斷所依據的證據與推理,使編輯能夠評估各份報告的實質內容。審稿人的職責在於提供具有合理依據的專業評估,而非確保某一預先設定的編輯結果。
Review Timeline / 評審時間安排
Approximately 2–4 Weeks
Indicative review period after accepting an invitation
一般參考評審時間:接受邀請後約 2–4 週。
Reviewers are typically requested to complete their evaluations within approximately two to four weeks after accepting the review invitation. This period is an indicative estimate and does not constitute a guaranteed or universally applicable deadline. Reviewers should follow the specific schedule communicated for the assigned manuscript.
本刊通常希望審稿人在接受邀請後約兩至四週內完成評估。此時間屬參考估計,並非保證期限,也不代表所有稿件均採用相同安排。審稿人應遵守個別稿件通知中列明的具體評審時間。
The appropriate duration of a review may depend on manuscript length, disciplinary specialization, methodological complexity, the extent of materials requiring assessment, and other circumstances relevant to the assignment. The indicative period should therefore be interpreted as a planning reference rather than a fixed requirement that overrides the schedule agreed for an individual manuscript.
適當的評審時間可能受到稿件篇幅、專業領域、方法論複雜程度、需要評估之材料範圍,以及其他相關情況的影響。因此,參考期間應作為安排評審工作的依據,而非凌駕個別稿件約定時程的固定要求。
Reviewers who anticipate difficulties meeting the agreed schedule should notify the editorial office promptly. If circumstances prevent a competent and timely review, declining or withdrawing from the assignment may be more appropriate than submitting an incomplete or insufficiently considered report.
若預計無法按照約定時間完成評審,審稿人應及時通知編輯部。如客觀情況已無法支持充分且及時的專業評估,拒絕或退出評審可能比提交不完整或缺乏充分考慮的報告更為適當。
The individual review period should be distinguished from the journal's overall editorial timetable. Reviewer availability, requests for additional expertise, manuscript revisions, and editorial deliberation may affect the time required to reach a decision.
個別審稿人的評審時間應與期刊整體編輯時程加以區分。審稿人安排、補充專業評估、稿件修訂及編輯討論,均可能影響稿件形成最終決定所需的時間。
Reviewers should not compromise the quality of an evaluation merely to meet a reference timeframe. Where an extension or adjustment appears necessary, early communication allows the editor to consider the circumstances and manage the manuscript appropriately. The journal's published estimates do not establish a universal entitlement to an extension or a guaranteed date for an editorial decision.
審稿人不應僅為符合參考時程而犧牲評估品質。如有必要延長或調整安排,及早溝通可讓編輯考慮相關情況並妥善管理稿件。本刊公布的估計時間並不構成所有審稿人均可自動獲得延期的權利,也不代表編輯決定具有保證完成日期。
Ethical Responsibilities / 倫理責任
Reviewers are expected to follow the ethical standards described in the journal's Publication Ethics Policy and Protection of Intellectual Contributions. They should inform the editor when they identify circumstances that may raise substantive concerns about research integrity, appropriate attribution, or the ethical conduct of the research.
審稿人應遵守本刊 Publication Ethics Policy(出版倫理政策)及 Protection of Intellectual Contributions(智識貢獻保護)所述的倫理標準。當審稿人發現可能涉及研究誠信、適當來源標示或研究倫理的重要疑慮時,應向編輯反映。
Reviewers are not expected to function as independent misconduct investigators. Their responsibility is to identify concerns that arise in the course of a reasonable scholarly assessment and communicate sufficiently specific information to the editor through the appropriate confidential channel. Ethical issues should be evaluated on the basis of evidence, fairness, and the distinction between an apparent irregularity and a substantiated finding.
審稿人並非獨立的學術不端調查人員。其責任是在合理的學術評估過程中辨識相關疑慮,並透過適當的保密渠道向編輯提供足夠具體的資訊。倫理問題的評估應建立在證據、公正性,以及區分表面異常與已有充分證據之事實的基礎上。
Concerns Requiring Editorial Attention / 需要編輯關注的問題
-
Potential Plagiarism or Misattribution: Indications that text, data, ideas, images, methods, or other scholarly contributions have been used without appropriate acknowledgment or authorization. Reviewers should identify the relevant material and explain the basis of the concern.
疑似剽竊或不當來源標示: 文字、資料、思想、圖像、方法或其他學術貢獻可能在缺乏適當確認或授權的情況下被使用。審稿人應指出相關材料,並說明疑慮的依據。
-
Potential Duplicate Publication or Prohibited Simultaneous Submission: Concerns that substantially overlapping work has already been formally published or is concurrently under consideration elsewhere in a manner inconsistent with the journal's policies. Legitimate preprints and other permitted forms of prior dissemination should be distinguished from prohibited practices.
疑似重複發表或不符合規定的一稿多投: 具有實質重疊的研究可能已正式發表,或以不符合本刊政策的方式同時接受其他期刊的正式審查。應區分合法預印本及其他獲允許的先前傳播形式與不符合規定的行為。
-
Data or Research Reporting Irregularities: Apparent inconsistencies, unexplained alterations, missing information, unsupported claims, or other indications that the reported research may require further examination. A methodological limitation should not automatically be characterized as evidence of fabrication or falsification.
資料或研究報告異常: 研究記錄中可能存在的不一致、缺乏說明的修改、資訊缺失、無充分依據的主張,或其他需要進一步審查的情況。方法論局限不應自動被定性為捏造或篡改研究資料的證據。
-
Research Ethics and Participant Protection: Substantive concerns involving applicable ethical approval, informed consent, confidentiality, privacy, or the responsible treatment of research participants and sensitive materials. Reviewers should assess these matters in relation to the nature of the study and the ethical requirements applicable to it.
研究倫理與參與者保護: 涉及適用倫理批准、知情同意、保密、隱私,或研究參與者及敏感材料之負責任處理的重要問題。審稿人應結合研究性質及其適用的倫理要求評估相關事項。
Reviewers should report concerns with sufficient specificity to permit editorial consideration. Suspected misconduct should not be presented as established fact without adequate evidence. The responsibility to assess allegations and determine appropriate editorial action belongs to the journal's editorial process.
審稿人應具體說明相關疑慮,使編輯能夠進行適當評估。對涉嫌學術不端的情況,在缺乏充分證據前不得直接視為既定事實。對相關指控進行評估及決定適當編輯措施,屬於本刊編輯程序的責任。
Preprints and Prior Dissemination / 預印本與先前傳播
A manuscript's prior availability as a preprint is not, by itself, evidence of improper duplicate publication. Reviewers who encounter an earlier version should distinguish legitimate preprint dissemination from previous formal journal publication or prohibited simultaneous submission, in accordance with the journal's Preprint Policy.
稿件先前以預印本形式公開,本身並不是不當重複發表的證據。審稿人如發現較早版本,應依本刊預印本政策區分合法的預印本傳播、既有正式期刊發表,以及不符合規定的一稿多投。
Reviewers should avoid taking unauthorized investigative steps, contacting authors independently about suspected misconduct, or disclosing allegations outside the appropriate editorial channels. Confidentiality, fairness, and the need to distinguish evidence from suspicion should guide the handling of ethical concerns.
審稿人應避免自行開展未經授權的調查、私下聯絡作者處理涉嫌學術不端問題,或在適當編輯程序以外披露相關指控。處理倫理疑慮時,應遵循保密、公正及區分證據與懷疑的原則。
Where an apparent irregularity could have a legitimate methodological, disciplinary, or documentary explanation, reviewers should describe the uncertainty rather than assume deliberate wrongdoing. The editor may consider the available information, request author clarification, or undertake further steps in accordance with the journal's existing publication ethics arrangements.
當表面異常可能存在合理的方法論、學科或文件記錄方面的解釋時,審稿人應說明相關不確定性,而非直接推定作者故意違規。編輯可以考慮現有資訊、要求作者澄清,或依據本刊既定出版倫理安排採取進一步措施。
Ethical responsibility also applies to the review itself. Reviewers must avoid misrepresenting the manuscript, selectively ignoring material evidence, deliberately obstructing publication for competitive reasons, or exploiting unpublished information obtained through their appointment. Professional disagreement must remain separate from personal interests or retaliatory conduct.
倫理責任同樣適用於評審行為本身。審稿人不得歪曲稿件內容、選擇性忽略重要證據、因競爭目的故意阻礙發表,或利用受邀評審所取得的未公開資訊。專業上的學術分歧應與個人利益或報復性行為保持區分。
Contribution to Scholarly Community / 對學術共同體的貢獻
Scholarly peer review contributes to the development of academic knowledge by subjecting research arguments, methods, evidence, and interpretations to informed critical examination. Reviewers support this process by helping identify both the contributions of submitted work and the limitations that require clarification or further investigation.
同行評審透過對研究論證、方法、證據及解釋進行具有專業知識基礎的批判性檢驗,促進學術知識的發展。審稿人透過辨識投稿的學術貢獻,以及需要釐清或進一步研究的局限,支持這一過程。
The value of review extends beyond recommending acceptance or rejection. A carefully reasoned assessment may improve the transparency of a research design, identify an overlooked conceptual problem, strengthen engagement with existing literature, or help authors recognize the limits of their conclusions.
評審的價值並不限於建議錄用或拒稿。經過審慎推理的評估可能提高研究設計的透明度、揭示被忽略的概念問題、加強與既有文獻的對話,或協助作者認識研究結論的適用邊界。
Silence recognizes the particular importance of fair evaluation for research that questions established interpretations, documents unsuccessful investigations, examines fragmented evidence, or develops ideas through scholarly dialogue. Such work requires critical scrutiny without prejudice against its unconventional form, unresolved questions, or unexpected findings.
《Silence》特別重視對質疑既有解釋、記錄未成功研究、考察碎片化證據,或透過學術對話發展思想之稿件的公正評估。此類研究應接受嚴謹的學術檢驗,但不應因其非傳統形式、未解決的問題或非預期發現而受到先入為主的負面判斷。
The reviewer contributes most effectively when criticism is both independent and accountable. Intellectual independence permits the reviewer to question a manuscript's arguments without deference to reputation or prevailing opinion. Accountability requires those criticisms to be supported by appropriate evidence, disciplinary knowledge, and fair representation of the work under examination.
當批判同時具備獨立性與責任意識時,審稿人的貢獻最能發揮作用。智識獨立使審稿人能夠不受聲望或主流意見影響,對稿件論證提出質疑;責任意識則要求相關批評具有適當證據、學科知識及對所評估研究的公正呈現作為基礎。
Constructive evaluation can also contribute to more reliable scholarly communication by distinguishing substantive weaknesses from legitimate uncertainty. A negative result need not indicate defective research; disagreement does not necessarily imply error; and an unresolved question can remain academically valuable when its evidentiary status and implications are accurately explained.
建設性評估亦可透過區分實質缺陷與合理不確定性,提高學術交流的可靠程度。陰性結果不必然代表研究存在缺陷;學術分歧不一定意味著其中一方存在錯誤;當未決問題的證據狀態及其影響得到準確說明時,相關研究仍可能具有學術價值。
The journal appreciates reviewers who contribute their expertise with intellectual independence, ethical responsibility, and constructive engagement. Their participation helps support a scholarly environment in which research quality is assessed through evidence and reasoning, and where legitimate uncertainty and intellectual disagreement remain open to examination.
本刊感謝審稿人以智識獨立、倫理責任及建設性參與的方式貢獻專業知識。審稿人的工作有助於建立以證據與推理評估研究品質的學術環境,使合理的不確定性與智識分歧能夠持續接受檢驗與討論。
Through rigorous and fair peer review, Silence seeks to strengthen the integrity of its editorial decisions and encourage meaningful scholarly exchange across different disciplines and forms of research. Reviewers serve an essential role in this process by applying expert knowledge responsibly, respecting the confidentiality of unpublished work, and supporting the careful evaluation of scholarly contributions.
透過嚴謹且公正的同行評審,《Silence》致力於提高編輯決策的完整性,並促進不同學科與研究形式之間具有實質意義的學術交流。審稿人透過負責任地運用專業知識、尊重未公開研究的保密性,以及支持對學術貢獻的審慎評估,在此過程中發揮不可或缺的作用。
Expertise · Constructiveness · Ethics
專業 · 建設性 · 倫理